Skip to main content
Loading video...

Pond Review | Cute Frogs, Cutthroat Gameplay

Transcript 8:50

Look at these frogs. They are adorable. They're colorful, they have their own little factions, and they're about to spend the next hour relentlessly attacking each other for control of a pond. Pond looks like another cute cozy board game, but underneath all of that adorable artwork is a surprisingly confrontational combination of deck building, area control, and combat. But does Pond actually bring something interesting to those familiar mechanisms? Or are the adorable frogs doing most of the work?

Hi, I'm Sarah and welcome to Let's Table It. Today we're taking look at Pond from Brother Ming Games, who have provided a deluxe copy of the game for review. Pond plays two to four players in about 30 to 60 minutes, and sits comfortably in that medium lightweight range. Let's take a look at how it plays. In Pond, each player controls their own faction of frogs, and your main goal is to spread across the board and control as many ponds as possible. At the beginning of your turn, you will deploy new frogs, then you'll use cards from your deck to take as many actions as you can or want to. You might deploy additional frogs, move them into neighboring ponds, merge frogs together to create long frogs, or attack your opponents and try to take control away from them.

At the end of your turn, you score one point for every pond you currently control, plus points for lily pads. And I think that timing is important. You don't have to maintain control for an entire round. You just need to have the majority when your turn ends. Then your opponent might immediately march in and take it right away from you. And you'll probably try to take it right back. That creates this constant push and pull across the board. But Pond isn't only an area control game. You're also building and constantly trimming your deck. And this is where Pond started getting particularly interesting for me. Every time you need to shuffle your deck, you have to choose one card from your discard pile to hibernate.

That card is permanently removed from your deck. Normally, I'm a huge fan of calling cards from deck builders. Give me a lean little deck full of exactly the cards I want and I'm happy. But Pond makes that decision more complicated. Those hibernated cards can eventually be spent to gain hero frogs, which give you powerful permanent abilities. So, you're sacrificing part of your current deck to strengthen your faction long-term. At the same time, you're deciding what kind of deck you even want to build. Do I want cards that let me attack more, move farther, deploy frogs quickly, build more long frogs, control lily pads? Our three strategies ended up looking surprisingly different. Drew focused heavily on lily pads.

I tried to spread out and maintain a presence across as many ponds as possible. And Emma? Emma [clears throat] chose violence. She was much more interested in attacking and stealing majorities. And I really liked that the card system gave us enough flexibility for all three approaches to work. The first thing Pond has going for it is obvious. It's incredibly cute. The artwork is fantastic. The board looks great once it's covered in frogs, and the deluxe frog meeples are ridiculous in the best possible way. But I particularly like that the factions aren't just cosmetic. Each has a slightly different starter deck, and your player board gives you another special ability that encourages a particular style of play. So, choosing a faction actually matters.

Mechanically though, the hibernation system might be my favorite part. It forces your deck to evolve. You can't simply keep adding cards forever. Eventually, you're going to have to decide what no longer belongs. And because you're building toward those hero abilities, thinning your deck feels like a progression rather than a punishment. I also expected the combat to bother me more than it did. We don't usually gravitate towards highly confrontational games. But, because pond scores at the end of every player's turn, losing an area didn't feel devastating. Maybe Emma attacked me and took control of my pond. Fine, she scores it. Then my turn comes back around and I march back in, attack her, and try to take it back. It felt more like a tug-of-war than someone destroying something I'd spent an hour building.

That distinction made the interaction much more enjoyable for me. There are still things I think prospective players should be aware of. First, that hibernation system is a double-edged sword. You're removing a card every time you shuffle. So, you need to keep recruiting enough cards that your deck doesn't become too thin. Pull too aggressively without replacing what you're losing and you can create problems for yourself. There's also some downtime. We noticed it even at three players because you can take multiple actions on your turn and there are quite a few things to consider. Another player's turn can occasionally stretch a little longer than I'd like. And toward the end of our game, I did start to feel like we'd seen most of what that particular session was going to offer.

Most frogs were deployed, long frogs were established, strategies were pretty clear. At that point, the game could start feeling a little samey while we waited for the victory point pool to disappear. One much smaller production issue, I occasionally had trouble distinguishing the frog icon from the lilypad icon. That's minor, but because those symbols actually affect the gameplay, it did cause a few double takes. I think that Pond is going to work best for competitive families and groups who enjoy direct interaction. If deck-building is already one of your favorite mechanisms, the hibernation system gives you a genuinely interesting variation on it. I'd also recommend it to players who enjoy area control games, but don't necessarily want something incredibly heavy.

And obviously, if adorable production is one of the ways a game gets your attention, Pond has that covered. The slightly ridiculous comparison I kept coming back to was Dominion meets Ethnos, but make it frogs. You're developing your deck while simultaneously using it to fight over territory. That's a pretty specific combination, and I think it gives Pond its own place. If you don't enjoy other players directly interfering with your plans, I'd be cautious. Pond isn't secretly a peaceful game underneath the cute artwork. You're supposed to attack each other. You're supposed to steal majorities, and someone absolutely can undo what you just accomplished. I'd also skip it if your favorite part of deck-building is creating an enormous deck full of cool cards.

Pond wants you to prune. If permanently removing cards makes you uncomfortable, the hibernation system may feel restrictive instead of satisfying. And if you're completely burnt out on cute little woodland creatures and adorable board game production, well, these frogs aren't exactly going to solve that problem. Pond surprised me. We don't usually reach for particularly confrontational games, so I wasn't sure how much I'd enjoy fighting over the same spaces again and again. But the scoring structure made that interaction feel temporary enough that I actually enjoyed the back and forth. And underneath that adorable production, I think there's a genuinely interesting combination of mechanisms. The deck building determines what you're capable of doing. That hibernation forces your deck to evolve. And the area control gives you an immediate reason to use all those new abilities against the people sitting across from you.

My biggest hesitation is the pacing. The downtime and slightly repetitive late game kept this from being an absolute slam dunk for me, but it's sticking around for now, and I'd happily play it again. Especially because I'd like to explore what the other factions can do. If your collection needs something cute with a bite, Pond is absolutely worth a look. So, now I want to know, how mean are you willing to let your cute board games get? Are adorable frogs allowed to ruthlessly attack each other, or should cozy-looking games stay cozy? Let me know in the comments. And if you enjoy reviews that help you figure out which games actually belong on your shelf, subscribe and join us for the next one. Thanks for watching, and we'll see you at the table.

Progress saved