Evergreen & Seasons Reviews - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm sharing my thoughts on these two ball games I'm going to take a look at Evergreen and also Seasons now these are going to be very brief reviews going to be shooting from the hip just so you get some of my overarching thoughts about them now before I get started on these reviews I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so let's start with Evergreen now this is a Wonder to four player game that takes 45 to 60 Minutes to play uh on average and from my experience that is accurate now if you're familiar with a game called photosynthesis that really did blow up maybe five or six years ago now and this one is directly inspired by that one and I believe it is the same designer but the difference between photosynthesis and Evergreen is at this one you have your own player board where you are trying to map these trees out as efficiently as possible to absorb as much light as possible whereas in the original photosynthesis you're playing on a shared board therefore making it way more Cutthroat and confrontational now I do like the clear objective in this game where you are simply trying to get as many light points as you can by absorbing the sun through this Ultra Cool thematic mechanism that I was always impressed with in the original photosynthesis as well as Evergreen which is so inovative where each round the Sun is going to rotate around the board and depending on the orientation it's going to to shine on the trees the
bigger trees will absorb more light but it will cause more Shadow to the trees behind it of course taking the size of those trees into consideration I love that mechanism it works so so well and it's clear a clean rule set and I really love everything about the way that mechanism works now there is also a degree of engine building here where when you take certain actions through the drafting of these cards your skills will raise um by moving up these little markers which will let you do more growth you know plant more trees even plant these little bushes and rivers which can help you grow things quicker and connect things together because not only are you getting points in this game by the light shining on those trees but also you're going to score points based on your biggest kind of cluster or group of those trees and those two mechanisms tend to butt heads because you know the closer your trees are grouped together it means that the more trees are going to be in Shadow now the way the game works here is as I mentioned used through this drafting system where you'll put as many cards out on display equal to the number of players plus one those cards will kind of dictate what actions you can take and where you can take those actions so you you can see on the board here you have this terrain broken up into all these different types if I took say a white card that means I can build in the white area now there are some exceptions when you get these bonus actions but that's generally the uh the rule of thumb there and there's also this cool mechanism which I really like and it's a general rule that I like in games which is when you are done drafting the one card remaining will go
into this pool which means that these little um symbols here on these cards will mean that every fully grown tree in that section at the end of the game will be worth more and more points if those build up so not only again are you getting those light points by spacing things out you get in the groups but also these endgame points by the means of those you know endgame cards that have built up which you really do need to take take into consideration and it can really mess with your scoring if you ignore that so I I love the the ownership you can take of your board here um I like the way you you can map things out perfectly try to score as maximum or as many points um as you can there's a good degree of kind of um initiative as well because you can try and snatch the initiative order to make sure you're going first next time um and stuff like that um and also the the card drafting in general is is a good idea to divert from that kind of pure abstract nature of the game because you're not allowed to just do free will and do what you want to do at all times because you are going to be pigeonholed by what those cards say what you can do and meaning that it's not going to be know repetitive and you can't always take uh the same strategy now this game also has a great pacing in terms of earlier in the game you get to take more drafting well you get to draft more cards in relation or in comparison to the later turns in the game where you get fewer and fewer turns so the guy game kind of squeezes you down as the board gets populated um with trees so you know mechanically I think this game is
wonderfully elegant it's so smooth and there's not much I don't like about it at all to be honest now when I mentioned the photosynthesis earlier that that a game I've always enjoyed but I always thought that it was a maybe a bit too ferocious for me a bit too vicious um and it had a few rough edges when it came to managing your player board and putting things on and off of it this one doesn't have any those kind of rough edges but I do feel like maybe it went a little bit too far with being a bit toothless because you know with photosynthesis is so ferocious this one is a little bit too forgiving I think and maybe a little bit a little bit too tame and whereas I would have liked to have seen maybe a little bit somewhere in the middle to get that perfect balance now don't get me wrong I think there's going to be a huge huge audience for this game because it is so pleasant to play um it scales well it ticks along at a nice place uh Pace it's um nicely produced I mean I think maybe people with bigger hands might find it a little bit fiddly you know moving little trees around but that is a nitpick and I do like that forward momentum of you know the gate your board filling up as well as your stats increasing as the game goes on but all in all this is a really nice family game um I know when I first played it I was super keen on it I'm rating about a seven maybe even a 7 and a half out of 10 the more I'm playing it the more I'm finding that I can get a little bit too much done for my liking I find it a little bit too forgiving being being able to just you know sprout trees everywhere and grow everything um and I would have liked it to been a little bit
tighter and have you know maybe allow you to tread on other people's toes a little bit more and be a little bit more in your face whereas you know it's a little bit too loose um for my liking but um it's a quality game you know maybe I'd rate it about 6 and 1 half out of 10 now I don't think it's going to stay around long long term um before those reasons but still a very good design um that I think you know more family weight orientated gamers are going to get a lot from this one so that is Evergreen okay so let's move on to Seasons this is a two to four player game that takes around 60 Minutes to play and i' would say the main kind of features of this game are engine building as well as a bit of dice drafting so it's a hybrid of a card and dice game where you're trying to get as many points as you can of course now this game does start with a closed draft where you'll be given nine cards each and you'll be doing like around rob you know taking a card and moving the remainder of that hand onto the next player and you're trying to build up a formation of cards to carry you through the game so as I said it is quite front loading and you are somewhat restricted by The Cars you've chosen before you even start the game itself um because they're going to very strongly dictate the way that your game uh plays out now there are ways to get more cards into your hand but I have to say that's probably one of my one of my nitpicks with this game is that I do think the flow of cards should be a bit easier to give you more flexibility and options as the the game goes on as well as I I think maybe it's a little bit too
restrictive in terms of you know giving you too much of a choice to make too early in the game with what you're going to commit to but other than that once you're past that initial draft I think this game flows wonderfully it has a nice sense of direction in the game as in each round you are simply rolling a bunch of dice equal to the number of players plus one you're going to draft those dice um which will dictate the actions that you can take or some bonus actions you can take and then you can go into playing these cards which will be basically you will buy these cards by cashing in these different kind of energy tokens so you can see that this one requires like a flame token as well as one of these feather tokens and the way that you the the main way you achieve or gain those tokens is through drafting these dice which you can see this one would say give me a fire energy token a feather energy token but there are some other symbols on these dice as well such as drafting more cards being able to um increase your limit on how many cards you can play in your Tableau uh which is a feature that I tend to really like in these Tableau building games and you can see here that this track determines how many cards you can play and which means you are drip fed the cards as the game goes on so you're not completely overwhelmed with your options to start with because you might not even be able to play anything until you raise this track so you can't just constantly play everything you want to at any time this game also has quite a nice feature where you can take these bonus actions to get you out of sticky situations by converting tokens into other tokens you giving you that extra
um space to play your cards Etc but each time you use those actions you're going to start generating negative points which is a nice little feature to kind of mul over but I I really also like this feature which um also featured in Evergreen where the remaining uh dice left on that in that drafting pool will determine something and in in this example it will show how many rounds or how many spaces around this wheel uh the round will turn and how these seasons will go because this game actually only lasts three rotations around the wheel and depending on which season you're in is going to show which dice are available to draft which means that certain resources are going to be more scarce or more common but it'll also show the value in which you can sell Surplus energy energy tokens for uh depending well depending on if you draft uh one of these dice based on if they have this kind of wheel symbol on it as you can see here so you can see in the winter phase uh the water and the feathers are going to be worth only one point each whereas the green one here the leaves will be worth you know three points each which is definitely a nice bonus and something to consider when it comes to those timings and when to hold on to tokens and when you get rid of them because again you do have a limit on how many of these tokens you can have at any time and as you can imagine with a kind of engine building Tableau building Style game the things you can do with these cards is quite remarkable you know the game does come with a a nice array of cards and if you get more expansion material it essentially means more cards to play with which is a good
uh option so you know you can see these cards do tons of different things letting you go filter through the deck know choosing your opponent and replicating their tokens they have so if you trigger these at the right time they're just gaining Straight Up victory points and so on and you know even some cards let you manipulate the dice some of them will let you um you know get rid of existing cars to fre up more space for you so you know the combinations are pretty much endless and they even combine with each other so the bonuses kind of um compound get even stronger should you wish to go a certain route so pretty much everything about this game I enjoy and I like that restrictions of the tokens you can hold I like the restrictions of the cards you can play the dice drafting is nice and tense because you really do need certain symbols at certain times and you do use your bonus abilities take that hit but also get to do what you want to do uh and finding those combos between those cards they're really nicely put together together get a nice flow here good decisions to be made as well now one of my main issues with this game is not the game's fault it is that recently a game came out called the veil of Eternity and this game has a lot of crossover with that game um but I think I prefer veil of Eternity quite a bit more because it's just a little bit more rained in I think it's a little bit more precise in the way that those cards work with each other now admittedly I am a much more experienced player when it comes to the ve of Eternity so I may not have unraveled the wrinkles of this game yet or discovered what what is yet to be
discovered and I'm willing to do that I'm willing to put the work in with this one because I see a lot of potential with this game system but I prefer drafting cards as you go rather than doing that you know initial um you know that initial close draft I find that a little bit too again a little bit too restrictive and puts you down a certain pathway now I do like the fact that you can put those in the PS you see fit so you know if you want some earlier benefits that you're going to carry through the whole game you can get those played instantly and carry these kind of endgame bonus cards that might be a bit more expensive and put them in your third pile so they won't get unlocked Until the End anyway so you know there are definitely ways to get out of those situations um but still I I'm not a big fan of determining your fate so early uh in the game but all in all um I can certainly see why this one has a fan base it's a really good little card hand management game nice synergies between those cards good decisions to be made um I love again love that remaining dice system that you can use to catch players of players of guard and you know Speed the game up if you wish to now again my biggest um apprehension is that it is fighting for the same game space as the veil of Eternity and I think that one because of being so fast and me preferring the ongoing draft rather than the initial draft I think that one is just going to Edge this one out but still really glad I've played this one and I'm going to explore it quite a bit more so that is Seasons okay so that concludes the video two very high quality well polished games here definitely a joy to play them both now I'm not entirely sure if these
games are right for me in my collection right now and Evergreen maybe a little bit too loose of me and Seasons being in direct comparison with another game but I'm still very happy that I got a chance to play these and I'm definitely going to I'll never turn down game of Evergreen and I definitely want to kind of sink my teeth more into Seasons finding those combos to see if this is going to be a real keeper or not but still hopefully these reviews have been useful for you if they have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye