Skip to main content
Loading video...

Catan Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 14:48

hello welcome back to another video and today we're going to be looking at an ancient game that changed the face of ball game in as we know it today and that game is the Settlers of Catan or was now called Catan for some bizarre reason and yeah in this video most big one I had placed an A but we're still going to give you the rules overview very brief will be telling you what we do like and what we don't like and then we'll come back and more tell ya our force on whether or not this game it's still worth playing and whether it's still relevant in twenty nineteen twenty four years after it was released in 1905 and I can't believe it's been that long but if you like this video please consider subscribing to the channel leave a comment in the box down below and we'll see you after this games so Settlers of Catan this is a year ago this artboard class Tauber and in this game you will be trading resources and you'll be building different things will be building different things on the on the map so you got this you've got lots of little hexes all all put in this frame and there's sea surrounds the island of Catan and you've got different types of of X resources like brick sheep wheat or and wood and every one of these

hexes has got a number associated with it so when you'll turn your beet rollin to d66 on advice and then you'll be looking for the number of the hex and then if you've got a settlement on the intersection of 100 texas and then you'll get one of the resource that associated with the dye number you wrote if you've got a city you will get two resources of the number that you roll you'll take the cards into your hand and then you move on Phase two which is the trade of fate and in this phase you'll be able to trade ask people if they want to trade different commodities support other come obviously you can say that you know do you want to trade ship for weeks right sheep for week any one sheep

Keep Calm Mike it look like we don't know what happened make you look like you done whatever yeah yeah yeah Oh cheap brick baba Papa blood and you'll carry on doing that into you could not go to trade no more and then you move on to the face which is the build phase and then your border for fees you could build your roads you could build settlements and then you can build cities and you've also got the opportunity to buy development Cullerton and you'll pay a different number resources and for each one of these buildings and all cards and then you will place them on the board you may score points rips out throws don't give you any points on their own but if you've got the longest road more than three sections then you will take the longest road card and it'll give you to vigilance settlements give you one victory point and cities give you two victory points and lobby said cities give you more resources if you buy commodity card you just different things in there this there's green cards that give you a one shot extra special ability and you've got yellow cards which should give you victory points and then you've got Knights in there that if you take three nights into your hand and three three or more nights then you will have the largest army in this these they're like the longer throughout these which it points will chop and change right okay and then Knights will also allow you to do something else which is the same as activating that Lincoln robber so if you roll a seven you will activate the Robbin it there's a little grey porn on the board and you'll be out

you'll to move the robber to it another hex and then the hex that the robbers off doesn't produce any resources what you'll do you'll take a random resource from one of the people they've got to set them on your city on the intersection that house and you'll take that at your hand and also if you've got more than seven cards in your hand you'll have to discard down to half and it's that stops you for important card so you gotta be mindful of whether or not the robber will be more for they're not yes because seven is the most common number you get this curve to do the testings done here or C 2 and 12 their least occur in numbers and 7 being in the middle is it likely to come up more so yeah what you kept looking and doing this until somebody's got 10 victory points and the first person to turn village of points is the winner there's probably a little few little things that we missed out obviously unitedplanet and a hill not I'm not here to teach you to suck eggs so yeah that's a rough rules I'll give you about to play pretend right so what do we like about Catan 24 years after its release the way the game start you've got these different hexes everything so you'd be placing these hexxit out in a random of all motions you're shuffling on you put them out random didn't fit in the frame so the numbers associated with the hex will always have been the same all over the hexes themselves it will be on a different order so that's a nice contrast thing going on with this day we love the fact that you start off with next to nothing and you see your empire grow and sprawl out and blocks people in and it's just

it's just a really nice feeling to if you have to spawn something nothing and for it to blossom into this wonderful well-oiled machine or you know what sure your opponents empires crumble into dust so there's that nice nice finger a numbers game where Big Ear Empire the more rewards because obviously there's more cities you get out of order the more resources you get but then there's that location factor but the more resources you get in the roller 7 and then you've got more chance of losing all those carts you you can acquire more but there's more risk of losing or so far for that the game length is just pop a just about perfect and it lasts for about an hour hour and a half at the most and the fact that you get more points as the game progresses means that the game sort of funnels out and then collapses in on itself it's the end zone so you will always acquire more points towards the end of the game so it's this it's this slow builder and then suddenly this is massive explosion of the people who are scrambling for the cities trying to get one last thing that they needed to take him up to ten points so the robber I mean a lot of people download the rubberiness but we think it's fantastic it stops your opponents from hoarding all in carts that you want yeah and you never know when it's gonna come so there's also there's also that gamble in that case you thinking if I keep these cars back do loads of stuff on my next cone but then the bank you saw he rolls a seven and the robber turns on and in their block the hex with your three cities on it so all that brick it was scarce you've been saving up it's gone so you've got off there's that nice thing going on where you could do one thing but then it just proved a random

luck which some people don't like it could turn itself on its head but us that's the people the beauty of this game if it's the gambling I spent the risk/reward element it's really high on this one so one of the other things that we really like - there's so many different ways to get rich of course you know you give vision and the longest road from having the largest army from just building settlements or building cities you know you've got the random victory points in the development Colin so this there's a plethora of ways to get rich reporting this and that means that there is a plethora of strategies that you can deploy to win this game and but the thing that stops there have been one major strategy winning strategy to this like games like Porto Rico where this is one tried-and-tested path is the random element is the dice rolling and the random placement of all the hexes so what don't we like one of the things that can be annoying and can still kill the game is if if your player serafall player came in you're you're in the middle of the initial placement when you place your initial settlements out I mean the initial settlement placement is key to winning this game oddly and if you're sort of in the middle you're not going to be able to place first out so the first supplier places faster than you go around and then the last player will place first in the second placement so you're stuck in the middle and you're not really getting the best of anything really so there's that I mean you know it's a minor con but if you're unlucky enough to sort of be stuck in the middle

with the initial placement it's gonna make it a lot harder for you to maybe do as well as you would hope he start it's almost like starting off a second second place in in a sprint you know another thing that I mean I don't particularly - but when it happens to you it's a real pain bump and is that people will going up on the leader when we play we always call the leader every one of the roles that we always say an unread will not just you do not trade with the devil all right so if the person is in the lead you don't try and when it's okay when you're on the other side of it but when it's happening to you and no one's trading with me up then is it can be really frustrating but on the flip side of that when you're not in the lead that's quite good catch I'm making some sort of a pro and a con at the same time so yeah the random dice rolling even though it keeps the game fresh and stops that one overall strategy from emerging it can be very frustrating because we've played games where Julian's initial placement all or whatever any card branch out with with a decent road network so so random dice rolling may mean that you might may go through portions of the game without getting anything and I think when they design this everything in terms of die wall and bell curves where things will average themselves out more than not I think what the designer was going to go for is

that everybody will get some kind of decent number settlement next to a number but sometimes I don't happen I mean some people call this a design flaw and it's a bad so on but I don't know I mean we've had good games and bad going so that's one of the causes you you never know when you can add that bad game and it might be the next guy into your pipe so in my personal experience of the playlist with four players then more often or not not always but born or not one player will always be left trailing behind and if you're all that player that can't get a little hold you boxed in too because there's not enough room for everybody I mean that's one of the people to this game is it's not enough room but on some occasions one player is always left with nothing I mean they don't get the dog ropes that they want they can branch out because I've been boxed in and they're not getting the resources I want they might have loads and loads of all at the beginning the game but they they meet that at the end but that you can't because you don't really need or we don't removing me cheap

really I mean then you're sort of yourself trying to climb up this this sheer cliff face John Connor and you just can't get out a hole whenever we play this going one of the one of the prizes and sometimes left behind and it's not very nice experience for them and it's not very nice experience for anyone else blue sea game is all about having fun on there it's not very pleasant to sit there picking so finally the final thing ticks me off about Catan is that it sense to get sort of slapped off now nice you know this game gets a bit of flack I mean I've seen comments online and all these forms and Facebook and wow they're so nice going mom saying you know it's a bad design it's rubbish don't like the tan blob and it suffers from the same sort of thing as Monopoly done it you know I mean I don't like monopoly I don't want to play it but I try my best not the slogan off look is that's one of the games that I played when I was a kid that thought it was a light bulb moment for me you know I mean I don't like the game is about this bad game but we played it when I was a kid and that's the sort of thing that I remember as a child to sort of play in these sort of games and I think people lose sight of the fact that this game is Settlers of Catan what's earth it was a game changer and it changed if it wasn't for Catan then you wouldn't be enjoying all of modern board games that you would be enjoying today Chris this game it's legacy is unquantifiable I mean 1905 nobody seen in four locking people playing games Avalon Hill games and I think the Hermit no playing whistle still and when this

turned up people are like oh my god never thought about gangs in terms of this before and there was no suburbs people essentially fameless' you know there was no use of characters of the game but the mechanics were it was it was totally new and it blew everyone away and it sold millions of copies and I really really get ticked off I'll get fed up with people having a garden of Catan just because it's it's old and I played it to death and they don't like it but my opinion is one of it should be an inflection everyone should have to push your players Catan if you haven't played it you need you'd need to blow this guy so certain as a concern 25 years 24 years off this release is it still relevant this is the workplane and to be perfectly honest with you I'm gonna say yes it is still still relevant still love it I love this game I'd love to set up your tent I've had so many laughs or this every time we bring this out we have an absolute blast I mean we've played it this is probably a game that we've played the most and it's probably the claim that we think the most giggles of you know because we were always every time we play this game is we're showing each other in good humor of course but Shannon each other everyone's laughing everyone's it's all these running gags you know that we've gotten every time we play those guys come out and you know it's a timeless kind I mean I defy anyone to turn manhood put their hand on their heart and then say they actually don't like this game order have never liked it thought we said this it's a masterpiece it changed the face of ballgame it and if you haven't played you really really

really really really owe it to yourself to go and buy a copy at least try it you know no hesitation recommending this one you know I love with sellers get ain't we all everyone are played at we have loves it it's just a real shame I guess it's a bit greater than that you know so maybe maybe that's just called a new but but yes and the content I serve to say no I think it's amazing that it played the support to death and still love it now but yeah so let's get an whole hide recommendation so it for you know air like we said please consider subscribing to this channel for more board games card games role-playing games anything to do with games tabletop gaming subscribe to the channel there's a five stick a comment in the Box down below and we'll see you

Progress saved