Personal Demons (C) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
So, final grade. Do I want it? Personal demons. Um no, I don't. But, I will say I thought I was going to hate a lot more than I did after a 4-minute 13-second video, which very very easily could have been cut off a minute, and probably should have been cut off 2 minutes. I think we could have an argument whether it's 1 or 2 minutes. I think for your fans, they'd say 1 minute. I think for everybody else, they'd say 2 minutes. But, at the end of the day, it still was fine enough. You showed me the outside of the stuff. You you're like, all right, it's a simple enough mechanism, the drafting mechanism. Um You have a solid track record. So, do I want it? Is Uh if this is your style game, then then maybe. I just Like this looks like the most Reiner Knizia Reiner Knizia game I've seen in a while. Like it's like Mhm. And that's fine. It's not the the end of the world. I just mean Reiner Knizia games generally no theme. Or pasted on. Do I want it? Not really.
But, maybe. Can you do it? Yeah, I'm not worried about that at all. You're making money hand over fist on these stupid crap you got down here. Like Yeah, hardback book. Now granted, they might not be making nearly as much money as the hardback books. But, those deck of cards, 14 bucks for a deck of cards. I work for a manufacturer. Let me tell you, it doesn't cost 14 bucks to make a deck of cards. Nowhere near. So, good for them. So, can you do it? Yeah, I'm not worried about that. Uh do I think this game is going to be amazing? No. No, I don't. So, I will throw that in there just as an aside, which is normally not what this segment is about, but it's just Everything about this kind of scares me of like, is this going to be a fun game factor? Cuz it's like if you're not there for the theme, like yeah. Do I want it? Maybe. Can you do it? Yes, but Yes. And how much is it? Um 33.
So, it's like we're looking at like an MSRP of like 60 bucks for this base game. And that Like yeah, sure, component-wise, you got these custom boards, which are Like I talk about this a lot. Like this is an impressive game I say this is not an impressive game manufacturing wise. This one is though. That board is going to be costing extra. Like, it's just it's an interesting shape board. It's got the stuff on the outside. It's going you're probably going to have to get to a pri- higher print run or something in that L. You have black core cards which is obnoxious and unnecessary and quite frankly stupid, but for 30 for 40 it it plays into your price, right? It plays into your price. I would honestly lean into that stupid feature you have more. Um and then, you know, you got you got you got free screen printed maples or the the wood pieces.
I guess is there just a shot that shows all the uh the components in the game? The pledge level? Maybe maybe was that was it? Yeah, you you didn't really have that one shot, did you? The long sexy scrolling shot that's like, "Hey, here's how many cards is in the Oh, here it is. Here it is. Yeah." So, how many cards are we actually getting here? 13 37 73 uh 100-ish 140 160 Oh, 34 Okay, so 34 of these cards. That that actually does make me more Build a mini engine? Okay. Where was this? Where was this crap? Where when you were shoving all your stupid artwork in my face, where were these 34 courage mini cards that actually make it look like there's some gameplay here and not just Oh, hey, I got to get three yellow symbols. Okay.
That right there. That right there actually makes me more excited for the game. 34 is a decent number, too. I just came around. I still don't Really, I'm not that excited and I hate the cut of your jib and I hate the fact that we're leaning so hardly into artwork, but do I want it is now I'll give it to you. I will give it to you. I think it's just my like that 34 a little bit better cuz everything else here has no text that's actually useful or valuable. So, final grade is
I'm trying to put aside my biases. And I still it's just I don't know. If I don't like artwork and I don't want your stupid crap, I don't know. It just feels It feels fine. Feels Feels fine. I'm going to go with C+. I think they could have done a better job spotlighting their track record because I do do believe that uh or at least the at least the awards they won on the one game cuz I'm pretty sure that Fishy game did win some awards. That's a nitpick more than anything. Uh the quotes sucked. I think overall those quotes were very bad. And leading off with a quote that just made me feel like this game is flavorless oatmeal of theme. They give you a quote where it's like, "Oh, like uh" I don't know.
And I honestly I think you definitely are to blame with that video. Cuz if I'm sitting here for four four minutes and 13 seconds and I am really paying attention to your video because I want to study and analyze it and see if this is something for me and I've just like, "Yeah, I don't see the actual game here aside from oh, put this here and it's going to be worth three points. Put this here and it's worth two points. Flip it over and I get to move this track three ti- like the decisions didn't seem interesting or fun until I was like, "Oh, but there's 34. So now maybe I'm sacrificing points but it gets cool special abilities and it's just C. I think it's a C. I'm having a hard time putting putting aside my biases. I don't feel like it sold the five to six player upgrade kit very well but I feel like it should like Here's the thing. I don't imagine that the five to six player upgrade kit add much time to the game. I would spotlight that. That's one of the beauties of drafting games is that a lot of times you can bump the player count up. Why do you think Seven Wonders is so popular?
Because even if you're playing seven players versus two players, it's not going to massively in theory increase your play time, assuming everybody knows what they're doing. Yeah, I'm going to go with a C. You could talk me into a C plus. You could talk me into a C minus, but I think it's a C. Let me know in the comments what your final grade is. Yeah, this description kind of sucks, too. I don't feel like the main image is very good, either. A spatial puzzle. No, it's a drafting game. It's a drafting game. I mean, yeah, it's a spatial puzzle, too, but it's a drafting game first and foremost. Like, that's your big mechanism. Um Yeah, C. Let me know in the comments what your final grade is. Yeah, C.