Great Western Trail Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about great western trail by alexander fister this one came out in 2016 to a lot of praise this one's extremely highly rated um i think it's just outside of the board game geek top 10 at this point this one accommodates two to four players takes two to four hours to play depending on that player counts uh the game takes place on this board here which depicts the old american west as you start off with your meeple here traveling up these tracks stopping off in these different stations on the way that can be your own player color or neutral ones or you might even have to pay a fee to pass other players buildings eventually getting to kansas city at the top here where you are going to deposit a number of different cow cards you've collected and the more different types you have the better because when you get to that point you can trade in um one of each different type of cacao for the money depicted on it so here i would get 4 7 10 12 14 15 coins so this is a this is a strong example because i should have said this game is actually what the board would look like at the end of a game this particularly is at the end of a two-player game you also have your own little player board here where you can collect these different types of um i suppose crew members you've got your cow cowboys you've got your builders and you've got your engineers and at the at the start of the game these would start with a lot of these areas covered up by these disks but they will get deposited as you go up to kansas city and
as you um as i said as you deposit your cows and get your money you can choose to drop them off at these different ports here either getting points if you get the um get a duplicate set like like this for example where if you go in albuquerque and el paso then you get an additional six points or even if you go to the lower ones the not so lucrative stations you can even get negative points for example if you go to topeka and wichita um the the the way you get up this track here is by paying from the cows that you've just deposited and for every x mark you got here you've got to pay an additional coin to go higher up this track so you are going to have to invest to go up this track but additionally at the same time you're always moving your train up um like this and say we've got quite far here because as i said this is at the end of the game but you would start right at the beginning um as you move your train up obviously those fees are becoming um cheaper and cheaper because you've crossed so many x's so already so the further you get along that track the cheaper it's going to be and you've also got the opportunity to stop off at these different little um little train stations here where you can get you can pay a small fee to drop off on your disks which will not only give you points but if you choose to trade in a uh one of these crew members then you can get additional end game bonus points here for doing different things which i'll talk about shortly so the actual um mechanisms of the game are extremely simple actually for a for a game that's quite involved quite deep quite complex you only do one thing basically which is
to go one two three spots along the trail at least to start with anyway so so this should be here the um yeah as i said you've got your little people here so you can either go one to three spots so i can go like one two three or just go one or so on because this is my place another player's building i couldn't actually use this building um i could only do what's called an auxiliary action which are the ones on your player board here which are either to get more money to swap cards in and out of your hand and as you invest in other things you can do um other quite cool things as well and and these buildings do lots of interesting things such as being able to um trade in specific cow carts to get money you can buy new crew members from the little market here where you'd start right at the top and they kind of fluctuate in prices and as you collect these people you add them to your player board which will let you do more things so the the cowboys allow you to rustle more castle from the market here this should be under this little um this little piece of the board here which decides what you can buy so for example with one cowboy you can buy one level three card for six coins with two you could buy a level three card for three coins and so on and eventually if you get loads of cowboys you can end up buying a couple of four cards for say eight coins or five card for six coins and those those cows are really good because not only do they offer you more variability they can also give you quite a few points at the end of the game um so that's what the cowboys do the
builders allow you to build buildings and put more buildings onto the board for example everyone starts with a setup of buildings like this um some of them have already been put on the board of different values so these these show the buildings the amount of builders that you need to have in order to build it um but um additionally they give you or you can put these onto the board anywhere if you can afford it because because for each building level you have to pay two coins and again they give you points depending on how many builders you get on the board and the engineers which you can see this player hasn't invested in at all um will allow you to move further along the train track when you take that action so for example here if i went to this building um for every engineer i have i can move my train along the board which is what i personally invested in in my example over there um so whenever i went there i'd actually move quite far along the track so let's have a look at some of the other things you can do so for example you go here which is one of the starting buildings where you can um get two coins for every building that i've got in a forested area so as you can see some of these some of these areas i've got trees on so if you're touching one of those trees you get more points if you go here you've got you can trade in pairs to get money and move your work or another spot along the trail you can upgrade your little um little ribbon here which is like this little track here which offers you more coins when you get to kansas you can take objective cards and the objective cards are over here which again give you something
to work towards such as you know having a number of four cards and collecting these tp's and dropping more disks off and so on um and the cool thing about quite an interesting thing about these objective cards is when you take them they actually go into your cow discard pile um like so oh i haven't actually got a discount pole here but if you if you did have a discard pile they go in there and then when you draw them you can choose to commit to those objectives and get an instant bonus but if you don't fulfill it by the end of the game you actually suffer negative points which is something to be wary of um you can also take tps which have this kind of fluctuating market here so as you put more tps onto the board you can get you can get more money and not only is that good because you get to um you get the money itself but because some of these objectives require teepees some of the areas have these um blockages as well these hazards which if you go to certain spots like this for example you can choose to remove one of those houses by paying a fee and getting the additional points which create new routes as well so you can kind of navigate around other people but if you if you ever come across a building with a black or a uh or a colored hand like this you have to pay a fee either to your opponent or to the bank which is um quite interesting so you can put these buildings in some quite um quite well used routes and get a bit of an income that way and so on so that's what you're doing really so as the game develops more and more buildings are going onto the board which creates a
bit of a a longer trail and you have to think about more way where you're going to stop you've got to think about when you're going to go to kansas city to cash in your cards when you've got the best hand of cars which is a particularly good one here you've got to decide on when you want to invest in your in your player board because as i said you can you can go here which lets you move more spots which i've fully unlocked here or even go here where you start with a hand of four cow cards but the more you invest in these in these different um points here then you get to um have a larger hand where you can have up to six cards which can really pay off big time so that's going to be basically how the game is going to work um you know as you get further and further along this track you can go to these different stops here and get more points down um and so on so there's quite a few different routes you can go down um so that's going to be how the game's going to flow so let's talk about and what i think about the game so first off i must say i'm i'm really impressed about how actually easy this game is to teach i was expecting something a bit more involved a bit more complex and it's actually surprisingly intuitive because all you actually do is as i said move one to three spots along the track and that's simple in itself and of course you know you get lots of different abilities by going to these different buildings but they're all simple you know take take a take one of these crew members and put them onto your board do you um you know go along the track and you can decide to go off to these different stations you can you know do very simple things and sometimes you're just taking those auxiliary actions which are quick and simple and so on so actually the the thought decision about what you're going to do or at least mechanically is not
difficult whatsoever which is quite which is quite interesting um can when you get when you get to um kansas you've got this quite uh ongoing tension where you want to tinker your um your cowl neck as you're going along trying to get all the different cards you can manipulate the deck as much as you want as much as you can really because some of these abilities let you say ditch off cars from your deck which can get rid of the duplicates which is a good thing because if you have duplicate cards then you are not going to score for that duplicate you're only going to get money for each individual card so having lots of different types is good so for that reason you know if you're going to certain spots here and you have two white cards for example you can choose to get rid of one for the money so that that's quite interesting as well so you're always trying to think about what how many cards you have because that is going to be your income for the future rounds which you're going to invest in doing lots of different things such as said buying new car cards buying new new staff members buying buildings to put out so yeah there's quite a there's quite a cool economy here where you do want that flow of money in order to do what you need to do so i do like that so lots of interesting decisions here boiled down into some pretty simple mechanisms i think it's all that's a pretty intuitive the only thing that may be a little bit out there is this um when you when you do cash in your cows and get the money is paying those additional fees to go up this board here but still simple enough and i do like the way that you are incentivized to go to the higher regions by getting the pairs and getting um you know the additional
points additionally you can always you can't go to any one of these spots more than once you can only do it a single time per player but the san francisco one you can do as many times as you want and for each disc you got there you're gonna get nine points but at the same time if you go to the kansas city spot by you know you might have to do that if you don't have the money and you haven't invested in moving your train up the track then you are going to have to um you get you get money but you're going to lose six points for each disc there so you i said always incentivize to go as far as you can up these tracks so let's talk about some of the um other issues here so or some of the things about the game so balance wise i was really impressed by this game because escape this game for example um is said a two-player game i've gone for a a completely engineer route there as you can see and my opponent here has gone for a very cowboy orientated route um we did very different things we played very different ways and you see i've really invested in the train track here by dropping all these things off um this player's got loads of cow cards so we said done very different things but at the end of the game there's actually only one point in it for this for this um this particular game which is quite interesting so i do like the way that no matter what route you go down whether it's focusing on those buildings focusing on the engineers focusing on the cowboys or um you know or doing kind of a more mixed approach you um you know you're going to get a fair result of that so i do really like that you know how how these different approaches um do weigh up at the end of the game is
very fair which i like the um the mechanisms in the game as i mentioned pretty clean and i do like the way it is so easy to explain and it does give that feel of a heavier or at least a mid weight to heavyweight euro game and usually those kind of games come with a lot of exceptions a lot of um fiddlier rules ones that aren't so intuitive and this one really doesn't have many of those it's it's very straightforward but it still does have that meat on the bones which makes you think outside the box and make sure you actually weigh up what you're going to do with your tongue so i do like that it's that it's done a great job of blending the complexity with the simplicity and um that's that's not to be sniffed out really um time investment probably one of the only issues i have with this game is that it does take quite long for what it is um i i've heard a lot of rumblings over the years this game does take a long time to play and personally myself and my brother who i play with generally um are really quick players we don't we don't have any analysis browsers really we get through things really quickly um for example in this game here we we didn't take long at all with with our turns very snappy and the game still came in probably just over two hours which is quite long i think um and on that longer end of that scale that i'm willing to sit through um it did not say it's welcome i will be honest that in that way it always did feel engaging there was always lots to do but um yeah that time
stamp is going to be a bit of an obstacle to overcome the uptime as i mentioned is is pretty quick actually because the actions are simple yes some buildings come with you know lots of choices for example here you know you can do either of these two or one of these some buildings even come with three options like this for example but all the actions in their own right are simple you know just trading a cow by potentially two staff members one with a additional fee on so they're pretty they're pretty simple actions and they're not really much too you know to get really paralyzed about so i do like that and the uh the replayability as well is pretty decent at the beginning of the game you're giving um a setup of these buildings and they used our dual siders so you've got your a setups and your b setups and every player is going to have the same the same array of buildings available to them so that offers a bit of variability there because you can play with all the a's or the b's or any kind of mix up on those you can focus on different things from game to game by unlocking different objectives or different um these abilities you can focus on different um different crew members you're going to get you know different different objectives available to you and so on so there there is quite a lot of um variability there as well again additionally with these end game bonuses here you can choose to invest in different things and go for just try different options so there is that but there isn't a tremendous amount of um set up variants uh the neutral buildings do say you know for the first game put them in certain spots and from then on you
can mix them up how you like which will which will change the feel and game the feel and flow of the play and kind of change your decision process but pretty similar from game to game um the interaction is limited i mean there is some tension in terms of getting the staff members here but generally it's just a few kind of power or a few coins in it if you want to get to those more cheaper spots getting to kansas um it's a bit of a strange one really because you know you've not got attention of getting to the different places because you everybody everybody can go on each building at least once um and whoever gets here does get to choose which new kind of people to put out and which new buildings to put out um tps and stuff so there's not a tremendous amount of player interaction um only with um kind of the market and stuff you know getting the cows that you want and also getting the or crossing people's other buildings as i said if you if you stop or pass someone's someone else's building with a hand symbol on it then you're gonna have to pay them a fee which is um which is quite an interesting amount of interaction i do i do admit that and i do quite like that but overall there's not a tremendous amount of interaction as i said aesthetically i like the way the game looks it's um you know it's got that old western feel to it which works well i think the the game mechanisms themselves suit the suit the theme yes it's not a not a thematic game but no it works well with what it does you know wrestling with these castles sending them off to kansas selling them
and so on so that works absolutely fine you know investing in your cowboys to make wrestling cheaper your builders to build things cheaper or build more impressive buildings at least or your engineers do actually travel around that train track quicker so you know the theme works and it's pretty um you can you can tie it to the mechanisms in a in a reasonable manner the um component quality is way up to scratch i mean there's some good there's some good the cards are good quality the board's good quality these tokens are good so completely up to scratch here um it would have been nice if the playboards were a little bit thicker but no real issue there as well you know it just stores all your disks and things but yeah components are absolutely fine and um in fact they're pretty good um the setup and teardown time not much of an issue again you've got your different kind of level discs or different tokens here which go in these um different spots but um yeah it's no real issue to set up at all and um you know very proportionate the progression of the game is a strange one because the game actually ends up stretching out as it goes on longer and longer because the trail will start with only a few buildings on you know just those neutral buildings and as the game goes on more and more buildings are going onto the board meaning that the uh each turn or each kind of track across the map is going to take longer from time to turn as more buildings are put down which is quite a bit strange uh pacing and i think it does work quite well you know as the game goes on the the more interest in those in those
spots all the stops you're going to take actually do um come into fruition so i do like that in terms of the in terms of the pacing and progression you know you're going further along the track making things cheaper but at the same time getting to those more important train stops and so on so and also again your deck building gets better and better as you go on as well as you as you accumulate more powerful cows and um also increase your engine in terms of actually the the staff members you gather so it does have a nice progression um you do feel more powerful as you go on you get more and more money from turn to turn so yeah i do like that quite a bit uh the scalability works absolutely fine i mean any player count this works fine i would hesitate to play four player simply because of that additional um time it's going to take because i said it it does take probably two to probably four hours at a stretch really a four player game but um it's um i i would hesitate to play more than three players for that reason because i don't really like playing much more than um you know much more than two hours already so yeah bear that in mind you know if you do like sitting down for a longer play account or a longer game then maybe bear that in mind the comparison wise this one is often compared to um maracaibo um which is my personal favorite alexander fister game i think the reason for that is because of the almost rondelle nature where you're going down a track
stopping at different spots you know that's very you know in aligned with maracaibo but i must admit i didn't feel as strongly as a um connection with that game as i thought i would um which is a good thing really because i like you know games to be as unique as they can really so i do definitely think this game holds stands in its own right and um i would certainly say it warrants having both of them because they're certainly not as closely as i said not closely as connected as i thought they would be um but i say this game is much easier to teach than maracaibo um which kind of leads into my final thoughts really so let's get let's just get my final opinion on the way so i i i will admit i i was slightly um underwhelmed for this game and not not because it's bad or anything like that i think it might have been a slight victim to the immense praise it's received over the uh over the years you know extremely highly ranked um and for that reason you know and obviously i love alexander fista games in their own right um i was expecting this game to be an absolute masterpiece already and it is rock solid and there's absolutely nothing wrong with it whatsoever i will say i i do prefer maura kaivo quite a bit over this one um but objectively i can see why this would take off more than that because go back to the my thoughts at the beginning of the video really this one is so much more intuitive much simpler to explain a lot of it plays um you know takes place on the main board itself where you
can you know that simple mechanism going one two or three spots or potentially more if you invest is is where this decision space lies and i think that's a bit more accessible a bit more inviting than all the exceptions and all the different tracks and side objectives you get in in a game like maracaibo so this one's a lot more straightforward but it still gives you that impression of that medium to heavyweight euro which i think is quite a nice balance and something that's going to appeal to way more players and i will put myself in a bit of a niche where i like that extra level of complexity almost extra layer of fiddliness really to give the that extra kick whereas this one just holds those reins back a little bit more to give you a more balanced approach in terms of being having still having the strategy and the tactical decisions but still having as few as exceptions as possible to make the game's uh game's rules a lot clearer to the average person so i do like that and i certainly think that's why it's taken off as much as it has done so yeah overall um i i do like the game i think it's really impressive i enjoyed it a lot my head i like all the different elements all relatively straightforward um but i i will say that it didn't quite live up to my expectations of it now that still is way higher than your average game you know alexander is a tremendous designer i would put this somewhere around a seven or seven and a half out of ten where i would per say maracaibo um at
a nine or a nine and a half out of ten so said it a lot of that is probably because it was a victim of its own hype and a lot that's on me but nonetheless rock solid game if it does appeal to you you are going to like it i assure you you are going to like it and i did enjoy it and i don't want to underplay how much i did enjoy this game it is fantastic but it just didn't quite hit those heights of um of maracaibo and even mombasa i think i prefer mombasa over this one as well which is which are strange because again they are quite significantly lower rated on number game geek than this game but hey everyone has their own flavor and you know this is still a rockstar game that gets my shield of quality so that concludes my thoughts on great western trail um i hope um you've enjoyed the video if you have please hit like and subscribe to the channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye