The Hungry Gamer's Shiver Me Timbers Gunpowder Exp Mini-Preview
Transcript
Ooh, that looks tasty. Welcome folks to the Hungry Gamers back with another mini preview and today we are talking about Shiver Me Timbers, the Gunpowder expansion. And Shiver Me Timbers is a game that I covered I don't know, three, four years ago. During the pandemic, I think. And the video you're about to see up there, that's actually from my original video where I talked about the core how to play. I'm not showing the new stuff off in this video for the most part because it's all still prototype and the original stuff just looks so much nicer, especially when you think about the cool toy ships and stuff you're moving around and all of that. But as a reminder, Shiver Me Timbers is basically Sid Meier's Pirates in board game form. I mean, it really captures the vibe of Sid Meier's Pirates. The only thing it doesn't have is the dancing that you could do. Everything else is there.
You're even still potentially getting married and all of those different things. So, it still covers all of that. And back in the day, I said I really enjoyed that cuz I loved Sid Meier's Pirates. I played a ton of it. In fact, I wonder if it's like on PS5 that I can get it. Like, what a great, great game that was. But I loved that game. I played the heck out of that game. And this game really does capture a lot of that. It has And then it has this awesome toy factor as you upgrade your ship, you actually pull it apart and you add more hull, and you put more cannons on it, and it's very, very silly and very, very cool. Just awesome toy factor, fun game. And truth be told, I don't know what happened to my copy. Clearly I lent it to somebody and I never got it back. And so, funnily enough, when it came time to do this preview, the designer asked me if I would cover the expansion. I said I'd love to. I don't know where my copy is.
And there's not a lot of copies out in the wild. And so, he actually sent me, from Germany, a Frankensteined edition that has English cards in it and some actually some upgraded bits that I didn't actually have originally, some metal coins which are awesome, and in a German box, and it's I love it. I love that this is the edition I have now. But, anyhow, the core of what I'm going to be talking about in this video is the new stuff that it comes with, and then I'll talk a little bit about kind of my overall on the game now that it's been a few years since I played before I played again. And then, obviously, I'll talk about my quibbles, which will mostly talk about my quibbles with this specific expansion, though a couple of things from the original as well. So, with that being said, let's jump into the new stuff.
And the new stuff is kind of broken down into a couple of different three different modules for the most part. You have the Pirate Republic expansion where you have this big three-piece island in the middle. And that starts with nothing on it, but you're going to start there. That's where everyone starts. And throughout the game, you can build up this island, build towers on this island, and each tower as you build it, it's going to do something different. And the things that it does are going to be things that normally you would have to travel very far to get to. So, there's that. And then there is the exploration module. And the exploration module simply means you don't have the board pre-built. You start with nothing, and you can take an action and do a build, and you put out a sea lane and an island at the end of it. And if you take the long sea lanes, you're going to wind up getting some extra gold that goes with it.
And then also kind of baked into that are the allegiance tokens. And on each island, there's going to be two tasks that you can potentially do. And if you do these tasks, they'll be worth points, and also they're going to be a thing that you're going to be able to use to help build up these towers on the main island. There's points to be given for people who actually help build these islands who actually help build these towers. And they're to be used at the end of the game for the third extra module. The second extra module will be in the exploration, but the third extra module, which is the voting. So, at the beginning of the game, what you're going to do is you're going to decide what is your allegiance. Are you a royalist or are you a pirate republic type person? And based on each allegiance token that you have, you're going to get to vote what it is. And if multiple people have allegiance tokens from a single island, you're going to kind of compete and if you disagree, then there's like the little paper rock scissors type thing that you can do, which can cost you points as you try to get the allegiance as you want it.
Then, if you pick the right allegiance for whatever the majority of the islands are at the end, then you're going to get 10 victory points, but you made that pick at the beginning of the game. And then the last thing, I mean, there's lots of little things in here, but the last thing in here that I really want to highlight that there is is there is a solo mode, which is kind of a two-part solo mode. You have just a challenge mode where you're playing by yourself, you're going to move around and try to accomplish certain things within a certain amount of time. And then there is the life map thing, where I'll talk about that in just a little bit as well. So, with that said, what do I like about this new expansion? First thing is within the just small things that are added, there's new events that go into the event deck. And there are these bounty cards, which has specific pirates that you're hunting down, trying to find. And you do that and the first person to do that is going to get a reward. And there's also other kind of contracts that stay out until someone does it.
Again, you do it, you get a reward. Those are fun. They're not just this thing happens and deal with it, but there's things that kind of change the state of the sea until someone deals with it. Next, the exploration overall, I really do think it's very, very cool. I like that you can kind of pick where it is you want to go. I like that you're rewarded for taking the harder routes, the longer routes. I think that's really cool. I also think the allegiance bit is cool, if for no other reason than it's giving you things to do at each island. So, now it's not just a pick up and deliver, but now there are other things that you're doing within this pick up and deliver. And so, ah, you need this specific thing at this specific island. You do that, you're going to get their allegiances going with points, which I really, really like. Next thing I'll say is the whole voting module is really clever in that, as I mentioned, you have to make a choice at the beginning of the game, and you can kind of make your choice based on vibes, really. But, you're going to make this choice at the beginning of the game, and then getting it to happen. That means you're pushing the accomplishment of these different allegiance tokens on the map, which kind of pushes your strategy. This is what I have to do in order to make this thing happen. Really, really clever, but then you also have that idea of, well, maybe I'm just not going to pursue it.
Maybe I'm not going to worry about getting my thing because I can get more points doing all this other stuff. Or, I'm going to grab these allegiance tokens, and I know that I'm kind of ahead of the game here, and this person's close, so I kind of think I know what they're trying to do, so I'm going to try to send these islands traitor or whatever, so they're not going to get those points. It's a clever little bit of interaction that you have beyond just the fighting each other, which I've always found not very satisfying to fight other players in this game cuz it's kind of overly punishing, and you're definitely giving somebody a leg up if you do that. But, I like the way it kind of all comes together, and it's it's an exciting thing to get that 10 points at the end. Next thing I'll say is I love that there are souls there. I think the solo kind of sandbox challenge mode is pretty clever. It just lets you kind of just play. Just very quickly, just kind of play and get that feeling, get the experience theory AI for when you're fighting something. It's a little bit wonky to get your head around, but once you do it, really is pretty darn easy. I like the way that it works. It's very clever. It's still being developed, but I do like where it's going. The other one is the life map, and I I printed this not quite the right size, and I laminated mine so I can just put little dry erase marks on it. But, the way this works is you're starting over here as a young captain, and as you do things, and it all tells you down here what they are, is you're going to be moving over as you age, as you get older and older, and you're moving up as you get more successful. And these little gray spots here are little There's tokens there that when you land on those, they're going to flip over, you're going to get something, and you kind of jump over those things. And so, by the time you get to the end, you want to be as high as you can. And actually, over here,
what I printed this the wrong size, there's things that kind of tell you how successful you are. It's kind of a beat your own score type thing, but the way you do it is kind of fun as you're kind of moving across this little map. And I like it. I really like the way that works. It takes a beat your own score and makes it a little bit more interesting. So, with that said, what are my quibbles with the game? I'll start with the solo mode. The solo mode I really wanted was a bot. That's what I really wanted. And understandably, I'm sure logistically, really hard to figure out. But, it's not a bot. There isn't AI for the combat that works, but there's not a bot to where you just have someone else kind of running around out there, another ship to deal with. And more importantly, it's not a bot that you can put into a two-player game. Cuz that is my next thing. This game is best at three plus. That's where this game shines. And to my mind, the expansion, I think, exasperates that a little bit.
Exploration feels very slow with only two players. Now, I do know that they're thinking of kind of changing the rules a little bit for two-player, but as written in the current iteration, the prototype, exploration becomes very slow cuz you're using an action and so on. In addition to that, I think the voting module is just not as interesting with only two players. Cuz either you're going totally against each other, or you both want the same thing, and it's obvious immediately. And so, unless you're going against one person, which is kind of interesting, but again, I don't think this game is at its best as a head-to-head game, unless you're just going cutthroat against each other, the voting becomes less interesting. It's when you have that third or fourth or fifth player in the game, that's when the voting gets really interesting. And along with that, one of the things that happens with the Pirate Republic is you get to build, once you've built up all the towers, and there's special pirate forts that go there, which are really rewarding, but harder to kill, and you have to have at least two players to attack them. Not as interesting in the two-player game, because again, if we're just going against each other, well, we're both going to get that success in some way, and it just doesn't quite work Again, I know they're working on changing some of the rules for two-player, but as I said, I think it exasperates the desire to play this game with at least three players.
And the last thing I'll say is, and I definitely mentioned this originally, it takes up a ton of space. You start putting out those lanes, and it looks really good, but it takes up a ton, a ton of space, and it actually takes up a little more space now when you use the exploration module, cuz you have to have space to put all the stuff out, and space to put out the market of the things that you're trying to potentially build. So, it takes up a ton of space. But, with all of that being said, it still captures that Sid Meier pirate vibe. I still think it is one of the best pick-up-and-deliver games, and I think this expansion makes it better, cuz you add those allegiance tokens, you add those pirate hunting quests, and all of those things, and suddenly, this pick-up-and-deliver has a little bit more meat to it, and a little bit more direction to it. It's not just I'm going to get some rum here, and then go sell all the rum over here, where it's worth more points, or I'm going to pick up this thing here, so I have what I need to go do this treasure hunt. Now, there's little things you're really driving towards as you play, and I think that is fantastic. I think the Pirate Republic thing in there is very cool, cuz you get that big island in the middle, and suddenly, you've built this thing up, you're going to get points for building it up, but now you can do so much cool stuff at that island, which kind of takes away the need to go all the way across the map. All these things I think make the game significantly better. I think it's a really, really good expansion.
And I'm pretty high on it. And so I think if you are someone that is nostalgic for Sid Meier's Pirates, this is one for you. The I think if you've been looking for a pick up and deliver game, this is one to check out. I think it is a really good option. If you like pirates in general that romanticized pirates that that we all love, I think it's really fun. And I especially think it's one to pick up if you like the idea of that. And in general, you're going to be able to play this with three or more players. And then every once in a while, just bust out the life map or bust out the challenge sandbox cuz it's a fun little mode. It It really is. But there you have it, folks. That is the gunpowder expansion for Shiver Me Timbers. I was high on it back in the day. I'm still high on it. I don't plan to let anybody borrow my copy this time cuz apparently they don't come back. But there you have it, folks. As always, if you found this video useful, please like, subscribe, share, maybe become a channel member. As always, thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful, wonderful day.