Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ethnos - Additional Thoughts & Review Q&A

Transcript 10:30

hey what's up everyone this is Jack from the cardboard Herald and we're doing something a little bit different today this is me recording the end bit audio to RTC BH reviews podcast where normally I talk about little extra thoughts about the game and additional thoughts about making the review whatever it is except this is a video forum and that's in pockets normally about a written form it's all very complicated but the point is that today this is a video that will also supply the audio for the end of our TCB H reviews podcast featuring ethnos one of my favorite games one of the critical hits of 2017 so sayeth the cardboard Herald aka me well I guess Luc was also in on that but the cardboard heralds critical hits of 2017 included ethnos nonetheless so this review was a trip to go back over and read because I still hundred percent stick by how incredible ethnos is and think that it is a modern classic that is deserving of so much more accolades so many more accolades then it actually got like here's the deal is I think that this game whether by intent or by accident is a incredible subversion of fantasy area control gaming and it is wonderful and how it delivers that from the artwork

juxtaposed with the little tiny Lightning skittle disks to the whole idea that it's a race versus a TAC game in how you're actually competing over the territories how it's like a 40-minute game that looks like it has the shell of like a three hour game is all very cool and at the time that this came out I didn't have I guess like hunt for the ring another one of our critical hits of 2017 and so this was the most tolkien-esque game that I could get my hands on that played a high player account that that could deliver the feeling the uber of this epic high fantasy yet in a very short period of time and yeah there are some other great area control fantasy games I mean the the the elephant in the room is small world because that is the other really lightweight friendly approachable fantasy area control game but at the same time small world is more silly it pokes fun at itself it doesn't have the self-serious nature that ethnos has while at the same time being self-aware or hopefully self-aware of what it was enough to kind of again subvert your expectations so it was cool going back and seeing that I still

completely agree with whoever wrote that review in other words me but it feels way smarter than me because I sound a lot smarter when I'm actually writing my words instead of just rambling on like I am to you right now now the other thing about this review that I thought was worth talking about is I really struggled with how I wanted to discuss that that grandiosity of the idea of subverting a classic fantasy area control gaming trope like I was like God do I just sound pompous and just like I'm some art critic going like oh this subverts all of your expectations that you have for the genre and I decided you know what be authentic go with it if that's how I interpret the game then that's what I want to go with because I go into games to enjoy them I don't go into games to criticize them I I want to get the best out of a game and this game totally felt like how I imagined playing bigger war games as a kid when I'd see the all these cool packages at the store and eventually I would play them and they would deliver notes and feelings and tones that I kind of tired of overtime and while I still will just sit down and play some game of

Thrones second edition with some friends if I have all the time in the world and I feel like I'm up to feeling like I completely betrayed all of my friends and feeling guilty over a win that was probably me just taking the advantage over someone else's stupid move or more likely than anything else just completely getting flattened well yeah I still love doing that but it's not fitting into my daily life that often it's not part of my routine schedule and so this is just a cool thing that delivers what has the tones over of that big experience into a much teeny tiny or smaller package and that's cool that's great I played a coffee shop I talk about that a lot where I like games that feel big but I can play at a coffee shop because I spend a lot of time at coffee shops at least once a week I'm gaming at a coffee shop here in Juneau and so I want something that can fit that niche and even better if it actually feels instead of just aping something bigger it feels totally like something bigger the other thing that is worth noting about my experience with ethnos is maybe the the only aspect of it that I've grown more tired of and that's that certain races don't always work well or some races play together better than

others I still like the game no matter what combinations come out I do advise that people when experienced play with random set ups taking the the cards that are just great ordered and they are one of each race and coming up with your own random setups but there is a little bit of curation that might occasionally need to happen if you're playing with something like elves + wizards + centaurs then new cards are ever going to hit the the market or you know people are just going to make frustrating combos or I guess Wizards aren't necessarily part of that but elves and centaurs and fairies the Pomo race and that's another thing I try not to hate on promos I appreciate promos but a whole nother race as promos I can't get behind that that's kind of yeah whatever I wish fairies had been packed inside of the game they're cool they're not absolutely game-changing but still making something exclusives that gamers out there really want to buy that they really want to get their hands on but it's something that's only available at exclusive conventions or for backers or for certain portions of the population not a fan power to the people put it into people's hands put it back up on bgg so that way people can support BoardGameGeek that's what I'm saying

make it available to the masses hear me cool many are not all of my power as a cardboard Herald post I think that you should bow to my whims and make sure fairies are available to everyone that said I'm in a position of privilege I have fairies but I had to get them at a convention just like everyone else and yeah so that's it I still really like this game I think the review is kind of the evolution of what I wanted the cardboard Herald to be where it was commentary on not just is a game good or bad but why why is this game cool why is it a value because that's very authentic and true to who I am I want to find why I value something and I nearly always try to find the value in something or someone that doesn't mean that I'm automatically saying something is good I don't find everything good but I try to find what is value what is of worth what is worth discussing what is interesting about any individual person place or thing in this case a board game so that is my additional thoughts on ethnos this video may be completely hated by everyone does ramblin mess that no one wants to put up with and maybe this is a video that you absolutely adore I want to know in the comments if this is something worthwhile something that is of interest to you I definitely do much more put-together

reviews both a video and written form that you can definitely experience if you want to hear the review that I was talking about you can find it on TC BH reviews which is on Google and iTunes and stitcher and all the podcasting stuff you can also find in our website cardboard Herald calm as well as the written version and this video itself is just kind of an experiment in my continuing documentation of my experience and and review thoughts and and journaling I don't know vlogging I guess I'm vlogging congratulations welcome to the cardboard Herald vlog but if you don't like this crap there's always the much more structured stuff I never pretended this was anything but my rambling so welcome to the cardboard Herald let me know what you think let me know what games you want to see reviewed let me know what you thought of the review and please do all the social media stuff if you found lists of help if you found this charming if you found this likable then do all the stuff chair like subscribe definitely subscribe that helps us out a ton and go check out the other stuff I've been jack for the cardboard Herald huge fan of ethnos and you keep on gaming

Progress saved