Hegemony - Board Game Review - Help! Help I'm Being Repressed!
Transcript
come and see your father's inherent in the system help help I'm being repressed bloody peasant hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences so in today's episode I've got a doozy of a game one of the biggest most time intensive games I've had to invest myself into in past recent months but this is just recently fulfilling off Kickstarter now and it is hegemony it leads your class to Victory and I know that's the pronunciation because I've heard of voicemail from the designer say so but the idea of this one is that I was tempted by this one at first when it came out on Kickstarter but I wasn't certain if I was going to get into a asymmetric roll game where every player plays a different faction and style of play to everybody else so I kind of held back on it despite the fact that the the concept and the theme sounded interesting not that I'm into politics or anything I never get involved in politics but just the idea that a game where you've got inter-class politics going on is that's a bit different from most games but also because of one of the designers Vangelis Badger Takis this is a book who I know also who has done some work on Pursuit of Happiness one of my favorite Euro games of all time and
so I was like oh okay something new from him I want to check it out but they offered me a review copy again thanks for that and it's taken a while to get into this because um it's a big game it's quite a big game asymmetric rolls heavy best made with three or four from what they say a lot of rules and I do mean a lot of rules we'll get to those later but essentially what you're doing in here is that you take control of a class system so working class capitalist class middle class or the state government and each player has their own means of scoring victory points but they play a different style of game the capitalist is out to make profit with companies the working class wants to get their people employed and help them prosper and so forth and by the use of action cards each player is taking it in turns to perform various actions and interact with the other players because as one player does one thing it's gonna influence what another player does it's pretty big there's a lot to get over and to be honest it's probably best if I just get on with it foreign the nation is in disarray and the economy is failing and political tensions are rising the working class faces a dismantled welfare system the capitalists are losing their profits the middle class is gradually fading and the state is sinking into a deep deficit hegemony is an asymmetric card-driven board game in which players take the role of a specific group working class middle class capitalist class or the state itself each player plays differently and tries to pursue their own agenda the capitalist class runs
companies workers come to work for them and produce Goods which they then sell for profit the working class has workers who work in exchange for money which they use to cover their basic needs such as food health and education the middle class also has workers and smaller companies and acts as a bit of a hybrid of the capitalist and working class selling and consuming in order to cover their workers needs and increase their prosperity and finally the state is trying to increase its legitimacy working hard to keep all the classes satisfied and in Balance will you help the state try to keep it all together together or will you try to enforce your agenda no matter the cost to the country of course at the end of the day the one with the most victory points of course thank you the main thing that you need to understand is that this is an asymmetrical roll game so every class is playing differently from everyone else you have your unique stuff that you use you play differently you have your your unique cards you have your own mechanics in some respects there's overlap for sure more on that later but much like games like root and Merchant's Cove and crescent moon and vasta Crystal Caverns these games usually also had you playing your own faction now you need to gauge whether you are comfortable with that sort of play before digging further into this game because if those games were hard for you to get to the table because of their unique roles then this might not be the game for you but if that was one of your big pulls towards those games I mean root has certainly got its fans I'm indifferent on it but it's
certainly got a fan base then if that was comfortable for you then this is possibly going to be up your street as well of course taking on a much more serious theme than something like root did so let's get one thing straight already this is a heavy heavy game okay this is a 35 Plus page rulebook it's got a lot of information in here you are playing four unique classes okay and your classes also have a little reference guide yes but you can also have the big reference guide we have a sheep devoted to entirely your class there is a lot of stuff going on in this game you need to be aware of this and also the fact that it's asymmetrical meaning that your roles are different so just because you know exactly how your class Works does not mean you know exactly how the capitalist class works for example but as much as I have to give that caveat so that you know what kind of game you're getting into I Gotta Give perhaps where it's due this game does a fantastic job of making it as accessible as possible for the heavy gamer now when I say accessible I do not mean that a mid-weight gamer or a light gamer is going to have any chance in picking this up it's not gonna happen all right this is a gamer's game through and through but a lot of heavy games can make it a chore to get into and I've had to invest a lot of time to learn these rules I've got to learn four factions worth of rules a 35 page on rulebook how the intricacies and how they work and how the capitalist exportation is different from the middle class exportation
there's a lot to get down and you can trip up very easily but man this game does a brilliant job in making that process as smooth as it can it's a curve it's a learning curve but it's a curve that you can Traverse it's not like a sheer Cliff it's just right I've got the equipment I've got the climbing gear I can get up this mountain it's not like the mountain is sheer and all you have is a couple of little suction cups and that's your only means of getting up the mountain this is definitely more accessible partially because the rule book as much as it is a lot of text and not a huge amount of pictorial representation which is kind of something I would have liked to have seen more it is a well written rule book the rules are not ambiguous and they're sectioned out in very good ways you start off with all the components then you've got the player boards and the setup and it's a clear setup diagram step by step then you've got the main rules to the game you've got individual player set up and then the individual sections for those players it's a very good rulebook but then on top of that you have got these brilliant player aids for each player and it may look like a lot but basically this is just regurgitating what's in the main rule book for that player so if you want to know properly all the rules that are associated with your class in all the phases of the game then this rule Aid will tell you everything you need to know but then if you just want the shorthand version you've got little leads as well you've got one for the main game sequence and all the taxation bits involved but if I'm playing middle class I can just look at this and go oh
I see that's how you build that's how you say oh yeah I remember now and these are brilliant it may take up a bit of table space but honestly they could have if this didn't have those AIDS oh my God this would be a bit of a chore to learn the fact that they've put in the effort to really come up with some good high quality reference AIDs that do what a reference age should do for a game like this it's brilliant add to that the graphic design as well the graphic design is Crystal Clear minus a couple of nitpicks and I do mean nitpicks you have to track your wages on company cards with translucent cubes and it can be a little bit hard to see what way to level each company is a little nitpick and I would have also liked to have seen on the export cards some indication by color that a deal that it gives you is a good or bad one because the price is fluctuate little nitpicks like that but otherwise I mean the board itself is already a really cool Stark board it's this really good mix of black and color I always mention that white with color is a good mix but there's something about black with bright colors everything is popping on here I can clearly see policy table blue companies yellow companies grade companies State events you know Public Services immigration site everything's Crystal Clear even your player boards you know they've got individual layers they've got individual sections and you can tell that these two are fundamentally different from the capital storm which is even more fundamentally different from the state one but nothing is like you never look at this board and
go I don't quite understand what that symbol means or I can't quite tell what this means or I can't see where the companies are it's all crystal crisp clear and yeah okay it's not filled with glorious artwork everywhere you know it's not got pictures and photos of everything although the cards have got some really good art they're some good photography artwork on them but it just looks cool when you've got this fully set up as you'll see from the pictures the color just pops out of there and this is a theme that's not exactly lending itself to being aesthetically pleasing but it such a good job and all of these things come together to make it a much more accessible heavy title you've got screen printed meeples for the working class and the middle class good wooden screen printed multiple colors they don't come with a Plano box I've used that for Speedy setup but you've got pretty decent quality cardboard tokens for the resources that are clear as day to distinguish and see the numbers translucent cubes to track things you've got more cubes you've got color cubes yes I know cubes aren't amazing but they are nice distinguishable colors and also bright you know they're good quality you've got screen printed markers in fact really and even the cards are cool you know there's some decent photography artwork on these but they're good linen finish quality I've saved mine because I don't trust Gamers with my games half the time so I'm like okay I'm gonna sleeve it but honestly you could get away without sleeping this game and you do pretty well even the player boards they are
dual layers they've got little slots and everything's in there and everything's just clear and crisp man they went to town on the good production quality here and the rule books and the player rates again lend that really the only component I'm not the biggest fan of is the money the money is cardboard tokens and little cardboard little circles that's probably my weak link for the money but honestly that is why well I'm not gonna get it for the purpose of this video but you've seen me use the iron Clays and various other means of money on my pictures and stuff I use iron Clays to replace the money and most people who have it will as well but like I said the money is not terrible it's not paper money but compared to the rest of the components here it's probably the weak link but honestly if that's your weakest link with everything else that this game has all the cards and tokens and meeples and bags and everything that's a small problem really thematically this game is just on point apart from a couple of really minor abstracted principles that you have to do in order to make the game work this game is really doing a Justice to this theme the interaction is is where it comes through mainly because it's not just simply saying oh yeah the capitalists want to make profit okay fine the state wants to keep everything in Balance okay fine the policies make sense with where they want to be for the various classes you know the capitalists want low wages they want low tax they want to it's health and education to be expensive so that people will buy from them flip side to the working class the working class wants High wages because they want to get paid more they want High tax because they want the the rich people to pay their fair share you know
case in point Great Britain um but they also like the fact that the state could fund free healthcare I mean we have the NHS in the UK for while it's working and education if education was free that'd be fantastic as well so it makes sense What policies each class was but here's the real meat of the theme the interaction with the players if you're into the sort of thing that oh yeah yeah euro is always multiplayer Solitaire and it doesn't matter what they're doing play this and tell me that let's get is one of the most interactive Euros I've seen and it's not necessarily negative interaction yeah there's occasional times where you might weaken another player by strengthening your own that's just kind of part and parcel for the course but there's also positive interaction you know a player produces a bunch of goods well now you can go and buy them off them granted it's giving them money but then you're getting the goods you need in order to do your thing but just the way that these classes interact in the game you are constantly interested in what everyone else is doing nobody is just sitting on the back line just going well I'm just going to do my thing here and are you doing that whatever you know it's not important no if the capitalist is sticking a bunch of workers I could stick into my middle class companies I want to know if the state is about to go bankrupt I need to know because it's going to cause a reset of policies the working class wants companies to open well the working class can't open them they need to get them to do it well you know why haven't you built any companies right I'm going on strike and doing demonstrations in order to force your hand to do it
the gameplay itself is really solid you're going to be here for the long run more on that later but I love this card system it's not quite multi-use but it does force some pretty difficult decisions you have a decent selection of cards again all unique with all the other players but you have seven in a round and you're only going to use five of them in the round you hold on to the other two for later but you either play it face up so that you can do the special action or you discard it in order to do a basic action and the basic actions are still useful you can't underestimate them but it forces you to look at the options that you have and think well that would be cool but then maybe I should do it later maybe now maybe that's the right time but then you might think well I need to do a basic action oh great which card do I get rid of then I mean am I going to do that am I going to do that and it's tense choices just with this card system let alone anything else you're doing you know do you need to open up another company is it worth getting the workers as the working class suddenly like got a bunch more workers at work well can I get them before the middle class nics them the state constantly looking at the other three players to kind of think well capitalist is kind of running away with the game here I need to start helping these other two okay here's some state benefits for you too all right okay that'll bring it back in that's all good and everybody else just doing similar things this game is meaty through and through but it feels smooth once you've got the rules down and that is going to be your biggest hurdle the rules front it's a lot of investment but you are certainly gonna get your money's worth in terms of the meat involved all your decisions are important scores are
tight I've had multiple multiplayer games and a bunch of solo games and in all the multiplayer games specifically the scores have been super tight like barely a few points in between first and last place for the most part and even if there is a bit of a gap there's still like a one two point difference maybe between first and second place man this game feels very balanced you know from the plays I've had solo varies a bit more we'll get on that later but yeah it just it feels smoother than it should be you listen to all these rules you see all these age you see these big backs with this theme on it and you think that the game should be a massive clunky grind Fest it really isn't once you know what you're doing this game does go at a nice smooth clip even if it does go on a little bit long foreign well yeah this game is quite a long Affair you are looking at a minimum minimum three hours with a free plus player game you could get it done in less time with two but and certainly solo but even then your first few learning games are gonna be a bit of a slog you're gonna need the time you cannot think that this is gonna be something you're just gonna get out quick firstly the setup is long there's a lot in here I mean I showed you the setup diagram there's where is it there we go set up set up set up all of that is set up there's quite a few steps to follow and that's just the main board that's not even individual players who have to do their own setup then the game itself five rounds doesn't
sound like a lot a lot of stuff happens in those five rounds you've got five action cards you've got all the production you've got the taxis you've got the wages you've got the covering your needs and then you've got the elections which multiple policies might need to be voted on and then you've got preparing for the next round there's a lot of stuff happening each round this game is gonna take some time and that is a little bit of a downer I do wish that the game was a little bit shorter but linking back to before there's a lot of good decisions and you are invested in what everything is and everything that's going on that even though it will feel long it doesn't feel like you've wasted your time I you might check your watch now and again thinking oh you know we have been here for a while but at no point am I sitting down for this length of time and going I'm bored or I wish this was over and for a game this long to be able to do that that is saying mean something but you gotta put in the effort it's gonna be a long one to play it's gonna be a long one to set up and it's going to take you multiple iterations of reading these rules to get used to the game 40 seconds but I wanna know there is also a little bit of a luck factor with some of the stuff in this game and it is a long game so you need to be prepared for that mainly though it comes from a couple of things the drawing of certain cards like the immigration deck or even just your own action cards can have a bit of an influence on what you're doing you might want certain companies to appear at your deck and they don't appear you might think well I know there's certain cards that would really help me out of my deck once you're more familiar with the game and you don't draw them until the end when
you would rather have them early those sort of things are going to happen but you usually have good options during the round even though it's not the main thing you were hoping for the main aspect of luck though which is gonna be something you're gonna have to consider is the voting bag the idea with these policies is that you basically have different numbers of cubes in here based on what players have done and then you draw five of them and then these cubes are basically put on the board in order of sort of like yay and no and then you can do a closed fist building with influence cubes to affect the vote but what you're drawing out of the bag is entirely random and these could be critical changes the policies that you're after and you might just not draw the cubes that are yours even though you might have twice as many cubes as other players and you just might draw theirs well I didn't vote for you you're gonna have to accept that that is a factor now it is mitigated to an extent because let's say on this scenario you know the the blues and yellows clearly win this vote well they just go out to the bag permanently and this one goes back into the bag so it mitigates future elections in your favor if you have lost but you might have really wanted the particular policy to go forward and you might not desperately need it for later these things will happen it's an aspect of the game and you need to be comfortable with that of course it's not fair and the damn good thing too now yes players I've played with have mentioned this but it's never bothered them to the extent where it's destroyed the experience for them but you have to accept that this is not entirely skill based I mean the better players will generally win I can
guarantee you that but occasionally the cards maybe the voting bag and the last specs like that are gonna host you at times give the like a ball break the vote and we'll be back to cavorting Druids death by stoning and dung for dinner with asymmetrical games comes an element of locality issues this is another game you're going to get to the table on a regular basis for the most part because of the long setup and because it's pretty much mandatory to get people to read the rules ahead of time before you start playing you try and teach this to randoms from scratch like I tried to do once you're gonna be there for a while you're not gonna have a voice afterwards people need to do their research go watch Paul grogan's tutorial and play through that we did live you know to learn the game because trust me you're gonna need it you want players to prep in advance and trust me the game goes a lot smoother if you do but it's still not a game that you're going to get to the table that regularly because of it so you might think well I bought this huge game and it's just sitting on the shelf you can play it with two three or four players two player is okay but I don't think it shines as much at two players you only have to work in class and the capitalist and I feel like you need at least the middle class in there interacting with the two of them to make things a little bit more interesting toughs at the top plebs at the bottom and me in the middle making a fat pile of cash now some people will say they only to play this with four because they want the state player in the game the state player is fun but best either given to the teacher who can concentrate on helping everyone out all the relatively new player who doesn't want a ton of
actions to have to contend with because the state does have a little bit less to do than other players which is a slight bit of a downer you know a middle class has got all this stuff to juggle around in the state in comparison doesn't have a huge amount but maybe the player just wants to do that maybe the player is just happy to sort of oversee the game and maintain order and to be honest me as a teacher can have a good amount of fun as the state player you know because I have familiarity with the game and I understand who I should be helping at what times but it because they don't have as much to do I can teach the game better but that being said three players I didn't notice a massive deal about not having the state player in the game you lose a couple of things like state benefits and events but losing that didn't really detract from the enjoyment three players and four players still works great thank you now I want to mention the solo mode because the solo mode is not in the base set of this game this is the extended edition which includes an expansion called crisis and control it will be available separately on retail but it does mean spending out more money for it but that is where you get the solo mode or Tom knows from there's a couple of other little mini modules in the expansion which I haven't really played and touched up on but I want to talk about the solo mode because this makes a big difference to your enjoyment of this game because the optometers are basically a unique deck for each of the three main classes so not the state but the other three and you can play them in two ways simple and advanced AI the idea being that you flip a card over and you
follow whether it can do any of the four actions on it it's got a couple of other little bonuses depending what they do and there's a default action if they can't do any of them and you can play it simple or Advanced simple is nice and easy you just go through the card check the conditions and you go with it but the advanced one involves you having to mess around with these little tokens and little markers and priorities and then you check conditions and you move the priorities up and down and once you've done all that fast then you work out which actions at the top and then you do it that's too much effort for me okay it creates a smarter AI yes but it's also a lot of time investment okay much prefer the simple Ai and I think that's how you should use it but the great thing about these is that the simple AI once you're familiar with the game is not difficult to Pilot it doesn't take a huge amount of time but you can slot them into multiplayer games so you could have a two-player game with the working class and the captain's class and the middle class is the autonomer or you could mix it up a bit three players could have a state human player providing say the working class is an autumna so it grants you additional flexibility and I have played several games of the solo mode two free I've not tried it all four but I have done two or three and again 90 of them with the simple Ai and it works really well it improves the replay value tenfold because now you can be flexible with your player accounts but it also May means that for a game that's really hard for me to get to the table I can get it to the table because if I feel like a free player game of this and nobody wants to play it with me well then fine I'll play the working class and I'll just have the capitalist and
all time there and the middle class Autumn though I'll pilot them both it's going to be a longish game but the game's already long anyway but I now have that ability for me and the fact that they're unique decks means that the solo AIS will behave slightly differently in each game depending on what cards come out in what order it's a really cool clean system hegemony for me has done wonders frankly it is definitely got the same issues that a lot of asymmetric roll games have for me the fact that they are very difficult to teach they're hard to get to the table they require players to do research which is not easy to find a group that will do that it doesn't make them easy to just bring out to random people on the game night you need to prepare for this like an event type game and you know that puts me off games like root and crescent moon a lot and I was worried it was going to push me away from this but what attracts me to this one more is firstly the theme integration being fantastic everything about this game is really doing Justice to the theme and setting it's doing enough that I can just have fun with it you know we're calling capitalist scoutman we're calling working class peasants you know we're doing it in jest but that's the sort of banter that comes out with this game and that's the sign of a good theme but then what helps this one along is the sheer amount of effort that went into making it accessible A good rule book even if it is a bit text heavy but these fantastic reference AIDs that do wonders I mean you you give each
player a reference Aid and they're semi-familiar with the game and they'll be able to pretty much self-teach themselves these are so good the clean graphic design the the you know the the focus more on making it clear crisp and easy to see what's going on rather than make it too busy again does wonders for this game I didn't get anywhere near as much enjoyment from games like root or vast when playing those asymmetric role games I've not played Merchants Cove or crescent moon yet but those ones I thought were fine but I didn't feel like I was doing a ton of interaction with other players you know occasionally we're bumping into each other but here you're constantly interacting with the other players and there's a lot of overlap with the factions you know some of the classes have got rules that overlap with others which means that you're a little bit more similar than you feel but yet you are still different you've got components that are really cool I mean yes you are going to want to sort of prep some like quick setup means but the stuff that comes in this box is good quality you are definitely getting your money's worth in terms of information and components and just the amount of gameplay that you're going to get from here and the unique different cards that you have for the factions games are going to play out very differently each time there's a lot of really cool stuff here if only it was just a little bit easier from a practical perspective but I need to give this game two ratings really because one rating I have is if you just have the base game and not the expansion and I need to give it a rating for the expansion as well because for me it makes a massive difference for the main game it really is enjoyable it really is
a great system but the practicality issues of getting it to the table the really long length the fact that it's not easy to teach to randoms and that means that the Mark is brought down a little bit because it can't be like amazing amazing if it does have those limitations but through the expansion in it's a different story the main game of hegemony is getting an 8 out of 10 for me a great rating a seal of endorsement that I think lots of people are going to really enjoy this as a meaty heavy game with asymmetric roles and I really do but if I didn't have the expansion with the solo AIS that allow me to mess around with the different player counts and just play it by myself the replay value would be limited but add those in and it makes a huge difference to me with the expansion crisis and control the rating for this goes up to a 9 out of 10 and becomes a seal of Distinction you need to consider what it is you're hoping from this game are you prepared to put in the investment are you prepared to learn these rules do you have a regular group you can play this with and are you interested to play it solo what your answers to those questions are are going to make a huge difference to your enjoyment of this game so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see please thumb it up on YouTube and thumbs up on Board Game Geek when the video goes live what are your thoughts does this interest you have you played it what are your thoughts on the different classes yeah do you like the solo AI idea are there other games you would compare this to by all means get the thoughts down below and I'll do my best to respond when I can until next
time you can check out more content on the channel including the recent reviews I did for Obsession the big other game which certainly got a good following and the last top tens I've been doing on the Casual two-player games and next step two player games until next time remember as always regardless of which class you are at the end of the day whether you're capitalist scum or their working class peasants it's still only a game bye for now
foreign