Tapestry Review - Chaz Just Played
Transcript
is the game tapestry a tightly woven civilization builder or does this game just come apart at the seams well I just played it so let's discuss my experience with the game tapestry tapestry is advertised as a 2-hour civilization building game for one to five players designed by Jamie Stagg Meyer in which players govern and grow a society starting at the very beginnings of humankind and reaching into the future civilizations will start from nothing and then advance on four different tracks one for science technology exploration and military to earn progressively better and better benefits the players can focus on a specific track or take a more balanced approach by spreading their advances out among multiple tracks along the way they'll also explore a central map to discover new lands as they spread across the board and as their civilization progresses they'll increase their income construct their capital city leverage asymmetric abilities earn victory points and play powerful rule-bending tapestry cards which all together will unfurl the story of their civilization so there's a brief overview of tapestries premise but does this game deliver on that premise in short yes mostly and I suspect that each time that I replay this game it will better
deliver on that premise each time that didn't really make a lot of sense so here's some examples of what I mean the simplest example is the game length my very first game was a 5 player one where four of the five players hadn't played before and that first game took about three hours from start to finish not counting the instruction period now does this match the two hour time frames stated by the publishers description of the game oh not exactly but I am absolutely confident that experience with the game will reduce the length of future 5 player games down into that 2 hour range once we all better know what to expect and that knowing what to expect it seems to be the general theme of my experience with most everything in this game huh that was pretty good and now that I know what to expect next time will be a lot better that was me doing my impression of me playing this game for the first time so the game was a good experience but but it wasn't the experience that I was expecting to come away with especially for a game in which a player has just two seemingly simple choices to make on their turn either play a card or move up a space on a track using just those two actions players will build an engine of combos and rewards in order to power their civilization and powering their civilization that was another aspect of this game that colored my experience with it I went in looking forward to
building that civilization but midway into the game I soon realized that I was playing an engine builder instead surprised and while that is not a complaint by I by no means the only thing that really made my civilization feel distinct to me was the unique faction card that detailed their special abilities essentially my civilizations personality was the exclusive combo that it could perform fancy and speaking of those different factions one of the primary concerns about the game that I've encountered is that the various factions may seem to be unbalanced to some players there's actually even an online spreadsheet that's been published to track the win-loss statistics of each individual faction and in that spreadsheet clear leaders appear to be emerging I'll include a link to the spreadsheet in this video's description if it's something that you'd be interested in checking out for yourself in our first game the factions that we had in play were the futurists the nomads the merrymakers historians and the craftsmen and our results actually pretty closely matched the exact same pattern charted in that spreadsheet except for the performance of the nomads which I played and who scored much worse than the be charted average so good job for me there cuz apparently no chart out there is gonna tell me how poorly to the game I also do want to mention though that while the futurists did win our game by quite a large margin that
faction also was controlled by the one player who had played the game before so that players additional level of experience very well may have had something to do with their final score which actually does bring up a point that I wanted to mention about the balance or potential unbalance of the various factions I wonder a little bit if it's possible that some of the factions actually lend themselves to a very specific strategy which actually may take a while to discover and use to its full potential and you know if so until the player does actually unlock that potential well perhaps their performance with that faction will suffer but once they do figure it out well then BOOM their scores gonna do much much better each time they play that faction that I don't know could certainly be the case here however based on what I read online combined with my own experience now no I wouldn't be surprised if a future addition or expansion included some sort of update to some of the factions in order to introduce some sort of tweaks or rebalancing of a few of them in addition to those factions which we all know and love so much another way to customize one's civilization as you played was with the use of these tapestry cards which would introduce either a one-time effect or a special ability that would last throughout the age now playing a tapestry card moves the player into their next age and those ages are important because playing a tapestry card moves the player into their next age and each player's game ends when
they reach their fifth age and so this allows the player to control when they advance and get more resources and have other special abilities trigger and unlike the faction abilities which seemed a little hit or miss to me nearly every single tapestry card that my opponent played made me leap to my feet and loudly complain how overpowered that card was people like it when you do things like that because it shows to them that you're engaged in the game these tapestry cards introduced a subtle element of timing that I found real interesting if you go out and you advance your ages of your civilization too quickly well you may earn some immediate benefits but you also risk running out of steam too early due to not yet having constructed a fully operational engine to take advantage of the resources that you require in other words you you drive your engine too far too fast you're gonna run out of gas and stall out early this individually controlled pacing of progressing through the ages can also have some really interesting results and our first game wound down with one player left with an entire - ages remaining for them to play out so they had the entire game to themselves like the last 10 to 15 minutes while they played out their final turns of course as a result the rest of us who had already finished our last turns did experience some downtime while they did that since since we were all done but that downtime actually wasn't too bad since it was near the end of the game and for some of us we already knew that we had lost so we were
able to go go get a corndog and once my corn dog was finished and the game was over I was left with the fundamental question would I play this game again well yes I absolutely would but I would certainly go into the game with different expectations than I did that first time yeah as I mentioned the game felt more like an engine builder than weaving the tail of a civilization to me yeah I never once felt like I was leading a great nation to conquer lands and do my nefarious ill will instead yeah I felt like I was hunting for combos to exploit in order to gain resources and then trigger bigger and better combos which you know is fine and fun but you know it wasn't exactly what I was expecting so if you go into tapestry envisioning a SIV building experience like a clash of cultures or a Gaia project well then you may be left a little disappointed but if a sturdy engine builder that expertly weaves together some territory expansion interesting card play and layout planning if all that interests you well then tapestry is definitely worth giving a try I tried it discovered it wasn't quite the flavor that I was expecting scored quite poorly still enjoyed it and I'm looking forward to scoring quite poorly at it again add a little bit of divine intervention to your dice rolls with either this dice or devil angel pin strapped to your lapel lanyard backpack
or other penile surface roll with grace and confidence with either one of these one inch and nano pins by your side