Can You Restore the Forest AND Beat Your Opponents? Treeline Board Game Review
Transcript
Imagine a world where civilization has taken over the forest. Towns have spread across the landscape. The trees have disappeared and the natural world has been pushed aside. But now it's time to restore your ancestral forest. In Treeline, you're leading a clan of forest folk, working to reclaim the land, turning towns back into forests and establishing your influence along the way. But there's a catch. This is a competitive game. So while everyone is working toward restoring the forest, only one clan is going to come out on top. Treeline's a competitive strategy game for two to four players from designer Christopher Chan and Burnt Island Games who sent us this copy to review. It was on my Essen top 10 list. So we're going to dive in and look at the gameplay and whether I would keep it on my top 10 list or not.
The first thing you're going to notice when you first set up Treeline is the large grid of cards in the middle of the table. This represents the landscape you're trying to restore. Each of these land cards begin with its town side showing. Flip it over and you're going to reveal the forest which has spaces where your clan tokens can be placed. And that's really going to be the heart of the game. Uh you're gradually transforming this landscape from a developed area into a forest while trying to position your people in the most valuable locations. On your turn, you're going to choose two adjacent town cards and flip them over to their forest sides. As the forest expands, you may even cause additional town cards to become isolated, forcing those areas to be restored as well. But here's where things get interesting. You're not the only one who gets to benefit from the land you restore. After you flip the cards, you get to place your clan tokens onto one of the two cards and then the next player gets the opportunity to deploy their own clan tokens onto the other cards. So even though you're the one choosing where the forest expands, you're opening up opportunities for others. And that creates really interesting and gameplay decisions. Which two cards should you flip?
Which card are going to choose to place your tokens, leaving the other for your opponent? And perhaps, more importantly, are you creating an opportunity for yourself or handing someone else an advantage? Your clan tokens are your influence. Normal tokens provide one influence, while energized tokens [clears throat] provide two, and you have a limited supply of all your tokens. The last part is important because as the game progresses, you're frequently going to be needing to move those tokens from one part of the forest to another. You can't simply spread your people out everywhere and expect them to stay there. Sometimes you're going to have to abandon one card to strengthen your position somewhere else. The ultimate goal is to claim castles. At the end of each row and column of the grid is a castle with a point value. When an entire row or column has been restored, the player with the most influence in that line claims the castle. Once claimed, that castle belongs to you for the rest of the game, but you have to give up a clan token and put it on the castle for the rest of the game. And if there was a tie and you won, you have to put two clan tokens on that card.
Other players in that row or column get to energize one of their tokens. So you're constantly balancing where you want to invest your influence, which areas are you willing to give up, and when you want to push for control of a valuable castle. And the value of those castles do matter. Some are worth more than others, so simply claiming a bunch of them isn't necessarily going to win you the game. Now, Tree Line includes a learning game that leaves out one of the more interesting additions, the Glades. Once you're ready for the full game, you're going to introduce three randomly selected Glade cards into the landscape. These work much like the other land cards, but when they've eventually are revealed in the forest, uh they're going to be introducing special scoring opportunities. And here's the cool part.
These Glades aren't owned by any particular player. The scoring effects can benefit everyone depending on how you positioned your clan tokens around the landscape. Some reward you for having tokens nearby, while others reward particular formations or arrangements across the grid. This gives you another reason to pay attention to where you're deploying your tokens. You're no longer just looking at the castles at the end of the rows and columns. You're also looking at the opportunities that might be created in the middle of the forest. I like that these are randomly selected because the scoring opportunities are going to change from game to game. It gives you something new to consider rather than simply following the same strategy every single time you play the game. Now, there is a couple of things I think are worth considering before you jump into Tree Line.
First, the mechanics are more prominent than the theme, in my opinion. Uh it can feel more like an abstract area control puzzle than an adventure through a woodland world. Now, that's not necessarily a bad thing, especially if you enjoy strategic spatial games, but it's something to keep in mind. If you're coming to the game primarily for the theme, I think it's not as much there as the uh mechanics. A small critique is the setup. You've got quite a few cards to place in the grid, and some might have a little issue with trying to keep all those cards lined up perfectly. Another [snorts] thing is that your turn can create opportunities for your opponents, and this is especially true in a four-player game. Your final score is based on the points you and your partner earn from the castles you own, but during the game uh the majority is based on your clan tokens for those rows and columns. If you play with a partner who isn't strategic, then they might not win as many castles as you like or flip the cards that are super helpful uh for you all and probably going to help the other players.
All right, let's move to things I liked. One of the things you uh first notice are the cute little clan tokens. Uh they all have different designs and fun little names like the Stumplings. I appreciate Tree Line for the interconnectedness. Um you're not just placing workers and trying to collect the most points. You're actually changing the landscape as you play, and every time you restore a section of the forest, you're changing the opportunities available to everyone at the table. And because players get to deploy tokens into the spaces you're going to reveal, uh there's this constant interaction between you and the other players. You might have a plan for a particular area, row, or column, and you have to and you have to consider what the other players are going to do with the opportunities you've created. I also like the limited supply of clan tokens. It forces you to make some difficult decisions. You can't simply occupy every valuable space.
Sometimes you need to pull people out of an area to make stronger plays somewhere else. The energized tokens are a nice touch too because um being able to increase a token's influence adds another consideration uh to the competition for those castles. I also like the glades. Uh they're a worthwhile addition to the game. Uh they create additional objectives that encourage you to look beyond the immediate competition for those rows and columns in the castles. Uh there's a satisfying spatial puzzle here, and the landscape gradually changing in front of you as the game progresses is pretty cool. I briefly mentioned player count earlier. I think I like this personally at the two or three player count because everyone is competing individually for the castles and the highest score is going to win.
Uh not sure I personally like the team play for four, but some people might like it. The four player game uses a larger grid, 8 x 8 grid compared to a 6 x 7 for two players, and you got the 7 x 7 for three players, and I think that all works well because the board scales with the player count, and I really like that. So what other games might Tree Line remind you of? I think there's a few that maybe have a useful comparison, although Tree Line is its own combination of mechanics. If you enjoy spatial decisions and positioning like maybe Kingdom Builder, I think you'll uh appreciate some of the decisions in Tree Line. Uh you're looking at a shared landscape, trying to position your pieces in the right places and thinking about how the board will develop as the game progresses. If you enjoy more abstract strategy games like Go, um there's some similarities in the way you're thinking about influence, positioning, and controlling sections of a shared playing area. Tree Line's a lot more approachable in how it handles all those decisions, but the same sort of spatial awareness I think is really important. Overall, Tree Line is an interesting strategic game that takes a fairly simple central idea and builds some cool decisions uh around it.
Now, I like the way the landscape changes uh throughout the game. I appreciate the tension of competing for castles, and I think the glades do add some welcome variety to the full game. So, I personally Well, I would keep this on my top 10 Essen list. Uh yep, I like area control spatial puzzle games, so it's definitely my type of game. And I like that it plays fast. If you enjoy area control games where positioning matters, where decisions affect everyone else, and where you have to constantly adapt to a changing board, Tree Line might be worth adding to your collection. Well, that's my look at Tree Line. Thanks so much for watching this video. Please subscribe to Change Your House's YouTube channel, and we'll see you next time.