Skip to main content
Loading video...

Coal Baron : The Great Card Game Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 14:00

hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm talking about coal barn the great card game and this is a game for two to four players by designing heavyweight duo Michael Keasling and Wolfgang Kramer the game takes about an hour or so to play and is pretty much a worker placement game that uses cards as its components now the game is based on a board game version of the game called coal baron I've not played that game so this is a purely individual review I'm not going to be comparing the two so let's go the so the idea of the game is you are basically trying to gain as much points as possible or as many points as possible by mining coal pick those coal onto carts and then selling these carts off on trains in order to fulfill orders and those orders are what's going to give you your points at the end of the game I'll see the person with the most points at the end of the game is going to be the winner now it's pretty unusual for a a worker placement game to use cards as its components but this game does that pretty well so instead of having a big board of all the different locations you're going to have a different kind of deck of cards but each different location and in order to go to those locations you're going to spend a worker from your hand because every pair has got a hand of different workers I'm level one workers there were two workers I think that I think it might even go up to level five depending on the play account and so yeah you go to assign one of these workers to a worker spot and take the reward in return such as

getting coal getting a new order card maybe you can get a new cart you can get a new train you can go to a spot lets you load the coal onto the carts in a kind of first in first out method you can send the trains off you can take bonus cards you can take stocks cards which let you kind of alter your previous orders and there's lots of things you can do now if somebody goes to the location you are actually not completely locked out of that location because as I said all your workers have a level assigned to them so if say someone plays a level one car to take a bunch of coal and put it on there in their player area and I can still go to that area but I'd have to pay one level worker higher than the person there before so if they put a level two there I'd have to put a level three there I couldn't do a level four it has to be explicitly one level higher now that's a quite a cool wrinkle to the game because you've got to manage your hand of workers quite carefully because you can find yourself shut out of positions if you have the you know the wrong worker left in your hand if every location has a two on the spot and you've only got a four in your hand you cannot play that card so you've got to really carefully think about when you're going to use those workers the another cool thing about this game is what I think is absolutely paramount for a worker placement game is the the tension

and the the need to get to places before the other players it's a very tight gayness it's all those spots are very sought after which is as I said which is what you really need and you know just because something goes there you're not completely shot out but as I said you need to you're going to be spending more workers to go that which means you're going to do less on your turn so that decision is really interesting and because all those locations have a deck of cards to you know just to represent them obviously when someone to go sell that location they're going to take the top card and because they take that top card the card beneath it could be something that you didn't want so you know you got the state of play is constantly fluctuating or constantly changing which is really interesting because the game isn't purely a method of getting record pick monitor carts and put them onto trains although it is that there is a puzzly aspect to it as well because all those different kind of fragments of the game have a distinct logo on them and those logos almost restrict you or they do restrict you on what you can do with them because only certain icons can go in certain carts without icons on and they can only go in certain locations on your board so you can really happen you really have to think about the order in which you're buying the cards to be as efficient as possible when you're loading them because as I said the the way that you take the coal cars they go in a in a complete IQ of cards

and they have to be dispatched onto the carts in a in in order basically and if you're not doing them all in order they have to kind of go to the side and in that way you're just stocking them up and not being as efficient as you can or not the flow-through of your car isn't being you know it's just not being as efficient as you can as I said it's just wasting your turns wasting time and I really like that aspect of the game it you do have to map your turns quite carefully you do have to prioritize where you're going carefully and for a game that only has one kind of one real pathway to victory which is basically fulfilling those all the cards you know the decisions are still there the I said the tension to get to the right places at the right time while they're still available knowing what your opponents are going to take and hopefully just leaving it there so that you know they're not going to get there before you are it is absolutely a really enjoyable part of the game and another thing as well is there is a nice bit of mitigation with the luck of the cars because there is a separate spot you can go to where you dedicate your workers to as normal and that lets you choose any pile unless you take the top few deck cards from the deck and then put the ones that you don't want on the bottom and take the one you do want so you're not completely at the mercy of the shuffle of the cards and you know you've got a bit of mitigation there in order to get what you explicitly want there is

also this another thing I really like about the game is the different trains you can get they said when you go to the cutlet location that gets you trains all the trains come in different colors and depending on on what colors you're getting when you go to the location that you off your goods by sending the trains off and you send all the all the trains of one color so you can really save up your whole kind of game building up these maybe two or three orders at the same time and then sending all those trains off together in order to get a bunch of points all at once or you can kind of keep going to that location and sending off one train airtime if you have kind of different colors going at once this game has a really nice kind of rules overhead to it there's there's really not that much rules to it and I think the coolest thing about this game is the fact how logical it is the visual appeal of it is just so straightforward it just makes sense so as I said you've got like the your play board it's basically like a train line that goes into three different depots which have your three different trains or train locations on and you're loading your coal on inner you know in that cue form as I said you are getting the carts on your own your kind of depots and you're putting those coal into the carts which just looks really nice and just and just as I said shipping them off when you fulfill those orders and that kind of lot of cool flow of the game and the theme of the game just works really well

it's a really unique concept for a worker placement game it's not your rinse and repeat kind of go here and collect a resource collect resource click resource build a building and get points in that way it has a completely different feel to it for a worker placement game which is really quite impressive that Lee said I mean these these game designers are absolutely at the top of their game you know that they're top of the industry almost like the Mount Rushmore of board game designers so you know their designs are almost guaranteed to be tight and sharp and precise and this game is just a so well designed it's extremely streamlined and it just the flow of the game it just works wonderfully the decisions are there the tension of the getting to the place where you want is there the frustration or the good frustration of people go to the locations you want first changing the state at the board it's like oh that's so frustrating when you want the right thing and you know it's all your fault because you prioritize in the wrong order and so that that kind of feel of the work placement is is absolutely raw and it's so enjoyable but again has a complete different feel to your kind of other games of this genre of the same weight the balance of the game is fantastic I mean you because there's always going to be somewhere for you to go in order to you know to plan your turn accordingly you know if someone's completely dominating this part of the board and you're getting shut out of where you want to go you can always prepare down the line by going somewhere else because those

places are obviously going to have less workers dedicated to them meaning that you can go there for a lower cost which is nice said mechanism wise so pure so simple the flow of the game is really good the timestamp of the game takes about 60 to 80 minutes to play for my experience it's probably about right for me I don't miss game warrants a 90 minute play which you'd normally expect for a game of this type it just has because it's got a kind of similar feel through the whole game this you're not discovering a lot of new things as you go so yeah there's not too much to explore so that short a timeframe just fit it quite well personally I probably would have liked to see in another 10 minutes or so shaved off of it but no big issue there at all I think the game is just in the ballpark for being appropriate for its type up time absolutely fantastic said players can really just wash their turns out really quickly so you're not waiting around for other players to do what they want to do if there's any kind of fault I have with this game is it is the replayability factor that being said or because as I said there's pretty much one route to victory one path to victory and you're going to be doing the same thing every kind of game of this you can't really try a different strategy so I think for that reason everything's going to have the same kind of feel to it player

interaction is really good just because a lot of fierce competition for the spots you want to get to so yeah just the kind of normal the normal level of interaction you expect from a worker placement game there's no there's no attacking other players there's no conflict or anything like that just the tension of getting to the right places at the right time visually the game is really good I mean the symbology is excellent and as I said the visual appeal to it look the way the cards fit together like when you get the coal the coal just fits into the carts really nicely just a little top pops out of it and it just it just fits together very nicely has got nice as a logical feel to it there's no you can explain this game very thematically just by the way it looks yeah I I do love the components I said just cards and it's surprising that a worker placement game works so well with cards and the illustrations are clear they're nice they're kind of cartoony but suits the feel and the look of the game really well yeah so overall this game is really good as you'd expect from Kramer and Kiessling I'm funny enough this game is actually back of me why it's not more popular than what it is it's so cheap to buy I think this game cost me eight pound from the from the UK game to Expo which is probably a bit lower than what it normally costs but you'd expect to pay no more than fifteen pounds with this which is fantastic price you've got

you've got a lot of game in there it's very enjoyable I'd actually I said I'm surprised this this game isn't more popular because it really is a bit of a hidden gem it's not talked about at all and I would actually recommend this game for almost gateway to maybe a slightly more than gateway worker placement game that people normally recommend games like Lords of Waterdeep 4 or champs of Midgard I think this game is a better game than them it has a very unique feel to it it's just different it's a bit more interesting it's it's just very tangible with it's very you know the worker placement is very visceral there's that constant changing state of the board which is really nice your own player board is just yours to manage the efficiency puzzle is there it's there's a lot going on this game that goes to its credit as I said the only thing for me is the the go back to it factor is not there compared to keep slightly heavier than it which is probably why I won't play this one as nearly as much as games slightly heavier just be I said that one strategy to it but yeah for games who propose you like slightly lighter games than I do you know that light to medium weight games then this is definitely one to check out you know it's not going to break the bank it's a small box it's just a bunch of cards it's got a great feel to it it's fun it's fast and it scales very well too so yeah definitely gets a recommendation via it's a very good verdict for me go

check it out that's coal Baron the great card game if you have enjoyed this video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too reven else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved