Bloodborne: The Board Game is NOT Genius
Transcript
season two of the tv show fargo features a lot of great characters but perhaps my favorite is ed blumquist just a regular chap with regular goals and regular ambitions of becoming a butcher unfortunately his wife is over-ambitious and also sociopathic and she runs over a person and instead of reporting it to the police she brings the victim home and then ed is unwillingly dragged into a reality where he's covering up for a murder all ed wants is the american dream start a family own a small business and live out a happy simple life in one brilliant scene when questioned by the police he recounts the tale of sisyphus the greek lost soul forced to eternally push the same boulder up a hill except he tells it like he's never heard of it before and he can't help but identify with sisyphus to him sisyphus is the hero and pushing that boulder each day only for it to tumble down again is his ideal so of course they made it into a video game series bloodborne the video game is something people love bloodborne and when i say people i mean youtubers i don't think there's been another video game that had so many video essays made about it from each bomber guy to folding ideas to boardgaming's very own matthew lees people who like layers love unpeeling bloodborne i however love
impelling board games that don't work very well and i love to see why and i think it's especially interesting when the board game in question is overblown needlessly expensive is an adaptation of an intellectual property and most importantly is nearly amazing so i bought all of this oh i bought all of this bloodborne the video game is frequently talked about in the context of its siblings that being the dark souls series and to a lesser extent demon souls and sakura shadows die twice all of these are different variations of the same concept and have been birthed in the primordial soup of creation by one man and his name is hidetaka miyazaki we skimmed past the dark souls series in our previous episode and it's a great primer on the design ethos of the miyazaki ubra but just in case you're not familiar the idea is that you'll traverse an expansive map that's tailored to maim you every chance it gets each time you die in bloodborne you're reborn at the last lamp you visited but this time you're armed with knowledge now you know how to overcome the previous obstacle until you realize you don't really have to fight these and you can just run past most of this stuff you could argue that killing things gives you blood echoes and blood echoes is like xp and money so you want that to get better things but if all players wanted was blood
echoes they'd visit a specific chalice dungeon a type of procedurally generated dungeon that's not part of the main game by entering the code come and get 83 000 blood echoes for completing it people like fighting monsters in bloodborne because it's fun every move needs to be precise a moment's lapse and you've slipped and once you slip you die getting better at finds in bloodborne is like learning to dance and perfecting your timing and execution is very rewarding this is the problem with adaptations what works in a video game shouldn't really work in a board game it's not that they don't work at all it's just that they too frequently lean on a surface level understanding that's trying to please the fans with visuals and using all the correct capital letter nouns this is how you end up with zack snyder's watchman as opposed to damon lindelof's watchman so imagine my surprise when i realized that bloodborne the board game this big overproduced expensive loaded with plastic bloated with needless expansions mess kinda sorta actually nails it in bloodborne the board game officially licensed product you will take on the role of a hunter and alone or with up to three friends you will try to complete three successive hunt missions each hunt mission
is the basis of a chapter and a chapter corresponds to one play session grouped together the three chapters form a campaign and there are four different campaigns in the main box each chapter will instruct you what three enemies you'll be facing these range from grotesque beasts to conservatives in my youtube comments these enemies are also the obstacles in the way of you completing the hunt mission and fighting them is daunting precarious taxing and most importantly fun when you start a campaign your hunter will be handed a deck of 12 cards comprised of three copies each of four different cards basic basic basic and basic like in most deck building games the composition of your deck will change as the campaign progresses but even at its most basic level things are pretty interesting this deck drives everything you do at the start of a round you'll draw free cards anytime you want to do an action whether it is to move your hunter loot a consumable item or reload your weapon you have to discard one of these cards and the funny thing is which card you discard is completely irrelevant unless you want to fight something when you fight instead of discarding the card you're going to use place it on one of the slots of your trick weapon these have two important characteristics the speed of your attack and how much damage you will do that's the trick part of the trick weapon because when you start an attack
you have no idea what the enemy will do sort of as soon as you commit a card to an attack you immediately resolve any effects that a card might have if the card says plus 1 damage then you will deal plus 1 damage if the card says draw then you will draw a new one as soon as you commit it to an attack if however the card says dodge or stagger i don't want to say things get tricky again but they do get tricky after you committed a card to an attack slot you will draw a card from the enemy action deck these will either say basic special or ability and then the enemy stat card will tell you exactly what the enemy will do and at which speed it will do it there are three speeds in bloodborne the board game officially licensed product fast normal and slow if your attack is fast and the enemy's response is normal you'll get to hit them before they hit you back conversely if your attack is slow and the enemies is for example fast they hit you before you hit them and the thing about this game is that you never ever want to be hit at all fighting monsters is a bit like bringing a keg of beer to your college soiree you think you'll be the life and soul of the party but five minutes later half of it is gone and nobody cares you start each chapter with six health each time a monster hits you he'll hit you for at least two damage sometimes free and some monsters will even gleefully chomp you for four that's two thirds of your health gone
let's see how this works in practice i just started a new game explored a new area and of course there's already some conservatives i need to fight this should be easy the obvious question is can you heal and the answer is yes yes with ten caveats some characters are even great at healing the saw cleaver character heals one damage each time they kill an enemy and also draws a card and that's something the hunter axe character has one slot on the trick weapon that lets you heal for as much damage as you've dealt so if you survive the fight you'll come back as fresh and strong as a newborn baby the problem is that once you've placed a card on your trick weapon it stays there and the only way to remove it is to spend an entire action to clear your trick weapon and even then you can't use rallying strike again because when you clear your trick weapon of cards it transforms to the other side with an entirely different suite of abilities so if you really need to heal you have to spend two-thirds of your turn just twiddling your thumbs yet there is a way to completely heal up not only that but you can also put your discount pile and deck back together get rid of poison or madness clear your weapon set it to
whichever side you like and swap old cards in your deck with better powerful versions all it costs is a single action and whoop you are teleported to the hunter's dream where all of that magic happens but as always there is a bigger cost and you never want to pay it each time you and the other players end your turn that's when the round ends at that point you will redraw free cards and you're ready to begin again you also have to advance the round tracker one space and if it reaches the end you have one last round to finish your mission or lose the game worse yet each time the round tracker reaches a red space everything on the map resets all the loot is back but also all the monsters are back all the boss characters heal up fully and sometimes even your mission progress gets wiped but all of that is manageable since you only advanced this once after each player got a chance to do something however as soon as anyone goes to the hunter's dream the round tracker immediately advances this is such a cool mechanism almost at any point in the game you can say you know what i bid off more than i can chew hubris got the best of me i guess i have to go to the hunter stream and that's when everyone immediately groans because you didn't just cost yourself a turn you cost yourself two turns and every other player a turn in the game when you reset and buy upgrades you all lose
collectively a bare minimum of 12 actions in a four player game it's just great health is such a precious resource so we're back once again to combat and you not ever wanting to get hit some cards let you stagger an enemy but they only work if your attack is faster than theirs and don't forget when you commit a card to combat you have no idea what attack at what speed the monster will be doing the other option is more complicated after you've committed a card to initiate an attack and you've revealed how the monster will be retaliating you can play a second card that has the doge keyword sorry i mean the dodge keyword i don't think those jokes are legal anymore you might have to cut that out if you played the dodge card to a slot that is at least as fast as the monsters attack then you negate any effects of the attack that would directly affect you such as being damaged staggered stunned poisoned etc on the surface both of these effects seem pretty similar but bloodborne the board game plays within razor thin margins the most minute details create the most profound differences stagger only works if you're faster so stagger effects are useful on quick low damage attacks so you take a quick jab and if you have another good slot you can hack your cleaver again into a what is that that's a
a female beast patient delete that bit too whereas if you plan to dodge you can pretty safely activate a slow meaty thump if you have a fast slot clear or if you have a fast slot at all the problem is that you're spending two cards to do one attack worth it if you can kill the monster but seeing as most hunters can deal at most free damage and most monsters have for health if choosing which card and where you'll place it is the overture in this ballet of knives then the enemy action deck is whatever comes after the overture i don't really know anything about ballet random monster attacks might seem punitive and unfair but there's only ever 3 options and the monster activation deck only has 6 cards 3 for basic 2 for special and one for ability furthermore the enemy action deck discount pile is open information so you're not jumping in cold you know the odds except the odds are always at odds with you let's say you're fighting the scourge beast and this thing doesn't look nearly as unpleasant as the conservatives so it can't go as bad you know there's only two cards left in the enemy action deck one basic card and one ability you consider going in with a heavy slow hit with a dodge card as backup because the basic ability
on the scourge beast is fast and there is no way i can stagger that but wait a minute what if i don't draw basic what if i draw ability well then you're kinda because ability says that we're gonna spawn a new scourge beast and dodge doesn't really stop that from happening so i guess we better do a quick stagger attack instead but then if i don't draw ability if i draw basic it's gonna hit me for two and i'm only on two health i think my favorite part of this system is how cool you feel when you pull off a good attack you didn't just get lucky you paused you evaluated the situation you considered the odds and you executed the perfect move and sometimes it might seem like there's no good answer but that's just because you haven't considered all the options in the scourge beast example there was no right attacks so the answer was to not attack if i run away another hunter can have their turn attack something else restart the deck suddenly the odds are not that bad anymore but my favorite part is that over the course of the entire campaign you can assemble the coolest deck imaginable with powerful cards with multiple effects but none of them do anything unless you actually fight with them the game is telling you get into scrapes
push yourself into danger and you'll get rewarded honestly this game is genius i i didn't say that i take that back i didn't say that i think designers eric lang and michael chanal should be really proud of the system they developed it doesn't feel like an adaptation of bloodborne the video game it feels like an adaptation of all those essays on bloodborne the video game it distills what people really like about it and then they sort of patted themselves on the back and forgot about the rest when you kill a monster you get a blood echo token you can only spend these in the hunter's stream coincidentally each time you die you are also sent to the hunter's dream and you advance the round tracker however you lose all your blood echoes before you can spend them which is again a nice touch blood echoes are spent to upgrade your deck and it only feels right that to utilize them you have to balance the ludicrous cost of losing an entire round and managing not to die because these upgrades they're just too powerful let's say you're playing as the saw cleaver hunter you love staggering things as each time you do you deal extra damage but stagger only works if you are faster than your enemy well problem solved because this card doesn't just let you stagger it also increases your speed by one which means you can outpace almost any monster this card lets you
move before you attack and also deals plus one damage this card deals two damage to any enemy when you dodge them guaranteeing a one-shot kill if you do these cards are so powerful they swing the fight heavily in your favor and that's a problem throughout each chapter you won't just get new cards in your deck you'll also collect consumables that are one-time effects which provide various temporary upgrades and firearms which generally let you stagger regular enemies or even rewards which have potent effects you can use once between each hunter's dream visit you turn from a scrappy hunter that has to constantly outsmart their opponents into an unstoppable wave of destruction and that's really boring in each chapter in most campaigns you will fight the same three enemies and whilst they are double-sided with different statistics they're not somehow magically stronger or more challenging they're just the same old bag of tricks in chapter one you're the blade runner of excel sheets dancing on the precipice of the thinnest margins and in chapter three you're a middle-aged man taking out the trash to the bins over and over and over again bloodborne the video game is famous for its boss fights they're tough dynamic and ask you to constantly reevaluate the situation in split-second decisions they're the perfect crescendo in the dance of do die repeat in
bloodborne the board game officially licensed product bosses stand in as glue that patches this system together if flunkies no longer give you the edge there has to be a bigger challenge except bigger doesn't always necessarily mean more fun one of the campaign's bosses is the cleric beast it's also the first boss in the video game a quick pirouette with a hulking behemoth that teaches you how bosses work without overstaying its welcome in cardboard however the cleric beast is a long arduous protracted fight and once it's done you'll breathe a sigh of relief not because it was a challenge but because you're just glad it's over and you can move on to something else oh wait there isn't anything else that's the end of the campaign instead of using the enemy action deck bosses have their own deck each card simply tells you what the boss will do all clever play goes out of the window because you just have to choose an attack hold and hope that it's fine and most of the time it is because remember by now you're a beefcake but when it doesn't go fine you don't feel like the game outplayed you you feel like you just made an arbitrary choice and then some random stuff happened the cleric beast also has a mechanism that seems to incentivize clever play spend a resource make the beast weaker but then it once again randomly removes all progress and it does so so frequently that instead of feeling punishing it just makes the system prohibitive whereas the ability can't teach you to
get into fights that system teaches you not to engage with it because it's pointless each boss is split into two phases each phase has its own unique boss activation deck and if you reach one of the red reset rounds the boss stays on the same phase but heals all of their health meaning you want to time your attacks just after the token reaches the red space what do you do in between wait i guess there isn't really a reason anymore to engage with anything else i get a lot of flack for not liking big flashy kickstarter projects with lots of plastic minis and i tried to enter this game without any jadeness towards that side of the industry but looking back on it i don't really know how to not lay blame on the kickstarter model eric lang and michael chanel are both clearly very talented game designers not only did they devise a fantastic system that extracts everything that's fun about bloodborne but they also reimagined it in a different medium this is damon lindelof's watchman but in a universe where he wasn't given enough time to develop and collapses midway through the season one of the ways the game deals with unpredictability of bosses is to give you a taster session in chapter two you'll fight phase one of the boss familiarize yourself with what it can do and then in chapter three you'll fight phase one and two again and that sounds smart except it feels more like a hasty patch than an actual solution
instead of making the boss fights more interesting it just gives you more boss fight which in turn means you're spending more of the campaign in an arduous slog you learn a thing or two about it but not in any way that makes you react cleverly to the challenge in a way that is totally unrelatable in 2021 bloodborne is set in johannam a gothic european-esque hellscape ravaged by arcane traditions and also a plague the video game goes out of its way to give you a sense of place via architecture costumes and level design that feels expansive and purposeful bloodborne the board game officially licensed product is mostly just plastic miniatures of the monsters you see in the video game there's father gascoigne that's the conservatives and this is that thing that bricked you that one time and then you learn to shoot it before it does it again it's relatable it gives you that oh look there's that thing from the thing that i like sensation typical two kickstarter projects but it forgets everything else the tiles that unfold the world you inhabit feel less grandiose and more dungeon crawler from the naughties your player boards are flimsy and the graphic design is just a great texture with some gothic filigree frames it looks less blood-borne and more blood you know that shooter from the 90s thank you to the three people who remember that game when you explore johannam in tabletop each chapter doesn't have a set design some tiles have reasons to exist
in the scenario but there's no tailored map they're just shuffled in randomly with other meaningless tiles and then you'll trudge through the map opening up new locations hoping that you draw the right one purpose is replaced with arbitrariness and the same mission can range from silly easy to unnecessarily difficult based on that shuffle each chapter also comes with side quests called inside missions narrative divergences that serve to evolve the plot here you'll meet various familiar characters like old hunted jura or that's got my name on it ios efka well that's just blatantly a lie everyone knows i'm a pc boy to call these missions pedestrian would be doing the game a massive service there's a wisp of narrative here sulfate that sneeze and you'll miss it i suppose narrative isn't exactly bloodborne's main focal point the story reveals itself through bits of dialogue or set design or some dude's youtube videos to chanal and lance credit there's a pretty deft and simple system that offers narrative branching but because of the random distribution of map tiles you might never pick up on the threads that you started also the very first quest i encountered was a damsel in distress scenario and i wasn't exactly impressed with that bloodborne the board game comes with four playable characters meaning that in a four player game you have to play
with all of them fine if they're all interesting not so fine if three of them are interesting and one is about as much fun to play as the winner in twilight imperium saw cleaver frederick kane and ludwig's holy blade are dynamic hunters that weave layers of strategy that intermesh with the game's systems the hunter axe is just a dude who hits the axe and then sometimes heals his strategy is don't dodge don't stagger just take the axe and hit it really hard have you got some extra damage cards because i'll take those and with my axe i will hit it very very hard i will take that axe and i will hit with the cards very hard it's so indescribably dull worry not for there are a lot more characters in a kickstarter goodie box that's not available to buy forever and ever which is a peak come on move if bloodborne the board game got you itching and curious don't rush to buy this goodie box from the secondhand market fueling the scalper economy that come on thrives on it's predominantly filled with monsters you won't use because most campaigns have predetermined monsters you'll be facing there are two campaigns in the core box that use randomized monsters and a few more splattered across the sprawl of kickstarter expansions and they're worse for it because it furthers the arbitrariness that's in stark contrast to the design ethos of miyazaki's games what i don't want to
do is make you feel bad if you back this game on kickstarter if you got all of this so be it enjoy it you already spent enough money to feel invested in it which is how they get you but they did get you so don't let me ruin your fun let me instead tell you why all of this glut bothers me it's not that there's a lot of it it's that a lot of it means that there's so much design work that's needed i had the privilege of designing a tailored scenario for a dungeon crawler and whilst i'm under no impression that the work myself and elaine did is any good it at least gave me an understanding of just how long this stuff takes to make and how much work you have to put in just to make it playable there are 15 campaigns across these boxes which means there's at least 45 scenarios and if come on was a publisher that concentrated their efforts on one design for a while i think they would have come out with something less arbitrary and more focused i can't help but wonder what this game would look like if they just published two boxes or maybe three and then some more later down the line i bet that people who backed it on kickstarter and the people who bought it in retail would end up with something much sharper i'd be lying if i said i didn't have fun with bloodborne the board game officially licensed product there were times where i literally jumped from my chair when i risked my last hit points on a 50 50 draw and the cards just came up right it has
its moments and if you really really really really really really like bloodborne i won't tell you not to get this you're your own parent maybe use your birthday money you could do so much worse with dungeon crawlers you could also do a lot better but i'm not allowed to tell you which one's the really good one because people get upset when i do but i can tell you it rhymes with schlumen i purposely avoided saying how i feel about bloodborne the video game but now here's the skinny it's nice i like it i've had a pretty good time with it nowhere near enough to write mammoth video essays about it but what's important is that there are people who write essays about it bloodborne means something to them it's special and i can tell that this adaptation only reflects some of that vision bloodborne the board game is a fractured mirror a vision pierced and incomplete it's not a bad game it's a good game just a disappointing one and all shortcomings are antithetical to the source material it deserved more time under the hood
so
you