BUY OR SKIP Bantam West (2nd Edition)? BEST Open World Role Playing Board Game?
Transcript
We just spent way too much time pouring over every shred of gameplay footage we could track down for Banttom West. I mean, it's like the Wild West on steroids. Open world, sandbox, chaos everywhere. And honestly, I'm itching to talk about it.
Banttom West. Are you going to buy it or skip it? That's what we're here to figure out with everything we saw.
Let's do this. No review copy for us, just research, gameplay breakdowns, and a healthy side of skepticism. All right, so here's what we're working with. Banttom West Second Edition dropped recently and it's got this whole Graves of Gold expansion packed in. We didn't get a review copy this time, so we basically binge watched every available gameplay session, read all the campaign details, and just went nuts picking apart community chat. The pitch is wild. It's not just an openw world board game. It's trying to be a true sandbox where you actually get full control. Basically, you play as one of the immortal deadly strangers running around Gallow Springs doing whatever it takes to rack up notoriety points. I'm talking working, fighting, trading, burning down cabins, the whole deal.
Yeah. And the base game set for two to four players competitively, but if you want solo or co-op, you actually need the expansion. That's what the footage and campaign page made clear. With graves of gold added, suddenly you can go one to five players and solo or co-ops only for up to three. The campaign didn't shy away from pricing either. The gold hound pledge was $108 and basically the must get for all the modes. And those play times, quick games were around 45 minutes to an hour for four players. That's if you call five notoriety points quick. Standards more like 1 to two hours. And if you go for the long haul, you're looking at 3 plus hours for 20 notoriety points. It's hefty.
Hefty is one way to describe it. The whole thing moves on a dayight cycle, which gives it this cool rhythm, but also ramps up the tension. The biggest early impression, Banttom West completely delivers on freedom. Unlike other sandbox games where you end up following a prescribed path, it genuinely lets you pick your own way and not just a fake choice where everything leads to the same place.
Exactly. And you saw how every turn you're chewing on these grit tokens. Three per turn now down from the first edition's four. That didn't seem like a nerf in the footage. More like it kept the action snappier. But you definitely notice every decision matters. Movement, endeavor attempts, defensive positioning. You can't just spam actions and hope for the best anymore.
And let's talk about those endeavors. Eight different tracks: hunting, mining, foraging, firemaking, logging, herbalism, outfitter, and coin carver. You go from novice up to master. And every level up means a tougher skill check. Watching someone try to mine silver in the mountains. She burned all her willpower, took damage, barely scraped a pass, and it genuinely felt tense. That's the kind of gameplay where you actually care about dice rolls and risk management. Yeah, that willpower roll system. The demos showed you can't push your luck forever. If you overdo it, you'll have nothing left when someone jumps you for PvP or an event card goes south. We saw some super close calls during those wildlife encounters. One guy barely survived a wolf attack, wound up mounting the wolf head in the saloon for an extra notoriety point, and it felt earned, not random. Also that card driven combat. Both sides flip through their little decks trying the rock paper scissors cancel thing. And it's fast but tactical. PvP combat plays the same but with more tension. If you whiff, attacker goes first. And some weapons actually force special skill checks. You saw those two-minute brawls in the demo. Real consequences, not just deal X damage, move on.
Don't forget events. You wander into a terrain, draw a card, suddenly you have a moral dilemma and a skill challenge. I saw a guy barely pass a strength check, leveled up his firemaking for free. Another time, someone failed a roll twice and their willpower tanked, so they had to eat the penalty. These cards can change your whole strategy in a heartbeat. And victory isn't just do this one thing and win. You track notoriety points. They come from tons of places. To-do lists, endeavors, cabins, mounts, enemies, bounties, personal keepsakes. One session we watched had three totally different paths. resource gathering, mount racing, cabin building, and all work fine.
But also, since cabin arson is 100% a thing, there's this wild metag game where you can torch someone's point and ruin their storage. Saw plenty of footage of people just waiting three turns, burning cabins to the ground. Not griefing. It's core gameplay.
Yeah. With actual consequences. If you get robbed in PvP, lose your gear, or end up arrested, that's part of the design. So, you're never just optimizing your own stuff. You're constantly looking over your shoulder.
Town's got four shops. Mount buying in particular affected movement. You pay silver, slot it into your board, and boom, every movement action just got better. It's satisfying, honestly.
Satisfying until someone steals your mount. But yeah, that's the grind. But honestly, let's pivot to what really works here, because there's genuinely a lot.
First up, the sandbox freedom is legit. In every game session we watched, people picked totally different strategies and felt like they mattered. You can be a hermit, build up endeavors, dominate resource runs, or just become a notorious outlaw. There wasn't any right way forced on you. That hit me hardest. The genuine agency,
right? And the designer didn't just talk up improvements. Actual fixes happened. The grit token cut makes turns snappier. Action feels tight, not restricted. We noticed nobody spent half their turn deciding. Less analysis paralysis.
Plus that rulebook. First edition couldn't get out of its own way, but the new edition hired a pro co-author. The difference is night and day, at least based on what's shown. Fewer groans, less flipping through pages. The tutorial video still took 35 minutes, but even so, it helped.
The notoriety track overhaul is another big one. Players can actually see each other's progress, and it keeps the tension high. No more guessing who's in the lead.
I also love the small touches. Dual layer player boards with recessed spots. stuff actually stays put during play. The resource tray they unlocked as a stretch goal fixes one of the biggest annoyances from first edition. No more constant sorting tokens.
Artwork's legit, too. Event cards look like proper western tales. The wanted posters and character minis keep things thematic. They're not showstoppers, but they're not generic at all. Actually adds to the atmosphere.
And if you play at three or four, the footage showed everyone stayed engaged even between turns. PvP felt meaningful, not tacked on. And you can literally flip your strategy midame.
That expansion changes things for solo and co-op fans. Without it, you're stuck needing a full group every time. But the Graves of Gold expansion makes solo and small groupoup play possible, even if the specifics weren't shown off much.
Pricing's another plus. That $108 bundle for base plus expansion is cheaper than buying separately later. And the deluxe packages aren't just fluff. They come with metal coins and upgraded tokens. Genuine table upgrades.
Okay, but now for the stuff that made us groan because it's not all gold nuggets out here. There's some fool's gold in the mix.
Mean thing, the first edition really struggled for balance and pacing. Some reviewers shredded it for being way too easy to score points, like win in three rounds with lucky goals, barely any opposition. The campaign promises fixes, but nowhere do they confirm notoriity was rebalanced or scoring tweaked enough. The changes focus on speed and presentation, not fundamental math.
Exactly. And all the gameplay we saw only showed partial games. Nobody played a full session start to finish, so we couldn't tell if that easy points problem really got fixed. It's a big concern when you need 10 or 20 points to win. If it's still too quick, what's the challenge? expansion is a double-edged sword, too. Campaign touts underground cave exploration, solo and co-op, new relics, but barely any actual details. No proof of how solo AI works, what co-op victory means, how caves interact with the surface. Lots of promises, minimal substance. If you're paying big money for that tier, it's risky when the mechanics aren't laid out.
And complexity is still wild. Even Streamline, we saw players flipping through the rule book constantly. If the goal was to make it more accessible, it's still firmly in heavy territory. Setup, tear down, actual gameplay. It takes commitment, not a casual night.
Delivery timeline's a mess, too. Wave 1 fulfillment says June August 2026, but pledge pages mention January 2027. So, which is it? Are you getting it next summer or the winter after? Fast shipping is apparently an option, but that's not clarified. I mean, seven months of production waves with lots of fingers crossed, not super confidence inspiring.
Base game at two players felt weak. Less action, less interaction. You end up just building your own thing. Unless someone rockets up the wanted track, everyone just does their own chores. Three or four is where the fun actually happens. At least from the footage and community chat. Solo and co-op, no game demos at all, so that's a mystery box.
Replay-ability looked solid in the short term. Lots of characters, tons of endeavors, asymmetry galore, but we saw only two or three plays in most previews. It's unknown if you hit a rut after a handful of games. If balance is off, people will just race the same strategy every time.
And that expansion documentation gap is a constant headache. If you're going in for solo or co-op, you have to trust the campaign without much evidence. That's tough for crowdfunding at this price range.
So, after all that, how do you actually rate Bantam West? I'm stuck between a six and a seven out of 10. Honestly, the good stuff is great, the freedom you get, the improved pacing, the wild theme integration, but the full satisfaction depends on whether the expansion actually delivers and if the balance is fixed. Eene 6. It's ambitious, but there's just too much uncertainty. If you actually want to buy in, you need faith that the flaws got fixed and that Graves of Gold isn't just hype.
Value is there. If you get the Gold Hound Pledge, you're saving real money, especially if you like deluxe stuff. For heavy sandbox fans, this could be the best Western RPG experience the genre has seen.
But for most players, Western Legends is probably safer. Proven reception, more accessible rules, better scaling if you play it too. Bantam West is a leap of faith. If you're not deeply into heavy games, skip it for now. Wait for retail verdicts.
If you're a regular solo gamer, Sleeping Gods is a better choice. You don't need to buy an expansion for solo mode. It's made for that. And the open world plays scratches the same itch.
If you want something like Banttom West, but in outer space, Ziao Legends of a Drift system has similar vibes and sandy mechanics, sandbox, upgrades, variable paths, just themed differently and with way less risk.
So, let's talk about who should actually back Banttom West. If you specifically crave a deep openw world western sandbox with more complexity than western legends and you have a group of three or four regulars, it's a legit contender. Just remember, it's rulesheavy. You'll need commitment and you'll probably reference the rule book a lot at first. And if solo or co-op matters, the Gold Hound Pledge is basically required. The base game won't help at all there. But if you mostly play two-player sessions or just hate opaque campaigns with big expansion promises and no details, you're better off skipping it. Anyone wanting proven balance, reliable delivery, or lighter game nights will want something else.
And riskaverse buyers, maybe just check out a Weston Legends bundle. It's easier to get into, cheaper, and validates itself with happy backers. Banttom West feels like a thing for the hardcore crowd. And for anyone with first edition, apparently you get half off the core box, but zero clarity about component compatibility, so upgrade with caution.
Still, for the rare breed of openw world Western Sandbox fans really wanting more than Western Legends can give, Bantam West might just scratch that itch if you trust this redesign and expansion.
You know, I still can't get over that cabin burning scene. It's the most western thing you could do in a board game. Petty arson for points.
Yeah, and that resource tray. Finally, some sanity for sorting tokens. Small improvements, but they really matter when it's chaos on the table.
So, that's our take. Banttom West is genuinely bold and mostly delivers, but it's got enough red flags and missing details to make you think twice. Hardcore fans with dedicated groups, go for it. Everyone else, give it a few months and see if those fixes really happened.
All right, that's it from us. Thanks for joining us on Board Game Critique. We'll be back with the next big release, hopefully with fewer bird cabins and more answers for solo players
and maybe fewer group texts in the middle of rulebook tutorials.