Verdant Review: The Grass Is Always Greener...
Transcript
hi everyone tally and Pharaoh here from portabear and today we're going to be reviewing bourbon the latest game from publisher flat out games which is also the third in their series of accessible yet crunchy puddle-like games with the other two being Cascadia and Calico burden for one to five players sees you playing as a plant obsessed interior designer or at least that's what I think where the goal is to organize plants in a house so that they all get the right light that they need while at the same time matching those plants to the aesthetic of the room and the items in that room like the previous games in this series an average turn is going to see you drafting something from a shared Marketplace in the middle of the table and then trying to fit it in your display in the most optimal way thank you on your turn in verdant you'll take one of the four tokens in the middle and then take either a plant card or a room card from the same column the one that you didn't take will get a green thumb then you'll place your plant or room
card into your house plant cards have to go next to room cards and vice versa once you've sorted that you'll use the token that you took if it's an item or a pet it will go into one of the rooms in your house and if it's a gardening tool you'll use it to increase the vertices of your plants venti will be one of the main ways you're going to score in the game every time you place a plot into your display it will gain emergency token for each adjacent room with a matching light symbol when you've gained enough currency equal to its vernancy value it will be considered complete which means you can score it in final scoring for its VP value which may be different than the verdancy value on top of that you'll gain a pot for that part and these if you're quick enough will have extra VP on them otherwise the score include having plants of the same color next to matching rooms and these points will be doubled if you also have an item or a pet in that room of the same color Euros to score for having many different items and pets in your house the more the better and if you play the advanced version you're also going to have endgame scoring objectives to contend with everything is scored up at the end of the game which happens when all players have completed a 5x3 set of rooms and plants looping back to the green thumbs these are going to allow you to manipulate the game you'll always be spending two of them but they will allow you to do a variety of different things you could wipe all the tokens in
the middle and draw new ones if you don't like them same with the cards or at least the cards that don't have green thumbs on them and finally you can spend them to just advancy to your plants in the hope that you'll complete the valency value jumping now to the gameplay burden is a lovely little puzzle it's really thrilling to snag a card and token combo which slots perfectly into your house and it's going to allow you to rack up all sorts of Point combos the fact that you have both the item tokens which will get you end game scoring but also act as a multiplier for your room and plant Combos and you have the gardening tool tokens which I needed to increase the valency of your plants makes for a really tough but very interesting decision when you're weighing up which token you should take it also means that there's a lot of different rules to Victory because you can't do everything in one game and as an example if you go for valency and the gardening tools in the middle this means that you're likely not picking up items to put in your house which means that you won't do very well on that end game scoring of having a lot of different items this Push Pull is the core version and it comes from the fact that anything you are scoring for probably means you're missing out on some other area in the scoring it just makes for some really gut-wrenching decisions another mechanism in verdant that we particularly like is how the green thumbs accumulate on the cars that aren't taken which means cars aren't
initially interesting to players could become quite tantalizing thus you have a tough choice do you go for the card that is probably subpar but to get all of those lovely green thumbs or do you go for something that fits a bit better but with the knowledge that you have less flexibility in the future one particularly fascinating element of verdant is the fact that you are forced to create a 5x3 grid by the end of the game so you'll get a lot of interesting choices about how to optimally work outwards and at which point you define what is your fifth column and your third row because at that point you're then locked in and your game becomes more inflexible the fact that the plants and rooms also have to alternate as to the intensity of the puzzle overall this is just a nice cozy game which can be played by a wide range of people due to the approachability of the actions and the Allure of the theme we have a real respect for flat out for continuing to create these games which absolutely nail that midpoint between having such a simple rule set that anyone can play but creating a really engrossing puzzle within that same rule set so that hardcore Gamers like us remain utterly engaged one thing we would note though that this is a very standard Solitaire multiplayer game we're the only real player interaction is basically hate drafting so be aware of that when you introduce it to others now we're going
to shift tact and talk about Cascadia and whilst it might seem a little bit unfair to compare verdant with Cascadia they are from the same publisher occupy the same space and almost wholesale have the same mechanisms so why recommend this when there is a better option and let's be clear Cascadia is the better game out of the two for numerous reasons first biggest problem is how it went Whole Hog with scoring you've got to consider room color lighting condition plant color item color type of item you have how many of them you have spatial positioning and three separate endgame scoring cards and all of this thrown at you means that it's much tougher to learn or for new players to do well immediately or non-games to do well than it was in Cascadia and the way that the the plant to room scoring works it's so fiddly and complex that if you have a non-game or a new player in that game they will be asking you to do it it's the kind of scoring that I can count it up knowing how to do it three times and I'll end up with two different values this means that you feel bombarded with all different things to keep in your head and you almost feel dragged Along by having too many options and this is in direct juxtaposition to cascadia's elegant scoring and smooth gameplay weirdly considering that theoretically
you have more maneuverability inverted because the green thumbs allow you to get rid of or swap out the tokens and both sets of cards you should have more chance to maneuver what you can get compared to Cascadia but actually I always felt more limited and verdant and I felt frustrated far more often than I did in Cascadia what was available in front of me and we think this is because the game has a negative Arc because you're filling in a preset 5x3 grid as the game goes on your options become more and more limited whereas in the early stages you can kind of maybe work around do a different tact in the late stages you're looking for very specific things and it comes increasingly frustrating when they're not coming up because anything else just isn't really doing much at all for you last thing verdant is quite famous despite the appearance I mean yes the phone calls are extremely beautiful and well done but the room cards are basically just blocks of colors and the items are kind of blinded and inspiring plus the connection of theme to gameplay isn't really there if you begin to think about it I mean why is it that once a plant reaches verdancy they are potted and I guess they don't need water or resoiling anymore when the plants are next to the rooms are they in the rooms or are they in the middle of the rooms or and we could go
on but you get the idea final thoughts we were just a bit harsh and burdened but it is a lovely game that we do recommend the issue we have is that it's arguably the worst game of the series that it's in and they all occupy a very similar space with very similar mechanisms on top of that if a theme and the gameplay there's a bit of a disconnect so even if you gravitated towards this just because of the theme you might still end up disappointed if you're interested in Cascadia then check out our review however if verdant still appeals to you then you'll certainly enjoy we will be keeping our copy and we do expect to be getting out to play often yeah it's a wonderfully cozy game and yeah we just we really enjoy playing it no it's really good fun so if you enjoyed this video we really appreciate it if you could give us a thumbs up subscribe to our Channel if you're not already please feel free to ask us any questions about verdant down in the comments or uh Cascadia or let us know your thoughts on burden also watch our Cascadia review if you haven't already yes and us and these two Doggers we'll see you next time thanks bye