Azul Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to jacket's games today I'll be reviewing Azul and this was designed by Michael Keesling this is a beautiful looking abstract style game where you will be drafting these various colored tiles from central pools in the middle of the table and you'll be trying to build out a pattern in front of you that will score you the most points there is quite a bit of player interaction here and I'll explain how the game plays first and then we'll jump in in my review here we have a player's board at the end of the second turn and I found that it's easiest to teach Sewell by explaining how scoring works and then talking about how we're gonna actually grab tiles so we are gonna go into the scoring round for this second turn and you know that because all there are some tiles out here already now the way scoring works is you always start with the topmost row and you're only gonna score one of these rows right here if every single slot is full of titles and you see this top row is just a row of a single tile so that means we do get to score this tile right here and we have to put it over into the spot that matches the color now as soon as you put it down you score that tile and if it has no orthogonal adjacencies then you're just going to get one point for that tile so we would go from four points up to five now we would go to the next row we see that it has two different spots and we have two tiles here so that means we're gonna take the rightmost tile and we're gonna move that one over here and now that you could see we have at least one adjacency it's this red one up above you now score the vertical right here and you get one point per tile so we're giving it one two points for placing down this yellow tile which we will track up on our track now we go to the third row but you'll notice we would need three tiles in order to score this and we only have two
so we're gonna skip this leave those tiles there go to the fourth row where we have four of these black tiles already so we can go ahead and take the right hand most one and we put it into the spot and we see that it is now jacent to two different tiles so we're not only going to score the vertical like we did up here so that's one two points but we're also gonna score the horizontal so that's gonna be one two points for that as well meaning that by placing this tile we've actually generated four points so we go all the way up to 11 on our track now we go to the final line down here we see it needs five different tiles we only have two so we're not gonna score that we'll leave these here and now we look down to this track down here this is the floor and any tile down here is gonna score negative points we see this first and second tile or both negative one point each so we're now going to lose two points and with that we can now reset our board for the next round you're gonna get rid of all the tiles that are on the floor and every single one of the rows that scored you're gonna get rid of all the tiles that were over there and leave the remaining ones behind and that is how you score a round of a Zul now that we know how the tiles score let's talk about how we actually acquire tiles and put them onto our board so that starts with these nine different factory coasters that we have in the middle of the table are you gonna use all of these in a four-player game but let's say for instance this was just a two-player game then four of these would go away and we would only have five of these in the middle of the table and we're gonna want to take this starting player token and we're gonna put it right in the middle of all these coasters next up we're going to grab our big bag of tiles and we're gonna pull out four of them and put them on each of these coasters
I think it's also worth noting that all of the tiles that were pulled off of our boards when we scored or when they were on the floor they can put into the cover of the box we don't put those back into this bag of tiles until the bag of tiles is emptied then we grab all of them and ricci the bag to keep playing on your turn all you will do is select one of these various groupings of tiles in the middle of the table and then you're gonna take all the tiles of a single color in this case we look over to our board and we know that while scoring this blue into this spot right here would be great for us we only want one blue to fill up that slot so we see there is a single blue here we could take this and put it right over there onto our board now we can put this down into any row as long as there is not already a blue tile scored over here on the side and the tiles have to match so I would not be able to put this down right here and I also could not put it up here because I've already scored a blue up there but this could go right down here and then all of the rest of the tiles that we're not taking get shoved into the middle it now goes to the next players turn and at this middle area is now a new spot that players can grab tiles from our opponent will now go and let's say that they grabbed these two yellows right here that would go ahead and shove these into the middle and now we get to go again and as you can see this middle area is going to change as we're playing and it's now our turn to pick again and let's say that we really wanted these two yellows right here now since this starting player token is still in the middle that means that nobody has taken from the middle yet because the first person to do so is going to take this token and it's going to immediately fall onto the floor which means it's actually gonna be worth two negative one points
to us but it means that we will get starting first dibs and choosing tiles in the next round which is certainly nice and now we have these two yellow tiles right here and we cannot put them here because we have already scored a yellow tile there but let's save for demonstration purposes we wanted to put it up here on the top now you'll see that there's only one slot there but scoring yellow would be really nice for us so we would put the one tile here and every remainder tile that did not fit on it that one given row falls down on to the floor aim is gonna score us negative points when we go to scoring plate would now go back to our opponents who will take a turn and we're gonna go around and around the table until every single one of these tiles is grabbed and that means we could find ourselves in the situation later on in a turn where we're forced to take tiles that don't actually legally fit in any of these slots and must fall down to the floor and we're gonna keep playing until every single tile is gone at that point we would go into scoring but you already know how that works everybody will keep playing around after round until a situation occurs at the end of a round where at least one player has at least one horizontal completed with all these tiles the moment that happens as you can see up here the game is now going to be over and we're gonna go into endgame scoring and it's really simple you can see it right down here at the bottom each player is gonna get two points for every completed horizontal set of tiles that they have they will get seven points for each completed vertical set of tiles and they'll get ten points for every set of five of a color that they have for instance with these five teal right here once everybody has calculated all these points then you see who has the most points and then the winner all right let's now go ahead and start the review off for Azul we'll begin with
a few positive points and the first has to do with the excellent pool drafting mechanics that come into play with this game now as an aside I do have to tell you that I am predisposed to lanagin because pool drafting is one of my favorite mechanics and the essential idea of full drafting is just there are a certain number of little pools in the middle of the table that have resources in them and under turn you need to grab from one of them and you're thinking which one do I need right now and which one of them do I still want but will likely still be there by the time I have my next turn because I think my opponents won't go ahead and grab it and those decisions are very much the forefront of what you're doing on every single turn of Azul but it also has this really cool extra tweak where when you are grabbing after one of these pools you are only getting one color time so you're gonna be pushing it the rest of the tiles it's the middle or of course if you're grabbing from the middle then you are gonna be just leaving other things available there for you and I'm gonna talk about the middle portion of the mechanic in a little bit in the second positive point but specifically with the pool drafting decisions that you're making I really like trying to figure out what do I need right now what do I my opponents need and what is likely going to go all the way around also you oftentimes have situations where you have two different pools that are going to give you the same exact benefit but have a different alternate I'll so you need to figure out which do you want to leave out there for you to potentially grab on the next turn if nobody goes for that other one and then also you need to consider how many times you want to grab when I first started playing my very first game of this I kind of assumed they more tiles was a good thing and for the first couple rounds that is kind of true
but relatively quickly I found that you will be in situations where you really want a single tile and I've seen many times where somebody becomes a star player and for their very first action in a round they take a single tile and push three more into the middle because that's the one that they needed and I was very happy to see that this was not just about trying to get as many times as possible it was really about trying to get the correct number of tiles because often times if you take too many tiles they're going to fall onto the floor and become negative points for you so all these things come into play with the pool drafting decisions and I think it's very elegant and I love how it works next up we have a positive number two and this one has to do specifically with the incentivization mechanic that comes into play with that central pool that is just fluctuating as you play the game it starts off with nothing but the starting player token in it and it's a really neat decision to be made like who is gonna be the first person to kind of break the seal and grab from the middle because well they do get to become the starting player for the next round which is definitely a nice thing to be but it also means you're gonna take at least one negative point for that tile as you put it down onto the floor of your player area but it also means you're gonna push get pushed into even greater negative points if you have to have more tiles fall onto the floor for you in that given around so it often seems like the central area just gets bigger and bigger and bigger until the moment that somebody says okay I am incentivize enough this is too good I'm gonna go ahead and grab it take the starting player token and then from that point on it's kind of a incentivization free-for-all because the there's no
penalty for going into the middle and it will just have and flow and things get bigger and get smaller but it also has this really neat thing coming into play and see normally in incentivization mechanics you have a thing get better and better and better until somebody finally goes ahead and grabs it but in Zul there's this neat thing where sometimes things get better and better and then they become worse and worse than they become terrible it's kind of a bell curve where you want to try and grab it at that right moment because if there are too many of a specific color tile in the middle then somebody is going to have to take it because the round will go until all the tiles are gone and that means that those tiles are probably going to slot into a row there will be excess those will fall onto the floor and or negative points so you have an interesting situation where you can actually over incentivize the pot and put like five or six of a specific color in based on the situation around the table and of course if there are five in there and you have the five row completely empty then you're happy but if you already have three in that five row and now there are five and the O and those are the only tiles left or that color you have a really difficult decision to make and I just think all these things play together in a very simple way but I really enjoyed how it worked for my last positive point I want to briefly discuss the scoring method for Azul now if you have played a coracle ever before then this will seem very familiar to you because they are functionally identical in nature and it works really well for both of these games specifically what I'm talking about is the way that you are trying to just maximize the amount of points you can get for every tile that you put down and realistically the cap that you can get for a single tile you put down is nine points you can score that one nine
times because it is one point when you put it down and then every time you go adjacent to it you re scoring that tile and realistically the person who's going to win the game is most likely going to be the person who is the most efficient and squeezing as many points as possible out of these tiles that they put down on to the board now it's very unlikely that you will get nine points for any one specific tile but trying to cluster these together in certain ways and try to make the best use of the options available to you in the draft so that you can keep clustering these is a very big deal now there are quite a few bonus points that you could grab for getting the completed verticals and a little bit of bonus points for completing the horizontals and ten bonus points for getting all of a specific color and these are other things that are keeping you thinking about what tiles you want to grab and also can maybe have you do something that is slightly less efficient as far as maximizing the scoring of the tiles you already have out there to specifically make that pattern or get that fifth tile of a specific color down onto your area and all these things come together to make a very satisfying scoring situation I think let's now move over into a few neutral points and the first of these has to do with the surprisingly cutthroat nature of the indirect player interaction in this game now there is nothing specifically direct that you do no specific actions that you do like mess over one player or another but the indirect things that you're doing with the pool drafting taking this tile is supposed to that tile this group instead of that one over there can definitely have big ramifications on your opponents and specifically at the
lower player counts like two players it really will feel like a direct indirect interaction because you can do things that will really mess over the plans of your opponents you might see that they need just one more red tile to finish out their row of five there's only one more red tile out in the middle and it's an okay play for you so you grab it and now they don't score that row all those tiles are gonna be sitting there clogging up their area for the next turn and they're gonna be more likely to spill over onto the floor on their next turn because they have four out of the five tiles there and like I said at the lower player counts it's much easier to also parse what your opponents need because if there's only one opponent you could just look across and see what it is and trying to play around that there are many times where you are trying to figure out what pool to grab from because you need two black tiles and there's two there there's two there and there's two there as well now which one do you grab well you need to look at all the your opponents see what they're trying to do because this is a hundred percent open information game and then try to choose accordingly so that you are not only helping yourself but also messing over your opponents and I have to tell you that I love cutthroat mess over your opponent's indirect action type of games but not everyone does specifically one person I played with felt that the game could be just too mean with some of the things that you could do with the specific timings that you're trying to do like if you're trying to win this game you will find yourself doing things that will make your opponents groan and I am okay with that but not everyone is so this is a bit of a warning for a neutral point number two I want to say that we've noticed that players who have a really strong starting turn definitely have a
leg up on their opponents it seems like there could be a slight runaway leader situation that can develop because as I mentioned before once you get tiles out into your tableau you can keep hitting them for more and more points as you put tiles next to them so that means if what player is able to score four tiles in the first round even if they're not even next to each other on the map then they are in a much better situation than another person who only scored two tiles because the first person has so many more opportunities to go adjacent to those previous ones and squeeze more points out of them it also means that that person for towels well they're probably gonna not have many towels in there Oh slept over so they're very free and open for the next round to grab a bunch more tiles but if you only score two tiles in that first round and odds are good you have some clogged up rows and you're gonna be in a little bit tighter situation in that next round so I think this is a neutral thing because it hasn't really messed up the opinion of every end if anyone playing the game so far and we haven't noticed that like the person who gets the most tiles in the first round always wins the game but it does seem like they're in a very nice situation and everybody needs to work a little bit harder potentially collude a little bit to deny good options to that player that is doing very well but at the same time it's not always obvious who is running away with the win until it's quite close to the end of the game because just having towels out in the middle like they're essentially points that can be harvested again so it's possible the person who scores those four tiles actually has less points than another person who only scored two or three based off of you know maybe the penalty tiles they took and all those various things but they are actually they're actually in a much better
situation but either way I think this is kind of okay because it does reward good playing like the person who is able to analyze the titles in the millet able in that first round in particular trying to figure out what will score them the best and what leaves them the most open to actually filling out those rows in that first round well they get a nice benefit of having a good head start in the game so I don't think it's bad but it's something to keep your eye out for next up we have a neutral point number three and for this one I want to talk about the variant sign of the board you can flip your player board over and you'll find just a big gray set of blocks areas where you can put these tiles down and the only real difference in the rules is that you are well you could put the tiles anywhere you want to you just can never have to a tile of a color in the same horizontal or vertical row and they just kind of play the game as it was building your own pattern in front of you and if I'm being honest I thought that I was gonna enjoy this the most because of the control and being able to have a different pattern that sounds neat as opposed to everybody building the same pattern in front of themselves but I found that when I played it it just seemed a little bit more forgiving than I'd like like you especially in the early rounds of the game you just put all your tiles over just have them in a row so you know put one down then put one next to it and score that one again then put the third one down score all those again and I liked the restrictive decisions of having that set pattern in front of you where like if you have a red on this row it has to go into this spot you don't have any choice in the matter and it does it's worth mentioning that with the variant as you get later on into the game you can definitely work yourself you can pay yourself into a corner where you have a spot where
you're not allowed to put any tiles down and you are not able to put the tiles anywhere as you slowly restrict yourself and that's fine but I think for me I am not very interested in continuing to play the variant side of the board but I think mechanically it works fine and I'm glad it's out there as an option for people who do prefer to actually build their own pattern maybe have a little bit of a nicer start and in general probably have higher scoring games because it's just a little bit looser for them finally we have neutral number four and for this one I just have to briefly say that yes this is a essentially seamless game it is an abstract game that works really well for multiple players which is unusual for abstracts and sure it has beautiful tiles and some nice artwork all over the place and you have this theme of like building tiles in front of yourself and the tiles could fall onto the floor and break and give you give you negative victory points but you never feel like you are actually tiling anything like you are just doing this mathematical puzzle trying to do the horizontals of the verticals trying to squeeze the most points possible and you don't feel like you made the best tile area in front of you in fact it's somewhat common that the person who one the game doesn't have a particularly pleasing looking thing in front of them at all they'll have holes right in the middle and various different spots because maybe they're going for those verticals or those various things so yeah don't go into this game expecting strong theme in fact to just go into this game knowing that it is a blatant abstract that looks pretty on the table all right it's now time for us to go into the negative section I have two that I'm gonna cover but I'll tell you right from the start that neither of these aren't that big of a deal to me so let's go ahead and do
the first and that has to do with the first couple rounds of the game specifically that first turn of the game I just feel like it could be more interesting you have no tiles that are in front of you so you look out and you try to figure out what you're gonna pull drafting like well I see three of a tile over there I'll just take that put it on here and I guess that's my turn and you move around and then you kind of do that same thing over and over again in that first round and there is some levels that you go to like you can start counting the number of tiles and figure out what you're more likely to taking this and taking that but those first few turns like there isn't even much to analyze for your opponents like what they might want what they might not want and I just feel like there was an opportunity to make that first turn in particular and a to certain degree the second turn as well more interesting and I'm not a game designer so I don't have any specific house rules I'm thinking about bringing into play but I just wish that the zeal and excitement that you have in like the fourth and fifth round of the game where things are getting kind of tight and there's a whole bunch of things to analyze I wish a little bit of that was in play with those first couple turns of the game and now for a negative number two I want to complain about a couple nitpicky graphical component type things now I will admit as I mentioned before I think the game is beautiful I think the tiles are chunky I like the silk screen on them it's a good-looking game but there are two things in particular the first is that scoring track that is at the top of everyone's everyone's area it's just a little tiny and then you have this cube that you're gonna put on there and it's so easily knocked out of the way it really seems like in my opinion they should have had a score track that went from zero to fifty and so all the spaces
will be bigger and then give you a disc that it's a low profile so it's less likely to get knocked around and sure the scores are usually in the you know 50s 60s 70s up to the 90s the low hundreds well you just wrap around the track like that's that big of a deal it's not gonna be hard for you to track in any way shape or form I just feel like that was a bit of a miss like we definitely had times where that tiny cube just got knocked over but like do I 51 or 52 points oh I guess 51 and so that's not great and the other thing when you look out to the table specifically the rows and that little pyramid tier thing that you have going on I really feel like they could have done a small graphical thing to help the teaching of this game because when you score a row you only take the rightmost one and you slide it over into the area and you discard all the rest and I really feel like that that full column the rightmost one in all of those scoring areas I feel like it should have been a different color or maybe have like a Philly border around it if something to make it very obvious as you're teaching the game so you could say when you finish the row out you take the one in the shiny area and you score that you get rid of the rest of them as opposed to saying okay it's just the right hand most wanted to get rid of the other ones it just feels like it's kind of the same all the way through graphically and I know this really is a nitpick but I feel like they really should have done that even just a slight different shading for that far rightmost column of the areas where you're kind of storing those tiles before you score them would have been really nice in my opinion it's now time to discuss the variability for Israel and I have to admit that it was a little bit lower than I was expecting going in now it is
an abstract game and in general abstracts you know they have that simpler rule set and just play it and you can play it 50 times and you get better as you go because it's always the same thing and I could understand it kind of an affinity going towards that from a design perspective but I also feel like in this day and age people expect a certain amount of variability from one game to the next not necessarily from the mechanics of what you're doing but from what your goals are and sure you have the two sides of the board and as I mentioned before I feel like I founded the variant side of the board a bit lackluster I just feel like there would there was opportunities for differing scoring endgame scoring options you know you could have the coracle style scoring all be the same every time you play it but maybe in one game you get to those seven points for each one of the verticals you do but in the next game you only get three points or maybe in another game you actually get negative points for finishing off one of the verticals but you get positive points for completing two-by-two areas or just various things like that I think to add a little bit of freshness to the game as you keep playing it but I don't think this is necessarily a problem like I've played the game a bunch of times already and I anticipate playing it more in the future I just feel like it was a bit of a missed opportunity from a variable perspective Azul plays two to four players and I've experienced all of those player counts and I'm happy to say that honestly they're all great if I was forced to pick a favorite it would probably be the three player game specifically because in a four player game that's just one extra person to try and analyze like what do they want to do how can I counter drop them it's also with nine of those coasters in the middle of the table it's just a ton of tiles for you to try to process and figure out what
you want to do now what are other people gonna want to do and the flip side is the two-player game which i think is great it really is but you would have to be ready for a very cutthroat experience like if you're playing this game well and you're you're playing you're trying to figure out what to do right now you have one opponent and you just look across it's very obvious what they're going for you look at the titles of the middle and you can map this stuff out be like yep I know do this and then that there's nothing they can do about it and it's totally gonna hose them over I enjoy those situations but not everybody's going to and I think three is best because it's kind of in the middle point between those and if you have a situation where you feel like one person is doing markedly better than everybody else then the two other people could try to collude a little bit and rein that other person in but as I said all three of these player counts were excellent and the play times it seemed like the two-player game is going to get you like the twenty to thirty minute range and the four player game is gonna be maybe forty to fifty minutes if you have some analysis paralysis going on there but all these player counts and times I think are very reasonable and worked well in the conclusion I've played as rule five times at this point and I really like it in general I don't find myself attracted to abstract games all that often and it is worth noting that this is a beautiful looking game like when it's being played out in the middle of the table it definitely has that eye catching allure like if somebody walks by like hey what's going on over here and then also from my things I'm predisposed to liking already this game is just a bunch of that stuff into a box like you have a pool drafting which I love already you have incentivization where things get better and better until somebody grabs it well this game has that as well and then I really like corkle and this game has
corkle scoring just you know cut out of that game and plug down right in the middle of this one so I into this one expecting to like it and I have really liked this game now I don't think I'm gonna be pushing to play it like every single week but I do think that this one could be played a long time from now like I'm not anticipating getting rid of this game at any point realistically because it is somewhat easy to teach I will admit it's a little bit convoluted at first you kind of need to teach the scoring and then teach how the pool drafting works but it's such a simple game and it seems like all of these elements just wrap right back into each other you know with the pool drafting working into that incentivization thing just so streamlined you don't grab the towels the rest of them go right into the middle and then that's a thing that other people can grab from you don't have any exceptions it's like you just play until all the tiles are gone if you can't place the tile it falls down on the floor you lose points for it all these things are quite straightforward and it just it's a very tight experience and I found that I really enjoy it and I do very well at this game like I haven't won every single game but I've usually come in I think out of my five games I've come in at first or second pretty much all of them so I think it does work well not only for the mechanics that I'm predisposed to liking but also my brain enjoys and the decisions that I'm making and I appear to do well at it and of course that's gonna probably induce a little bit of favorable bias into the situation but I do have to say that I think Israel is a very impressive game and I'm looking forward to playing it more I heartily recommend it to anyone who is interested in strong in direct interaction kind of cutthroat style games and yeah the only thing is don't
go into this looking for a theme it really isn't there this is an option that plays well with more than two players and that in and of itself is a pretty cool thing that you don't see that often so that's gonna wrap it up as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you could do so have patreon.com slash drawing it's games and I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching