Skip to main content
Loading video...

Brass: Lancashire Review

Transcript 17:37

people who said I'd lost my touch and was only doing pansy simple games I thought get your heads around this yeah I do actually quite a design Don spite I've done that so many times you wouldn't believe it nice yeah I've designed games just to annoy people design games just to annoy people do annoying people hello yes yes actually today we are not reviewing a poor game we are reviewing a legend originally published in 2007 and known only as brass this not so very pretty game with a not so very pretty theme of establishing factories in the bright and cheerful setting of Industrial Revolution England has outlived many board games that are now forgotten and despite the addition of the subtitle languages somehow in this new edition it is way more beautiful than it has ever been reviewing a game that came out more than a decade ago and it survived the hostile environment of the number of board games more than doubling is pointless because if you came here to see if we thought this game was good then the answer is obvious of course it's good but just because it's good it doesn't mean that you should go out and buy it because it's entirely possible that a complex game about digging canals and building factories no might not be for you hold onto your boats because we are getting ahead of ourselves in brass

Lancashire you will take on the roles of one of six old grumpy men or two grumpy ladies who dream of becoming titans of industry you will receive a cardboard slab that is littered with tiles that represent five different industries you could focus on building cotton mills which has the best cost two points ratio but it will only score your points if you flip them and you will need ports to do so building these industries and the links that interconnect them requires resources so you might want to build iron and coal mines and you will quickly learn that you want to diversify yourself because all of these abstract looking Tarver interlinked but the more you focus into one of the more reward you will get so you'll want to build all of them and then you'll say dad dad can I can I build more tiles please and dad represented by the brutal and unrelenting design of this game will say shut up and go to your room on the surface brass is very much like a ham and cheese sandwich it's simple straightforward and abstracted to its most basic healthy ingredients like in most euro games you will build buildings that will turn produce you resources like coal iron and money and then you'll turn those resources to build more buildings that will score your points hilariously you'll place these industries on the most conceivably mundane British locales such as Burnley or Manchester Preston Britain what do you mean they're not in Britain I'm sure I've heard of these Harry Potter oh so

that's the surface clever stuff done the next bit is a little tricky brass is a game that isn't complicated but is complex except that it is also complicated the rules for internet soif a thin manual that's padded out with illustrations examples and strategy tips but it's not the amount of rules that makes it complicated but their intersection I know this doesn't mean a lot yet but bear with us to illustrate how frustrating browsers can be to grok we've installed this complexity encouragement device in the next scene F Cahoon hasn't been shot for relaying an experience rather than the rules that's main how to build a factory each time he meets a detail a subtle interaction or just plain gets it wrong I will employ the device ready no go let's say you want to build a factory that's pretty simple you'll start each game with a hand of cards depicting either locations you can build all types of factories you can build spinner guard and you'll be able to build in that location or that type of factory if you decide to spend say an iron mine card for example technically you could build in any space on the board that allows for an iron mine to exist except you are restricted to only building in locations within your network meaning they have to be built in locations where you already have a factory or have your canal boats or railroads linking to a location where you already have a factory whereas if you spend a location card you can build anywhere whereas if you

spend a location card you have to worry about resource costs if your factory requires iron to be built it must be consumed either from a player's factory or the supply which incurs an additional cost if your factory requires coal however because historically coal was needed in huge quantities wherever your building has to be connected to a source of coal which is kind of like being in your network which is nothing like being in your network because being connected means that it doesn't matter whether it's your bugs or someone else's boat you just have to draw in line towards whatever you're building to a source of coal via boats boats or railroads and that the rules for building factories and in the first half of the games you can only build one building per location and that's the rules to building factories each turn in brass is an exercise in frustration because everything is so interlinked that you'll find yourself thinking you can do something I need to realize you forgot they saw that or the other so why even bother your greatest plan your genius move that you've been building up to four turns will be scuppered by someone interrupting you with a toy I'm not sure you can do that sometimes even building just a single tile will feel like climbing the tallest peaks of Mount

Everest each action you take requires you to play occurred and draw a card turn after turn this debt gets smaller and you have yourself a pressure cooker situation going brass is a game that thrives on stress for some of you and I don't blame you this will be the line in the sand that you just won't see the point in crossing it's easy to dismiss brass as just dry mechanisms ink to link together forcing you to think about cubes and cardboard chips grinding like old gears until they forcibly click into points and to some extent this game is that but stay a little while longer and listen because you might discover that those cogs spin into something beautiful inside the dusty heart of brass is emergently meaning every reaction feeds into a potential response let's say you want to build an iron mine it comes into play with our in cubes every time someone needs iron they use your iron which is a good thing because as soon as all the iron clears from the tile it will flip and score your points not only is it thematic each business using resources other businesses create to fuel their own goals it creates incentives and opportunities for future actions similarly if you develop meaning discarding lower level tiles from your board to give you access to higher level industries you have to pay one iron for each tile you discard what happens in a situation when there is no iron either on your opponent's factories or your own factories well

that's not really a problem you can still use iron from the general market paying money for each cube you discard from there which could potentially lead to the situation where no iron is on the general market that's alright you can still buy it's just very expensive but what if you were to build an iron mine when the island market is depleted that's good news because all the iron that would potentially go on that tile instead goes on to the general market not only may be automatically flipping that tile for points but also giving you money for each cube you put on there what does this all mean well developing consumes iron therefore decreasing the supply and increasing the demand and increasing the price of iron which incentivizes to do things that actually produce iron like building an iron mine which then floods the market with iron and suddenly the price for iron goes down because the supply is plentiful and the price has decreased which means iron is cheap which incentivizes you to then do actions that actually consume iron such as developing so therefore the game becomes self-fulfilling it's like somebody knocking down the first domino and then the dominoes keep falling in a circle infinite esily until the game ends it's like an robberies of resource exploitation it's like somebody starting the car and going how long can we drive this for it turns out forever

because driving the car makes the fuel what about the low-cost underpaid labor force in the car yeah in the car like the tiny people that making the fuel in the engine oh no don't worry about them they're abstracted away despite logic just like the mechanisms in the game infinitely rotating I bet I could go on about the clever interlocking mechanisms in brass forever because they just don't seem to end and I could just sit here and list them over and over and over again but that would just be way to self-indulgence just kind of proving my own intellectual capacity of understanding this game so for the sake of brevity which is not going to do that Khan Mills are the tiles that will score you a lot of points but to flip them you have to be connected to a port you can of course build your own port that's fine but as soon as you do someone will sense an opportunity build their own cotton mill and then flip your port and their cotton mill effectively flipping you the finger and you'll go okay no I'm smart I'm gonna wait for someone else to build the port and then I'll need to build like a road connecting to that pole to my cotton mill and then I'll flip my cotton mill and that will be fine except you then realize that in this game cotton mills are some of the most expensive tiles and each time you spend money it goes on the iniciative tracks but the most and next time you will be lost

giving people ample opportunity to once again flip you the finger I promise I am done now and actually I have to admit that I have avoided playing brass for the longest time having a game held up in particular breviary can be mildly off-putting especially when that reverie is this game is for smart people which makes me think I'll be spending my evening with unwitting victims of the dunning-kruger effect who will try to prove their intellectual superiority by learning rote strategies but having played bass I realized there isn't really very much that is wrote about it it's a rhizomatic organism that blooms each time you sit down and play and its growth depends on you you don't need to be small you need to sense opportunities you need to Zig when these are and maybe you need to be a little bit clever and then you can be good at bras clever read the scene up didn't you yes that's not to say that brass is somehow easy and forgiving catch a wave and you gracefully coast to the shore of victory points but slip up in your face plant onto the board that's the surfboard not the game board oh I suppose the analogy works for both in a game where you're constantly trying to find opportunities to exploit your opponents it's very easy to find that you're the one who's always being exploited all of that is to say that brass isn't a very nice experience when you know that you're losing we already mentioned the brief rule set that on the

surface things like it's easy to learn but it's not that the minutiae of the rules is hard to understand in fact I'd argue that brass is a relatively simple game it's just that the minutiae constantly gets in the way of actual play I often found myself asking my friends whether they remember to check if they're connected or if they've spent a card as part of doing an action as if I was checking up on them as if I thought they didn't know how to play but of course they know how to play it's just that if one of us didn't do that someone would forget and make a mistake which made me feel like I was an immigration officer on an episode of border patrol checking for spelling errors on someone's visa document and what about the game literally having to be played twice what other game does not halfway through the game the canal face will be over which is when the game like an angry mother who found out you haven't done your homework borrowed jizz into the bathroom and takes all your toy boats away all the links you have been carefully building between your factories will disappear as the industry discovers that digging all these ditches was sold yesterday in the second railroad face you'll end up playing the game sort of again but this time the level to factories on higher still remain on the board but everything houses taken away and you have to reconnect everything again and in this time it is so much harder and more punishing and what really fascinates me is that even in the first phase every decision that you make even if it seems to be the best possible decision at the

time is tinged with this aura of uncertainty because you're just not sure how it's going to play out when everything is upended I find that beautiful so that's brass in a as much of a nutshell as you could actually fit a ticket to right-size board game about seven times more game than ticket to ride into an actual nut shell it just it doesn't fit to some this video might seem like a truncation and if it does then you probably already love brass Lancashire or might be someone that would or if all feels like a bit too much and you weren't intrigued then you won't or it might have just enough curiosity to finally play this game that you've heard about mentioned in dark seedy cardboard alleys from strange men who pulled board games out from under their trench coats and if you're not one of those people you might not have heard that the new edition comes with a companion brass Birmingham and if you're just intrigued enough to get one of them then you'll have to wait a bit longer but I know you can tell these games are a bit complex and each of them deserves a good amount of time spent on them our review of brass Birmingham welcome in the future but for now I will leave you with a special message from Africa have you ever wondered why is it that you know every

YouTube video ends with if you like this video like and subscribe it and like hands and things ending every which way and pointing into nothing really isn't it banal isn't it try on youtubers self-aware do they just not get how cliche the whole thing is and I'll tell you why we do it because it works and not only because it works this is because it's beneficial not just to us but to you as well because YouTube is run by machine algorithms you know every time you click a like' or dislike' or a comment or subscribe every time you engage with the video in some form doesn't matter what it is you are helping a scroll because you're telling the algorithms that people are engaging with this thing and the algorithms are pushing the thing upwards and right now actually we really need that because YouTube's algorithm you want to push everything down rather than up it's really actually hard to go up so we need you to to press a thing you know just press anything it doesn't even matter just press it and the reason that beneficial to you is because the more engagement we get the more it feeds back into itself and the more viewership we get and the more viewership we get the more potential revenue we get and the more potential revenue we get the more we can dedicate all time and resources and finances to making better videos have you noticed how NPI videos have been just going whoa in quality that's cuz of you right you made that happen not us that's you you engaging in the

comments and saying something nice or just liking or whatever even disliking so you know if you never left a comment or like the video or whatever maybe do so just because you know what this will be better and also you never know what you might even find a friend because the people who comment on our NPI videos really nice even if you haven't anything to say about this video you just have questions about board games maybe leave them down there and maybe someone else will answer them and you might make a friend which I think would be just the nicest outcome that I could imagine that so there if you enjoyed this video like and subscribe and leave a comment okay see you later

Progress saved