Witchcraft!: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and to D I'm doing the discussion over witchcraft which is the newest solo game from Salt and Pepper games uh this is from the same designer team and Publishing team that did uh resist now in this video I will not be comparing the two because I haven't played resist so I obviously couldn't but for my understanding they're uh roughly similar at least in terms of some gameplay obviously this has some differences with like the juror and persuasion and stuff like that but that's the extent of my knowledge between the two um now if you watched the channel before you know that I am typically not a solo player like even though I have quite a few solo variants and run throughs and discussions over them I mainly play those for the channel and then I really never touched them again however it is kind of funny that this year I have done uh reviews over solo only games quite a bit and one I just recently did was over 20 strong um so I might just be lying to myself saying that I'm not a solo gamer but anyway what do I think of Witchcraft well this is a theme that is kind of popular or it's coming up at least within my own personal life uh as well because I'm going to become a witch uh no it just seems that this is kind of
the buzz there was another game that came out of the same theme called Septima which is about a coven of witches and I think it is a wonderful uh theme this game is Loosely centered around these Salem Witch Trials although the theming the world are all fake like it's like like hey the Salem witch trials happened but they mentioned at the beginning of the rule book that it's meant to be uh an honorable depiction of those horrific acts it's it's bringing you know the witches up and defending the village uh from these horrible Supernatural things that are pulled from a bunch of different folklore and I think that's really cool um I like that little twist on it I think that by being like hey by the way uh we're actually yeah we have Powers but we need those powers to defend from Baba Yaga and from Jenny green teeth or the possessed tree or things like that so it's like we're going to help and we're going to show our powers but at the same time uh through fear and unrest and uncertainty you're still going to jail us so we still have to persuade you that we're good um yeah theming is really cool the art is fantastic I really like the depiction that they did for all the different missions that you go on uh the twist with like the the Dual sided cards where it shows like their villager or their Hidden Side where they're regular
people and then like uh just a different art style of the same person when they're a witch like Jay Bone splitter is like it looks like a traveling Merchant and then whenever they're ready to throw down they pull out a shield with a skull on it in a massive you know Magic um there's Adelaide Miller who just looks like a young little school girl on The Hidden Side and then she's as powerful lightning Summoner as the witch I think that's really neat uh but what I find extremely fascinating about this game is how much control you actually have as you're playing there's a lot of different combos you have within the different families of the witches so uh at the very beginning of the game you can you draft witches until you have your own deck and you can create a lot of really cool synergies with that you can go all in on one particular family that's like hey for each person of this family that you play you know do this better ability you could diversify so you can deal with whatever uh is kind of coming your way but you're not really you're not deck building in this at all you're actually deck deconstructing because whenever you're playing you have hand of five cards so let's just say these are the five witches in my hand you get to play witches for their powers and mainly you're going to be playing witches that will say reveal challenges challenges are these uh face down cards
on the missions that you have to deal with as well as whatever the mission itself says you're mainly going to be doing that so you can kind of get some insight and what I really like about this game is you get I'm about to cry uh is you get to play witches before you even choose a mission so let's say you're like oh this Mission looks really easy and then you play a few cards flip over some challenges and you're like that's not even beatable anymore with what I currently have so never mind going to course correct and I'm going to go and do a different Mission now you did use those witches to reveal that information so you can't reuse them but it's like well now I know and I can plan ahead then you choose a mission and then you continue to play witches and I like the fact that whenever you're playing you get to you know play their hidden or revealed side and then whenever like then you choose a mission and you can do the same thing again like it's you're not like locked in on being like Play hidden witches okay now choose a mission now play revealed witches it's not like that you have a lot of freedom with what you're dealing with which is really cool considering the fact that the challenges are completely random like the deck is constructed with I think it's like 20 b basic cards but then depending on your jurors uh you'll have challenges that are kind of thematically tied to them in the challenge deck as well um so that also gives you some type of insight if you're going up against hacket you know
kind of what he's going to be bringing in the challenges you don't know where or when they're going to pop up but you know kind of what he's dealing with uh and you gather that kind of insight but I still even though those are random you still never feel like you're really topdecking because of the way you get to play your witches it's not it's not like oh okay I play all your cards now reveal all the challenges and hope that you're able to kind of do stuff you can be like okay I'm going to play this one that reveals this okay cursed chickens it's only strength two I'm going up against eight okay I've already calculated my max power which could be 14 so I'm still good there um and then you reveal then you're like now I'm going to go okay that's a three that's a two and that's another two oh wait that's a familiar I have a card or a witch that lets me take a familiar so that gives me that um so you get to react or you get you get to be proactive and then you get to be reactive and also this game is still relatively challenging like even though I'm talking about the freedom of playing it's not not like oh well what's the point you're going to win anyway um no because you're not going to know the values you might know there are a bunch of wild boes in the deck but you don't you don't know what the value of which wild boar is going to be out and you also have to pick and choose like if you
add up all your uh uh Power and going up against a mission eight and you have 14 okay well you can choose to deal with the mission that's eight so now you have six left over but you have have 10 of the challenges left so you have to decide what you can deal with and what you can't it's like okay that wild Bo is a three that'll make me lose a random hidden witch I played all my witches as hidden so I don't know which one I'm going to lose oh wait that possessed is there if I take care of that one I'll get to see a conviction card on that one which will let me know how much I have to persuade them oh and there's a familiar it's that kind of stuff uh also having ways to recruit more witches into your coven is nice I'm glad you're not just stuck with the uh the cards that you drafted at the beginning um because what's also really neat I mentioned this game was deck deconstructing is Every Witch obviously has better um revealed Powers so whenever they come out as a witch they have it's either a a buff of their hidden power or it's just a straight up buff of their actual power however after you're done with the mission all the witches that you played as revealed go to jail which is better than the alternative of what it was in real life so uh but that's not the end of it because there are some families that are really good about getting people out of jail so it's not like they're gone and remove from the game although you're the
one making that decision if you're like uh okay do I risk it that's them they have a really good hidden power do I want to keep that for the whole game or do I want to use their once per game uh revealed power uh I don't know can I get them back maybe you never know depending on the mission some missions have a success that say oh get someone out of jail back into your coven this game just feels very fair and I also like the fact that you can take penalties and that's not the end of the world like there are mult it was funny reading the rules it's kind of like oh by the way if you do this you lose if this happens you lose if this happens you lose just kind of as you're reading uh and you can lose in multiple ways um if you ever draw a hand of five cards and it's there are no witches you lose uh if you ever have to draw a curse card which curse cards just go into your deck uh they just basically clog up your deck if you ever have to draw a curse card and you can't you lose uh there's a small village deck that ranges from zero all the way to three when you have to lose a villagers card you just flip that over and if that ever uh is five or higher like the total value is five or higher you lose to cuz you're trying to defend the village so if they just die or if too many villagers die it's like well we didn't really defend them um but I think that's the only way oh and also when you go to
trial and you haven't convinced enough jurors you you pretty much lose there's like if you convince all three of them that's like a super win you convince two out of three it's a a draw if you convince only one you lose and then obviously if you don't convince any then you super duper lost um but the um I like the fact that whenever you are deciding to you know fail certain things you're you're allowed to do that you can be like well I can handle putting a curse into my deck or well I can handle flipping over a villager's card uh you're able to make minor mistakes which softens the blow of you know Randomness from a deck of challenge cards uh and I like that some some games like I mean I guess this is technically Cooperative I'm cooperating with myself um some of them are just like insanely brutal where you have to be as efficient as possible and if you make any mistake you're guaranteed to lose and that's like annoying whenever it's like well I can't control what the deck is putting out uh I could do my best but you're allowed to make some mistakes um one thing I also really like about this game is I like the conviction cards because you have a conviction deck which ranges from all the way from one to six and there's only one six there are there's one one uh two
twos 33s three fours two fs and one six so there are families that deal with revealing uh um the conviction cards and whenever you're revealing those that gives you some insight on how much they're on your side some will be insanely high like my angel needed 10 she was actually the one that I didn't convince in this latest game I had eight and I was like ah there's there's no way I like cuz I even removed she she was a six at first six and five and I was like that's insane and and I got rid of the six and replaced it with a face down one I'm like sh I'm at eight chances are it it skews three and four it's probably three so I I just me it we're good um everyone else I got Martha was a one and a two and hacket happened to be a three and a four and I had seven so I met him Martha was on my side from the very beginning she's like hell yeah women uh and jel was like I [ __ ] hated all of you [ __ ] from the start uh I he there was nothing you could do to convince me I have it out for you uh probably cuz we didn't let her in recover cuz she smells weird um but yeah it was like well that's that I didn't get her even though like the very next card would have been a four anyway so doesn't matter she yeah wasn't happening but that's okay um I also like when you complete
missions uh the missions are assigned to a specific juror so it's like hey by the way hacket we goty rid of that possessed tree and he you can give him five persuasion or you can give someone else three like I like the fact that you don't have to beine and go after one specific juror if you're like well this is an easier mission for me to do well I mean Martha needs three I have six I don't need to convince her anymore I don't I can do the gather medicine at the edge of which I don't need to give her four okay well I'll still complete it and I'll put two somewhere else I like that this game just feels very giving while also making you still feel challenged the entire time and there's a ton in this box I don't know if resist was like this I pretty sure it probably was um but this game was insanely cheap which is why I also backed it because I'm like well why not uh and you have a ton of different of of cards uh ton of different witches that you can combo uh the missions are done in three different acts and you have a ton of different jurors that come in the jurors themselves their persuasion doesn't change it's still -3 up to 16 um but they each all the different jurors have different acts of missions so they each have three which come with a bunch of
different um uh ways to play and then also the challenge cards are tied to the jurors so you're going to have a lot of variety of just randomly placing the jurors out which is going to cause random challenges and different missions that you're going to have to go up against and on top of that this is also based off of the fact that you draft your coven uh at the very beginning you also have this uh tales of the Wilder greens werr uh scenario book so these are essentially it's not like a campaign as far as I can tell I think it's just different ways to play it might be a slight story uh overall but it's not like this massive narrative thing you're not going to be pulling for teller out for this but there are nine different tals that have different uh setup instructions and ways to play so you also will have that yeah I mean negatives I really don't have any like not a lot um yeah I mean you could theoretically I mean it it's it's a deck game it's a card game you're you could just get [ __ ] on your hand and then you still cuz you have to play your witches you
can't hold them I mean theoretically you don't ever have to do the ability so it's kind of like you know a deck builder where it's like you have to play out your whole hand but you don't really have to use any of the cards so if it's like oh well I don't want to move a face down conviction card you don't have to so you just you just have to play them it's really just you can't hold witches over from round to round so theoretically you could play this and you could have a really bad hand of like three curses and two witches and still have to go pick a mission and you know you're going to fail it um so that's just kind of the way it is I have never you know really had that happen like uh but that's kind of like just getting a dead hand in uh in any deck builder even though this isn't a deck builder you just try to mitigate the the negatives as much as possible um but also oh another way you can lose is if you fail two missions so one change that I noticed was whenever you fail a mission you actually just flip it over and now you only have two missions to choose from and if you obviously fail a second one then you just lose so but I mean if you're getting that kind of hand then just reset up the game it's very very clean to set up and uh tear down I I think it's great I think is great and I really like the theme um even though
obviously this say the witch trials and the witch trials in general were horrendous uh and completely [ __ ] up but it's uh I mean this is a game and not real life so yeah on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm going to give witchcraft a nine I I I really like it I again can't compare it to resist so I don't know if uh the differences or anything like that I know the theme of resist is I mean it's it's a war theme I think it's a the Spanish War I don't know which one though anyway uh this is more my speed anyway so I I really kind of lean more into this than the other one uh really wish I could tell you if it's worth owning both uh I don't know I guess if you have played resist and you watch this video and you're like oh yeah all that sounds great and different enough well then great get both but yeah that is my thoughts on witchcraft let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time upate it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run or reviews or cool
top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you