Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dead of Winter Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 18:05

hello welcome back to the port games 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings and we generally talk a lot of bollocks about ball games card games tabletop games welcomes and anything to do with that sort of thing so in this video we're going to be talking about game that's now no 5 years old I can't I can't believe this games 5 years old we're going to be looking at dead of winter this is a zombie themed post-apocalyptic from that game that may or may not have a hidden traitor and in this video we're going to be giving you a very very brief overview of the rules and a base game and we might throw in some stuff from the from the long night expansion and also the war in colonies expansion will be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not dead a window it's still worth playing today and in the future and whether or not there's other games that come out since its release in 2014 that are better than this one so if you knew it then please consider subscribing to our channel leave a comment in that section it downstairs in that box down there and we'll see you after this

games 4k so data Whitner how to plant we're gonna give you a rough rules overview so this game is divided into two phases and the first phase is the player's turn face in the second phase it's the colony face and in the plaster face you're all going to be well to start with you're going to be taking a couple of characters are going to be controlling one it's gonna be the lead character one it's gonna be a sidekick and on the card you've got me at the top you've got the character's charisma or their leadership qualities right and that's useful for who goes first in the round and then you've got the how powerful our fight in and then you've also got how good they're searching and in every character it's got a special ability here at the bottom so you'll be taken to ities and you'll be taken a number of dice equal to the number of characters that you've got plus one for the player and at the beginning of the player turn your reveal a crisis and this crisis will generally ask you to contribute a certain number of resources by the end of the that round and if you do it you get a bonus and if you don't something really really nasty happens so that's one thing you've got take care of so I also had a beginning of the round you will draw a cross wild card and this is a huge deck of cards is this guy's like a choice you gotta make so you read some flavor text and then of an individual or the group will make a decision and sometimes I'll have a folk and implement the results of the vote and yeah some of these some of these these cards are really quite sort of heroine quite nasty

and some of the decisions you've got to make aren't very pleasant and it's a good thing because it really does sort of hit home but yeah so that's one of the first things that you got do is you've got a resolve crossroad cards so so for you could do everybody rolls their dice and you'll be assigning those dice to a variety of different actions so some actions required dice others don't require dice so you can just take them anyway so the first thing you can do this you can attack a zombie or another player if you if you want it so we do you'll choose a target and you'll spend one of the dice you just roll and you have to choose one that is equal to or higher your attack value and then the attack hits okay but you also have to roll the exposure though if you are attacking a zombie and the way this works is is it's a 12-sided die you've got a one in 12 chance have been bitten and dying straightaway right so yeah then you can overtake a wound you take three wounds and you're dead or you can get frostbite and wounds appear each round until you're cured for frostbite all nothing happens so that's how you have a fight so the second thing you could do is you could search and there's a variety of locations in this game you've got the police station you've got the school we've got the library you've got all sorts of different locations that you can visit and what you do when you move to a location you can you roll the exposure die as you did when you have a scrap and then you move your character there so when you're at a location you can search the location for things and each location has a deck of cards that you will search for and each location

will have a majority of certain types of cards oh the gas station you might have a herb majority fuel the armory you might have a verb majority of weapons and so on and so forth so you search through a new looking for you take the items that you search for and there's a variety of items you've got lots of weapons like the shotgun you've got you've got food you've got a gas and you've got also got just just waste that you can pick up right so and also you can draw more cards but you make noise and that increases the chance of a zombie appearing at that location by 50% and that could be bad so lesser is a bit of a gamble so you can also choose any die it doesn't have to be any specific number and you can add a barricade to a location and barricades get destroyed before zombies appear okay so next thing you could do you can clean white so every time you spend food or spend anything in the colony which is where the survivors are so little hidey-hole you have to put a waste card on the Vice part and if the waste part gets too much then you lose morale because nobody likes crapping in their own nest right so you can also spend an action die to attract zombies to your locations as a good way of drawing zombies away from one location and bringing to a location where you can deal with it more easily so also if your characters special ability requires a necktie you can spend the action dye to perform that special ability and there's a variety of special abilities in this game you might have farmer can he's good at searching for food you might have characters that

are better at weapons we might have a character that is good at search in or something it's a huge huge huge huge pasture right home different characters especially policing this guy so the actions that don't require a a die is that you couldn't you can play a card so you play a card from your hand and then you do what it says on the card right you can also add one of your cuts of the crisis so if the crisis requires that you need to accumulate say six food tokens and you can play a food card and had that many tokens to the crisis and also you can move a survivor so we would have talked about this you couldn't go from one location to another and you've already expose your thigh and implement its effects so you can also expend food tokens and when you do this you can increase the number on one die by one for each food token that you spend so you can also request a car to multiply see say look I need I'll need some food overall some medicine over can you give it to me and then that player gives you the card it's also if you're the same location as another survivor you could hand off any items that are equipped to that character to another player at the same location and the final thing that you could do is you can vote to exos if you think somebody's a hidden traitor right then you can say look off in it Oh Jeremy be the weapon there's a traitor so you all have a little vote do this this this or this and then if they're XO certain things happen right so that's all the actions you can take yeah that was a tough one so we move on to the colonies if colony faced right so this is where you sort of do a bit of upkeep in the colony the first thing you have to do is you have to pay food that

you've accumulated and it's one food token from every two survivors at the colony and that's not just characters that you control you've also got those useless really annoying little survivors there they're painting I said you've got a lot of food but I don't do anything so you pay pay your food and move on to the next bit so next thing you do is you will have to check your waste bin and for every ten waste cart in the waste pile you will have to reduce the old morale by one and if morale goes to zero is over you'll you lose so next when you do you resolve the crisis and this is where the media came I saw you take all the cars of people who contributed to the crisis and you shuffle them and then you flip them over one by one and if you resolve the crisis then you get a bonus if you don't then something crap happens and if you're a hidden treasure you can add the wrong cards to the crisis so that every card that matches the criterion of crisis you get +1 therefore everyone doesn't you get minus 1 so if this is where the traitor can influence the game to try and lose the game because you because they're the cards are shuffled you don't know who put what in the crisis deck right so the next thing you do is you go out zombies and you're going to add one zombie every two survivors at the colony and a various locations you're going to be added one zombie or every survivor present right then you'll check the main objective and see if it's been matched if it with you if you've matched the main objective and

you match your personal jessica says two objectives it's a public and a private objective and you've got to complete both before the end of the game right and you move the round tracker and pass the first prior marker and then you rinse wash and repeat and that is essentially how you play dead a winner so what do we like about dead off winner so the first thing we got talk about where this one is the is it's wonderfully for Mac and this the characters in the game I know some of them sort of stereotypical a zombie movie zombie film Trump's yes so to speak but yeah there's a lot of love for our TV you've even got you've got the opportunity to play like a multicenter Wyatt you've got you've also got Michael Jackson's monkey bubbles is in there hello well maybe it's not bubbles but it's a monkey in there and you could be for pie like a circus dog you got ninjas in there and they've all got different special abilities and there's no that when they die you just you've got the opportunity to get more more characters out of deck because in the crossfire card you can recruit new members of your Posse right so there's that hasn't really a sort of famer we think if there was it wasn't such a diverse array of characters in this game it would fall a little bit more flat yeah so it really does evoke that not the Living Dead Day of the Dead Dawn of the Dead type of thing going on right so the second thing that we really like about this one is the hidden trailer aspect is augmented

by the fact that you've got a secret objective and if you think about games like you say shadows over camera on Battlestar Galactica there's no personal objective that you've got complete so this sort of adds to the this or Colin out of the trailer sorting because even though if you're not the trailer you've got that secret objective that you've got complete and that might make you look like the trailer so it really does add a sore dynamic sort of game and it makes the game that much more rich and more interesting so yes really good so the follow of an orphan is another thing that we really saw lifts elevators going above other games of its type other zombie games and other hidden treasure games it is the fact that the cross rope cards really do some fat a storytelling element to this game in it you can even download an app for your iPad or your Android phone or whatever where you get this get Eric some iratus so he reads off these cards here and that if I mean we don't use that could be like sort of 10 I'm telling in our own way there really doesn't add us a storytelling element to this already fnatic game so fantastic so the fourth thing that we really really really really really like about this one is that the cooperative and individual nature of this game combine to provide you with some power in choices you know you do you do try and complete your seat your secret objects your a personal goal first and the detriment of the group or do you try and help the group first because if the group doesn't perform

well and your morale goes down and you can lose the game to you you it's a tussle between what you do in for yourself and what you do for the group and I think that that would that's what I am sort of realistic conundrums that you've got a overcome if this was reality which it might be it's one of them things where in this situation in reality you would be torn between us or thing when you're so so what don't we like about dead of winter so the first thing that we tend to get frustrated with about this game is the fact that it everything hinges on random Darrow's and it might be the case that you you get crap rolls when you roll your blue action dice but there's ways to make right now but the thing that we find most of Australian is the exposure die and you could be trundling along really happily you've built up a well for stuff for your character and you think they're rock art and then suddenly boom out of blue you roll that one single side of the die that kills your character how right and into the death is never welcome we hate into the death and it's the same the zombie so I suffered from this kind of thing with the targeting issue and that was resolved in in our sort result in future but you had to help small get out and is there a way a house wall in the cell I know it provides that do or die mechanism that is that it's kind of needed but it's also very for Australian if you if you continually roll those those into the death roll so one no so

another thing that is to do with randomization in this game is the random nature of the searches so you'll just essentially where you got a search you've just taken the top and seeing what you get and there's no there was a way to sort of those sort of ways to influence what's in the debt quite through various means but essentially it just it's just hitting hope right so you the way the decks set up is that's how that's always like pretty determined and if you add in the expansions that creates more problems you gonna have to start taking cars out of decks and doctoring the deck to make it to even up and I've done office a better way of doing this maybe I took your tokens out of a bag that's still wearing the minute I don't know but it can be very very frustrating but whatever so the third thing that we find frustrating is that the expansions make this game far to blow it when you add it in the racks on facility and you've got a bandits hideout and all this stuff going on and it's just it's too many for us to pull out and it is modular but why would you want to buy an expansion if you're not going to use all the stuff in it so it makes no sense to me but there was there should have been better ways to implement the extra content and the fact that the long night is a standalone game but it's also a an expansion it means that you're buying stuff that you've already got in the box yeah so there's a pair of a ripoff at the end of the day so the fourth thing and the main thing that is a

problem with dead of winter and probably all hidden trailer games or any and all these sort of these games is that the endgame could be realized way way way way before the actual endgame so you could do really really badly down to a man of dollars on random cart draughts and you might be you might see that everything's lost before you actually get to that point so you're playing out sort of the third the last third of the game or the last corner game for no reason because you know you can't win so that's a big problem with these hidden treasure games in these disease in these creeping death type of games like CSA the Robinson Crusoe is the same things that suffers from the fact that you you know you can't win quite early on and you'll just play it out a slow demise so two summer is dead of winter five years in is it still worth playing today has anything superseded and we're going to say this is an excellently thematic zombie apocalypse game and the added element of across our cards there's a lot of story to this this they cross write cards aren't really sort of that they seem to crop up and then you know well that's that's a bit weird that doesn't really for him you know so you have these scenarios on the crossroad cars that sort of don't really tie in very well and this game would probably do well if had some kind of campaign system or there are say a legacy aspect to this of dead of winter Leduc legacy would be a phenomenal thing right but you need some

sort of structured narrative that way I think the game would improve through some kind of a structured narrative so like we said the expansions probably add a little bit too much for this and the fact you're repeating what you've already bought is a problem so but the modular nature means that you can chop and change out stuff you don't play with so there is a way of Mecca in that problem but it's still a problem nonetheless I gotta give this game all-stars our five and yeah you add the expansions in it really does become a complete game you've got the war and colonies expansion which so lets you that's that's the main way I've get them over the fan you've bought stuff twice because you can use both sets of components and fight it off amongst two rival colonies so I think if you have got the longer expansion to service and though brainer to get the boron colonies because it gives you extra extra kha'zix with crossroad cards gives you extra characters extra stuff this this is a complete system it really does work really well we do recommend then it went out there's not really been any kind of hidden track going to sort of overtaking this in the last five years since its release it's worth looking at showers over Camelot as a sort of a counterpoint to this one because it's a lot more simple and a lot quicker but yeah four stars out of five what more do you want from Assam be hidden try again it's like we said if you're new here then please consider subscribing to our channel leave a comment in that box down there and we'll see you next time

Progress saved