Skip to main content
Loading video...

Eclipse 1st Edition Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 15:43

Hello, welcome back to the channel and this is the channel where we give you reviews, playthroughs, unboxings. We generally like to talk a lot of bollocks to top gaming in general. And in this video, we're going to be talking about a 4x game. We're going to be talking about about Eclipse. And in this game, you will be trying to explore, expand, exterminate, and exploit the galaxy to give you victory points that will allow you to win the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules, be telling you what we do like, we don't like, and we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Eclipse is still worth playing 10 years after it first released in 2011. So, remember, if you're new here, then please consider subscribing to this channel. Leave a comment in that section down below, will you? See you after this.

Alex. So, Eclipse, how do you play this game? So, Eclipse is a 4x sort of euro/ trash game. It's got elements of both genres in it. Like most games, it's going to be a race to get the most victory points before the end of the ninth round. And the game follows a set number of phases. You got the action phase. You have then got the combat phase and you got a bit of clean up. And then you've got the upkeep phase, right? So you're going to start the game with your home planet on the board. The game board will be different each round due to the fact that you've got the galactic center. And then you've got three different rings that revolve around a galactic center. You got ring one, ring two, and ring three. You'll also have a player board that will have your races economy track. It will have your resources track and it'll have the blueprints of your ships where you'll be placing upgrades. Right. So the first phase of this game is the action phase.

This is where you'll be taking actions. Funny old thing. What you'll do, you will move a disc from the influence track and you'll place it on the action that you want to take. There's six different actions that you can do. The first action you can do is the explore action. You'll point to the blank sector that you want to explore and then you'll take a 1, two, or three tile and you'll look at it and you'll decide whether or not you want to place it. If you decide to place it, you'll place it face up and you'll have to orient the tile from wormhole to wormhole. You can't have half a wormhole going in deep space, right? Unless you've got a wormhole generator that you have researched, but we'll get to that later. So, you'll see on the tiles, you may have a certain amount of planets. You'll have the option of populating these planets, and you'll look at the color of the square that's on the planet. And you'll take a cube from the relative spot on your playerboard. That'll either be your economy track, it'll either be the materials track, the brown track, or the research track, and you'll place it on the board. And you'll see that as you take cubes off of these tracks, it will give you a certain amount of income during the upkeep phase, right?

Similarly, the more actions you take, the more costly your empire is going to be to run because it's going to expand, right? So, if you do place population on the planet, you have to use your Billy Connelly ships and you will have to flip over one of the ships to show that you've used it. Sometimes when you explore, you'll see that you will have a discovery tile space. And if that's the case and you do decide to populate a planet by placing an influence disc in the center of the tile, then you will take that discovery token and you will look at it and you'll decide to either use it for the victory points or you'll use it for the bonus. Bonus can be anything from resources to ancient alien technologies that you can place on the blueprints of your ship. There's loads of them and always handy to have. Sometimes you may reveal a skull on the tile and that means that there is one of the old ancient aliens that you will have to destroy to get the goodies and to place an influence disc on there.

Right. So the second action you could do is the influence action. This is where you'll be manipulating the influence discs on and off the board. You get to move two. You can either move one on, one off, two on, two off, or whatever you want to do. Right. Next action is the research action. You'll look at the research board and you'll choose a technology that you haven't already researched and you'll pay the cost. two different costs on the research board. You'll have the current cost and the cheapest cost. And the more of each of the type of technology that you research, it might be weapons, grid, or nanotechnology. Then you'll get a discount for each space that you occupy on your board. Right? When you research technology, it might give you access to extra weaponry, extra upgrades for your ship, or might just give you some special action like neutron bombs that destroy all of the population on the planets that you take over. Right. So, the next action is the upgrade action.

This is where you get to upgrade your ships. You will choose a technology that maybe you've researched, maybe you haven't, and you'll take the relevant tile and you'll place it on either an empty space on your ship or you'll cover up an existing technology. Right? You have to make sure that your ship's energy production can accommodate these new upgrades. So, it's in your interest to get a pretty hefty energy source to beef up them ships. You know what I mean? So, the next action is a build action. This is where you'll be able to build ships or structures, right? You'll pay the cost which is in the brown circle and then you'll place the miniatures or the monolith or the orbital markers on a territory that you control. Next action is the move action. You'll look at the amount of hexagons that you've got on the ship and this will tell you how many spaces it can move in a move action. You can do two move actions with this. You can either have one ship make two move actions or two ships make one move action and you'll just move your ship through the wormholes. Right. So, the last thing you can do is you can pass. And this is where you'll flip over your little cheat sheet board and it will tell you that you've got a certain amount of reactions to take. And these are basically just dumbed down versions of actions that you could have taken previously. And generally speaking, people don't bother with these, do they? Otherwise, you wouldn't have passed, would you have?

So, there's also diplomacy. If you've got an influence disc that is adjacent to a another player through a full wormhole, then you can trade diplomacy markers. This will give you victory points at the end of the game. But if you ever break that alliance by invading somebody else's sector, then you will take the traitor tile. And this will mean that you lose two victory points at the end of the game if you're still in possession of it. Right. So once everyone's passed, you'll look to see if there's any combat if you're either in a space with an ancient or another player. And then you'll have a scrap. You'll look at the ships that are in the spaces and you'll look at the initiative value of each ship. These are the little arrow things that are on your blueprints, right? The ships with with the highest initiative will go first. And you'll look at the weapons that you got and you'll roll a dieice for each die printed on the blueprints, right? A one is always a miss. A six is always a hit.

And you might be able to boost the attacking value of your dice with some nice little upgrades. So if you hit, you look at the amount of damage you do, then your opponent will choose which ship they want to destroy. Ships ordinarily can absorb one damage, but depending on what type of hole you got, it can absorb more. Right? So keep doing this until one player is destroyed. There is an option to retreat. The opponent will be able to give you a slap on your way out. And then the winner will look at the little cheat sheet thing and it will tell you how many reputation tiles you can draw from the bag based on just being in combat, which ship you destroyed and you'll draw them out and then you'll choose one and you'll place it on the little slot on the side of your board. Right. Once you've done that, you can choose to destroy all the poor little innocent bystanders on the planet. You'll either do an attack or use your neutron bombs. And then once the population's been destroyed, then you'll be able to put an influence disc on that spot if you want to. So once everyone's out of punch up, the next phase is the upkeep phase. This is where you will pay the cost of your empire and balance it with your resources, right? If you can't do that, then you can pay three for one with other resources. And if you still can't do it, then you have to take influence discs off the board, right? Then you'll do a bit of clean up. You'll draw out some extra research tiles. You do this for nine rounds. then you'll t your victory points on your reputation markers maybe on the sector tiles that you control on your diplomacy markers your discovery tiles and all that sort of stuff and then the player with the most victory points will be the winner of Eclipse. So what do we like about Eclipse?

So the first thing that we really like about this game is the balance that you've got between being able to take actions and the resources that you spend. The more actions you take, the more expensive your empire is going to cost to run. But in taking more explore actions, you're going to have the opportunity to exploit more of the planet's resources. You have to be very careful, though, because it all depends on where you explore. You'll probably find there's going to be more resources on the outer edges of the galaxy, and there's going to be more opportunities for combat on the inner rings of the galaxy. Yeah. So there's a nice balance and a nice choice to be made between whether or not you just blow your stack all at once or whether or not you hold back a bit of cash to maybe do some ships up and then go for victory points in combat. Right. Nice. So the second thing we like bad clips is the fact that you get rewarded for just going into combat. You don't actually have to win the combat to get a chance at nabbing some victory points. Okay, you're not going to be able to draw many tiles.

Well, you're only going to be able to draw one, ain't you? But the fact that combat is lucrative if you win, but you're still going to have the chance to draw those reputation tiles out even if you lose. So, you got a chance of drawing that four tile means that when you play this game, there's always that tantalizing option of getting stuck in even if you know you're going to lose. Right. So, the next thing that we like about Eclipse is the fact that the galaxy isn't predetermined. I mean, if you think about games that are sort of unfairly lumped in with this game, like Swallow Imperium, the board is actually randomized, but you know exactly where all the resources and all the planets are when you start off. In Eclipse, you don't know that. You're just going to start off with all your home planets, and the board evolves as the game progresses, right? And you've got the option of maybe not placing the tiles you don't want to maybe gift to your opponents through those worm models, right? So the fact that you're always on a knife edge as to where the next resources are going to come from and there's just a little smidgen of disappointment if you don't draw the right tile and it keeps you on the edge of your seat and it makes the game a little bit more exciting, you know. So the final thing that we like about Eclipse is that there is a really good variety of different alien races to play. And what makes it even better is on the reverse of these there are the Terran or the human characters that you could play. And so everyone gets the option if they want of choosing a human character if they want an easier time of it. Yeah. If you add in the expansions, there's going to be a huge huge variety of different alien races. And you can even download the free Santa Claus character if you want and ride around on your galactic sleigh. So yeah, the fact that you got a huge variety of races

keeps the game fresh and the fact we've been playing this for 10 years and haven't really got bored with it speaks volumes about the amount of variety that you got in this game. here. So, what don't we like about Eclipse? So, the first thing we don't like about Eclipse is that the reputation tile draw is too random. Yeah, you might take on the ancient in the Galactic Center that allows you to draw, I think, it's five reputation tiles, but you might just be drawing the low ranked tiles and then one of your mates comes in with an interceptor. You blow him out of the water, but he draws the four, right? So, it's a really really unbalanced and uneven way of distributing victory points. Well, I know there's more chance of drawing the high rank tiles. There's also a chance of drawing absolutely nothing. So, this is one of the things that drags the game down. Yeah. You just got this random element to the game that could make or break your experience, right? I mean, I don't like house rolling things in if I have to, but really what we found is that if you look at the cheat sheet, then you just get that many victory points. If you destroy the Galactic Center, you get five. If you just take part in combat, you get one. And it seems to work a lot better if you do it that way rather than rely on the random card draw. I can't really understand why the designer of this one decided to chuck that random element in, but it's in there and it's really, really disappointing. So, the next thing that we don't like about Eclipse is that this is said to be a 2 and 1 half hour Twilight Imperium experience. It's it's nothing of the sort. A, it's nothing

really like Twilight Imperium, and B, it doesn't play in 2 and 1/2 hours at all. You might be able to get a two-player game in in maybe 2 and 1 half hours, but what's the point in playing a 4X game with two players cuz one of you is going to get your ass handed to you, there when you go into this, just understand that it's not going to be a 2 and 1 half hour game. It's going to be more like a four to 5hour game. So, next thing we don't like about Eclipse is that the expansions probably add too much bloat to the game. Right, there are three expansions for this. There's the Rise of the Ancients expansion, which adds more research, more technologies. Then you got the Shadows of the Rift expansion, which adds even more stuff. And then you've got the ship pack one. There was never a ship pack two, which is a bit disappointing, which gives you just a load of miniatures and a couple of extra alien races, right? There's also some mini expansions like uh the Nebula tile and the black hole and all that sort of If you chuck everything in, then this game just becomes too much of a mind to understand and keep an eye on everything at the same time. Right?

So, you want to pick and choose wisely what you're going to throw in and what you are going to leave out. So, the next thing that we don't like about Eclipse, and this leads on from the last thing about there being too much bloat, is that this game is an absolute bloody table hog. Yeah. And I'm talking this takes up the entire table. The player mats are absolutely huge. And unless you've got some kind of tray to put the cubes in, they're going to be flying around all over the place. Somebody sneezes or knocks the table, then all this stuff's going to be all over the place. I'm going to be struggling to get it back to where it was. The tear down for this game is especially a nightmare cuz there's so many different moving parts. So many little tokens and little chips are going to be flying around, cubes and ships and everything. Every time I play this, I just leave it on the table and I come back to it the next day and I take it down in little bits. Yeah.

Not only is it a long game to play, it's also a long game to tear down. Right. So, to summarize, is Eclipse still worth playing 10 years after it was first released? So, we're going to say yes, we really do enjoy this game. It's a seminal 4X experience that has a wonderful blend of Euro economic style management with a trash miniatures combat. Right. It does suffer from an unbalanced, uneven, random reputation tile draw, which is the place where you're going to get your main bulk of victory points. Yeah. So, that sucks. And that stops the game from being amazing as opposed to just being great. You could say it is a fourstar game instead of a fivestar game just because of that. You can house roll it in if you want, but I don't really like house rolling things in unless I absolutely have to. But on this occasion, sometimes you have to do that.

Right. Having said that, it's still one of the best 4X/ Space Opera games that you can get. It has had a second edition. We have had people moan at us saying, "Why you still playing the first edition when the really nice second edition is available?" And my answer to you is that what's the point in spending 120 quid on a game you already own, right? So, the first edition with the expansions is more than enough gameplay to mess about with. And we're still playing this today where it's a 10 year old game and it's still got that charm. It's still got that sense of wonder and that sense of exploration and some novel combat as well. So there you go. That's Eclipse. Remember, if you are new here, please consider subscribing to this channel. Leave a comment in that section down below. Hit the like button and all that We'll see you next Tuesday.

Progress saved