Above and Below: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And Brad and I are doing a discussion over Above and Below. Um, a game from 2015, 10 years ago. Ryan Lockett's debut game.
No,
isn't that his first game? It's definitely his first game in the series in like
didn't he do um uh you know that space game was his first one?
Oh, Empires of the Void.
Yeah, I think that was his very first.
Empires of the Void.
City of Iron.
Yes. Yeah.
The first edition of it.
Yeah, you're right. Empires of the Void was 2012. Um well, Above and Below is definitely his first game in this
series. His first good game. Um, and the reason why we're doing um a review over it so many years later is one, this is never, we just haven't done one, but I have a review over Near and Far and Now or Never, uh, which is this is the first in that trilogy. Um, and I think it's always a good uh thing to go back to kind of games because they just kind of always get lost in the sauce with just
when brand new games come out, it's always like you we don't even appreciate brand new games that come out, it's always like what's the next thing?
Um, which I was I was thinking the other day, I'm like, man, if I was a designer, I'd be pissed every time I heard that. It's like, hey, what are you working on next? This just came out and it took me eight years to design, so [ __ ] off.
Um, but this has always I mean has always been in my collection. It's always kind of held a a special place in my heart to kind of this was almost like fun adventure storytelling before those were really popular. Mhm.
Uh and as 10 years later, this is so bare bones of of a game in terms of that narrative element, but it's it's really neat. You you look back and appreciate it in my opinion to kind of see where he came from and where he like from above and below to sleeping gods is like just uh
it's just really nice to kind of see where that all started. Um but Brad, what do you think? What do you think of Above and Below? I've always this has always been and I I haven't played this for a few years.
Mhm.
Um but this is still my favorite of those that tight trilogy.
Yeah.
You know, the now or never, the
Near and Far, and then this. This is still my favorite of those.
Um because of the
just the simplicity of it.
Oh yeah.
You know, Near and Far angered me for a lot of reasons. the other game, uh, now or never was almost too
it was like too much.
Yeah. So, like this is like the sweet spot for that. And I'm not as I haven't messed with Sleeping Gods, so
they're so good.
Um,
they're so good.
But, uh, but yeah, this one's still probably my favorite of the games I've played of his.
Okay.
Um, so far, you know, of the stuff I've messed with. But, um, having that Foreteller narration is nice, too.
It was nice. Yeah. you know, got gets that sound effects and voice acting and stuff in it.
Um, but yeah, I mean, it's just solid.
It is a very solid one. Yeah. I think now looking back, it's
it kind of hits that point of like it's a little bit too simple for me, but then I'm like, well, it's also not long. and the you just kind of go into it knowing like one it's not the most strategic game in the world. Um how well you do boils down to just how well uh the exploration um comes into play. But what was nice about Above and Below compared to Near and Far uh and Now or Never is the the to me the most exciting part is of course the exploring. It's the the quick blurbs of the of what you come across.
But you always get to do that. You always get to choose. I want to go exploring.
Great.
And in now or not now or never. Uh no, it is now or never. Uh near and far now or never. It was almost a race, especially near and far was the fun exploration parts you had to race to and then once those tokens were gone, then it's like, oh, guess that's not happening anymore. It's like, oh, well, that's kind of the fun most fun part of of the game. Um, so the one thing I wish he kind of did is whenever you do have the exploration and you make your choice on what you do, it just gives you something and it's like, oh man, it'd be nice to know kind of what happened afterwards,
which didn't they do that in near and far does have a
Yes, after the
They do. Yeah, both of those have just an improvement in the narrative element. So, if we're talking about just the storytelling aspect, Near and Far and now are never are just superior.
Um, but again, they come with their own caveats and and here it's just so straightforward.
Yeah.
Um,
well, and I haven't messed with cuz there's another book of missions that was in an expansion for another game,
the desert and the I don't know if that has stuff after choices cuz that came out afterwards. You know what? Let's uh let's find out. I'll just look at um
And then also, while you're looking that up, um the newly released Haunted. I don't know if that is going to
Yeah, I have not looked at that at all. Um so, let's just see hypothetically. I would be surprised if he did for this one cuz this came out pretty shortly after.
So, uh this 301 if you
Nope.
Okay.
Nope. I I bet Haunted has more of that though since he's learned.
That would be very interesting to see how how much he improved on on this whenever we get a chance to play that.
Uh but yeah, I mean at the end of the day, everything you want to do in this game, uh there's never really any like, okay, I got to do 18 things before I can do that. It's just like you're never really stressed for money. Um never really stressed for resources, even though you're not really spending resources. It's more of just a way to go up a track and get victory points, but the game is quick. Like you get you get fun little adventures. Uh especially with the Foreteller makes it even more immersive. And yeah, I mean I wouldn't call this game like I would never be running out to tell people like Above and Below is a hidden gem,
right? Um, but if you can get it and you've played now or are never near and far, I still think it's worth owning. Like I'm not saying like, oh, because I have those two, this is obsolete. I still like it. I think it's it's charming.
Yeah, this is the only one I own of those. Like I I had Near and Far at one point. I got rid of it and we played
Now or Never Four Hours
and it was Yeah.
I have played Now or Never more recently. It was like a year ago. Um, and it is very good. I do enjoy it. I still own both. I want to go back and play Near and Far because it's been a bit since I've played that. Um, but I mean my favorite is Sleeping Gods. It's like not but there I don't really put that in the same vein as these three
because it doesn't have the cool and part. It's not Sleeping and Gods. It's up and missed opportunity part. Yeah.
Sleeping and God distant and skies that part of the trilogy. I think this trilogy and that's you know. Yeah, those are their only thing. But if he has a knack for doing trilogies, third Sleeping Gods,
I'm sure it's coming.
Uh because what's his next game that he's working on?
Well, he just put out Creature Comfort Caravan.
Uh Creature Caravan. Yeah, Creature Caravan is also I think it's very solid. It kind of has that similar It's nice. His one-off games are very simple. Creature Caravan is really cool because it just has a bunch of different types of card combinations. um with the relative above and below simplicity of gameplay. Uh so yeah, I I've always enjoyed Ryan Lockett games. I love his universe. Um not for any particular reason because it's not like he lore dumps you on a bunch of [ __ ] It's not like this whole D&D world he's created, but you could just see references from every single game that you play. vein that goes through all the
right. Um, but yeah, like it's it's a very clean one. I I I was worried going back to this one I was going to be like, "Oh man, like this is I'll play I'll play 15 other games before I touch this one." Like, what are we even doing? But it wasn't it was it was nice. Sometimes it's nice to have a pallet cleanser game. Something that's something that's a little higher than a a little gateway
quick, you know, game, but not quite a huge game. Something that's slight in the middle that's not too stressful.
No. Exactly. And if you're wanting that little sense of just kind of
the the story, if this game did not have the storytelling, I would actually like it significantly less. Yeah.
It's not like you make you make decisions, but it's really just which check do you want to try and go get? And the results are almost if you go for the higher check, obviously if you get it, you get more stuff. Um, but it's just nice. It's it's a very it gives like almost this high fantasy just little little quick adventures and then and then you move on and you're like okay that was that was cool. Uh so yeah I I think this game is incredibly charming but I will say I'm I might be the opposite of you. I think out of those two I again need to go back to near and far again. Um, but this one might be my least favorite
between the three just because I am such a narrative I mean all my top 10 is like narrative driven campaign games. Um, NDCG uh coined the term. It's actually trademarked but uh those games offer more in terms of the storytelling element and in gameplay. But that doesn't mean that doesn't like diminish this in any way. So, I mean, that's pretty much it. I'm excited to see what Haunted brings.
Yeah, for sure.
Um,
see if it just adds more or if it's
It's literally the same game just with a ghost theme. I do like boo.
That's actually one I didn't I didn't back it actually.
Really? Yeah, that's surprising. Oh, yeah. Cuz I was surprised that you didn't.
Well, cuz I hadn't played this in ages. I, you know, I'll probably find it now after playing this.
Yeah. Kind of refreshed it. Yeah,
it was very nice to not have touched this game in so many years. And then I mean
it's probably been four or five years since I played this game.
Oh man, that's that's a little bit more recent. Mine's probably since I got it 15 years ago. Didn't it come out 10 years ago?
No, I know. No, I it's been 15 years since I played it.
Ryan Lock and I go way back. We were boys like in elementary school. Um, man, wouldn't that be wild to like find this? It's like, wait a minute, we go to elementary school together. Yeah, I kept telling you about my world and you kept making fun of me. You bullied me relentlessly and
shove me in a locker because I was talking about a radio or whatever his whatever the world
whatever his world is.
Oh, yeah. Yeah, you're right, dude. The Gen Con nerd. Um, but yes, it is it was nice to just really take no time at all to learn the game again.
Um, and that gets lost a lot, I think, where it's like if you if you take a 5year hiatus on a game, it's almost extremely daunting to try and relearn it. It's like, is it really worth it?
Right.
Uh, so highly recommend getting Above and Below. I would recommend the trilogy, but if this is like your speed, like this is like your max, then never mind. Do not get the other two because they've just gotten increasingly more and more complex as I would assume as as I think you you should. But if if you have a range of um like gameplay experience, then the trilogy is a solid one to have. Except I hate that it's above and below, near and far, now or never. It's like, what? What? What happened, Ryan? See, that's what happens when you quit bullying people.
Must be now and never.
Um, kids bully people.
It should. Yeah. Now and never, which I know doesn't make any sense, but just stupid. I hate it. Um, so on a scale of 1 to 10, what are you giving above and below?
I'll probably just I'll probably roll in at like a seven. That's actually where I'm at too, funny enough.
Yeah. Yeah. Just I mean it's it's I can't rightfully give it higher than that because of it being fairly simplistic, but it's awesome for what it
fits. Yeah. You know,
um but pretty much since we both give it the same score, that just shows where our other rankings for those other games are. Mine probably go a little bit higher in each one and then yours go lower. Might
be lower.
Um yeah. So yeah. Anyway, that's our thoughts on Above and Below. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.