Bits, Please! Ep 2: Everdell 3D Printed Walnut Shell Resource Holders
Transcript
oh you know what's going to be a good one when i've got my purple craft mat out hi it's ryan from knight sir on a table and this is the second episode in a series that i was tentatively calling nice bits but i didn't feel all that comfortable with it so thanks to my funny friend sean i've renamed it bits please so this is a series that is all about the additions that we can make to our board games to make them look really cool and feel really good to play and if you watched the last episode you'll know that i recently purchased a 3d printer so that's what i think most of this is going to be about the shenanigans i get up to with that including this episode now i'm talking about everdel which if you know the channel you know is my absolute favorite board game of all time it's often accused of being over produced but for all its overproduction there are still some interesting flaws with the game namely these goofy resources which in the original edition they decided to make perfectly cylindrical so they roll all over your table all over the board they get away from you and in the second kickstarter campaign i believe they redesigned the twigs because enough people demanded it and they made them sort of with a groove on them so they were more they're flatter and they didn't roll quite as easily so that was that was definitely an improvement however for some bizarre reason they kept the perfectly spherical rubbery berries perfectly spherical so as you can see there they stay a little bit they're slightly
squished but there's a lot of there's a lot of roll factor to those things what you kind of need in everdel is to have a bucket or a crate or something to hold all these rollier roundy resources just to keep them in place at the top of the game board and the very first thing i thought to make when i got my 3d printer was one of these resource holders for everdel now like i say if you know me you know that everdel is my favorite game if you know me even further you know that i deeply dislike the publisher of everdell starling games formerly game salute my passion for how much i dislike starling games matches my passion for how much i like everdell and you say ryan why why what did they ever do to you well i've had a few personal disappointments in my dealings as a consumer with starling games as have many other customers i would characterize them as a customer hostile company they seem very interested in their own profits at the expense of the experience of their customers case in point there's this thread on board game geek that went up about a year ago where people said this is weird people who are making aftermarket add-ons for everdel using probably 3d printers and offering them up on etsy are receiving cease and desist notices from the lawyer at starling games telling them to take their stuff down never mention everdel keep my name out of your mouth kind of thing and a bunch of people jump onto this thread and say oh my gosh that's awful that's ridiculous how dare they and after maybe half a page or a page or
so of people railing against starling games the official starling games account comes onto the thread explaining their legal position and i don't know if this is actually one of startling games attorneys writing this we don't really know but i'm going to try to do an impression of this person as if it's startling games attorney and this is what the attorney effectively says hey look we appreciate what you got going on with your creativity your creative people we're creative people we got this game you got your little your little tchotchkes listen baby here's what i'm gonna ask you to do you can still put your stuff up on your little online marketplace all we're asking and it's not a big ask is that you don't include pictures of our games that you made the things to a company and you don't use our logo and you don't ever say the name evidel yes that's right it does mean that if people search evidel they're not gonna find your stuff but hey that's that's fair that's that's the law what are you gonna do that's the we gotta protect ourselves it's the law in the ensuing bleep storm many commenters are quick to point out that that is not actually the law that's not how it works at all and one person rightly points out that if you were an after-market car parts manufacturer and you made a part that fits the ford mustang if you weren't able to say fitz ford mustang
those trademark names in your parts listing in the description of the thing you're offering there wouldn't be an aftermarket car parts industry they couldn't exist so for this individual to suggest that it's the law that you can't say the name of their game in association with the thing that you're producing that works with their game is um i think the legal term is bapkus now this goes on for pages and pages and pages you can read it yourself if you're interested if you're watching this on youtube i'll link it in the description below the video a lot of people jump on and are quick to point out that yeah startling games stinks but the creator of everdel james a wilson the designer is a fabulous guy top-notch guy and a bunch of people come in and agree yes yes he is and that's kind of how i feel about everdel and other sort of creative properties that have been tainted by the bad behavior of certain individuals involved them like felicia rashad from the cosby show she didn't do nothing and i'm not suggesting that anybody at sterling games is roofieing drinks that's not that's not it at all but by page six ceo of starling games dan yarrington gets involved he jumps in with his hot take and he says look i can't do a daniari impression he says look all we're trying to do is protect our trademark uh it's what we're legally required to do because if we let enough people uh you know use it then it waters it down and me so he's providing like the the kleenex or the band-aid defense if it
if it becomes common parlance enough then you have not proven that you've protected your trademark well enough and it could be taken away from you but as good a game as everdell is i mean get over yourself it's not kleenex dan goes on to explain that they will have official etsy shops that offer authorized aftermarket pieces that you can use with everdell and this is where people kind of cotton on to like no okay i i get what's going on here so the idea is presumably scare off everybody who's making parts for everdal so that you can authorize a couple of shops and then presumably get a kick back from those sales now the most recent everdell kickstarter campaign launched earlier this week and it became even more clear what they were trying to do dan says that this has been in production for a year and a half this thread went up a year ago so the season to hystenosis went out a year ago and look at this on the kickstarter that launched this past week look at one of the items that's on offer this collection of resource containers for everdel which look a lot like some of the resource containers that unauthorized dealers were offering on etsy aha so of course the thread doesn't end here a bunch of people pile on to dan saying you can't control everything that everybody makes and does and says about your game you just have no legal recourse to bully these people and have that level of authority over what people make to enjoy with your game and people further point out that people
creating aftermarket parts for your game is a high compliment and it increases enthusiasm and excitement about the game some people are quick to mention that nobody expects stuff that's offered on etsy to be authorized or official stuff everyone kind of gets that it's small time crafters cranking out stuff in their basements for little to no profit so after pages and pages of this of bad pr and people stopping all over starling games and rightly so i think dan yarrington comes back and says okay we've talked to our legal counsel and we've clarified our policy you can take a picture of your stuff with our game components in the picture oh well thanks dan for allowing people to do what the law already allows them to do he says he says you can't use our logo in any pictures the title of your listing has to say that it's unofficial and you have to have some kind of proviso that everdell is trademark startling games okay find all the stuff that people would already be required to do under existing law that hasn't changed due to starling games sending out these seasoned assist notices if any of this leaves a bad taste in your mouth rest assured this is only one episode in the storied history of starling games slash game salute there are many other threads that you can peruse if this leaves a bad taste in your mouth and it might and it should i encourage you uh go buy another board game there's absolutely no reason they're at you know cracking 1.7 million on the kickstarter last time i checked they don't need your money they'll be fine without it
so go buy something else if you don't want to support a bullying skeezy publisher like sterling games me i already own a copy of everdel so i'm going to make some cool stuff for it and i tell you i don't like the pieces that they have on offer to be honest i think they look a bit crude and lumpy i'd like to see them a little bit finer more refined i don't know why that oyster shell has a pearl modeled inside it when it's meant to store your pearl components for pearl brook it's weird it's weird and i've got a 3d printer so i think i can produce exactly what i want for my own copy of the game let's go so here we are at etsy which is a marketplace for crafty kind of stuff and you can just type in everdel much to the chagrin of starling games and a bunch of different things pop up a couple of things are official and they say so they're authorized these acorns are really really nice but they weren't up i think when i was making this decision and these are the sort of bulky kind of gummy goofy looking ones that are available on the kickstarter that i wasn't too enamored with but i've always liked the look of these things these walnut shells they look really cool 23 bucks canuck bucks but i think we can do better than that so instead i'm going to go to thingiverse.com punch in everdoe and this is where people make models for different things that you can just print out on your 3d printer and look at this
look at this the exact same walnut shell or very very close to it is available on thingiverse you just have to sign in with your account and hit collect thing and you can grab those stl files amazing now what i find really really interesting if we're talking about rights issues is that if you scroll all the way down here on a thing that's on thingiverse and you look at the license it tells you what the author of the object intends for the use to be and very often you'll find this dollar sign with a slash through it and the creative commons license which means you can't use this commercially so i wouldn't be able to grab this model print it out paint it up and then sell it on my etsy store i can't do it because the the original designer of the model intended it to be for free to use for people so if you look back i don't know if this is the exact same wallet shell that you find here but like that's that's pretty darn close maybe it's a little bit different because this is a smooth interior edge but i'm pretty sure i have seen many times things that are available on thingiverse that are available also on the etsy shops and they're definitely marked not for commercial use so i don't know what to do about that if you see something you really really want you don't have a 3d printer you really want to buy it maybe the solution there is to ask the etsy seller whether they have permission to make it or if you want to just go ahead and ask for forgiveness rather than permission maybe you can buy the thing and then on thingiverse
uh whenever you download a file watch this collect the thing you get this option to tip the designer so maybe that's a solution you know you pay the etsy shop owner a bit and then you you pay some money to the designer which the etsy shop owner should really be doing now if you had an fdm printer you'd be ready to go you just open it up in a piece of software and save it as a certain file and you'd be ready to print but since we're printing on an any cubic photon s resin printer got to follow a couple of extra steps so i'm going to open the file up and there's the walnut it looks really cool this is the thinned version so it's not so thick on the inside and you get a bit of that walnut texture on the inside as well now what you have to do is you have to print this with supports and that's sort of like scaffolding so that things don't this represents the build plate which is the thing that goes upside down and dunks into your resident vat in your resin printer so it prints what you're going to see upside down like that so you could picture that it would be really difficult i think for it to build those lighter layers and possibly build out if things kind of like pop into existence like you have overhangs or you have characters with arms things are going to print properly so you need to print these struts the other kind of rule of 3d resin printing is that putting things parallel to the build plate like that it doesn't like these big flat surfaces because it doesn't do flat things very well and it creates this suction force when it sort of like dunks
in up and down in and out and it goes and pops out and it's possible that you can rupture this delicate film delicate expensive difficult to replace film that you have on the bottom of the of the vat that it's it's dunking into and if that rips and resin leaks into your machine you are hosed so one of the things you're going to try to do is is rotate your model in a different way so maybe you know we could rotate it up like that and maybe we can move it over here i think we could fit more than one walnut onto the build plate and anytime you see it go red like that that means it's out of bounds so you got to get it back in there but a little bit more out of bounds so it's really got to play with it a little bit oops this tab over here is where you create the supports that's what it's going to look like a little post with a stick and it angles up in a little ball and it attaches to your model so you can either do this automatically or you can start clicking where you think the supports should be and this is sort of more if you're a little bit more advanced and you know where the supports need to go these are thin ones i think but you can go heavy supports for for bits that are going to really bog down and and weigh on that build plate or if the story if the model is like a threat to pull off the build plate because remember it's printing upside down like that and it you know if if you've not got enough supports the whole model could just like rip right off the build plate and splash down and then
it would be a bad time for all involved it also will tell you this piece of software where it thinks you should add support so these little dots are where it's like no models look a little bit heavy you should probably stick some supports in there so this is what i eventually came up with i was able to fit all four walnut shells that i wanted onto the build plate at the same time pretty cool and notice how it's putting supports inside that'll come into play in just a second so picture i'm going to print it and i'm going to have to snap these supports off and hopefully those connection points are weak enough so that it's not a big deal just pop them off with my fingers though you can use sort of craft snips or tin snips to get them off i'm going to skip over the next part where i actually print this and show it to you coming off the build plate and snapping all the sports because i was so excited to get these walnut shells printed i didn't record any of that stuff but in future bits please episodes you're going to see that step writ large what happened with these ones was that these three shells printed and then this one didn't so then i just went and i took the file and i deleted all but one of the ones that i knew would work and i reprinted it and then i had all four shells printed just fine so this is how those first three shells printed out i was really happy with the results look how great they look they're nice and detailed sorry this is just a still image but they don't have those lateral printing lines that you would get out of an fdm printer i think they look really smooth and really great
however when i pulled the supports off i left little nubbins on the edges of the of the plastic and this is because i shine uv lights on these models to cure them before i took the supports off and i know better now a better process is to wash them with isopropyl alcohol and then pull the supports off and then cure them so that you're not trying to snap off hard cured supports so before i do any painting i'm going to have to file those nubbins down here i am in my old whitland chair there's a better view in the sunlight you can see those little bumpy nubbins those little barnacles sticking to the ends of the model which aren't great i'm not going to want to paint that because they they feel prickly and it's not nice to pick the model up so let's fix it and how do we fix it well i picked up these really cool specialty sanding sticks that are pointy on one end and sort of rounded and blunt on the opposite end and therefore precision detail sanding they've got a strip of sandpaper that goes all around the outside of them and they come with a couple of replacement strips for each one and they go in different grit levels so the red is the coarsest one and then all the way up to black which is the finest one red is 120 grit and the black is 500.
so really i suppose you could get away with using just a flat piece of sandpaper for this but i think that these will come in handy when i'm doing much more detailed work on more sort of miniature models if you know what i'm saying now i have been thoroughly warned that the dust that this resin kicks up when you sand it is not at all safe to get into your lungs so trust that i'm wearing a mask while i'm sanding the pieces down the next step was to spray paint them to get them looking something other than gray and i had a lot of anxiety around this point i just realized why i don't think i've ever spray painted anything before my life i think this is the first time in my in my entire life i've actually held a can of spray paint and done spray painting things with it and i always associate it with you know naughtiness you know spray spray-painting things where things aren't supposed to be spray-painted so i don't know i had it like my heart was in my throat as i grabbed this rattle can of brown rust-oleum paint and primer i don't know if just paint would do it because i don't know if just paint would stick to the resin i don't have enough experience painting resin yet but i shook this sucker up and since this was my first time using a kind of spray paint naturally i wasn't a natural so i held it way too close to the pieces and i laid it on way too thick and this stuff is supposed to go from wet to slightly tacky in about an hour this is in my garage and i live in canada so this is early march the temperature's not that warm so it took i mean i expected it to take a long time to dry 24 hours later and this stuff was still glistening so not a great first attempt this is the
next day you can see how shiny they still are they they're nowhere near dry you know more than 24 hours later so i'm going to flip them over and do the insides but again my my spray paint technique is just not up to snuff but here look i'm learning i'm holding the spray paint can way way way further away and but the problem with this method i think i'm gonna need to get an airbrush because with the spray can you're supposed to hold it 12 to 18 inches away from the model the problem with this is i kept spraying and i didn't realize there were parts of the model that i wasn't covering because my eyes are nowhere near the model i can't see what i'm painting and what i'm not painting so i think if i had an airbrush and i could actually have the model close to my eyeballs i wouldn't be missing so many spots and i wouldn't take so many attempts to get complete coverage on the model i'm not going to lie it took a bunch of coats i think this is a few hours later one big change that i made is i didn't keep the box in the garage the entire time after that first 24 hour ordeal i started moving the box into my bathroom which was heated with a nice space heater and i put a fan on it so it was able to evaporate a lot of the paint a lot more quickly all right so after hours and hours and hours and hours and hours of paint drying which i've spared you from although watching this whole video is a little bit like watching paint dry this is what i came up with this is the final piece the almost final piece all right here's what it's going to look like with
those resources in it they're not going to go anywhere you're going to shake this thing around they're not going to go they're not going to oh no they're going somewhere oh you can't really shake it that much you can't be too vigorous with it but they look great i think they look awesome and i think they're going to make a beautiful addition to my beverdale game but you know what i think i can make it slightly better this evokes the essence of walnut but it doesn't really look like a wallet these are what walnuts look like and i want to try to get this looking like that picture and i think the way that i can do it is to bust out my little model painting kit that i used way back in an episode with my first time painting a model so i think i know how it's going to go i think i'm going to try to water down a dark brown or a black paint and do a wash over it and then once that dries i'm going to dry brush or stipple paint a lighter color just to bring out some of the highlights on the shell and hopefully get it looking a little bit more like that picture of real live walnuts now is a good time to mention that these 3d printers have really come down in price that's the only reason i own one if you want to pick a 3d printer up for yourself i really like the anycubic photon s and those sanding sticks are pretty cool too i've got some amazon affiliate links in the description below if you click those and buy any of the things that i've mentioned in the video your price is going to stay the same it's not going to go up but i'll get a small commission from amazon that i'll use to buy more stuff for the channel to entertain you check it out i'd really appreciate it and this is how they look when they're
on the board that fancy model painting step isn't strictly necessary especially with my rudimentary beginners technique but i do think it added a bit of dimension to the shells so what do you think was that worth the time and effort or would you pay the xd bucks to the kickstarter campaign to buy those resource holders that startling games came up with let me know in the comments and i would also really like to know if you owned a 3d printer and you're a board game fan like i am what would you make with it ultimately what is your favorite way to spruce up a game that could be stuff that you're making yourself or it could be parts that are available in the aftermarket that you've found at your friendly local game store what are the best bits to spruce up a board game that you have found if you want to see me continue making board game content like this there are three really important buttons i want you to cook they are the thumbs up button the subscribe button and the bell button to get notifications once you're subscribed you can also click the thumbs down button if you don't like this kind of content that's cool too the algorithm doesn't know any differently and will think that my content is engaging whether you like it or not and one more plug one of the ways that i can afford the 3d printer and the plastic spools and paint and all that stuff is because i have patrons supporting me on patreon if you want to be one of those people that fuels this kind of content please head over to patreon and consider tossing me a buck or two or six or 15. could be 50 i'm not going to limit you thank you so much for watching this one and i'll catch you in the next episode of bits
please did you just watch that whole thing oh hey to 100 this video click the badge to subscribe and then click the bell to get notifications when i've got new stuff