Pipeline Board Game Review
Transcript
friends viewers let's oil your pipes in pipeline you will play at an oil magnate during the infancy of the privatization of the oil industry the demand is high so all you have to do is buy crude oil refine it through a network of pipes that you've built and make a hell of a lot of money wait wait wait wait wait that b-roll doesn't look anything like the review copy that publish a capstone game sent us well what does the review copy look like I mean that's fine we can we can work with this yeah just uh you know pour the oil in the top comes out the bottom that's the video right pipeline I'm sure and ironically is a closed loop the pressure mounts up and eventually erupt to shower your face with sweet sweet dollar bills it's an explosive game that will churn and churn and churn you through the wringer until eventually you come out refined and rich or crude and collapsed let's have a look at its systems technically pipeline is a worker movement game where each turn you'll pick up your worker and place them on one of ten possible actions but I think it would be more accurate to call it a trundle through indecision but that's not a criticism it's a consequence of a game that is wound tighter than the president of your school's debate club they still have debate clubs right this
is 40 bucks remember that number because that is all the money you will start with to make a little bit more you'll need to buy crude oil there's four markets that sell it at different prices and availability and three different types of oil orange bubblegum and vanilla let's buy too oily orange barrels because they're cheap only ten bucks in total and then we can just kick back pass the turn and start watching those oranges mature oh no that is the secondary action alarm ringing in your head but first let's talk about worker movement games unlike worker placement in these games you'll only have one worker you move them somewhere they do the thing that's on their location in some of the best examples of the genre like Istanbul or the gallerist there's consequences to that movement you might create a trail you need to follow back or maybe you're introducing extra costs to opponents to their location you are in pipeline does none of that you can go where you like do whatever buy what you want as long as a it's available and be and this one is important you have the money every time you take your action on the main action cross you can take a secondary action as long as the secondary action you want to take is right next to the main action you want to take and it's gonna cost you an additional ten bucks you know what I'll pay the extra ten bucks because there's only eighteen actions in the entire game and ten bucks is a small price to double up pipeline is
undeniably about creating a slick engine that will burst oil through every pipe Pole and being able to get an extra turn oh especially since for an extra 20 bucks oh I can get myself an upgrade and in the words of the Queen these are banging I mean actually at the beginning they're not really they're a little bit rubbish since a level one they're just more expensive ways of getting an extra tank or some extra pipes but if you persevere and keep buying upgrades you'll advance to level 2 and 3 these completely warp the economic rules that you are playing under to your advantage they make you feel like you're doing something a little bit naughty that shouldn't be allowed so we definitely want some of those and of course we need pipes themselves thankfully the government is rubbish and has four big buckets of pipes that it's selling at garage sale prices in what can only be described as an industrial pick-and-mix you can buy one two three four or even five pipes from one of these quadrants but just like in a real pick and mix the more you buy the more the cost will increase per pipe one will cost you five to ten and all of a sudden three cost you 20 and so on this was deliberately set up by the designer Ryan Courtney to punish you for being greedy it all comes back to those eighteen actions you want to do so much but the game allows so little except you can take sneaky shortcuts like buying
five tiles all at once and you'll pay through the nose for that but designer Ryan Courtney you can't trick me with greed I'll play it safe and cool and just buy two tiles I'm sorry Elaine that is the-- you ran out of money alone this is 40 buck they're cheap only ten bucks in total you know what how do I get more money again you can't well you can you just don't want it the only way you're making money in this game is if you buy oil and then send your person to refine it in your pipes and then eventually sell it to one of the markets with one exception visiting the contracts and loans action space will offer you the wonderful prospect of getting yourself a loan of 15 bucks that you never have to pay back this might sound good but actually it's about as fair as taking out a short payday loan every time you take a loan you have to take one of these red cubes and this red cube can burn in hell for each cube at the end of the game you'll have to pay back money and remember money is your score you've got one penalty cube that's 20 bucks taken away from you at the end of the game to penalty cubes 50 bucks free penalty cubes 90 bucks and so on and now let me
draw your attention to what happens when you take ten penalty cubes dun-dun-dun pipeline is a constant fight for survival to sell your oil you need three things to happen first of all you need oil in your pipes then you need a pipeline network that is able to refine that specific oil and finally the ability to sell it at a profit a high you say I'll sneak in and buy the oil whilst it's cheap at the crude oil market whilst I was busy doing that however someone else snagged the tiles are wanted from the government pipe supply another player claimed a contract that would have been perfect for me to get some quick sells I can still get a contract but that contractor oh it's about as good as hitting up your local sushi spot doing happy hour and finding out that all they have left is cucumber Maki are you need still sushi technically but at that point I might as well as just stayed at home and dip some cucumber into a bowl of soy sauce this is where pipeline starts to show its brilliance you don't have to look hard to find a tightly wound economic simulator but frequently they feel like a lot of oysters and no pearls so many times life play the game that it's up its own cucumber then it makes you feel like you've just done an eight-hour shift at the lumberyard and all you got to take home was 79 splinters and maybe
a free log what don't look at me I ride pipeline made me do some of the hardest mental arithmetic in any board game ever and I say that as a recent survivor of my very first 18 XX experience but it found time to deliver those little moments of joy and satisfaction by giving you just the right piece that slots perfectly into your plan array of beacon and hope in a crumbling metropolis of dashed oil dreams which brings us to the final bit of the rules pipes and who wore them best it might seem a bonkers idea to put a complicated spatial puzzle into an economic simulator but then you remember something like a feast for Odin and suddenly you think maybe it's not bonkers maybe it's genius oil comes in for grapes crude and the free levels of refined which are low medium and high the more you can refine a barrel the more its potential value but each flavor of oil has a different amount of refinement steps it needs to become more sophisticated achieve the sorry amount of links in your pipe of the right color now when you send your person to that pipe they'll take the oil with them and come out the other end with better oil it's magical not only is it magical but when you send the person to that pipe there this so greasy already they don't care they'll climb through all the pipelines whatever tile you put that person on they will go through every network of
pipes that's connected to that tile making for one heck of a devilish puzzle now you want to connect as many different pipes extending from one location on finding those pipes isn't exactly easy the government pipe supply is ever dwindling as your opponents swoop in like hawks and fly away with the pipes you wanted somehow cackling and carrying that pipe in their beaks at the same time and initially not even all for government our quadrants are available to buy from in the first year only the first two quadrants are available and which one is available as determined by simply someone purchasing from them here you are building your little oil empire with cool upgrades and mature oranges only to watch the tiles you so desperately needed to make it all work get locked out in dish it's enough truism but if restriction breeds creativity then pipeline is a tight corset that will squeeze your pressure I know our viewers are probably being a little bit suspicious because we do have a tendency to pull the rug out every so often the pipeline isn't just great it's best game I've played this year whoa that's that's strong because you know best game this year I mean you haven't even made like a music video for it or anything funny you should say that
I used to be Noli then so your rainbow smile well hi I wasn't expecting to see you again quite so soon you're just a barrel of greens but you put me he's a wee the pipeline to my heart Oh the pipeline and the way you move is so refined oh you other pipe line Oh the pipeline oh you mother pipeline to my heart pipeline is a game with as many twists and turns as a pipeline when you set up a game it will look exactly like the last game that you set up but then you will start to notice the subtle variations the orders the contract the endgame valuations even the tiles themselves it's the same appeal as a Where's Wally book you already know he's going to be on every page but the puzzle comes from finding him within whatever
else is going on in the same way you make decisions based on this particular game with this particular setup and it never feels like there's only one correct path will you go big and gamble your pipes or will you follow a more sensible path with more assured returns you could sit there and do the maths but honestly it's impossible so sometimes you just have to hit that button and see whether it feeds the goldfish or just lets all the water out the tank this led to some of my best moments my most efficient turns my greatest piping it also led to some minor catastrophes let's look at valuations each game will have a set of four and in addition to all the money you raked up for your final score they'll provide bonus points for things you've achieved they can be as simple as have a lot of orange oil or hair brained rewarding you immensely for having different types and different sizes of pipes attached to your machines oh yeah machines instead of sending your person through pipes you can get a robot to do it what a world we live in when you buy a machine you place it somewhere on one of your existing pipe tiles not only immediately destroying the intricate web of tubes you've been making but giving you the ability to run all the pipes attached to that or any other machine for 15 bucks every single turn buying a machine seems like a no-brainer and I'd even argue that it's a necessary step to succeed it's not if you're gonna buy a machine it's when but buy one too early and your hamper your meager pipe
struggle to pay for automation or even oil and now consider setting up three of these to get all nine pipelines of different colors and sizes to get the maximum score of 450 it's slightly stoopid hampering all other aspects of everything else you've been building but if you can pull it off that's 450 bucks a stupendous and likely game-winning bonus to add to anything else you've made I love how intricate this design is I found myself watching other players not just to see how their actions affected mine but more to see the mechanisms spinning around at times it was entrancing like opening up the back of a wind-up clock to see the cogs and the springs synced perfectly in perpetual motion I've never been to an oil refinery but I did grow up near a lot of factories and pipes I'm not the most cosmetic of features they're generally grubby ganglion if you want them in anything but gray then you're probably gonna come unstuck grubby this game is not though and not just because the colors remind me of a bottle of iron brew which we all know is made of girders and not at all oil but because the colors each have a purpose and only that purpose if the pipe is steel LLL carry tail oil there are red cubes but there are no red pipes so they represent financial death and the player colors are different from the colors of the oil
helpful in equal measures frustrating and satisfying is the tessellation of the pipe tiles especially if you're the sort of person that gets lost putting their jumper on there were times that I would spot the tile a combination of plants that would perfectly nestle itself into the chaos and it would come back round to my turn no one else had taken it I would pick up drown cently and then discover it was exactly the opposite of what I needed and as much as I'd like to provide a count of wait a minute the camera angle didn't change that's better and as much as I'd like to provide a counterpoint to it lanes critique pipeline is a game that escapes criticism like a puddle of oil clutched with bare hands for example I thought that surely the stark confrontational nature of getting upgrades is going to be a so pimp nicking out of this sleek design each game you'll have five different sets of upgrades each coming at free levels in your first year you can to get a level one upgrade maybe I'll tabal in some human resources everybody loves those and they make your secondary actions free but that's more circumstantial than you might think and sinking in 20 bucks at the start of the game is less rewarding than you might imagine on top of that I have to immediately block off that upgrade path for myself and anyone else for the entire year that way I can only ever buy a level to
upgrade earliest at the start of the second year and a level free upgrade earliest in the third year and whilst the level ones are frequently a harsh investment the level two and three ones they are game warping if I continue down the eight-hour path it can eventually get a second action every time I get an action that's twice as much that's not it every time I buy an upgrade path and block my own advancement for the year I may according to the rule book block another one and that's two out of the five upgrade paths blocked for the entire year by one person's action and don't get me wrong I wasn't frustrated by the unforgiving nature of this I wasn't frustrated by the restrictive nassif your game plan relies on having a level free upgrade you might as well forget about it you'll have to sweat blood and tears to get your hands on it it is that May that bothered me imagine if the designer of this game asked us if we liked it and our response was you may say that we have liked this game there's just no room for this sort of indecisiveness either make me ruin my friend's evening or don't and don't make me make that decision in front of them that's rude but then we realized that that decision isn't meant to be made during the game but just before it when learning pipeline there's enough systems to keep
everyone busy with analysis paralysis and rubbing oil on to yourselves there's no reason to add friction to the equation but once everyone has a player to go nuts get cutthroat make it an oily human slip and slide with knives pipeline is not the first game that's very unforgiving for mistakes and I don't mind a good gauntlet and having played quite a few of them lately I find these designs arrogant plenty of board games feature traps in baked into the design and players pursuing certain paths will find themselves in a dead-end except because they're playing a board game with other people in real time they have to keep playing these paths out as if they are hitting their head into a wall over and over again pipeline also has traps but unlike other games these traps are symmetrical there are no wrong moves because they are all wrong all right taking an upgrade as your first action might be brilliant or disastrous and it all depends on what's your plan and how you execute it and what the other players do and that's just two examples and let me tell you right now I was concerned over so many things when I read their roles to pipeline for the first time I feared for replayability because it's the same closed loop that you're running over and over in every single game I feared for scalability because the game is much more open with two players rather than before I fear
that the game is too confrontational it's not confrontational enough and all these concerns washed away like oil washes off of a duck except of course oil doesn't wash off of a duck they die so is this a total recommendation from NPI I think so I think it's slightly too unforgiving and to punishing to be as widely enjoyed of something like Great Western trail but for people who are looking for that sort of experience it's perfect and then there's the rule like we should be forgiving since it's designer Ryan Courtney's first game and it's capstone games his first original publication but it's not great fine to make a game punishing as long as you don't make it punishing to learn but aside from that we loved it ESCA yeah just one thing yeah why are you holding a tiny puppy well you see this tiny puppy is a reward for subscribing to no pun included as soon as you click that subscribe button you will be exposed to much more tiny puppies in your world and also other ball games that we love and are they a great board game reviews so click on them subscribe and just rub yourself into cardboard as if you would rub yourself into a greasy barrel of oil I'll leave you with that