Fate of the Fellowship Review - The Best Pandemic System Game in Years
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Board Stupid. My name is Wayne and I'm Matt. And this is our review of Lord of the Rings: Fate of the Fellowship, a pandemic system game, which is a new game from Matt Leok, the architect of that series in a fabulous IP that we all know and love.
Yep. Instead of fighting diseases, we fighting um the old of Saruman.
Yeah, absolutely. And if you want to find out if this is just another pandemic game or if there's something more under the cover, then well, hit the subscribe button.
Absolutely. Do that and then join us after the theme song. And remember, one does not simply walk into Moldor, especially in this game.
Rolling dice, feeling nice and games. Click subscribe. It's a vibe. All we need to be sup for you and me. What's the Here's what you should play and see. Lord of the Rings Fate of the Fellowship is the latest evolution of the pandemic system. A fully cooperative game where one to five players takes on the roles of the iconic members of the Fellowship as they race across Middleear on a desperate mission to destroy the one ring. This dramatic adventure replaces outbreaks with the spread of Sauron's influence as orc armies march nazoul hunt and the eye moves ever closer to spotting Frodo. Players must manage their actions, battle the forces of darkness, and evade Sauron's ever searching eye on route to completing missions inspired by Tolken's epic. With iconic story beats, high tension, and a fresh thematic twist on the classic pandemic mechanisms, Fate of the Fellowship immerses you in a race against corruption where teamwork, timing, and sacrifice are everything.
So, Matt, let's talk about the mechanical design of the game. And yes, there are some pandemic type things in here. And if you're unfamiliar with that game, then we're not going to go through the details. It's a very famous game. You go check that out. And if you had it already, brilliant. Uh if not, it's available everywhere. So in a very different flavors.
Yes. Exactly. So we're more going to focus on the differences, I think.
Yeah. Exactly. Cuz uh again, this is a very much a pandemic game. Once you play it, um, of course, everything is going to be, um, uh, with a with a a flavor of Lord of the Rings. Yes. But kind of like as soon as you start playing, you'll start recognizing, oh, this is this, this is that. Um, cuz again, being a pandemic system, there are few things that are always the same in that in that in that system. For example, having a lot of cubes on the on the map. um having a large map that in this case is representing the um the middle herd and you don't have this is a skew but you got a lot of little soldiers around the map. Then of course you're going to have your deck where you're going to get your cards and you're going to um need to hand manage your your your card and your resources, your locations. Uh you're going to get events. you're going to get um uh the card the special cards that are the bad cards that are the epidemic card that is basically yeah the the epidemic cards that is when something really bad is going to happen.
Um but yeah, but for the rest again, um there's a lot of characters that old Lord of the Rings, you get all your friends. You got Froen Sam, you got Mary Pepe, you got you got you got all of them. You got all of them.
Uh from Yeah. From the Golem, you got all of all all the good guys from all the fellowship really
more good than than others. And these are going to represent like in pandemic the medic, the military and and so on the the researcher blah blah blah. So each one of the of the character will have some special action that they can only do.
First difference, you're not controlling just one character in this game, you're controlling two. Massive difference. So, this is a interesting thing that gives you uh real uh decision making sort of depth, right? You're going to pick one of your characters to do four actions, then one of your characters to do one action. And which one of your characters does four and one is up to you.
Yeah.
So, and that's really interesting. You might, you know, one turn want, you know, Aragorn to do four things, go fight some orcs, and the other turn you might want to try and stealth uh Frodo and Sam across the map. Um and which one you choose will be you know very dynamic based on the board state
depending on what's what what's happening and um again as we say like two character each one with special things of course every character got um the the standard action that you could do that is going to be moving attacking conquering um um a location or mastering that is different again from the normal pandmic uh that basically lets you take one of your cards each card is going to have the suit. So, uh in the in the pandemic, you got different colors on this. You got different suit. There's going to be uh swords, ring, hearts. Uh what you can do uh you can take one of those cards, discard it, and take a to a token matching that um that suit. Uh this will let you keep um a maximum of seven cards in your hand but as unlimited of these tokens. So you got a little bit more of um uh resource management there that you can
more resource management more flexibility. You can spend those cards to get those resources instead of having to always throw them away if you go over your hand which you would do in normal pandemic. Right. So
exactly and then the special action. I mean there's thousands. You need to you need to read them. But just for example, one is um Frodo. Frodo can put the rings on and and disappear and you're going to lose hope. Then we're going to touch in a second, but it's going to let let Frodo and Sam sneak around and and not be seen by the eye and the nuts ghoul and all the the bad things, all the stuff. For example, um I don't know, uh Gandalf will let you reroll one of the dice. cuz he's as a wizard. He can do whatever he wants. Exactly.
But and so and so on. So I I'll leave you guys to discover every single one cuz it's very it's very cool. Very thematic.
It is. It is the different characters.
The game at the starts will will tell you use this character for your first game that normally are frozen, Marian Pipin, um Aragon and Gandolas. Uh, but to be honest, I always prefer like when we went blind and just like mix the card and give the give the card.
Of course, the entire game is about throwing the ring into Modos or Frodo and Sam in this case are one card. So, they count as one character.
They're always going to be in the game.
Always going to be in the game. Absolutely. So, that takes us to the objectives of the game. Whereas in normal pandemic, you'd be just trying to cure the four diseases. That's all you're trying to do. In Fate of the Fellowship, your objectives will be different every time you play. You've got this wonderful stack of different missions that you're going to be doing. And you're going to be drawing three. One of them is always going to be destroy the one ring cuz that's you always have to do that. But the other ones will be uh randomly dealt. And they are very varied and very different and very challenging. It gives great variety to the game cuz there are tons of these.
Yeah. And the the best things for Lord Lord of the Ring fans out there, they all every one of those missions is very thematic.
Very much those story
be it's really cool. Every time that we played and uh we found like a new one that is like oh this is exactly like in the movie. I mean no spoiler but I just want to talk about the one that we were playing the other day that I think was the super cool one of the mission cards. You rap Gandalf and needs to find a bar rock. Yeah.
And once you do that, you you need to achieve certain condition to to achieve it. And basically what happened is uh the Gandalf die when you when you actually achieve it.
He comes off the map.
He comes off the map. But the next time that an um a pandemic cards comes out darken cards. Yeah.
He will come back on the board as Gandalf the White. So he'll be OP.
He's a very OP character.
It's awesome
again. And and there are so many of these cards and they all like you you will all see and be like, "Oh, that is like in the books. They're just like it's amazing. Really really really cinematic."
Absolutely. Very very cinematic. So the way that you win the game has multiple ways because you have all of these great objectives and there's typically three that you're going to be doing. But the way that you lose the game again is very different to pandemic where in standard based game pandemic you would lose the game in numerous different ways, right? through outbreaks or through a disease cube running out or uh numerous other ways. Um or getting to the bottom of the deck, all those things.
In this game, none of that happens. You only lose when you run out of hope.
Yes. And that is a very cool mechanic.
It is. Everything feeds into this hope mechanism. So, whenever you would run out of uh bad troops, the troops of Sauron, and you need to put more on, you lose hope. Every time you run out of player cards, you need to draw more. You lose hope. Everything is tied to hope, which can be manipulated. And you can gain hope by doing the missions that we talked about. That will give you some hope.
Yeah. Conquering conquering strongholds like enemy strongholds.
Exactly. Killing the enemy strongholds and turning them into havens. Another great way of getting hope.
But the game will always try to let you lose hope, especially with Frost Frod is always in the game. One of the main mechanics for Frodo is the fact that he needs to travel. But every time that he travels, he will need need to roll dice. And this is the other different things from
is the amount of dice chalking. This is cool. So
yeah, you will have to roll a dice um for enemy um every enemy troop and not school present in that um in that region and location. And uh whatever depending on what you roll, you might lose more hope because
because you're being found and this is representing
um Sauron looking for you with his eye, right? So, and speaking of which, there is a token to represent Sauron's eye, which is going to be darting around the map, and you can manipulate that as well, which is really fun by starting battles everywhere. And uh
uh really, really cool.
Let's talk about those epidemic cards, Matt, because they're slightly different. the skies darken. Um, as always, the you're going to have a sort of threats level,
um, which will tell you how many what would be the country cards in normal pandemic where you draw those and put the cubes out.
But in this game, we're very different. Um, you have this uh other deck.
Remind me what it's called. I can't remember what this deck's called.
I have no memory of this place.
Well, man, that is the shadow deck. It's the shadow deck.
Yes,
the shadow deck. Okay. You draw cards from the shadow deck and that will do things like putting troop bad troops on the map, moving them around. And that's another big difference with the map map.
Yeah, exactly. Because in in a normal pandemic, the cards will tell you put a cube here, put a cube there, put three cubes there, and and and so on. In this case, instead, um the deck is divided the shadow cards. It's a very cool mechanism where you're going to pull up a card, put it next to the to the deck, and the deck has got a two different cards. One with a black bottom and one with a a red top. So that means that depending on what card is on still on the deck, you will need to do the top action or the bottom action. In this case, the top action is going to be moving. Usually it's going to be moving troops on the map. Um, each map, each location on the map is connected by a variety of arrows of a lot of different colors. And this is going to tell you, for example, you need to go from ENAD to Elm's Deep following the um the orange um route. That means that all the shadow troops or all the orcs are going to move from tom steep following that. That means that
they all going to move one step one step closer. Um, this might create um uh conflict because if the if the red troop, the shadow troops get into a place where you got your own troop, your friendly troop, you're going to
roll the dice and see who dies who who does then.
Exactly. And that can have farreaching consequences cuz if that happens in a haven, which is one of your own like places, which you can give you bonuses if you do actions there.
If there's no other friendly troops in the haven, they will take it over and guess what? You lose hope. Of course you do. Of course you do. That can be and it's dangerous as well. You lose a lot of hope doing that. Six three hope is brutal.
Yeah, it is. It's quite um since you starting with six is quite it's quite a lot.
So don't let that happen.
Um the instead going back to the shadow deck if you get the bottom of the you need to activate the bottom of the card is normally putting down troops um in specific location and something moving the eye.
Exactly. And yeah, Nazul and and um Sauron are going to do like very bad things. On top of that, in the shadow deck, you're going to have the Sauron and the um and the Sauron cards. Again, bad things. Uh you're going to lose hope and la all bad things, nothing good. So, this is a very every time bad things are going to happen with this. And of course, the threat level is going to tell you how many of these cars you need to flip every time. So when you start adding like three, four, five,
start flying around the map and it gets pretty spooky. Pretty spooky.
Um, and this goes to the to the cooperative things of the game because, okay, so um, the deck does a lot of bad things, but you and your and your fellowship can do a lot of good things for Middle Earth. For example, you can you can create more troops on the on certain location. You can move the troops around. So there is kind of like um um this very cool mechanisms of like um board control as well moving troops around and get them in key locations stop the orcs because again like in pandemic you know what cards are going to come well up to a certain degree you know which cards are in the deck and which one came out. So when you reshuffle the deck again you know which one are going to be on top. So you're kind of like, all right, we definitely need to defend Laurian or we definitely need to defend Minister Ste because too many cards pointing toward direction came out. So you want to put more troops there and trying to be safe and maybe leaving one of the two character that you control in me steer. It's because they're good at fighting and they can help with the with the fight.
Absolutely. But even that is less predictable than in something like pandemic where you would just shuffle the countries, put them back on that deck and then draw them because the backs of the cards are so important when you shuffle and put them back on top. The backs of the cards are in different orders as well. So you flip it over and that that front that that was moving the troops here is now going to be instead putting more troops on the board and and doing other stuff. So
there's slightly less control over that which is very interesting as well,
making it slightly more cinematic, which we'll talk about later. And and talking about cinematic because this again
it's a it's a great cinematic game. Um, how do we win the game?
Because that is again there is only one way to win the game and is of course throwing the ring into um Doom and
all the other character can be all like scattering around doing battle doing stuff but you want Frodo to arrive at Montum and throw the ring doing a certain specific action. uh you need to have a certain number of ring. In this case, you will need to have five rings in your cards or the token as we say as we said earlier. And then you do a one last big roll with all all the dice. H the number of dice will depends on how much hope have you lost during the game. How many Nazum So everything is against you. Uh there are some mitigation that you can do with spending all the type of tokens, but at the end of the day, everything always finish with a one last cinematic roll of dice.
Yeah. Really cool.
And you're going to win the game that way or or you might just lose the game that way. That's that's another way of losing.
Absolutely. And and there is which goes to another big difference which is the fact that there is this dice rolling mechanism in the game. Um and there are essentially three layers of randomness, right? You have your player deck randomness, you have your shadow deck randomness, and you also have uh the dice chucking of two lots two lots of dice. So that is what it makes it different from the from the other pandemic. So absolutely what I will say, let's go and talk about who's this game for. Is it for you? Is it for him? Is it for her? Is it for they? Is it for Frodo? Or is it for Golem? Let's find out. Okay, Wayne, who is this game for? That is a great question, Matt. I think this is obviously if you are a Lord of the Rings fan, uh, and you like the look of it, and I think you should because the production, frankly, is is pretty good.
I mean, I I love the artwork. I love the little Naz Ghouls. I love everything around these, like all of the little details, the standies, the wooden standies, which I I really like as well. I mean, it's a a really cool product. this very this very cool mini meeples um fighting meeples with their sword raised or with the with the axe for the for the orcs uh that really cool um all the character in this like cartoony way you you can immediately see is Lord of the Rings but without being a copy of anything else so it's quite quite new the map um let me touch quickly on the map because the map looks the first time that we saw it I it was like whoa that's busy
and It it is busy. Um, however, as soon as you start getting into the game, you start recognizing the patterns and what is what like immediately it's going to take you um a play or two, but after that I think you you start flying. Um, it's u if you know the location that will help. So if you know where minister is on the map, that will help you out because a difference from pandemic is like you you taking out the cards the New York car.
You know where New York is. You know it.
If you're not a Lord of the Rings fan, you have no idea where home is. That's a problem.
That could take the car the car kind of like tells you but
points you out which region is but
but it's quite busy. So like finding it is still challenging.
Um and also
but the cool things is you got a lot of little Easter eggs on the on the map there. So to to discover, you just need to look at it and there is a lot of like very cool Easter eggs.
And if you are a fan of the franchise, look, you look at this absolutely extra dice tower. I mean um um unnecessary but the game so much
also somehow totally necessary.
Also somehow totally necessary. So going back to it but the the question is
yeah if you're a big fan of of the Lord of the Rings franchise I think and you are also a board gamer that enjoys that system you have to I think get this game it's really really cool because it is so cinematic it does hit those um story beats I say cinematic as if it's the movies I think they based it more on the books right
yeah c one would say cinematic is the feeling of the game feelings yeah exactly when having like very uh big drama moments where you think like That's it. We lost. We We lost. And then you swing it back and uh and then you lose hope again. And then you're just like, "Oh, but we can conquer um card." And then and you just like everything comes back together and at the end you are at the at the last row when Frodo is there ready to throw it and
holding everything. Yeah. Super cool. But I do say and I will say that if you're just like a casual fan of like the pandemic series and you're expecting this to be that with like a Lord of the Rings flavor, be aware this is significantly more complex.
So if we check out the board complex meter, this I think goes square in the advanced category.
Yeah, it is. Um again because um the diff the added layer to the pandemic system, the fact that you got um a little bit more randomness with the uh with the dice rolling uh with another set with another different deck,
multi-layered cards, with the troops on the map,
all the character with different powers, the missions that it changes all the every time. um the moving troops around, fighting and moving the Nashville, moving the eye. There is a lot there is a lot going on. Um so it's not just like all right is um just a risking of a pandemic system. Uh like what maybe we saw in the past with all the IP more or less I'm not saying a complete risking but uh this is this is it own thing. Um and uh so but you need to be aware it's not an easy game. You will lose more time than what you win.
You will lose more than you win. And it is a more complicated game than than the original.
Absolutely. Absolutely. But that is what makes it better for me at least. What you think?
Exactly. Yeah. I agree, mate. So is there anything you want to talk about more for who it's for or should we go for final thoughts? Yeah, I I will say um if you looking for a for a challenging game
Oh, hell yeah.
Um if you love the the Lord of the Rings or the Pandemic, even if you don't like The Lord of the you're not a big fan of The Lord of the Rings, but you're a big fan of Pandemic and you want to want a challenging version of the game,
more complex, deeper potentially. Yeah,
this this is the thing for you. If you're Lord of the Rings and never played Pandemic, give it a go. It might take you a little bit to get into the into the mechanics, but um after a while you'll get into that and you you're just going to love it. It just is bring the Lord of the Rings stories in into the game and every game is going to be different and you want to play it more and more and more.
Yeah. And it really does drive the cooperative feeling as well this game. So it's very much so.
All right, Matt, let's talk about our final thoughts of the game.
Let's go. So, Matt, give us your final thoughts, overview, uh, impressions of Fate of the Fellowship and any sort of critiques or niggles that you might have.
Um, what what I will say is when we received the rule book ahead of the our first game at UKG with Matt Leo, that was was a fantastic experience to to play this game with him. Um, and getting his thought process behind the the creation of the game. Um um I I told him and and I told to to to a lot of people I was a little bit burned out with Pandemic.
Yeah, we both were completely
because we we played Pandemic a lot. Uh we had the good idea or bad idea I don't know to play the entire legacy like in a very short uh period. So we were playing pandemic like bum very very finished the entire the entire legacy system. Uh, and I was like once we done that, it was like I don't think I want to play Pandemic for a while.
Um, when we received the rule book and I started reading it and I was like, ah,
okay.
Sounds interesting. And after the first play, I was just like, this is probably my favorite pandemic ever.
Like full full stop. not just for the uh for the for the team because the IP of course an IP that I love but the game itself is if it was ste with um I don't know butter Galactica or uh or some sci-fi things it will still work excellently as a game. So um this is my favorite pandemic system at today.
Love that. Um yeah I think this is probably the best pandemic system game released in a while. Uh, it is definitely one of the more complex. This is like almost like the the end of the pandemic legacy game, right? Where you've got all these different things going on. It's kind of more like that, like where you've taken it to the nth degree. You got more things going on, more additional mechanisms, more stuff to keep an eye on.
Um,
in terms of general thoughts of the game, it's been really fun, super cinematic, like we said, very dramatic. Yeah, there was the last game that we played, Matt, where we we we would have lost were it not for like the luckiest ice roll you've ever seen. Like literally, there was this one guy, I think it was in Helm, Steve, like holding on against like four troops, killed them all. Like unreal. Like there's no way that should happen, but it happened. And then we we won that game.
So it can swing. We
were really pumped about
You were pumped about it. Yeah. It's like the game keeps you on a knife edge like throughout the whole journey of it. again very thematic and I love that that that Matt has obviously thought um Matt Le not this Matt Matt Leo thought very deep in the name
thought very deeply around how to weave his system around the story beats uh which just goes to show the amazing flexibility of that system I mean to the point where as you say it doesn't even really feel at first
go like a normal pandemic game at all it feels like something different like a different beast Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Um, in terms of critique, I would say that it, like you said, it is quite busy. The I think there's no getting away from that. The board is busy. I don't know how you do anything about that without making a massive Porsche possible. I I would say, yeah, probably just having the double double the size, but that would make it not really playable.
No, exactly. Uh, and when you're moving the little troops around on the map, it's a bit fiddly. So um and moving the little girl who will fall over
in in like the tactile things can be a little bit like oh no this guy oh it's over again. Oh yeah exact a little bit fiddly but that aside it's a tremendously uh satisfying thrilling adventure cooperative game.
Yeah absolutely. And uh do you think this game get our seal of excellence?
Should we do it?
Should we do it?
Okay. Should we do it? Three, two, one. Hey,
we didn't prep this one. You surprised me with that one. I'm not sure.
Well, actually, yeah, I think
we did not prep this one and Yeah. Oh, fair enough. So, we both we both thinks that this is um an excellent game.
It is an excellent game.
It's a game that I will tell people to go out and buy. It was the most sold games. Um, and it's going to be I'm sure as as well for the rest of the year or or the years to come uh because it's um it's it's so cool and in it just everything fits right. Um I did in the past play like the the the the Warcraft version. Um and I love Warcraft. I did not
really enjoy the game. I don't know. I didn't I didn't click with it. Um, and that this one is just like the the best version of the pandemic system. Again, sorry to myself.
So, yeah, I think in the games that we've played uh through either failure or or success uh it's always been very exciting. Yes.
And we've always been like
get nailed by the game that you lose, you're still like enjoying it and uh having a very good time around the table with the people that you're playing with. And this is what what we think a game should be. You should have fun around the table with the other people. Depending on if you're winning or not, that should not be a thing. So,
absolutely.
Yeah.
So, there we go.
So, that was our review of Lord of the Rings Fate of the Fellowship. Wow. Matt, what an interesting game. What a great product from Gman Games in Asland Day.
Oh, absolutely. This one is a knock out of the park and it's a home run as the American will say.
Yeah, it's a home run. It's a beast of a game as well for a pandemic game. Uh and uh yeah, really glad uh that it is uh in our in our hands.
Yeah, and we were playing more and more. This this is not this is a game that is here to stay and um we we really appreciate it and we will play more. Uh we'll definitely invite you guys to give it a go, give it a try if you are all of the cons. So, you should certainly give it a try. Um, as we said in the who it's for, it's even though we love this game, still not might not be for you. What we love, you might not like, go and try it. And if you're burned out on Pandemic, this still may be too pandemic for you.
Yeah, it's definitely a layers there. Um, but what do you think? Did you pick up a copy at UK Games Expo? If so, have you played it to death already? Let us know in the comments below if you feel like it's different enough to own in uh conjunction with the other versions of the Pandemic System games.
Yeah. And if you go and check our Patreon page, you can find our exclusive interview with Matt Lee where he talks at length about the game and all the the the process on how he thought about the games, the mechanics and the how he he put the team into the pandemic system. And not just that, even what his favorite board games of all times are. And it's a very lovely chat that we we were lucky to have with Matt Leook. So that is an exclusive content for the um for the patron
for the patron. So go and check it out.
Absolutely. Otherwise, just click the subscribe button.
We always appreciate you if you do that. Be part of our fellowship.
Yeah.
And subscribe.
Ah, that was so nice.
Thank you, mate. But I think we need to close because it's really hot today and I feel like we're having monk dooms. I just like
it is like being in the fires of Mount.
So check out the rest of our videos and we'll see you at the next one.
Ciao. See?