Skip to main content
Loading video...

Catacombs Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 9:44

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings generally like to talk a lot of bollocks what's up gaming gym and in this video we're going to be talking about a dexterity game that involves flicking discs funny i think we're going gonna be talking about catacombs the third edition and in this game one of you will be taking the role of the overseer the other players will be taking the role of heroes the overseer will attempt to kill the heroes and the other players will be attempting to kill the big bad boss but in this video we'll be giving you a very brief overview of the rules between what we do like what we don't like and we'll come back and tell you whether or not catacombs is still worth playing 12 years after it's first will it's not this version this is third edition there's like another couple of ugly shitty versions previously to this but anyway remember if you're new and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and all that youtube see you after this bollocks so catacombs how'd you play this game so catacombs is a one versus all dexterity game one player is going to take the role of the overseer they'll set up their board with one of the main bosses and the other players will take the role of heroes and they'll set up their balls you've got spaces for abilities items and spells and you'll stick any other things in no space this way so the overseer will select one of the rooms that's available they'll stick the board for that room in the center of

the table and put this barrier around the board this is there just so if you get some nuggets and want to flick disks halfway across the room then it's going to catch those discs in it army so the concept of this game is actually really really simple all you're going to be doing is trying to flick a disc against your opponent that will give it damage and hopefully kill it there's different types of shots in this game and you may even be able to have a shot sequence which will allow you to do different things so the first thing you could do is you could take a rush action this is basically just flicking a disc without actually doing any damage if you do happen to hit a monster while doing a rush action then the monster doesn't take any damage at all so there's also shot sequences that you can do if you see the fist icon this means you can do a melee attack if you see the arrow head icon then this means that you can pull out your trusty bow and take a range attack what you do with this you'll take the relevant disk relating to your weapon you'll stick it within an inch of your hero and then you'll flick it and try and kill the monster also before the heroes will be trying to kill all the monsters in the room and if they do that then they'll be able to progress to the next room if any of the heroes die i.e if they lose all their health they will be dead but they will resurrect themselves somehow ready for the next room so effectively nobody gets killed unless everyone gets killed so if the heroes kill all the monsters in the room then you'll resolve that room you'll look at all the monsters that each hero killed and you'll get the amount of gold that's listed on that monster you'll be able to use this gold to trade for items and stuff in special rooms like althea the healer you'll be able to trade in free gold for one health right you might be able to go to ish check the merchant

and this is where you'll be able to buy loads and loads of different items and there's also the amarath in you'll be able to trade eight gold to get one extra health per player this will take your health above its initial value this room will have a set of special items you could buy and you'll also be able to trade 10 gold to recruit an ally an ally is one of the heroes that wasn't used in a game right so keep doing this you'll keep going through all the different rooms i think there's eight or nine of them and then eventually you'll get to the lord's lair the aim of this final room is to kill the big bad boss if the players manage to do that then they will win the game but if the overseer kills all the heroes in one room then they will win the game of catacombs so what do we like about catacombs so the first thing that we really like about this game is that there's really nothing quite like it tries to blend the best elements of the exterior games that you're used to when you're flicking discs and like that with the rpg elements of sort of dungeons and dragons it was the first game that we know of to do this right if you look at so many other flicking games like korean belarus or even games like rampage they're very very basic they're lacking any kind of depth but with catacombs you've got these special abilities automatically linked to the monsters that they represent yeah there's loads and loads of different ways to upgrade your characters as you're going through the dungeon you might be able to pick up some magic items like the cloak of invisibility this allows you to teleport to anywhere on a board you might want to pick up the vampire sword which lets you nick health from your opponent if you do a successful melo attack or you might

want to pick up the massive phallic looking war hammer which lets you do a rush action and then do a critical melee attack so there's loads of different ways to expand again there's even pets in this game called familiars that could follow you around and battle these act like extra characters these allow you to act like a world war one general where you can send the plebs over the top instead of getting your ass kicked right so the second thing that we like about catacombs is there's loads and loads of ways to expand this game you've got the caverns of solof expansion you've got the wyverns of wylamur expansion there's the more simpler catacombs and castles game that can be merged with this one and then you've got all the little special mini expansions that are only available on the manufacturer's website right so all in all once you dig deeper into this game you're going to find that there's just so many different ways to play this game there's so many different options it's all mind-boggling so the third thing that we don't like but we do like catacombs is that there's no player elimination this means that the people that are this game aren't going to be set out for too long you will be set out for a little bit only until your mates decide to kill all the monsters but you'll be resurrected ready for the next room i mean it is a little bit weird i suppose that you could die and then come back to life just because you fancy it right i suppose at the end of the day thematically it doesn't really matter because it's a fantasy game it's just a board game based on a load of fantastical nonsense right it's not saying to be taken seriously like a lot of ball gamers seem to do these days so the fact that nobody is going to be sal doing bugger all like a certain game

called nemesis back there means there's going to be nobody crying into their pillow when they go to sleep that night right so what do we like about cocoons so first thing we don't like about catacombs is that there's just too many icons in this game i mean the basic mechanism of flick move repeat it's all bogged down by the amount of different things going on in the game right when you've got different options for rush you've got different options for melee you've got missile you've got viable giant fireball boulder ice target monster shield wizard shield sorcerer shield teleport roll shot open sake it drives me up i can never remember what all of this means so i'm going to be constantly digging into the rule book stop looking for a tiny little bit of sweet corn in your granddad so the second thing that we don't like about catacombs is it just feels a little bit empty where the game is just a load of discs on the board and all you can be doing on your turn is just flicking in a variety of different ways there's not really any kind of story going on it would have been nice had there been some sort of campaign or some kind of event that happened or maybe some sort of objective that you've got to do items to collect or something i don't know i'm not a games designer i ain't got a clue but it just feels like the concept or flick disc do damage flick disc do damage it just wears a little bit thin after a certain number of plays right and such i just feel that this game is just lacking that certain thing to make it more cohesive so the final thing that we don't know about catacombs and every time we review a

dexterity game of this nature the same thing comes up is that when you flip the disc forward you're going to either leave yourself out of position or you're going to leave yourself open to attack we had the same kind of complaints about that classic football game actually there's a pile of dog on a cebu when you flick the defensive footballer forward you'll be leaving a massive hole in your defense and the same is true of catacombs when you flick the disc to try and do damage more often than not you're going to be leaving yourself vulnerable to a counter attack from the monster so unless you've got a rush attack tagged onto the end of your shot sequence you're going to find yourself just flicking backwards and forwards at close proximity until somebody does a bunk and then hides behind one of the pillars and just feels a little bit cheap on occasion i mean so to summarize this catacombs still worth your time bother 12 years after it was first released so we're gonna say yes this is a unique dexterity game that attempts to merge the basic idea of flicking discs with more traditional rpg elements right it suffers from a horrendous amount of bloat and confusing iconography that you'll never ever ever gonna remember this slows the game down creates some unnecessary and unwelcome frustrations however the amount of options and variability sort of lifts this up over that minor gripe whilst we do have some misgivings with the way the game's played there really isn't anything else quite like this if you like dexterity games this is really going to be a bit of a no-brainer i suppose you could say that catacombs is a bit of a flawed masterpiece and being fans of dexterity

games ourselves i think we can live with that so there you go that is catacombs third edition of it remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit the like button and all that youtube see you next time

you

Progress saved