Skip to main content
Loading video...

A more thematic and interesting version of Arnak, to me | SETI Review

Transcript 19:29

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this video I'm going to go over my review of seti so this is a tabletop simulator version of it but I will say that I own this game I went against what I usually do and I purchased this game without having played it only Having learned it and or I should say heard about it and learned very vaguely what this game was about and so it was much of a surprise to me as it might be to you but uh so I went out of my way to get this game because I it had received a lot of good feedback from players and it seemed like it was up my alley of what kind of game I would be interested in and this game is really good so let's get into why but to go over the the game as an overview what we're trying to do is as the name implies we are searching the Galaxy for signs of life and in this Euro game adaptation or abstraction of that concept you are taking actions of which there are many which include launching probes from Earth moving them around the solar system to land on planets or moons or to orbit them also playing cards from your hand to make these actions a little bit easier to to do you're requiring technologies that make your actions easier you're scanning the sky for data points or you pieces of

data that you can put onto your board and analyze all of which leads to gaining three different kinds of resources the signs of life as I call them you place them onto your uh these flipped alien boards until uh it one of each color is full and then you flip over two of these five randomized aliens Midway through the game these give you extra abilities to score points as well as different car s and opportunities to once again score even more points games of this usually go up into the 100 plus range of points you do this over five rounds and you go back and forth taking a main action until someone or until all people pass who are playing the game and whoever has the most points after five rounds wins so that's a basic overview of what this game is all about so moving on to some board game comparisons there are two I want to make first is another cge game lost Runes of arnac which is a very popular game of course now I did not know this ahead of time when I learned this game and it makes sense now uh some people have made this this comparison to arck in that the round structure is very similar where you have all of these different actions and puzzles you know kind of like a you're solving a puzzle with those actions and and the cards that you have in your hand which are multi-use by the way and you

have a very open-ended approach to what you can do on your turn and to when a round officially ends you take turns and go as far as you can doing actions as efficiently as possible to extend the amount of time that you have to to you know get as many points as you can and so it very much felt like lost Runes of arnac instead of having a a board where you place out workers and explore a board and flip over tiles in this game in or and also you have a kind of a track that you're progressing through as you turn in resources in arnac as opposed to in seti where you have a board where you are moving probes around and racing other people towards the uh planets before you know before they can which is I guess very similar to the worker placement Board of arnac but instead of a track that you're moving up you are you know I guess essentially focusing on moving your probes around that board playing cards taking different actions more of like an area control type of experience with scanning as well and so the decision space ultimately felt very much like arck did when I first played it very open-ended and lots of actions to take and you know it took a lot of time to really figure out what I wanted to do and how best to progress through the action selections you know the selection of actions that I had on each turn to um maximize the

amount that I could do on my turns and the second game I want to compare is Arc Nova now both games have a large deck of individualized cards which is very appealing and part of the reason why I decided to buy seti in the first place but I will say that these games feel very different and it kind of alludes to the decision space that surrounds how you take action in seti you have a very wide amount of different actions plus threee actions that you can take I don't know off the top of my head what those actions are or how many there are but there's like you know like eight somewhere between five and eight different actions that you can take plus another five free actions or so right in addition to all the different cards that you can play for actions as well so you thec the decisions that you have in this game are very variable right versus an arc Nova it branches off from five actions that you can take you know AR NOA I've always thought was like a meteor version of wingspan where it's easy to understand where you can launch off to take an action right okay I have five different action cards that I can you know choose from they all vary in the power that you can do so and so some actions are going to be better on certain turns than others but the decisions really come from what can I do with what I have now and make the most of it to create an engine and get my ball rolling with points right and so Arc NOA feels a little bit more restricted in what you can accomplish and you're trying to just

get by as efficiently as possible whereas in seti it feels a lot more open and it's up to you to kind of find those uh most efficient paths yourself with more I guess variables and data points right to to choose from so each game does offer some variability a lot of variability with different cards and whatnot but the way that you take actions and the way that I feel it makes you feel as a player from turn to turn is a lot different in the scope of what is available to do so moving on to the peer review of which there were a lot of comments I didn't go through all of them but I tried to summarize what I found on Board Game Geek for those who have already played this game and to summarize what I found here people really enjoyed uh the production of this game in you in physical format the Thematic integration as well I I feel like the designer uh domas ho really uh put a lot of thought and effort into making this game play very smoothly but also be very close to what it might actually be like to explore space as we do now and to discover Life out there so a lot of people enjoyed that I'll have more to say on that later people thought this was a pretty strategic game and really enjoyed the alien introduction element of this game about halfway through or so like I mentioned before you do alter how the game might be played and offer different ways that this game might be approached another

game that I failed to mention at this time or at at the time that I spoke about the aliens was newford there's my Rosen Rosenberg pick for the video uh so newford introduces those endgame sea buildings near the end of the game like about two-thirds of the way through and so it offers you a few different tantalizing options to pursue before and they offer to you privately before offering it uh publicly to everyone and so u i so yeah I'll I'll save my comparisons and thoughts for that later too but some people did have some issues with the game it is pretty lengthy and one part that makes this game lengthy is the same potential issue that you would find in a game like arac where the uh fact or even like games like everdell where the fact that if someone one ends their turn earlier and has used up all their resources they may be sitting there watching other people play their turns out uh for an extended amount of time and so it does not automatically uh have you know an equal turn structure per se for everyone and so that might help or hurt people by helping them or I guess making them feel like they're they're you know missing out some other things that people found issues with are the um resource constraints you know I I think some people especially at higher player accounts found that there weren't a lot of resources enough in the game box to go around and uh the randomness

as well sometimes you get right cards that you need to uh really turn your strategy into something more efficient than your neighbor whereas they have no other uh potential comeback to um compete with you uh overall though a lot of people commented on the replayability and variability I think plays a big factor in that with a large deck of cards the potential for alien expansion content as well in addition to expanding other things like tax and cards was a highlight of this game and something that people would look forward to and probably found meaningful as they played the game and thought of the potential benefit of having the game for future content to make this game even more replayable down the road very similar to another very thematic game in terraforming Mars which shares a lot of the DNA with this game as well I feel like that game has had a lot of you know it has legs to be very replayable nearly 10 years later because of the additional expansion content in a very uh you know added on to a very variable and uh you know exploratory type of game as a base and so you know this game obviously has that same potential to be replayable uh with the content that you have now but also in the future so a lot of people like that as well

so getting into my final ratings and I've listed them out here already for you to look at overall 8.7 a very good enjoyable game so I'll go through these one by one so rules and gameplay I felt like the rules were easy enough to learn there are still some instances where I did turn to the game rules espe with my first play as I had tried to internalize the rules beforehand and when it came you know time to play I was a little overwhelmed with all the choices that I had at first right it like I said you know it's not as easy or straight As straightforward as Arc Nova is in terms of what you can do on your turn in this game it took a little bit more of I guess a learning curve to learn what you could actually do and then it became a little bit more strategic now for strategic Avenue news you know how diverse could each game be from game to game in which you score points you know I I feel like you have a pretty equal opportunity to score a lot of points whether you really focus on scanning the solar system or sending out probes to land or orbit planets or then focusing on those aliens as they come out as well mid game there are a lot of different ways to really I guess diversify focus in on one area or kind of have a combination you can be I think you can be pretty successful with either of those and in the games that I've played I feel like I've been able to have a diverse game from game to game and there

are a lot of other variables that affect this in addition to the different aliens you have the different endgame goals here that are in yellow as well as you know the different texts that you acquire throughout the game as well as the cards that you have to play with and so yes I do feel like there are a lot of different ways you can explore and be successful in this game which I appreciate although it does I going down to skill ceiling I I feel like this isn't as a skillful as a game as Arc NOA is or even like terraforming Mars I think this game while it's very uh interesting and Broad in how you can acquire points I don't I don't feel like it there is much of an ability to really I guess get better at this game I think it's more in the game to game ability to recognize what the most optimal plays are going going to be in games like Arc NOA agrica there are certain ways that you approach the game that utilize a lot of skill and repetition to understand what is the best move and when is it right to deviate from that and kind of a sequential order right there are certain things that you should do in the early game of Arc NOA and then pivot to continue your engine of points building up throughout the rest of the game and that is variable based off once again the cards as well as the map that you're playing Etc in set it feels a little bit more tactical in nature where you're really going off of just what the cards you have in your hand are allowing you to do

more efficiently as well as what the board state looks like and so it I don't I feel like there is an opportunity to be a skill to be skillful in this game but not to the same degree as very competitive games I feel like like Ark Nova terrsa Dune Etc now back up to thematic integration this game is very thematic I I think this is one of the most thematic games that I've played where every single C it reminds me of Arc Nova well no not even that like it reminds me more of terraforming Mars and wingspan where the cards themselves oh and agrica of course the the cards are very thematic everyone feels like they've been tailored with care to represent what uh technology or you know event in history that has led to us going you know going to the stars and looking for extraterrestrial life and there are FL you know there's flavor text on on the bottom of each card which is amazing and so you have the cards right you have the board one of the coolest things is this board where um as you take certain actions in the game and as it progresses the board will rotate and affect you know how your probe is located in the solar system and how it uh its movement might affect the solar systems movement might affect the movement of your own probes you either help or hinder you based off of what is going on and essentially the effects of your actions as well as your opponents and so it's very thematic it you know the middle part spins as F you know faster than the outer parts does as it does in the solar system anyway and so

this Central board is fantastic I I think this is one of my favorite if not my most favorite part of the game I love the aliens as well uh I there are probably thematic Integrations about those uh aliens that maybe are not I guess not like fantastic but more predictable based off of the science and what we know already so I really enjoy that as well and so this whole amalgamation of uh this game as far as the theme is concerned is a masterpiece in my opinion doesn't make it it you know does it make it the most skillful game probably not but it does make it very thematic and very enjoyable to learn more I just felt like I was learning more about space and science astronomy than I you know you know it reminded me of going to college back in the day and taking my astronomy course then you know so uh if I could get that while still having fun playing a thematic board game Euro game rather then that is a plus right and that's why I think this is a very fun game is you know it's got a lot of replayability it does miss out on the opportunity to have more uh alien species to mix up the mid game and just like with Arc Nova and the different Maps you have like 10 maps in the base game it' be so cool and and I understand that you know in SE the aliens really do affect how this game will play and so there's a lot more that goes into making those aliens that perhaps there would be for maps but I with additional content that

replayability will just increase and the variability is already there and I think that uh it's it's those aliens that I feel like just misses out uh you know uh a little bit you know uh for the solo mode uh it was a pretty interesting solo uh you flip over a card you know do as do an action that you can you know with the card itself and there are different ways to upgrade the uh difficulty with different objectives Etc and so I I thought the solo mode was well implemented and very fun to do it really simulates the actual multiplayer game pretty well and I really enjoy the interaction in this game I think in addition to interacting with the central board not only in the movement of probes when you do rotate the solar system but also for vying for area control for these Stars around the uh the solar system if you're scanning for data and uh you know placing your own personal markers on those Stars Whoever has the most when that you know little data uh spot is filled you know will get some benefits there right and so there's a a little bit of an area control type of um competition going on in the main board and so there's a lot of interaction there there's a lot of interaction for the planets themselves to send probes there as quickly as you can uh interaction for racing for milestones and uh placing your markers on these endgame placeholders or uh uh markers you know uh Racing for tax Racing for the different alien bonuses as well lots of different races and so it feels like terraforming Mars in that regard uh and so it's a really delicious uh race type

of interaction in this game so so overall a fantastic game one that I enjoy and am pleased to have in my collection physically and we'll continue to explore this game and see if the skill ceiling does improve over time if there is an element of Mastery to this game to the same degree that I would hope for it to have you know similar in in vain to games like arcn NOA and agria but even if it doesn't have it I think this is still a really fun game to pull out and play and and just have fun with right so those are my thoughts and my review on seti thank you for Consulting with me today and hope you schedule an appointment with me real soon take care

Progress saved