Skip to main content
Loading video...

Lunar Skyline: The follow-up to the 2023 GOTY is a Trick-Taker?!

Transcript 15:14

let's talk about lunar Skyline a trick-taking followup to my 2023 Game of the Year welcome to brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald and this episode we're going to well just in time for Halloween we're going to preview a trick-taking game that's a real treat this is a game that's a followup to my game of the year last year which was lunar rush you might be able to see just the bottom of the Box on the shelf behind me uh but this one's a game called lunar Skyline this is coming to Kickstarter very soon lunar Skyline is a trick taking game like I said it works for between two and six players kids age 10 and up can figure this one out but there are some strategic wrinkles that we're going to talk about and games can take anywhere from 15 to 30 minutes they could go even longer because they're a variable number of rounds you can decide to play extra rounds let's take a deeper look at lunar Skyline from Dead Alive games lunar Skyline is a trick-taking game but it is medium in terms of its complexity there are some strategic things that are happening here that that push it just above I would say a light level what you're trying to do in this game is earn the most points after a set number of rounds typically you'd play three rounds and certainly in a three-player game that's how we did it I've only played this game at three players even though it works with between two and six how do you earn

those points well you're going to earn points by winning tricks that have certain symbols on them we'll talk about those if you earn a certain number of tricks that you bid at the beginning if you win a certain number of Tricks you're going to get to grab one of these contracts and you're going to get to build one of these buildings on the moon's surface so there are a number of different ways that you can earn points but primarily you need to win those tricks and win the right number that's going to allow you to grab these contracts are game changers for sure one of the things that you might notice immediately when you look at the cards in this game is that each card has two symbols on it each card falls under two different suits and that really does complicate things and a lot of these trick-taking games you're trying to shed a particular suit so that you're more flexible in terms of the cards that you can play this does make it difficult to do that because all of the cards have two suits on them but before you even play that first card you've got your 12 cards and from that from those 12 cards you're going to secretly take one and that's going to bid that's your bid for the number of tricks that you're going to win so if I play a two I'm guessing that I'm going to win only two of these tricks in this round if I win fewer than that there's not a penalty except that I don't get to grab one of these contracts because I haven't met my bid if if I earn too many I'm going to have to discard tricks that are above this

number and I lose two points for each one once players have all chosen the card that they're going to use as their bid everyone simultaneously reveals that card it slides under this other card that's here that shows your building bid that way everyone can see how many tricks you expect to win how many you want to win and which symbols are going to earn you points once everyone's revealed their bid the player with the highest bid the highest number that they've bid here is going to lead the firsthand and then after that is the winner of the trick that's going to lead this is a must follow trick Taker and and I did a video last year that has definitions I do like trick takers a lot so I've got a video from last year with lots of definitions about trick takers and reviews of other trick takers and I'll I'll put a link somewhere around here so that you can track that down but must follow means that once a card is Led everyone has to play a card that matches the suit on the card that's LED unless they have none of those symbols you're going to go around the table clockwise each player is going to play their card as I said they have to play a card that matches if they don't have a symbol that matches so I could play a robot the same yellow card with a robot and a lightning or I could play a card that has just a lightning on it that's going to match as well if I play a card with the same number the later card is considered to be more powerful there there are ace cards the aces there's only six of these in the deck one for each suit there's only one symbol on the

ace you can play it as high or low although if you lead with an ace it has to be a low card which means you're going to lose that hand if you don't have a card with the suit that matches the lead suit as I said you can play any card but these cards will be considered smuggled at the end of the hand meaning that I take this into my resources so if I win a trick I'm going to place it like this but if I smuggle card it goes sideways to show that it's been smuggled there are some contracts that give you bonuses for smuggled cards that counts as a hand that I won so it's going to go towards my Four Hands here honestly at the end of the round these these smuggled cards are often the ones that kind of force people over their bid when they get trapped with cards in their hands that don't match anything else the winner of the hand the one who played the high card is going to take those remaining cards the ones that weren't smuggled and these are going to go into their resources face up up and down in in portrait mode but you choose which of these cards is going to go on the top and that's going to dictate how many points it's worth to you so if at the end of the game after all the cards have been played I've got a situation that looks like this well I've only won two hands one of them was smuggled I I haven't met my contract my bid here so I don't get to take one of these contracts or one of these buildings how many points am I going to earn well I'm looking at the symbols up here and I'm counting those symbols on these cards down here at the bottom so I've used

this green card that has an astronaut and a cyborg on here I have none of those symbols so I'm going to get zero points this round if that's the way that I played it obviously I would have looked at these symbols and I would have chosen if I won those two cards I would have chosen to put this one on top because I've got a cyborg that's going to earn me one point like I said if I win too many hands if I wind up with a bunch of smuggled hands at the end I get to choose which ones I discard if I have too many so in a case like this where I've got these four smuggled cards I I'll have taken one of these contracts I'll be able to get one of these buildings at the end but I'm going to have to discard one of these hands because I've won five instead of four and I'm going to lose two points as a result of that once everybody's counted up their points and added on the points that are are provided by their contracts that they've won and grab this building these buildings are worth bonus points at the end of the game based on the number of different ones that you have each suit only has two of these so you're really thinking about your bid at the beginning of this game because you've got to you're you're taking the building that matches the card that you used as your bid so if I manage to get my four hands in a round I get to take one of these green cards but there's only two of them in the game once you've played that set number of rounds and everybody's calculated up all their points and their bonus points well that's how you determine the winner the player with the most points wins and then you can start another game certainly this game goes quickly enough

that usually we never played only one we might have added some extra rounds every now and again but usually we'd start a whole new game with everybody beginning at zero after we played for about half an hour or so what skills though are you practicing when you play a game like lunar Skyline um well it is a game where you do need to plan ahead you're planning ahead in terms of uh how many tricks are you going to win when do you need to win those tricks so that you can get the contract that you want and which cards are you going to use as your bid so that you can get the building that you want on your Skyline so there is some planning and then you've got the resource management the hand management that you're doing in the game so you are managing those cards you need to play them at certain times to win the hands that you want to win at the right time uh and to make sure that you don't go over so sometimes you get trapped into playing a card that you don't want but you're you really do need to kind of plan ahead and manage your hand carefully and and when you are planning when you are trying to uh budget resources those are examples of executive functioning skills the behaviors that you need for gold directed action uh and in in this case your goals are your short-term goals are winning the right number of tricks and your longer term goals are getting those various buildings at the end of the game you you are also practicing in quantitative reasoning or math reasoning skills and and what what is the quantitative reasoning well how do you evaluate those cards in your hand to determine and figure out well how many

tricks am I likely to win so that you bid the right amount but don't go over so that you can earn the the right number of points that you need uh to defeat your your opponents um so there is that quantitative reasoning in the context of the the understanding of probability that you need because there are six Cur cards in in a three or two or three or four player game pardon me in a three to five player game there are six cards um how do you what's the probability that a particular card is going to be out there on the table you're also evaluating based on the other players card plays and their bid what are what cards are they looking for because you don't want to give them a card that's going to earn them too many points another Factor here is working memory working memory being the Whiteboard where you Keep information so that you can juggle it somehow and here you need to remember what cards have been played and what cards are no longer uh in circulation so that you know whether you're going to be able to win a particular hand or not final thoughts about lunar Skyline well lunar Skyline is it is a follow-up lunar Rush is a game that I really enjoyed you know you had worker placement you had engine building you had Resource Management the pieces were great everything about I really enjoyed the marketplace everything in that game uh I really really liked it was my favorite game of last year um this is a totally different Beast it's a trick taker as opposed to more of a worker

placement strategic kind of a game but it is a strategic trick taker um Beyond kind of the art style and the theme of building up putting buildings on the moon how how do these two games relate to one another well one thing that carries over is the idea that you're spend a resource to earn points so in lunar Rush you're spending victory points in order to determine turn order here in lunar Skyline you're using one of your cards to show how many tricks you're going to win and which symbols are going to earn you those points and those cards are valuable because you know you only have a certain number of cards in your hand and you're taking two of those symbols that you want to earn points from and those are showing the points as opposed to earning you points so it it is a game where you're spending I really do like the bidding mechanism in most trick takers I like the bidding mechanism but this one is so much more strategic it matters so much more because you're not just determining whether or not you're going to earn points because you can earn points if you don't make it to your bid you're also determining how how quickly how many hands will have to be played before you can grab one of these contracts are you going to be racing against the other players to get a particular card um you're also evaluating am I going to be able to get a different building at the end if I do manage to get the right number of cards so it's a real um it is a real strategic choice to determine which card you're going to place under

here as your bid uh and then of course you know you've got that trick-taking mechanic and with the with the extra kind of complication that each current has two suits so it does definitely make things more complicated no Trump suit in this game I mean you saw that Circle that it's not like there are ranked suits or anything like that instead you if you play a card that doesn't match the others that counts as a hand that you've won even though somebody else is also going to win that round too so that again that's another it keeps the strategy interesting there is a nice even in the Prototype there's a nice siiz deck of these contracts you're only going to see a few at a time they're going to come out in different orders I think that adds to the replay of ility here in addition to the fact that it takes a while to kind of learn how to predict how many hands you're going to win and to wrap your head around the double the cards with the double suits are there downsides though to lunar Skyline uh well not many because I you know I like trick takers and I I did love lunar rush and this is a great game um are there downsides well one is that you know some folks who play trick takers want things to be more straightforward and don't like that bidding mechanic I really do enjoy it um it's you know some of my favorite trick takers don't have that but uh I really like bidding on the number of tricks that you're going to win because then you're sticking players with cards that they don't want or hands that they don't want to win so that does make for a fun

trick taker for me but it may not be for everybody there's no in the Prototype that I was sent there's no points tracker so you're you're either writing points down on a sheet of paper each round or in my case we used poker chips to keep track of the points and the pluses and the minuses as you went through the game um otherwise I mean it's the the double suit of cards I I think that's kind of a fun strategic element to the game some folks might find it a little over complicated it does make it hard to shed a particular suit because everything has two uh two symbols on it so it it is kind of hard to make sure that you're going to smuggle lots of cards at the end um but that's not something that got in the way of our enjoyment of the game we really enjoyed lunar Skyline so I will put information about the kickstarter campaign in the show notes below the video if you have any questions or comments you can leave them in the comment section below or you can email me at Brian brainon games.cz on.cbs that's where future episodes will go and the previous ones are up there already brainson games is the X handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time

Progress saved