Gazebo and Gingham Reviews: Travelin' Abstracts
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel.
I'm Chris Ye. And I'm Mike Delio.
Today we're taking a look at a pair of bite-wing games that we're talking about together because they were released together almost like a set. They were made to look similar. Gingham and gazebo. Gingham is a really hard word to say.
I don't know that I've ever disagreed with you more. It's fine. It's an okay word.
No, I'm just I always like Is it cuz it's I I see ginger. Gingerbread
gingham.
It's not jingham. I don't know. The whole thing is confusing to me.
I've only ever heard the word gingham in reference to a gingham dress [snorts] from like 1940.
It's not a it's it's not a not a not a word that's used very often. So yeah, it's interesting.
A gazebo is something you attack in Dungeons and Dragons or at least if you've read the uh
the apocryphal story of
Oh, I love that story.
Go look it up sometime, Mike. It's amazing
whether it's true or not. I believe. Yes,
I believe.
Anyway, these are two abstract strategy game. One is about ants uh invading a picnic and stealing the good things from it. And the other one is about peacefully building gazeos to beat the snot out of your opponent and have more gazeos than them. I think
just like in real life.
Yeah. Here's how both of them play. In this game, players are going to play either on this four player board or there's a smaller board for two players. And you're going to put out some suites here based on a number of players. There's five different suites. Each player will get the same one. Players will have a bunch of ants of their color and two queens. Now, before I explain the rules of the game, I need to explain the stitch going down the middle here. This splits the board. So, let me talk about putting out a queen. On your turn, you put a queen. That means I could put an ant here, here, here, here, here, or here. But I cannot go to those four spaces beyond that. So, when you get a queen, you could put us them out in any spot. Or if there already is somebody in a spot, you may replace them, but then they get to take the ant that you replaced and put it in any empty spot.
So, you're giving a possibility of doing something. What you're trying to do is a few things. If you connect two of the same suite together, these are connected. Then you will take one and put it on top of the other one, and you'll score points for your ants. In this case, three points. players are going to be keeping track of their points here. When you get to a certain number, that's going to trigger the end of the game. Also, if you completely surround a pile of sweets, you can claim that with yours. That's pretty easy to claim these ones on the side, you'll score points for them. And if you claim one that somebody else has, you can steal it from them. Whenever sweets are taken off the board, it will show one or two sugar cubes, and you'll place that many sugar cubes in that spot. When anyone places an ant next to a sugar cube, they will take them. That's important because you can use those sugar cubes to activate these powers here. So I might score a connection one point five times. So rather than if I connect with six ants, I would get nine points instead of six. Or go in the same row as an opponent, put your ant across a stitch, move your ant instead of placing a new one or select the same row that you've already been in. Whichever one you pick, it will go to the bottom.
Uh, it will go to the top, I'm sorry, and get be the most expensive, moving the other ones down. I should mention that everyone's going to take turns putting out their two queens. So, once everyone has put out their queens and placed their ants on the side of the board, you're then going to do it on the other side of the stitch. However, in this case, you're going to start with the one closest to the star. So, pink would go, then blue, then orange, then blue, then orange, then yellow, then pink, then yellow. And you're going to keep doing this till someone gets a certain amount of points, 32 or 40. That will trigger the end of the game. You'll get a point for all the suites in the piles that you control. So bigger piles is better. Not only that, whoever has the biggest pile of each of the five types will get a bonus five points. Most points wins. In this game, you're going to use one of several of the boards that comes with it. And you'll put this board face up. Each player is going to get five tiles in a pile. They don't know what the colors are that show two of the same color on these dominoes. But you're also going to have a handful of dominoes with different colors on. Look, I drew three of the same type. On your turn, you can place a domino on next to one of the spots on the board that's colored like that. Doesn't have to match. I could put the pink here if I wanted to. Or next to a domino that's already in play. If you place two or more of the same color, you've made a nook. and you'll put your gazebo somewhere on that nook. In the future, you can continue to expand that
nook if you so desire. And if you ever get it so that it's five or more, it becomes a big nook and you can put another gazebo on it. Now, you'll never put more than two gazeos on a nook. So, there's no reason really to make a much bigger than five. As soon as any nook touches one of these patios here, the first person to do that will put one of their gazeos on that. Although, if someone, for example, let's say pink had this nook here and then later on, pink had another nook nearby. So now they have two nooks touching this as opposed to the well that's still two from there. But let's say pink got three in. They would then replace this with theirs. You can also absorb somebody's nook into your own. If, let's say, someone else had a nook that was size two and you'd want it with size four and you connected them, you would absorb it and they would have to take their gazeos back.
Although, once a nook is big, this one's five size. They cannot be absorbed any longer. These are fancy patios and when you connect to them, you get to put two gazeos on them. The point of this game is to get rid of your gazeos. You'll play with a certain number of gazeos based on number of players and the first person to get rid of all of them wins. Everyone has a pile of these single color tiles and when you at the end of your turn you can draw one of these or you can draw from the middle tile where you'll get the dual colored tiles. That being said, if you cover one of these here on the board, one of these spots, you will get to add another one of these to your pile because these are much more powerful. That's how you play.
Uh before we talk about both of the games, I wanted to talk about the components for them. Um Bitewing has some pretty nice stuff. I these both come with upgrade components you can get which are amazing. Mhm.
Um, that being said, if you do not get the upgraded components, then I don't like the mats at all.
They don't have enough weights to kind of keep down the the little folds in the mat. Right.
A box this size can hold a board. Why are we getting rid of the board? I don't understand this. I I don't like those mats at all.
Maybe Mike, you want to speak to it? Well, yes, there's been it's been a a topic of discussion amongst uh this publishers's fans and uh previous games that they've done that have had uh these kind of cloth boards, they are now in the process of saying, "Okay, well, we'll offer, you know, um actual boards if you want them." These were part of a kind of a Kickstarter campaign that was a travel line as well. So, in addition to those standard boxes, you could get some uh travel boxes that you can carry this in. And I think that maybe the idea was that they fit better into those travel boxes. But I do agree with you, if you have just the the standard components, it's definitely not a very satisfying tactile experience.
And I think that some games have done it better. Mike recently reviewed uh Eternal Dex, which has this
the the the type of fabric doesn't fold and crease quite like this one does, and I think that would have been better served with the cardboard components. With the upgrade and the nice stuff, you're not going to really have that issue. But that is a it's a decent cost extra to get clickity clack pieces that
Yeah, it is. And I'm not saying you have to get those, though. But they look nice. The box look nice. The artwork, the the design on it is pretty solid. All right, so let's talk about them. We'll start with the the older one first. And I say older because this is a remake gazebo of
Say it.
What's What's here? There you go. Your chin. Yes.
Chin with a Q. Anyhow,
um, so Gazebo is a game. Now, I do want to mention one thing here. This is a very odd note, and maybe I'm the only person with this problem. I'm not cuz I met someone else who was, too. But in the rule book, it keeps saying single single tiles and double tiles. And everyone on Earth I've ever met who plays dominoes calls a tile with only sixes on it, they say that's a double six. That's the reference term that. So it took me a while until I went back and looked at the list of components. I was like, why do they keep talking about single color tiles are better than double color? I get it. It was a mistake for me, but I just I don't think I'll be the only one to notice that. I don't normally call them that. I would say a single color, double color, not double tiles, single tiles.
Yes. And it matters with the setup and everything what tiles everyone starts with. Um, outside of that, I think the rule set is is good and it's a pretty simple game. I think the only hangup people have is I have to remind people when I teach you when I teach them is that uh unlike domino games, you can mismatch. You can even mismatch both sides and that also you can continually play from any part of the map. So someone starts building off of this little square, you can you can then build off of the other corners. Other than that, I think it's a really smooth and easy playing game. Yeah, I agree. Uh a hallmark of of this designer's kind of games is relatively simple rule set and kind of emergent gameplay. Uh we talked a little bit about Chin. To my understanding, because I played Chin uh years ago, to my understanding, the biggest difference is related to those single or slashdouble uh color uh dominoes or tiles depending upon which version you have. And it was, if I remember correctly, you didn't have them in separate piles. They were all part of a big general pile. And so, I think there were some complaints. One of the complaints about that design was that the the luck of the draw was too strong because if you draw one of those single color uh tiles, it's just strictly better than one with two colors. And so they addressed that here. And I think it's a very big improvement quite honestly um from the g the game uh way was originally. I think that's a pretty big deal. And I like the way that
they've kind of um incorporated that with these zen uh spaces on the board as well. Um that can be very powerful and it can kind of help guide your strategy a little bit.
Yeah, it's very much an in-your-face style game with a bit of a nod to acquire with the once a group gets too big, it can't be absorbed.
Yeah, but you want to absorb things. But the tile that connects the two, they have to be different sizes before Yeah. Yeah. I see those little connections. I I prefer it I think at two because it feels like a nice back and forth while with three there can be that possibility of someone getting squished out.
Mhm. And with four you definitely kind of have to team. Oh, that person's running ahead. Let's, you know, kind of pull them back a little bit and then try to shift and pull back the person who then is pulling ahead. Um, yeah, I think I I like it at two the most, I would say. and it's more funny and chaotic with the the more players you add in.
Yeah, I'm I'm another one that likes it at two. Um you mentioned probably my least favorite aspect of the game. um is that while the rules are relatively simple um the the merging I think is the least intuitive part because intuitively in my mind at least and maybe not everyone's mind works like this if you're merging kind of two things together right and you're adding a piece that would take you above the one that you're kind of conquering that makes sense but you have to have more pieces than the other side before you add the connecting piece. To me, that's counterintuitive. I know it's a small thing, but it bothers me. So, I did want to point that out.
Ladies, though, so that's why it doesn't bother me because it's the same rule there.
It is.
It is. Yeah. I didn't love it there either, to be honest with you.
I think it serves it well here, though, so that there's not constant takeovers. Uh, but yeah, overall, I think it's a really smooth and and solid game. I like that. Yeah, areas can get large enough you can double up and the neutral places on the on the board that you can take over if you have the majorities there. It leads to a lot of really good Yeah. Just good strategic play.
Yeah. And I also like that the
the goal is very simple. Get rid of your gazeos. That's it. And that's just an easy thing to teach for me. This is a solid 7.5 um in it. It's easy to play. It's quick. I like it best. Two to two players. Um, I don't care that there's not a theme. It's a nice abstract that's in your face, but also feels like a tugof-war, so it doesn't ever feel too mean.
Yeah, this is a really good game. Uh, I am coming just a bit higher at an eight. I think it's solid. I really do prefer it to, and I like that once you teach a few basic things, you just kind of keep coming back to I like playing this one back to back a few times, especially. I think that's kind of where it's most satisfying. So, yeah, it's a it's an eight for me.
Chin was a seven for me. This is an eight because I think that the the the tile distribution is a huge element. Um and the production is nicer uh as well. And so um that's enough to get it to an eight for me. Yeah, just another rockolid design by um Kitio who does abstracts quite well. All right, Gingham here. This is a a game that is about picnics and ants and then completely just gives up on that theme almost immediately. I you are going out and collecting stuff, but then you also form a ring of ants around it to protect it, but another ant can be like, "Excuse me, can you move?" And you're like, "Yeah, okay." And then you get out of the way.
I And the biggest the biggest thing is I don't know. No ad has got to the stitching up wanket and was like,
"Well, that's about the farthest we can go." But that's fine. I mean, it I I feel like the theme might have been added afterwards. Where I do run into an issue though is I that stitch to me I I don't know how to explain it because I can't say I don't I don't I don't like it, but I don't have a strong reason for it other than it just feels it feels out of place. I get what it is. The longest the row is, the more places you have to put it in, but that also means you'll go last when you flip to the other side. Um but I I don't know. But it it's it I'm playing on half a board, then I go play on the other half of the board, then I play on the other half, then I go play on the other half. I don't I don't find that part to be very interesting.
I really like it because it is the source of that tension. The exact mechanism that you're describing, the you can go first, but you have one place to place onto. I wonder where you're going to go. But you might choose to go first because this does the king domino or flororiferous type turn order thing where going earlier having fewer options means that you get to to set the priority for next turn quicker. You also if you go first get to choose which of the three sides you'll place onto next. So there's a lot riding on going earlier. And so there's a little push your luck of like I don't want to go in the very front space. I'll go on one like the second or third maybe and hope no one cuts me off ahead. So, I don't I I don't have a thematic explanation for the stitch in the middle of the cloth, but uh I tremendously like that.
I'm making fun of I don't really care. Sure. You know, but about the theming,
but no, you you don't like it mechanically. I do.
Yeah.
Well, if you want to go thematically, you just instead of saying it's a stitch, say it's a line of salt that is across the uh the blanket because I think Don't they say that ants?
Mike, I don't think it's ants.
I'm going to say it's ants. So, yeah. Uh, I actually that's my favorite element of the game is the turn order. And so the stitch I guess does play into that. It doesn't bother me. The only element of the stitch that bothers me. I guess I'm being really weird about small exceptions to rules today because this bothers me about this game is that when you have a special power that lets you move an ant instead of placing an ant, you can't move one that's beyond the stitch. Why? Because it has to be that way. Maybe. I don't know. That bothers me again because it's a game I guess this is another part is that it's a game that is relatively simple to explain except that I feel like there are certain elements that just don't seem to have again an intuitive nature to them like um I think it's a game that takes several plays to try to kind of figure out okay so why does it why are we moving when we're connecting why are Why is the moving a thing? Okay, so you're because you can create these things and it's easier here to surround it and harder there.
Yes, it's clever, right? It's a clever idea, but does it I'm I'm really having a hard time articulating it. Does it really serve the game enough for all of these little things that are going on? Because it it feels like it should be a simpler game to me than it is. Maybe that's the way I should put it. It feels like it should be simpler than it is because this is a game that again, even more so than in Gazebo, I prefer two players. Um, I don't like playing it at four. I I it it it gets into kind of devolving of so [snorts] many people kind of like bumping and moving and this and that and it just kind of to to the it gets to the point where it's like, oh, somebody didn't notice this big move because there's so many other things going on on the board and it allowed him to hit that point trigger and and end the game. Um I feel like it slogs at anything really beyond two. Three is not as bad, but this to me is a solid two player game.
three and four. It It feels a little bit bloated uh for what it is, right? It It's not a difficult game. It's not a complicated game, but it feels like it's more than it should be.
I like it at all. The player counts, but I will say I agree with Mike's I I agree with your point that it feels like it should be a simpler game than it is. It feels like the scoring should be simpler to explain than it is because what you're doing every turn is so simple. And to be perfectly clear, it's okay. That it is not what I was kind of expecting it to be. But I do have that issue where every time I teach it, I kind of have to go over the scoring again, I have to reread it to make sure I'm going to teach the right parts. When does it move? When do you put the cap piece on? How many points does it count? If you take over a control that someone already put their cap piece on, you count it and then you put yours on, but you do or don't include your own plus theirs plus the stack. you know, there's just like a little bit of those nuances. I think that you said Mike is a good word is it's it's a little less intuitive than it should be because for some reason it feels like it's going to be a much lighter, more approachable game than it is. But I'm okay with with what it is at the end of the day.
Yeah. I don't know for I get that. I I think what Mike said resonates with me. The game is very clever, but I don't know that it makes it fun for me. I I'm even stronger. If you want to play this with four, it's abysmal. I think it's the worst. Like, oh, it's just so chaotic. I I don't feel like I can do any strategy. I'm just waiting for my turn and Okay. Oh, well, you did that and you did that and you did that. I can replace one ant, I guess. And the sugar cube thing is even worse because it's a cool idea, but uh I'm going to do that special ability. Oh, you you did and now it costs three. Well, never mind then. And it just that feels random. Now, again, I suspect, and I'm not going to judge the whole game based on that cuz I want to go down to two players, and I feel like it should be a two-player game, but I don't even like it at two.
So, I don't hate it as much, but I'm giving it a five. I don't like the hidden scoring. I don't know what the point of that is at all. Why are we hiding the scoring?
Because Because that is the endgame trigger. So, you're not
Do I have to have a memory element now thrown in?
I just choose not to remember. I go, I got to score points. Okay, fine. But again, you would have to you would have to Anyway, I don't like that. I don't like the the stitch. I don't like the weird connection rules that you have to follow because you have to connect the closest one and sometimes that can be changed or configured and it's area control, but it's shifting. Maybe it's a good game, but it's definitely not for me. Five out of 10.
Mike, I'm curious. I think you might be next highest score if I
Yeah, pro probably. Um, I I feel like I'm kind of You both are making points that are compelling to me and that I resonate with one that you said, Tom, it feels a little more clever than fun for me. I resonate with that. And the thing I resonate with, Chris, is the fact that that doesn't mean that that's not what this game could or should be. Um, I just think, not quite as much as Utah, Tom, but this is is just kind of not what I'm looking for in this type of an abstract game. It's a little bit more than I want. It's a little bit more convoluted than I feel like it should be based on the experience that I'm having and and especially at higher player counts. So, I'm a little bit higher. I'm a six. I don't think it's a bad game mechanically. I think it's very clever and I think it's going to appeal to certain abstract gamers very highly, but I'm not quite that type of an abstract gamer. So, a six for me.
And I'm a bit high. I'm definitely higher. I'm at 7.5. I like this game and I I want to continue to come back to it and play it, especially with the same group because I don't necessarily like teaching and clarifying all the scoring rules as they were a bit unintuitive. And as Mike uh alluded to, um there's definitely a skill gap. You know, brand new players or people who have played it once versus players who have played it multiple times, they're [snorts] going to have a harder time seeing where to stop important moves. I think that skill gap is really pronounced in this game. Uh that being said, I still have fun with it and I it it gives me the feels uh similar feeling to one of my favorite games, Hanza Tatonica, with that bumping out other players pieces, which feels great, but then they get to place it anywhere, even beyond the stitch, which is a small rule, you know, niggle kind of a thing, right? Where you're like, "Oh, okay. Hold on. When can you when can't you?" Stuff like that. But it does I all of those rules do make the game strong for me. I think of it less as an abstract and more of a Euro game in the vein of Haunted Tatonica, but uh I I I like it, but definitely it's a a little notch down because of those issues that I have. So 7.5.
Well, there you go, folks. That's Gingham and Gazebo. Uh two-wing games. Check them out. I'm Tom Vassel.
I'm Chris Ye.
And I'm Mike Delisio. And we want to say thanks to some of our Game Pound baggers. Thank you to Graham, Julie, Haley, and Isaiah from Missaga, Canada. To Ricky, Rick ridiculous Stribel, and Scott Mocker. Thank you all for supporting the show, and thank you all for watching. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. So, if you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games. We do top 10s. We play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.