Skip to main content
Loading video...

Saint Petersburg (2nd Edition) Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 19:20

hey everyone today i'm taking a look at saint petersburg which is a board game that dates all the way back to 2014. this is the second edition of the game it accommodates two to five players and takes around an hour to play on average the idea of saying petersburg is that we're trying to build up a tableau or engine of cards to get as many victory points as we can before i get into the review of st petersburg i want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kianda.co.uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk and if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but let's get into st petersburg okay so a game of st petersburg is going to look like this when it's set up where you have the main board here and on this board you're going to have five different decks of cards each relating to a different phase in the game so you've got the workers deck here you've got the merchants you've got the builders you've got the nobles and you have these exchange cards as well which consists of all the different types now you're also going to have these two rows of cards which you can openly draft from the first of which is going to consist of the cards that have just come out but later in the game some cards might get neglected and shift down to the bottom row here where you can purchase them at a discount of one now in the second edition of st petersburg you're also going to have this merchant's track here which you are trying to climb to get victory points so the highest player is going to get x amount of victory points and the second player is going to get the next amount and as the game goes on you're going to use these tokens to increase um the points that they dish

out also you're going to have these tokens here which are divided out at the start of the game depending on the player count so you're going to divide those up as equally as you can and that is going to mean that whoever owns these specific tokens is going to be the first player in each of those specific phases so the objective of this game is to get as many victory points as you can by the time that one of these five decks is exhausted and on each player's turn you're gonna have the option of taking one of four possible actions the first of which is to buy one of these cards by paying the top left-hand value here the second of which is to reserve a card into your hand so that only you can buy it the third option is to purchase that card you've reserved and the fourth action is to pass and play will continue taking one of those four actions until each player has passed in a row so one of the key talking points in st petersburg is how the game flows and how each of these phases are resolved because what you're going to do is that in order you're going to play through each of these phases um i.e drawing um 10 of these green cards to start with these worker cards until the display is full here and then in turn taking those actions till everyone has passed in a row and then after that all the worker cards are going to pay out either points or money and then it's going to go on to the um the merchant space and again you're going to take um keep taking turns to everyone passes in a row then all the yellow cards are going to pay out then you've got the blue face again keep buying cards or you know reserving cards or playing them until everyone passes and then all the

blue cards are going to pay out so it's quite a methodical way in the way that these cards are resolved but let's have a look at what you're actually trying to do and aim towards so essentially each of these decks work in a very slightly different way and you're basically building up two or three types of currencies um throughout the game the first of which is going to be money itself so all these worker cards are going to offer you a certain amount of money so let's just say my turn i ended up buying this lumberjack here by paying three i'm gonna add them to my tableau in front of me and i'm also gonna get a discount of one coin for every identical card that i have so i'd actually only have to pay two for this lumberjack because i already have one and again we're going to keep taking those turns so that everyone passes then all these green cards are going to pay out so i'd eventually get a 9 a 9 pound cash injection which is going to be quite nice so once that green phase is resolved you're going to go on to the next deck here and you're going to replenish the tableau i'm refilling any spaces that were grabbed from the previous round with the next deck of cards you can see here i've added five yellow market cards to the tableau and these ones offer you money just as the green ones do but they also allow you to climb the market track here so let's just say i ended up purchasing this um fish card here by paying five again getting any discounts if i had duplicate cards and then i'd move one uh represented by this symbol up that fish track here like so and again you're gonna keep taking turns until nobody wants to buy any more cars

and you can buy previous um neglected cars if you want to and after that's done you're going to take your output from the money from the yellow cards and also you're going to score each of these different um goods and where you are on the track so you know at the moment only um only the yellow player has climbed up on the fish track so they would get one point like so but once that's done you're going to remove that token so next time the um points are going to increase and just like before once you've finished with the merchant phase you're going to go on to the building phase here you're going to replenish the tableau back up to 10 cards and then you're going to go again now the blue cards the building phases here are always going to offer you victory points or some way of generating victory points you can see here by spending eight by buying this customs house at the end of the blue phase i'm going to get two victory points or you might get certain different ones like this like this pub here where you can end up spending money up to five times to get up to five victory points the next deck these noble cards are generally more expensive and they offer you a mix of income of money and victory points but they also offer you end game scoring points based on this sliding scale down here so if you have say nine unique nobles by the end of the game you're going to get a massive 45 victory points now the final deck here these exchange cards are going to be a mixture of all the existing cards however these do work in a slightly different way so you can see here all these cards are squared off in one of these boxes and what that means is that these have to replace an existing card by paying the

difference so let's just say i wanted to buy this winter palace here i could do that but what i'll do is i would pay the difference between this one and the a card i've already got in my tableau of the same color so this customs house is a value eight this is a value 19 which is a difference of 11 so i'd only have to spend 11 money in order to replace this customs house with this winter palace which is always going to be an improvement because now this is going to offer me five victory points and two pounds income and another difference with these exchange cards is that they do not pay out at the end of the phase so all the other ones again you're gonna spend your turns buying reserving whatever and then getting the income from those cards but these exchange ones you do not do that and that is essentially how the game is going to work but once you've done all of the phases any existing cards in the tableau are going to slide down to the next row to make them one cheaper in the next round and if they still they're lingering after that they're just going to get wiped off the board also at the end of the game you're going to get a number of victory points based on money you have left over so for every 10 coins you have you're going to get another victory point but also for any reserved card you have in your hand you're going to lose 5 victory points if you haven't built them now something i should mention is that this second edition of st petersburg does come with a variety of modules to change the gameplay slightly um i am quite picky with what i've added into the game here but i think the first couple of modules um this banquet module and this one here this um in good company module i would

always include those ones because they're simply going to add more cards to these decks and they do slightly different things than the standard ones now this marker here is also an option to play with because the original didn't have this market um and again much like the other modules i would always include to play this one because it doesn't really add much bloat or any overhead okay so let's get some thoughts on saint petersburg so i have to say after reading the rule book for the first time i was a little bit concerned as to where the gameplay would come from here and the main kind of catalyst for my concern was the fact that there is only really two types of currency that you are managing in your tableau and in your engine i was kind of concerned that it wasn't going to be enough for me to stick my teeth into there wasn't going to be enough synergy between the two or you know you'd need more in order to get a more interesting engine going however you do start to understand how the flow and pace of the game really do affect the overall experience and the gameplay now the key to this game is balancing your income of money with your income of victory points which might seem fairly obvious but there is different routes you can divert down regarding that so of course you want to start spending money to buy new cards which can actually generate you more money as the game goes on and let you buy the more powerful more significant cars that will give you a bigger income but getting points on your tableau early is important because it gives you more opportunities to you know extract points from them because again at the end of each of those phases you are going to get those points so even if you invest in you know a small amount of points early you know if you do it right right

from the get-go that is going to trigger a lot of times and could potentially build up a lot of points by the end and i really want to stress how much this phase structure affects the game because this really does play a huge factor in the cash flow and the management of your funds because generally you'll get a huge chunk of cash in the worker phase here from you know from the um engine of cards that you've built up and this will get huge by the end of the game however you do need to use that money quite carefully to last you throughout all of the other phases and it's so easy to get sucked into a bunch of you know inviting cards that come out because you might want to use it to you know spam up the track or you know do do other things or even just buying points but generally you'll find yourself backed into a corner by the end of these phases here you've spent all your cash you've not got much other cash until it gets back round to the worker phase to get your you know to replenish your funds and it will leave you out of pocket for the nobles and the exchange cards so good i love how you've got to manage your funds and just resist at times and sit back and think you know what who knows what's coming out next i might need to spend that money more sensibly and i might get more value from it in upcoming phases i also really enjoy the way that the cards come out onto this the display because it is only ever replenished up to 10 cards and what that means is that if nobody is really buying anything for the first few phases then these aren't even gonna come out in the first place because there's no room for them to come out on so again balancing your funds is so important

because you want to spend it while you have it but you do want to hold some back but if you hold too much back then the new cards from this kind of end of the um of the phases here aren't even going to come out in the first place i also enjoy the very simple discount system here they're buying duplicate cards some you know exact identical cards always going to be one cheaper the next time but then two cheaper and three cheaper and that stacks very nicely and you know the additional um thread of everything slipping down and giving you a further discount here i find these exchange cards really interesting because you do actually need an existing card to build on top of but more importantly than that i love the way that these have a delayed payoff because this is again this is the only phase here that doesn't offer an instant payout and if you end up spending a ton of cash here on this card and you replace say a noble card you're not going to get the dividends from that until it gets all the way back around the other phases back to the nobles i think that four action system is fantastic it makes the game an absolute breeze to explain you know buy a card reserve a card play a reserved card or pass and the way that that reserve system works as well is is fantastic because it it kind of gives you a little bit of leeway and a little bit of mitigation to get around your cash flow issues so if there's a card you really want but you just haven't got the money right now you can spend your turn to take it for your personal supply ready to be bought later but as the game goes on you'll start getting invited by new cards and sometimes you'll forget about the ones you've already reserved and this added pressure of losing five points if you do not end up buying those cards in your hand just adds more weight

to that decision i think i mentioned earlier that i will always play with this market system i do think this adds a lot to the game uh even though on or at face value it does seem like a very simple you know track climbing exercise and yes it is that but the way that the drafting works in partnership with this um adds more meat to the decision because you know you are going to have to spend money to climb these tracks it adds a good level of player interaction as you're trying to you know be or at least lead the races here and if you really do run away with it as the game goes on you can start generating a hell of a lot of points for kind of monopolizing this part of the game now i've also brought out some other cards here that work in a slightly different way than the more basic ones i've already shown you and some of these are from one of the expansion modules but as i said i would always add these into the deck so these purpley cards here um you actually have to spend your turn to take them from the board and in a future turn you can play them from your hand but they work in really interesting ways like this money collector here actually means that you can you spend your time to take it but in a future town you can buy a card for half the amount of price but you don't get the victory points from them but it gives you a great way to basically get free money these orange cards here are great they allow you to really quickly climb up one of the resource tracks so you can see this fish one here lets me got four up the fish track like this and what that means is that yeah i'm gonna be in really good footing to win that every single round but it comes with a cost where you have to pay the higher amount of the victory points here but in money each time to keep hold

of that card and as soon as you forget um as soon as you relinquish that you're going to slip back down the track so you've got to you know really weigh up is it going to be worth it to you the potemkin village ones are also interesting because you buy them for really cheap but you want to be aiming to replace them with those exchange cards um but you exchange them with a higher value meaning that the difference is going to get squeezed and make it much more affordable for you the black marker here one lets you go through discard piles the um the golden donkey just lets you take money from um from the supply that will give you a double turn uh you've got the um like improved workers here this one has all the different symbols on them and the sar superstar actually lets you get discounts on other cards as you go out throughout the game and you've got this chap here he might look a bit familiar and he offers you um coins based on how many green cards you have st petersburg plays in around an hour which i think is absolutely fantastic and again it offers a lot of choice and a lot of depth for that amount of time the game flow is really nice and the way the game arcs is also decent because you end up building a massive tableau of cards you're gonna have probably triple or quadruple this amount by the end of the game um and you know when it gets to certain phases and you've invested loads and say blue cards you can really fly up that score track i've already mentioned the competition that stems from the track climbing in very simple stuff but it does add a lot of interaction to the game you want to making sure you're always you know a leg up on your opponent to get those maximum

points there and that can be significant but generally just the competition to get to the cards you want is there what are you going to prioritize and what is going to be best for you what you need to get fast and before somebody else grabs it from you are you going to hold back and let someone buy cards that you wanted just so you can buy stuff later but yeah this open draft works great and just a general you know generally good way of embedding player interaction into the game where everything is so inviting i also feel the game scales very well and i think it's nice to have that third player or so um just for the track climbing exercise but i still think even in a two-player game you have a bunch of other stuff to focus on um in order to build your engine up and you're mainly going to be focusing on what you're doing um but yeah i've got no issue with playing this at any single player account i'd even stretch playing it at five players which is quite a rare thing for me to say when it comes to euro games of this nature i think the production for st petersburg is a bit of a mixed bag now the generally the production and the layout of the board etc is more of a minimalist approach it's pretty much just a placeholder for all the different cards and things um but i do like the way that the iconography is clear and there's no no there's no fiddliness on the ball there's no kind of um no it's not too busy that's what i'm trying to say now what i don't like is the way that some of these characters look they just look a bit weird as if their faces have been kind of superimposed on these bodies but i kind of quite find it quite funny and it kind of brings me back to a time when people didn't really care about the way that these euro games looked so you know i

think that's going to turn some people off but for me it doesn't i think it's again i think it's quite funny um also a negative is that it does come with paper money unfortunately which isn't the best to handle but generally speaking i'm not i'm not unhappy with the production the cards are even of a linen finish so again quite nice to handle and they're gonna stand up to repeated place okay so let's get into my final thoughts on st petersburg so again i want to stress after reading the rule book here i was really having some concerns about this game being it's going to be too light it's going to feel a bit dated and because engine building has really taken off since um this game came out it's a big factor in a lot of modern board games now especially of the euro variety pretty much every euro game has some degree or element of tableau building or engine building and i have to say i was so wrong and i'm glad to say i was wrong on my concerns about this game because this is certainly one of those games that you need to play to understand how much this flow of resources matters um so i love the way it's passed just two simple currencies you know you could add the third one in with the market which i always would do but still even even with the market it's a very simple system just balancing those three things wanting to have money so you can buy new cars potentially buy more money but what use is money if you do not have a points engine so i love that i love that churning system and it feels really satisfying when it gets to your your best line of cards here and you get a huge payout there's some very clever little design points here you know the way the um the cards refill back up the discount system

again the cash flow it all comes together so wonderfully and it feels like a classic to me and i was very impressed by this one it's breezy but it's still thinky it's satisfying you can build a great engine and it's just a hell of a lot of fun and you know kind of a hark back to an older classic euro style game that you can get played in an hour which i think is quite remarkable so sadly i think this game is actually really hard to get a copy of and i'm really fortunate to have a copy because i've been after this one for a long long time and i'm glad i kind of persisted and managed to track the copy down because this one is not going anywhere from my collection if i want to play a fun but interesting engine builder tableau builder then this is going to be right at the top of that genre so yeah really couldn't recommend st petersburg enough i'm sure one day it will get a reprint or be more widely available because this one is certainly worthy of a shield of quality and you know what i even think that in the years to come this has a lot of potential to climb up my personal rankings because i think it is so beautifully executed

Progress saved