Beyond Solitaire Podcast 151: Joe Dewhurst on Developing Heavy Games
Transcript
it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as they're up to some amazing things their next game hydrologic cycle is currently on Kickstarter and you should absolutely go and check it out clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con the next course Jason Fury's crowdfunding with confidence starts on May 6th and we'll teach you all about board games and crowdfunding go check it out and I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com onol thanks to listeners like you I've been able to keep upgrading my equipment subscribing to streamyard and more uh but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is L Davidson from beond soliter and this week on the Pod I'm here with a very special guest this is Joe Dost designer and developer of many games for many companies uh how you doing Joe Hi l I'm doing really great uh it's very nice to be a to share with you today yes awesome um so for people who don't uh know you and your work uh can you give us a sense of who you're working for and what you're doing so I my my main work is as a Bard game developer and I do a lot of that with GMT games at the moment but I'm also developing a few games for other companies um and you know interested in looking at other other projects um I also am a game designer um I have two games on gmts p500 at the moment and various other games at stages of development as I'm sure you understand as well uh many things at once it's the way designers work indeed uh what are your games that
are mp500 right now so I have a game called the pure land which is going to be Volume 14 and the coin series um which is a um game it's it's a four player game set in uh 15th century Japan so the start of um what's called the Waring States period but this is the end of it that people don't don't tend to know so well um so it's about the collapse of the the mirachi shogunate um into a kind of Civil War status and also about um social conflicts of time so about uh peasants and uh kind of lower lower ranking Nobles and also um the emerging Buddhist uh sect the ioii who are kind of kind of radical um anti-establishment uh sect so these kinds of things um that yeah that's on p500 at the moment and hopefully we'll be moving into final stages of development for that later this year it's been qu quite a long time just because there's been lots of other coin volumes to get out of the way first um and I also have a an expansion for Cuba lib so coin again um on p500 called resisting Revolution um and that is a kind of uh um expansion consisting of several different components so the main game covers the period immediately after Batista's fall so from 1959 to 1962 so up to the Cuban Missile Crisis and is about the kind of cons consolidation of C's regime internal dissidence and external trouble from the US um the involvement of the Soviet Union this kind of thing that that's a four player kind of squl expansion um but I also have included in that a three-player
variant game for the original which kind of explores some different ways of thinking about the Cuban Revolution um and some some some new event cards for that uh and a a very small two-player game on on the Bay of Pigs which was actually how I first started working on this expansion so many years ago now me and a friend sha AEF almost is just a a kind of game Jam or kind of fun project um you know wanted to come up with this variant using the existing Cub Libra components and I thought why not also put this into the expansion so it's you know it's just a little kind of maybe half hour 45 minute you play a game quick playing thing excellent those are very different historical periods um would you say that you have a broad interest or was there a connection somewhere there is a connection the connection broadly is um social unrest and and peasant unrest in particular so a major aspect of a pure land is the involvement of these neutral peasant pieces which can be kind of used and misused by different factions um and they break out into into peasant Revolt sometimes and something like the Cuban Revolution I think in in many ways can also be thought of as a peasant Revolt there there's a major peasant Revolt component although also Urban unrest um and this is something which I'm I'm really interested in so particularly uh you know different kinds of lower class Revolt particularly peasant revolts in in different parts of the world um also Urban unrest um you know other games I'm working on for instance is something to do with the the minor strike in the UK which you might think of again as a very different kind of topic but it's this kind of urban unrest social unrest topic so that that's my my broad interest I would say
yeah that's really interesting and then I take it so and all of your designs so far have been coin uh yeah they have are kind of riffing on that system um I'm you know I'm hoping to move beyond that and explore some different things so you know I worked a lot on coin also my development work and had lots of conversations with other coin designers about about the the limits of the system um and we're now starting to think about ways to do things a bit differently maybe move in different directions um but I I still really love the core of the coin system I think it's very very flexible and very kind of fun to play while also showing you interesting stuff about history so would you call yourself a designer or a developer first um nowadays a developer so I I first started with design um and I still enjoy design and want to be doing some design um but I've you know since I've got into development that's become my main source of income and I also think I'm actually more uh more inclined towards development maybe more you know better suited to it maybe even just better at it full stop um so that that's probably my my primary identity these days um although the two things blur together very closely so you know some designers who I work with as a developer would would almost prefer to call me a Cod designer and it's a very close kind of working uh interaction in in those cases um but there's other there's other aspects to being a developer which I also uh enjoy doing you know like editing and um uh organizing you know kind kind of project management which lots of designers aren't very good at and I think I am quite good at so that
that's a kind of different skill set that I have to offer and enjoy doing yeah actually kind of leads into something I wanted to ask which is what are the essential differences you see between the skill sets of a very good designer and the skill sets of a very good developer yeah so um I mean there's there's there's different aspects to both of them but you know to be a designer you need to have you need to have some some really good Big Ideas some really interesting new ideas about about what to do with a game um you maybe also need to do a lot of historical research if you're a war game designer or a historical game designer um and you need to um have some kind of some some interesting or solidas about how to combine these historical themes with mechanics and how to put that together um to some extent you maybe need to be kind of a big a big picture Blue Sky thinker for that although some designers are much more detail Focus as well um whereas for the development you don't necessarily need to have done the research or come up with the ideas yourself but you need to be uh good at um refining those ideas you know making sure that they really fit together properly uh making sure it's all clear making sure it all works well um you know working on balance so there's lots of things here which are perhaps more detail oriented and certainly more oriented at getting the project finished um so I mean I I when I'm explaining the job to people I describe it as being closest probably to being an editor for books um but it's a little bit more than that uh in at least some of the roles I have there's there's almost a kind of more project management
role as well so you're you're overseeing the whole project you're communicating with lot different people like artists and like product managers um and this kind of stuff to work out what components should be used what they should look like how many we need you know there there's all these little bits which are part of the job um and you know some some designers could do that themselves and I do that myself for my own games largely um but you you don't necessarily want designers to be doing that because they might not always be the best people to do that they might not know all the details of these things um so that's the kind of nitty-gritty of it the bit where it gets closer to design is where you're working with the designer to um you know iterate on certain certain mechanisms and you know I might have some ideas how to solve a problem the designer has so that that's a lot closer to design but you're kind of bouncing ideas off of each other for that b so how did you get started in development I mean I I I feel like people design a game they go to a convention they pitch it maybe as like a very base form of getting into design but how do you get into development yeah good good question um I got into development through play testing and I got into play testing through through design so you know I've been working on this coin design with cure land and Jason KY at GMT saw so I didn't even pitch it which is cool i' just been like posting some pictures of my you know fan design I was working on and then he approached me and said we're interested in this um looks pretty good so yeah we started getting top 500 um you know having chatted to Jason I then started doing some some some play testing uh work so on all of saon in particular which is a sequel to another
coin game um and the way I liked it I was so annoying as a play tester that Jason decided he should hire me as a developer to you know better direct my my irritating uh you know overly focused uh skills so with with for of saon there used to be a victory condition where if uh the North Vietnamese conquered saon um they could just win just like that and I I think I must have done that you know 10 maybe 20 times just over and over again just to show that it was a bit broken as as as an objective and you know it it it walked the game in really bad ways um and those kinds of skills I think people like uh and then wanted to pick on and actually what happened is I I asked Jason how how he got into this work he's the head of development of GMT games and he said well we're actually looking to hire someone else to work on it and you'd be great so come and do the job so really I just locked into it but for anyone interested in in development I I'd say get into play testing um you know what do do a lot of that and then um see see where that takes you makes sense so it sounds like you're very good at pushing finding pressure points in games finding where things kind of twist out of shape how do you do I guess the soft side of development work where you have to communicate all that with a designer like what kind of range of relationship desires have you had and how do you I mean I guess you're kind of going from their baby to like our baby and you know how do you finesse that so that's
an interesting question and it really varies a lot depending on the kind kind of relationship I have so with you know Fred SEL or Steph razas I'm I'm also quite good friends with them and we work very closely through all stages of the design whereas uh for some some designs where I maybe never develop the the the designer less well I might come into it at a a later stage and really just help out with the the play testing once it's more more public and uh work on refining things there um so you know how I how I interact with each of these designers will depend on um how they are as people so there there's actually a large people management skill to it too I think um so for instance some designers might not react well to certain kinds of feedback from testers and it can be useful uh in at least some cases for me to be a kind of um not not a barrier but a kind of communication bridge between testers and the designer to to repackage the feedback and say you know here are here are a bundle of issues for testers they've been having they've got these ideas how to fix it but we should probably ignore those here are my ideas to how we can fix it or you know here's the general thing they've been feeling this this doesn't mean they hate the game it just means there maybe these issues we could work on so there's a lot of um translation I would say from the testers to the designer and then also from the designer to the to the artists to the layout people um so I I know how to describe how things should look in a way that will work well for a certain artist whereas um for a designer who doesn't work hasn't worked with that artist before there could be a potential for for miscommunication there so
there's there's a lot of a lot of that kind of stuff going on as well nice how many game does how many development projects do you work on at the same time uh a lot a lot um so maybe so certainly more than 10 right now um some somewhere between 10 and 20 for are at various different stages of um of of the process so some of them there'll be more or less work to do so I've maybe only got three or four like really actively in in in play testing right now some might be in a in more of a kind of predevelopment stage so where you're where you're doing some work with a designer before you begin wider play testing and and some of them we've we've really finished for play testing and we're just working on uh making sure the rules are really clear preparing the uh learn to play materials to to explain the game to people and then working with with the art stages um so while you know while 10 plus projects might seem like a lot often what I'm doing there is sending something off to uh the artist or to an editor such as yourself in some cases um and then leaving that with them for you know one week two weeks even while they while they work on it so there's there's again that that's where the kind the kind of project management thing comes in and and the time management as well so I have to be working out what to prioritize and what to shuffle around um you know across quite a large number of projects what about play testers are you the one who gathers them are you presented like with a list of people to talk to and are you the person who directly gets feedback from play testers uh yeah yeah pretty much yes to those um depending on the company there
might be a different kind of process so Mt we often send out calls for play testers in the monthly newsletter which is you know a super helpful way to to get lots of people for for a game uh recently we actually got uh at least 70 signups on that which which is loads for for this kind of scale of games um and uh you know for other companies I might use other kinds of roots to recruit those um and and I'm then normally the one primarily communicating with them so I'll I'll I'll send them some information about what what we're looking for um sometimes I'll use kind of feedback forms with certain quantitative data so scores and outcomes and things um and then I'll I'll normally be be talking with them so answering questions they have and taking notes on the kinds of questions they have which is often a really useful thing you know what what's unclear to them um and also trying to build a bit of a community there because it's it's nice I think for play testers to get to know some other testers and you can really um build up some kind of interesting uh friendships even uh you know there's there's testers I've worked with on several different games and I know they're good so I can invite them back for for future games that's kind of a nice nice thing to have so you're you're a heavy game guy uh in terms of uh what I see you talking about what you seem to be developing um so when you are dealing with games that are very long to have big scenarios that are kind of chunky how do you make sure that you're giving enough attention to each scenario or do you and then also how do you hold play testers accountable for that or assess data from people who
would have had to put in a lot of time to fully test something out no that that's a great question so you know the smaller two-player games are often much much easier to test so a two-player game which you can play in an hour or two hours you can get lots of iterations of um a longer two-player game isn't isn't so bad either because it's much easier to pair up two players to play for a game um the longer you know four or five or six player games like like some of the coin games are much more challenging to test in a in a kind of rigorous way because it can just just take a long time to sit down and do that um so there there's a couple of well there's there's a few things to say um you know firstly myself and the designer maybe some some close uh early um people working on the game with them will will tend to play these quite quite a lot together just to get a general sense of this um that that's useful to get you know lots of lots of repetition but can be quite vulnerable to um you know you know a kind of group thing there can be things that we miss so so it's important to do wider testing for that um for The Wider testing I tend to think of there being two different kinds of testers so you know when we had this you know 70 plus sign up for instance I I won't expect most of those to stick around for that long necessarily so the the initial batch of you know a large number 50 to 100 even testers I'm looking more for General feedback on uh you know Clarity whether their first gamees enjoyable whether there are things they they don't like about it um you know just just kind of generally First Impressions and that that's really valuable but then out of out of that maybe only 10% will stick around long term um and and what I'm
looking for there is a core group of maybe five to 10 people who can play the game uh multiple times with each other develop kind of different strategies and try different strategies um and again like that that's that's too small a sample for kind of proper rigor in a sense but it it's it's enough of a sample that you can test these longer scenarios and get and get a good amount of feedback on them um now it's I mean for for a game with with multiple long scenarios it's it's just going to be hard to do a lot of very rigorous testing on those and some times there might be some imbalances um the good news is that in games with more than two players a lot of those imbalances can be self-correcting so the games I work on tend to be quite High interaction so if if you have a four player game with high interaction um it it doesn't actually matter very much if if one one faction or one player position is is a bit more powerful because they'll be naturally reigned in by by the other players and that that might even be an intended part of the game so something like people power um a fre player game on the Philippine EDSA Revolution um you know intentionally has a government player in in a in a stronger position than the other two so they need to work together there um and again that that needs quite a lot of testing to get right but there there is a kind of inbuilt self-correction which you don't have in a two-player game so two-player games with long scenarios you know easier to get people to sit down and test but harder to get right and and you do need to tweak things more there um but so yeah I mean that's that's just to say very different kinds of strategies we use and it's hard to get exactly right with you know the time and the number of testers that that we have sometimes these games
so when something um is maybe not going totally right or uh if you think that you have a fix who gets the ultimate say in how you move forward between designer and developer because I mean the designer is clearly the person whose name is gonna go in the box but it's also your job to make sure that a game isn't G to like blow up when it hits Bor geek yeah that's that's a very interesting question um again like I said a few times it depends on the designer and my my relationship with them so some designers I might say here's a problem here's my solution and they'll say sure give it a go other designers might want to really be quite closely involved in getting that right other designers at the start might say actually I'm I'm I'm done with this more or less you can you can figure it out and that that happens sometimes and that's okay you know then it's up up to me to work out how to solve that and you know I'll I'll clear it with them in the end um even when the designer wants to be involved I I might try a few things myself before taking them some ideas or you know try a few things with some testers say you know let's try this let's try that um and and then take it to them um in in most cases you know you're you're going to want the designer to have have some say or some involvement in that um and and often they might have a better idea of how to fix it too um but uh yeah in terms of a final sign off that that's interesting and I think it's kind of a publisher uh philosopher DEC um philosophy decision in a way so you know some Publishers might want to take personal ownership of the final product and how it plays and so on um some Publishers and I think J T bit like this are happier to let the designer kind of
take the Reigns and take the lead on that and that isn't to say that they abandon the designer they're gonna they're gonna have somebody like like me helping out with that um and giving some advice but it's it's more of a kind of Auto directed project where where you'll you'll allow a designer to to to make the game that they want to make and that's that's on the designer to some extent and what what what we're doing then is is providing a platform for the for the designer to to bring that game to the world um now you know if if if the game was just absolutely terrible and there were huge problems with it then we'd have to intervene and try to fix it but there's there's some leeway I think for saying this isn't um exactly how I would have done it but this is how a designer wants to do it that's actually a really important thing as a developer so there you know if if you're also a designer like I am there can be a tendency to to want to kind of remake something yourself but but you need to you need to stop yourself if you feel that happening you need to say actually what what I need to do is work out what game the designer wants to make work out how to make that happen um so I'll I'll often go to a designer and say you know this is something the players are experiencing um it's negative for these reasons but I can see why you might have wanted to do that is that really what you want to be happening and if they say yes then you know that's that's what the game's going to be um and that's fine it's just to make sure that the experience and the outcomes are what they expect them to be and are desired and intentional um and I need to you know the point at which I need to step back and even if I disagree say that's fine you know you're you're all on doing it maybe you're right even you know I
I'm I'm not as experienced in design as lots of these people so it's important to to let them take take the lead on that yeah speaking of not being as experienced like I'm I'm currently suffering through this because I've got a game Design coming out I have other designs in progress but I feel so like raw and new all the time um when you're when you're a new developer um how do you get confident in terms of knowing that you're right knowing where to look I mean I feel like it's it probably gets easier with time uh but impostor syndrome is real you know how do you how do you handle that at the start yeah I mean it's just really tough like I I personally struggle with this a lot um I you know have a lot of self-doubt and of confidence which some people sometimes surprised by uh you know I often question whether I've done things right and get worried about that um you know this this is a bigger issue than just in development but for for development of course it's going to help once you have some games coming out or for design as well and you start getting feedback on those um it's also you know the play testers can help with that a lot you know if if a play testers are enjoying the game if people are playing it and having fun and you can observe that then then that should be you know a big plus and even even if the game's not perfect if if people are enjoying it that that's really all that all that matters at the end of the day um I guess like on the more General issue I think it's important to have people you you trust to give you honest feedback on this so you know close close friends or close colleagues who who will Who will tell you when you're doing something good and will tell you when there's a
problem too and um give you honest honest feedback on that and that that's hard to find but it's it's important in any kind of creative work to have that I think um the other thing to say of course is that there are there are lots of games published of lots of different kinds of quality and I think even if even if you have some doubts it's it's still likely that what you're doing is is is good enough in many ways and isn't isn't the worst thing out there you know so so it's important not to beat yourself up too much and it's also important to let yourself make mistakes you know the first games you work on aren't going to be perfect and there's going to be um errors going to be things that go wrong and that that's okay that's fair uh so it also sounds like I mean you take a lot of feedback um so fortunately night witches play testers were super helpful and also nice which I really appreciated yeah um but you know I've uh I've been doing Elder Scrolls edits uh and also looking at feedback that took that your play test giving and like again the feedback is super helpful sometimes it's pretty spicy so as a developer you know do you ever take any of it personally and also how do you uh modulate that for designers who might yeah no that's a great question um I I I definitely take some of it personally sometimes you know um on on a different different kinds of level so if if I put quite a lot of effort into trying to make something clear and then somebody says actually this is really unclear um that can hurt at first but I think it's important to kind of put that to one side and say actually let's let's let's hear what
they're saying um maybe they're just being really stupid but maybe they've got a good point here let's let's look at that so yeah there's a lot of kind of putting your ego to one side there I think which is which is hard um and and takes takes time um it it also helps for me personally and this is harder as a designer probably than as a kind of professional developer is is to think of it as as a job you know this is this is a job this is not not my whole life this is just just something I I do for work um and also sometimes I think of the stakes so so sometimes I think like you I'm getting this kind of horrible feedback about this or whatever but at the end of the day it's just a game and actually it isn't that important you know there are there are there are worst things that I could be could be messing up and that that kind of goes back to to your previous question too so when I'm feeling really bad about something or really uncertain about something I think like really what's what's the worst that happens if I publish this game and doesn't work quite right and it's a little bit inaccurate in some ways like not it's it's not really that ser serous maybe maybe 5,000 people in total will ever play it um but but to get back to to your to your question now the um the the negative feedback yeah so I I try to take that myself and I also try to field that for the designers as you said so um I I I do sometimes have the designers in direct contact with the testers um but I at least I I I you know with with some designers with certain kinds of personalities I say maybe it would be better actually if you took a step back and I I take this feedback I Cate it and then send you the the important points with some of the more negative loss taken out um I mean this is probably something as a teacher that that you've
experienced as well or kind of know about that when you're giving feedback um or or getting feedback as a teacher or as an academic or as a a writer or as a game designer um people can sometimes kind of phrase things in a way which is more negative or more critical than it really needs to be and there are ways to kind of adjust that such that it's more palatable while still delivering all the same kinds of points and this is something I've got wrong as well in the past so I've given feedback to designers um either as a as a developer or as a kind of lead tester on some games which has been too too too negative and and phrased in too negative of a way um so I have to think quite carefully about how I how I present these things sometimes um and that's tough actually sometimes for cultural reasons too so I you know being British and working with a lot of Americans I think I sometimes can phrase things in a way that's not negative enough um but then sometimes can be too negative in different kinds of ways and it's important that you're clear when there's a problem with something um that can be hard to communicate across these kind of cultural barriers sometimes yeah I mean I think about delivering feedback I it's it's so hard to deliver real feedback in a way that the other person is able to hear yeah um you know as a reviewer I don't really feel like my feedback is for the designer at that point it's for people who might get the game and be engaging with it um I know I think other critics might feel differently um but even then you know I try really hard not to just take a giant dump on a
game in like an aggressive way because I don't think that people can hear that yeah um but you know I also spend a lot of time being very careful with like little teenage hearts and minds they are not careful with me if you want to get roasted go to my job for day I think one thing that's important with with game feedback in particular is and and it part the translation from play testers to designer is to say you know firstly this is how the players felt about the game um and then you can say that there are number of you know there are numerous reasons for this may maybe this wasn't really the right kind of game for them or maybe there's an actual problem um and then if there's an actual problem I'll try to explain what the problem might be and then also to give a possible solution and I think that's really important and this is probably the same for giving feedback to to students as well is to um is to say you know this is this is something you can do to fix it or to improve it um and they might not want to take that solution but you've at least ended on a more positive constructive like that I think that helps a lot oh yeah yeah I think the hardest thing too is that when you get to a certain point in any work like I felt like this about my dissertation at the end too um it gets to the point where you're like okay what's the quickest easiest fix I could do but that doesn't actually mean the best fix yep how so the other question I guess is like timelines if something's really not working but you have a deadline what do you do yeah um I mean sometimes you need to settle for a good enough fix and not not the best fix um sometimes it is just about making making it work well enough uh particularly when
you're quite close to the deadline so when we're already I mean like all of this stuff I would ideally catch earlier but once you've already started saying sending things to layout or to an artist um you really don't want to be making major changes then because it's a lot more expensive it's a lot more timec consuming it's just a lot more effort for everyone um so at that point I'll be thinking uh you know ideally we could have we could have done things in this way right from the start but actually here we are now let's just let's just do this this smaller fix um and and you just need to be pragmatic about that at certain points of the process so yeah even if it's not ideal but at the same time you you need to assess what kind of fix is needed and you know if if if a bigger change is is really is necessary then you need to be honest with yourself and with others and say let's let's do this if we can that that's a hard call to make sometimes yeah that's that's a tough one so speaking of tough things we're going to talk about your favorite topic now yeah which is solo modes uh so first of all you make a lot of solo modes but are do you consider yourself a solo gamer we haven't actually talked about this so that's a good question um and the answer is yes or no because it depends what you mean so I do I do a lot of solo gaming uh not not least when I'm designing or developing projects so I think as a designer or a developer you absolutely need to be comfortable playing solo but that doesn't mean using a solo mode so particularly for historical games that means playing all sides at once even if there's some hidden information and kind of splitting your brain so you don't you don't think about that too much and and seeing how it all works and you need to be able to do that just because you can
iterate much much faster without having to put together a group every time you need to do that so it's important at certain stages of design to be able to play the whole game by yourself so I I do lots of that and I even enjoy doing that outside of work so um you know this is one reason why I particularly like the the coin series really because there's uh largely no hidden information in any of these games so you can easily sit down and play all positions and you know see see how it unfolds so I do lots of solo gaming like that which I think is much more common in the historical gaming or or the wargaming community than it is in in broader kind of hobby hobby Gaming Community um I I tend not to use Solitaire modes for games that that often um I I I don't I don't personally enjoy the additional cognitive load you have there I feel like that gets in the way of the game a bit um so I'm I'm personally not that kind of solo gamer even if I play games GES by myself quite often if that makes sense yeah I mean I would say if you if you're playing by yourself and you're doing it for fun at that point you have crossed over into the world of being a solo gamer but we all argue about definitions but that' be me however even if you don't like to play solo modes you do make them for coin so what solo modes have you made and what kind of process goes into that so the solo modes I've made have pretty much exclusively been using the the card based um Solo System for coin which um uh Bruce came up with for um gandi um he's the designer of Gandhi um him and Jason car worked on
that together um this this card-based solo mode and how that works is so prior to that the coin games would have these quite complex flow charts so you know it' be if if it's this turn and if this situation do that this of whole page of a flow chart um the the amazing Insight Bruce and Jason head is to to it split that onto these cards so each card is actually basically a mini flowchart but they're much simpler and you draw One send me at random each turn and then it says you know if the board state is like this and that top priority will be looking for something critical so you know if you don't have enough bases out uh then next step are you able to play some bases okay next step play some bases if not it would flip over to the back of a card and then there'd be something which would try to engineer the game State such that you can resolve the first condition that makes sense um so it's working it's working through like this um I I actually came up with a name for this system so Bruce had done it for gandi and then he'd made one for far in the lake so kind of a retrofit fire in the lake um I came up with the overall name for the system which is now called the jackard system and this is a little bit of a fun because it's jackard but it's uh also harking back to the jackard loom which is an automatic Loom from the early 19th century um and basically a very early uh computer so it so it used it was programmed with Punch Cards the same as early uh digital computers were programmed with um but it's just just a loom so I thought that that was a cool name for it um my I mean to give some context to that my my previous life I was working as a philosopher of AI and computation so was quite interested in these in these kinds of things um and there is another
connection there this is this is really getting off topic now there is another connection there in so far as I think how these how these card-based solo systems work is actually quite similar to some principles in certain kinds of um AI work uh so there's this idea from Rodney Brooks um for the subsumption architecture and basically what this does is there are a number of kind of switches or priorities and you rather than explicitly doing a lot of stuff you just revert to that behavior as a kind of default and that that's how these systems work so it will kind of default to a certain thing if nothing else is a higher priority and this is a very kind of elegant way to to make this system work um but uh I so I've so Bruce did Gandhi and Bruce did uh Trung for fire in the lake and then Bruce also did uh ton which was for for full on expansion to Far Lake and that's where I first got involved in this system so I helped with the testing and development of teson quite a bit while I was working on full of seon uh since then I've done jackard systems for people power which is called bonasio and for Sovereign of Discord which is an expansion for far called Min m and these are all named after historical figures associated with the country but not with the conflict is the general principle so because you don't want the bot to be named after one particular side so it's a kind of older historical figure often um so yeah people power uh Sovereign a Discord and more recently I've been doing one for Red Dust Rebellion um which is obviously in the future so we named it curiosity after the Curiosity Rover which cute uh
and I will soon be working on one for China's War the next coin series volume and I've also done one for the pure land already so I've already done that um kind of ready to go um so those are the ones I've done so that's I mean that's not that many that's that's three of these systems um one one thing to say about them people start to say when we were working on for instance the British way and jest of Robin Hood we decided not to do solo systems because they are small two-player games so in principle it should be easier to find a partner um the British way is easier to play two-handed for that reason as well um for the British way there are four games in one box so I would have had to make eight different solo bxs for each side of those games for Jess of Robin Hood they um is some hidden information which just makes it a bit more difficult um so we didn't do solo Moes those people sometimes say oh but you it's so easy to make these coin solo modes now there's this existing structure can't you just kind of plug it in do it done that's just not true at all each of these is is really custom built from the ground up um we we have a kind of a kind of Master kind of working document documentation about how the system works but you you need to study the game very closely you know figure out good strategy for each faction and then uh you know Custom Design This set of cards this set of tables for each of those and that takes a huge huge amount of work really um I would say um almost approaching as much work as the original design does just to do the solo design the testing for it development of it um so yeah it's it's
it's a lot of effort and there are good reasons why we choose not to do that for some games that said uh is there a common starting point for micke I mean it sounds like there's a document that talks about how the system works so when you're beginning to make one um does that process start the same way each time yeah it does and we've got quite clear documentation for this which which is great um Bruce and Jason wrote this up together and it's super helpful for anyone else wanting to work on these systems for other games um it you you start S in addition to these cards very tables for kind of common actions so if you're placing a um certain kind of cube down there' be a place cubes column and that would you know go through some this is where you get the kind of architecture again so you know if if there's one of these places place it there other always place it there and so on um the beginning of it is is to work on that table so you and and this is actually where you need to be able to do the other kind of solo playing to do this so you need to be able to play play multi-hand so what you do is you sit down and play multi-hand and you say okay what are the common actions for this faction and what are the the priorities for them and then you work on this table so you you you you mock up a first version of a table and then play um you know choosing which action to do for each faction but uh placing the pieces on the board using this table and you know changing it as you go and there's and there's a lots of iteration you know I'm often changing it live as I'm working on it I'm like all right there's this other priority which is really obvious I'll just add that in now and you do that until the table is working pretty well um then you move on to so with the coin system you need to choose which kind of action to do you
know whether you do an operation whether you play the event so you come up with a little table for that um and you start thinking about which events are more important than others so we call some events critical which you always play some events per which you sometimes play in some events you might just never play um for for some faction and and you work on that next and then you you're continuing to play using just these bits of the system while you do that and then maybe finally you get to the cards and then you need to sit down and think what kind of um six major objectives or kind of situations are there for this faction normally based off Victory conditions but maybe some other things and then you start thinking about what kinds of board States should trigger certain actions and then you start putting together these cards and working on the logic for the cards um that's going to take a lot of work as well because you need to make sure the logic covers most of the relevant situations and this kind of thing um yeah and then you start working on that there's a few other bits you can do a along the way like priority for which pieces to remove first and stuff like this but those are the main steps um and at each of those steps you need to be playing the game by yourself multiple times while you work on it oh that's interesting so you said that you prefer to play multi-hand but when you have done your own deck um do you find that you still prefer to play multi-hand or do you enjoy your own work uh I I enjoy no no is the answer I I don't enjoy using it that much um for me so this is very different for different people I think for me because I work on these games so much and I know the system so well uh and I'm so used to playing multi-hand it's it's much it's
much much much quicker for me to play multi-hand so I can play one campaign of a four-player coin game in about 20 minutes um with the bot system it's going to take me closer to hour because you need to stop on each one you know look at the table whereas I you know if it's placing gorillas say I can just look at the board and say right there there there there that's where the gas go uh with the table I need to look at each row and think okay here and that one and that one this for each single piece I'm placing down so it just takes so much longer for me and isn't a particularly enjoyable experience um the bit I do kind of enjoy now and don't tell Jason I said this is I I enjoy the the the kind of meta game of creating the bot system itself that that's kind of like a game for me or at least a kind of a puzzle to solve so I enjoy solving that puzzle and then you know sometimes when we start testing these someone will come back and say oh it's doing this stupid thing in this situation and then you know that that as a discret little puzzle to think how do I prevent that behavior or cause a different kind of behavior that that's kind of interesting as as an intellectual challenge but it's it it's more like a puzzle than a game if that makes sense so it's it's like it's like doing a crossbow puzzle or something for me and I and I quite enjoy that that bit of it as a mental challenge I I don't enjoy outcome so much which is a funny kind of situation to being so one thing that's really interesting is you know you mentioned AI is working on this I think one thing that's really cool actually now the next time I play a B like you've made now next time I like play people power it'll be kind of fun because be like oh this is what Joe thought was important in this game like it's almost like kind of meeting you across the table in a way
yeah um so I guess do different people's solo modes have different quirks based on how they play yeah that's a great question and I think a really important point and something I try to be aware of when I'm working on them because you you certainly will tend to make them play the way you play and when I'm playing coin games that can sometimes end up being um overly conservative so I'll tend to maybe slightly too narrow-minded pursue the objectives of that faction rather than doing other stuff and that can often that can often be a good strategy to be honest in in in coin games I think people get people kind of lose lose sight of the end goal and this this kind of kind of relates to testing more generally so I'll I'll identify what I need to do to win and then quite narrow mindedly see that sometimes um but you can get two focus on that and then not not you know be not dealing with with other factions not not messing with other people's scores and that's something uh I maybe have a tendency to slip into so I need to think about that and change that um and that's also why it's important um prior to this process I think to play with other people more so you know I I I do lots of multi- handing but it's important to play with other people and also just to observe other groups playing so I can do that and then see other strategies which I might not have thought of and then also you know program those into the into the bot system um but yeah you're you're absolutely right that there there can be you know there's going to be some charact some some of some of the personality or a playing style of of the designer in the system um and that's nice in a way so you know when my bots
beat people that that feels a little bit like I'm I'm beating them or at least there's some you know I have some role in that um uh but but it does mean that you might you might some things um and that's why yeah observing different players before that is important and also observing people using your system afterwards is important because they might find a way to trick it or to confuse it or something which which which you hadn't noticed yeah but also I mean sort of back to Ai and programming you're an actual expert on this which I think is maybe we have a lot of opinions and not a lot of experts in our field on this at the moment so when people talk about AI yeah are we even like talking about it properly like as somebody who actually knows what they're doing like when we use AI for a solo mode I'm assuming that still would mean something quite different from AI like I can remove the background from this picture in canva and AI like when we're talking about art you know how do you as somebody who actually knows what they're talking about um feel watching all these things play out so this is something i' I've given up fighting to some extent but I would I would really much prefer to reserve the term AI for M much much smaller set of things maybe none of which we currently have um I I think it's possibly unhelpful to do this so for instance the the current you know the things people are very excited about these days so chat GPT and um the AI image generation and so on um I think there's I think it's a bit a bit early to call those AI um now it's It's tricky because it it gets into you know questions about how how the human mind works and how how natural cognition
works and and we don't know much about that either to be honest um but uh what one you know even if we're going to call these AI is important to distinguish between certain kinds of systems so as as you as you hinted at the you know the very popular things like chat GPT and the image creation uh systems at the minute are working in a very different way to the uh coin boot which I work on um and and this I mean this actually goes right back to to quite fundamental questions in history of artificial intelligence um so basically it's it's a distinction between a between a rules based system um which just follows kind of a fixed set of rules and a more open-ended kind of generative system which is what lots of the modern um systems people are playing around with these days do um and what what they do basically is take huge amounts of data and predict the the most likely next step um and some some video game AIS work like this nowadays I think as well and some even some digital AIS for digital board games I think use this as well and and what they'll do is they'll be trained on lots of previous games um by by human players um and then use that to figure out what to do next um and that's quite different to the coin systems which uh just have these explicit rules programmed in um now of course the generative systems might might be picking up on certain kinds of implicit rules and they might they might look like they follow rules um you know whether something that looks like it's following a rule is really following a rule is is again just a whole different
whole different kind of question which we could talk about for hours um but yeah they're they're very different approaches and they work in different ways and have different kinds of limitations um it would be almost impossible for us to do the generative approach for the games we're working on just because there's not enough data you would you would need you would need thousands of of games um or you would need uh a powerful enough computer to get the system to play the game against itself thousands of times um when when it's programmed this could be possible so you know there's now quite a few games on on on rally with troops where all the rules are explicitly defined so you you could theoretically train a um a generative system on on this and get it to play lots of games against itself build up an AI that that that that could be one approach that that would work um but but you need to have already programmed the game in that way to do that oh that's interesting yeah we won't talk about the ethical aspects of it in this conversation just because it derails everything every time and I mean you know but um that's that's really interesting I remember I just took one computer science class in school and what my teacher impressed on us was that computers actually like no matter how impressive it looks or you know if it fails both of those are the result of human planning and working like a computer can only do what you tell it to yeah no matter how fancy the result looks um and I I I think that's very like do you see I mean you know I think
in a small version right when we talk about coin Bots you see human intention and preference like baked in um do you think that that's still true for generative AI even if we don't necessarily understand that like it's still coming from Human data it's still looking at human behavior yeah so there are there's at least two or three different things going on there I think so firstly there are the so the way the system is set up in the first place will um you know prefer certain kinds of patterns to other kinds of patterns and that may be done more or less intentionally by the designers but that's there so the system itself isn't neutral to begin with um and there isn't to say it's biased in any particular way that we would recognize but it will it will have certain kinds of biases for certain kinds of data structures and so on which it which it finds more more interesting in some sense you know that's that's one way to think about it um so that that's already in the system and then there's also the data you train the system on as you said this is a huge issue um you know I hav haven't been working on this closely for a while but when I used to teach AI ethics we we'd look at it a lot so for instance you'll your get systems for facial recognition which can't can't recognize uh non-white faces you know can't can't recognize black faces or struggle with this and this was happening with one of these systems which is used to check if students aren't cheating during online tests um a few years ago is it is it couldn't recognize certain kinds of faces so it would flag you as cheating because you're no longer in the room or something and then you fail the test so that that's a kind of obvious bias which comes in through through through data sets um and there's a third thing as well which is you know what what what
these systems are used for so you can you can use the output outcomes in certain ways that's another kind of yeah another kind of thing that's in there um and this is all through still of the coin bots in so far as um you know we're creating them with certain outcomes in mind and you know with the coin Bots there are certain things we abstract so they don't they don't follow entirely all the rules but they almost follow all the rules of games but there are some decisions we've made there which which change how they behave and and as as as we were talking about earlier it will tend to it will tend to play in in a style similar to me because i' I've trained it basically um um so yeah there's that that's happening in in both these cases I'd say oh that's so interesting but there's one more I mean we have limited time there's one more Trail I want to follow with you watch here which is so you primarily or entirely work on historical games yes uh well except for games like red dust Rebellion which is s the future and jest of Robin Hood which is kind of historical or not um but broadly speaking yes I mean more more generally than that I tend to work on what we might call conflict simulation games rather than other games that's not um that's not necessarily going to be true forever that's that's what I I currently work on what I'm particularly interested in but I I wouldn't be h of doing other work yeah so I guess it just leads me to ask when you are doing development are you thinking only about mechanisms and systems or are you also looking into the historical grounding of the work and making sure that it's expressing I guess
what it's supposed to um and you know how do you how do you handle that aspect of the work yeah that's a great question um I I think I've got some Duty as a developer to at least check a little bit of a history and of course I can't do as much research as the designer will have done um but I do try to read at least one book on each each game I'm working on and I will actually ask the designer for a recommendation there because uh this again is an interesting way to figure out what the designer wants to do so uh I mean as I'm sure you know history isn't neutral so whichever book for designer recommends will will will tell you their kind of take on the history and you know if if that seems really bad maybe then I'll I'll talk to the designer maybe I'll I'll question about that but if it's just a particular interpretation of things uh you know it doesn't need to be one I agree with but by reading the book they recommend I will understand what they're trying to show with the game um so I I I do that and I read at least one book if I'm particularly interested I might read more but I I I try to do that just to get some background understanding and that's important not just to you know check for history check for designers done their work which I'm doing to some extent but I'm you know I'm never going to have the knowledge to do that for every game um but it's more important really to to understand what what the game is meant to be what what the simulation is meant to be of so that I can I can help them uh get towards that goal nice have you ever had a situation where you really did have a serious disagreement with a designer's take and what did you do that's a good question I need to think carefully about how much I should say um
I I I've had cases where I'm I'm I'm you know I know enough about a topic that I'm at least worried about the the perspective of the designer is taking you know seems like it might be outdated and in that case I'll I'll first go to someone else I know who might who might know about history so you know I work with a lot to designers who are also historians or also social scientists you know have some kind of um expertise in these areas and I'll I'll ask them what they think about it and that can help me check if if I if I have the right kind of instinct there that there's something not quite right um if if that seems to be the case I'll I'll ask the designer about it I'll just say you know this seems like uh maybe quite an outdated perspective what you take on that um they might they might say oh yeah but I think it's still right and really dig my feet in or they might say like oh yeah that's right let let's think about some other kinds of options here um or there's a third thing which is that you might say that's right but I want this game to tell a story about that a DAT perspective and then it's more of a framing thing and that can be okay I think so for instance Twilight Struggle is a good example this um it it's quite explicitly presented as um almost a kind of fever dream of Cold War leaders focusing on domino theory and this particular idea about how International politics works and and Jason Matthews doesn't think that's uh correct necessarily but the game is trying to evoke particular kind of feeling um of people in the 50s and 60s and 70s who saw the world this way and and you know maybe that framing could be clearer but but I think like making making that
framing explicit sometimes can be enough even if even if the history doesn't seem quite right um I mean I mean just of Robin Hood is another good example um so Fred's quite quite clear in the supporting materials that he's not trying to tell a kind of a true analysis of the real Robin Hood or anything it's more about uh different different versions of Robin Hood and how we how we perceive those and how we think about them so there could be a kind of historiographical twist there which helps with the framing um but you know back back to the worst case scenario where the designer seems to have a really outdated view which I just disagree with uh and they're not budging on it I'll I'll normally go to the publisher then and say like this is a concern I have um and yeah not not not to say this has necessarily happened or not but in the worst case scenario I might say I'm not comfortable working on this game anymore it just seems like a really kind of bad um you know kind of morally bad uh way to present the history um or the or or they might be able to talk to designer or something like that but there's there's a point at which it's just out of my control and all I can say is I'm not comfortable working on this um so that that's something which I would I would do in in the most extreme cases but hopefully i' I'd be able to resolve that with a designer first and it could just be something they overlooked or something this yeah now I mean I I always like to take on people who care about history and games at the same time it's a good thing so uh kind of softy questions leading into the end um I guess uh first what games have you been playing that actually bring you some Joy not for work
question um I play so many games for work it's hard to say but what have I played recently for Joy not for work I've played played Dune a few weeks ago with some friends which was a lot of fun um the big which one classic the classic six player one um but the the modern version of that one yeah yeah I haven't played any of the other g games uh but yeah that classic one is great really love it it's a lot of fun um the the not for work question kind of blurs because I play a lot of games which are like kind of kind of like background work for work but we we played Angola with the same group as as well recently which is a classic four player war game which is a lot of fun quite chaotic that was that was really great um I've been playing uh Kings the king's dilemma with with a kind of in with with my inperson group here which is this um it's almost like a role playing game and I think that's right way to think about it so you're members of a king's Council over several different sessions maybe up to 15 over the whole campaign and your vote you're you're basically just voting on different dilemas that come up so so the actual gameplay is very thin and I think if you were just focusing on the gaml it would be very dull but with the right group of people and this is this is true of of so many games it's it's really great so you really get into character I'm playing this one particular house who got a real chip on their shoulder and like blame everyone else for everything that goes wrong so you know I can just seize any opportunity to like lay the blame on someone else or like scheme and this kind of thing um that and that's really fun so that that's been a really nice one I've been playing you know not not a conflict simulation or war game at all uh much closer to a role playing game really but having a great time um with with some friends oh that's awesome um and then if
you uh want to be found online where can you be found by people who want to follow your work uh good question um for now well uh on B Game Geek I've got B Game Geek profile and that says all the games I've been working on might be slightly update so I'll update it um I I'm semi-active on Twitter I don't tend to post very much but I I'm around and sometimes interact with people on Twitter just under Jerry deur it's quite easy to find me I think um maybe joeore deur uh that's that's really it in terms of like my public profile I I'd be meaning to set up like a portfolio website I haven't done that yet so I will maybe try and do that soon fantastic uh and Joe thank you so much for coming on it's been so fun to like just get to hang out for an hour and I know that I'll get to torture you uh via homo ludan at various points but it's it's been good to chat y yeah thanks very much for having me on really nice to chat to you and really interesting and I'm glad we didn't get too diverted because I could talk for hours about what what rules following is and these kinds of things so good good not to let me do that that might be a future conversation don't think you're off the hook just yet but for now everybody out there uh please like subscribe uh comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming