Skip to main content
Loading video...

Excalibur Review: A Hilt to Die On

Transcript 9:47

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel.

I'm Joy Evans.

Today we're taking a look at a small game called Excalibur, which as we all know is a great sword whether you're talking about King Arthur's sword or just a sword you find in various video games. Almost every video game that has swords eventually there's one called

Excalibur.

100%. And it's usually overpowered like this original one was.

Yeah, I know. Once you get Excalibur you're like I need no other sword.

Done.

This is a two to eight player game.

Yes.

Never played this at two so I can't answer how good it is there. 20 minutes. This is from Roxley Game. They're best known for Dice Throne and Santorini and things like that. This is a small game for them, but it's also pretty close to a party game. Let me show you. At the beginning of the game you're going to put out a bunch of chips here all over the board. You're going to take two chips, the cursed blade and Excalibur, mix them with enough other chips for the number of players, shuffle them, and give one each player. And then players are going to start each round of the game by taking the chip that they got and adding three chips to it. Then on a round of the game you're going to look through your chips and you're going to pick a chip, put it face out, everyone reveals them, and starting from the person who has the crown which will pass around the table, you will play your chip and do what it says. Some of the chips have something that when you open your hand it will something will happen. But like this one says draw two.

So I draw two chips, and if I drew a sword shout "Huzzah!" So I draw two. I did not get a sword. If I played Robin of Locksley, I would steal one from someone else and I would keep doing this until my hand has seven chips. If I played the merchant, I would draw two or steal two, then return one. I might want to return one cuz that's the only way to get rid of the cursed blade. You will lose the game if you end with this. So, we'll talk about that. The game is over when all the chips from one of these sections is gone. And at the beginning of every round, players will draw up to four chips and they can draw from wherever they want. So, they might draw from the same section if they think they're winning. Whoever has Excalibur in their hand at the end of the game is the winner. Unless they have both, in which case they lose and everyone else wins. If no one has Excalibur, which can happen cuz there are cards that force people to put chips back in the middle, then nobody wins and they all lose except for the person who has the cursed blade.

They're the losingest person. Um but this you can't win with this, period, even if you have Excalibur. And there are a few other ways that people could win. There's a squire sword that if you have it and the person to your left wins, you'll win also. But that is pretty much the game. I want to be clear, the game comes with a glossary and this matters because these are all the different chips. I'm kidding. Also, all of these. But all these different chips here and you'll be taking chips from other people and stealing them. Sometimes something makes you flip chips in the air and see what side they fall down on. But the game will end when all the chips in one section are gone and then whoever has Excalibur wins unless they have the cursed blade.

Okay, first of all, production value. This is close to being overproduced. It's that nice. And I want to be clear, when I say that, I'm talking about this production that I'm showing you.

The retail one.

It's pretty good quality. In fact, they give you an extra Excalibur and cursed blade chip in the thing, which I think is nice because those chips are going to be always used and they'll get more beat up so you can switch them out at some point. So, that's a cool thing. But even more than that, there is another version of this that comes with actual metal swords

Yes.

and wooden chips.

Yeah, or I They're They're so nice.

It is plastic or whatever. Crazy.

Yeah, it feels really And the swords are only dividers. They're They

Yeah, right.

No functional purpose.

So, that being said, I mean, Roxley, they're always top-tier quality. And so, whether you I I don't think you need to get the Kickstarter deluxe one, but I'm very impressed with the quality of the chips that are in this one. Like the one I showed you. This is a Like we said, I At the beginning, I don't know that this you could play this with two, but

Yeah, it's a I think it's more

It's a party game. This is a game meant for everyone to be pulling out chips and laughing. And to that end, I can tell you right now, some of those of you watching will hate this.

Yes.

And some of you will have a hilarious time. But, you got to be in that mindset.

And I think this is very group dependent, too. And you always say about party games, but this one I think even more so, because you really have to have a group that plays into it and gets into this.

It was really surprising. I still remember when I got this reference card, I'm like, "That's a pretty decent amount of powers."

Boom, more.

like, "Wow." Now, to be fair, once you start playing I think once you play this once, you kind of know what all the powers do, cuz you're like, "Oh, it's Lancelot again. Everyone flip your chip."

Yep.

You know, you you get to know the powers.

And there's a lot of these, too, because I I do not teach it by saying what each power does. Explain the game and then be like,

hand out the sheets. Figure out your own power.

Take a look and figure it out.

It And also, the game is 20 minutes. If you are in this game and you're like, "It's taking too long," you can just start grabbing all your chips from one section

Right.

faster. And I will say, at the end of the day, even though it's 20 minutes, probably only 5 minutes counts. The last 5 minutes.

100%. Yeah, and and everyone Then it becomes hot potato and everyone's watching and

Sure, and I do think that's fun for me to figure out who has the the Excalibur in their hand. I'm like, "Ooh." And also the cursed sword. And I love the fact that there are and now there are sword and squire sword and things in there. And there are some dumb things that people are going to hate like it's draw two chips and if you get a sword say, "Huzzah!"

Right. Right.

But I don't know. There's just something that I'm I'm I find this game amusing, but I do want to be clear that there are a couple folks here at Dice Tower who I haven't shown this to and played with cuz I know they will hate it.

Yeah.

So, this is not a game for everyone, but I think it's a game for a lot of people.

It's a game for a lot of people because there is that moment like you said towards the end where you follow where you're like, "All right, got it there." And you can tell by reading people and all this. And then there will be that moment where you're like, "Not sure where it is now. I know two options."

Right. Well, so Joey will steal it from Lucy and he'll steal a chip from her and he smiles and she frowns. I'm like, "He got the Excalibur."

Yes.

I think. I'm pretty sure.

Yes. And it's like sometimes people will try to bluff and try to do things. But then if you see someone continually stealing from one person, you're like, "There's something over there." You know, I I love that type of not deep thought that goes into this. Now, these the weird thing is there are some great powers in here, but they may not show up.

That's true.

of Locksley I think is in there or whatever. You know, they may not show up, but they add a lot of interest if they do. I There's not a lot more to say about it.

There really isn't.

You're just playing it. You're laughing. It's short. This is a filler. You might play it a couple times. It's an end of the night game.

Yes.

Uh that everyone's playing and you're going to like it or not. I played this and there was very much mixed reactions. Some people like, "Again?" And other people said, "Not for me."

Right. Right. Is that where you're at with the people you play with?

where I am. Some people are like, I got to buy this. Other ones are like, I'd play it again.

Well, where are you?

I'm at a 7.5 on this. I do like it a lot. I think it is very group dependent. Um I think it is it is a weird it's it's party / filler and you can really get going in this quick. You explain what happens, what you do, give them one of these.

is one page of rules like this, too, and it's almost on half of that.

Exactly. And then it's a we'll figure it out as you go. And then couple rounds in, they're like, got it. You know, so you really like that. Now, I will say what you mentioned, too, the upgraded components, it's nice because you don't have that Excalibur being very worn.

But again, it depends if they have two in there.

That's fantastic.

That's a good thing. I wish more games would do something like that.

100%.

Like if you have a card that gets used all the time,

Yep.

give me an extra of that card.

Yeah. Next, you can't sleeve tokens.

I'd give this a seven. Um very much on where you're at. This isn't a game I want to play all the time, but it is a great one. It's the end of the night, we have 20 minutes, but I don't want to go home quite yet.

Right.

And the the two four-player games have stopped and we're like, well, is there something for eight? Why, yes, there is.

And it looks good on the table, too.

Yes.

Yes.

Yes. It's the kind of game I think I hope I see this as a target.

I agree. And it looks great on a round table.

It just does.

Oh, I didn't even think about that, but you are you are correct. You are correct. Well, there you go, folks. That is Excalibur. I'm Tom Vasel.

I'm Joe Evans. See you

sir. Your name inserted here.

Lancelot.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things we review, games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Wee-ooh, wee-ooh.

Progress saved