Skip to main content
Loading video...

Quacks no longer of Quedlinburg - TCbH Review

Transcript 9:06

In 2018, The Quacks of Quedlinburg made its debut, and it was all the rage. Poppy and puzzling, it was a push-your-luck game with distinctly refined bag-building mechanics, and I didn't actually get to play it until 2019 at Mox Boarding House, where I got this hat, I might mention, and, you know, this place right here. And it took me that long because it was so popular and hard to get a hold of. And while I enjoyed it at the time, that was just a loaner copy that I could play it there, and because time went on and focus on other things, I never really found a good moment where it was something that I could speak about and had a copy in my possession to cover for this channel or for the podcast or for the blog, whatever position I was in at the time.

Cut to a little over a year ago, CMYK announced that they were revitalizing the game with a new name, Titan Edges, reduced cost, and a completely new art style. And you know, as you might expect, the internet was completely chill about it. The thing is is I remember thinking, "Wow, they're going for some David the Gnome by way of Rankin/Bass claymation sort of thing. That looks so cool." And finally, the name isn't the confounding Quacks of yes, the very real city of Quedlinburg. I mean, I know what they were going for with the original title, but it never exactly rolled off the tongue. And it also is kind of felt a little weird, oddly specific. It would be like saying, "This game's named The Bums of Bo Hoboken." The thing is, underneath all the controversy, there's still a good game here, a game that people fell in love with in the first place, that is kind of the source between the passion that surrounds the game and the subsequent change. So, let's talk about what is Quacks, how it's held up over the years, and dive into a couple new things about this new edition.

Quacks, players are alchemists, witchy-type people, boiling a cauldron of goodies, hoping to not cause the whole thing to explode. At the beginning of the game, cards are set out to define what precisely the different tokens do. A nice bit of versatility to make the most out of the same components. Then, each round, players simultaneously draw one ingredient from their bag and place it in a number of steps forward on their tracker equal to the number on their ingredient. You can stop at any time, collecting both the points and sweet, sweet currency on the space directly in front of the last token placed, or continue drawing until you bust by getting a certain threshold of berries, making you have to choose between either the currency or points. Then, players can buy new tokens to stick in their bag, each with different powers when drawn or strength values, some directly synergizing with others. Then, you collect the rest of your played ingredients, start all over, and play again with the most points at the end of the game winning.

This core loop is virtually unchanged from the original edition, and it's the tried-and-true loop that has been celebrated for all these years. And sure, it might be that the push-your-luck is super enticing and alluring, but the direct consequences of buying tokens to stick in your bag and seeing a rounds go from paltry earnings to explosive, combotastic turns is epic. Being able to draw and choose those tokens, moving crazy far if you've already placed a token type, setting up a point-generating wombo combo, it's all here. It's all great. It's not super deep, but it's sleek, smart, instantly gratifying while rewarding thinking ahead. And I particularly like the kind of concessions that are made to address poor or perhaps unfortunate play. Where busting doesn't fully ever go around, you just have to choose between cash or prestige. And the rubber banding by having your starting spot in the cauldron move up a number of places temporarily based on how far you are behind the lead player is nice. Speaking of, there's also a lever in the game where you can permanently upgrade your starting spot, which is another push and pull between how you want to build out, how you want to proceed. It's things like this that really lean into the broad family appeal of the game while still having these combo-tastic hooks that gamers like to latch onto. Though that's not to say that the design is immune to criticism. There's a somewhat

finicky setup and takedown of typical bag builders requiring things to be refreshed just so. And as much as it rewards thinking about the future, sometimes draws and even purchases just fall into obvious place. And folks wanting to sculpt precision in their bags are going to find some mushiness here. Some tokens work really well together, but there's little in the way of permanent removal and not enough time to make perfect synergy stick. And last but not least, for as many catch-up mechanisms as there are and you have refreshable potion bottles that can stick things back in your bag and some of the tokens let you mitigate some chance, this is a game where luck plays a big factor. It's not the type of game that I really grab onto when I'm playing with my core gamer group where everyone is down for a strategy games. But if I'm looking for something a little bit lighter or I just want something that's a little bit more casual for family time or for double date night or meeting new people who know that you're into games and you're not really sure that you want to break out something super intimidating, but they're expecting something that's more elaborate than just Bananagrams or something. This is a full-on game, but it has [snorts] that certain something that makes it feel like kind of a zany classic. So, yeah, Quacks is good. Now, let's talk about the specifics of this new edition. The first thing to know is that there are three new versions here. Quacks, Quacks Deluxe Edition, and the Quacks All In

version. Basic Quacks is as described, the game featured in this video. It's essentially the basic OG Quacks with new components and art style, though at a slightly reduced $40 MSRP, which I can appreciate. For 60 bucks, you can get the Deluxe Edition with some nice upgrades, but otherwise is the base game. For 100 smackaroos, you get All In, the Deluxe Edition plus two previously released, but now updated to match the new style expansions, The Witches and The Alchemists. On the whole, the new edition in a vacuum is perfectly cromulent. There may be some aesthetic preferences to one of the other. I personally find the new one is tonally better matched to its gameplay and likely audience, but making the three versions of the game where only one version is the only way to get the expansions is absolute insanity. For the type of game Quacks is, I'd be hard-pressed to recommend someone ever go All In off the jump, but if you get the affordable version, you can't buy the expansions as an add-on. I even reached out to CMYK to ask if they'd ever consider making the expansions available, and they confirmed that no, it's not part of their strategy. In their experience, not too many people bought the expansions. But wait, it makes sense to have three SKUs of the same game?

[clears throat and snorts]

Uh, okay, fine. That's a frustrating end to a review about a good game, but if that's how it's going to be, well, then it. I think that I, and you too, should consider the expansions to not really be expansions to this game, but more like promos instead. Maybe for the absolute completionist, but I can't recommend the all-in edition because 40 extra bucks on top of the deluxe edition for expansion content that I guess they don't believe could actually move on its own doesn't seem worth it. And it's not exactly like there's a witch or alchemist size hole in this game design. Quacks is a good light-hearted, but engaging game about clever combos and playing with probabilities. And while there are some annoyances around the retail structure, and there were certainly opportunities for a little bit more innovation beyond the cosmetic, but this new edition is a tidy, concise, affordable package that shows that Quacks its design, its principles, its core being withstands the test of time. And that's our review. But let me know, what is your favorite game that has had a substantial design change, a presentation, cosmetic lift, maybe even a title change. What is your favorite version of that? And also, what game do you think deserves one the most? Put it in the comments below, and as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help us grow. We rely on you for all those likes, subscribes,

comments, the sharing our videos, as well as checking out our Patreon. But above all else, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved