Skip to main content
Loading video...

Spirit Island - Additional Thoughts & Review Q&A

Transcript 9:38

this game this freaking game spirit Island has taken over my life and I am so proud of this review this was the culmination of a lot of things and if you are just listening to this via TC BH reviews the podcast channel and you're not checking out the actual video review you might not be aware that there's the presence of some spiritual manifestations and the way of sock puppets were that make their way into the review itself woven into the very fabric of the review so that is designed that you could listen to the entire thing and not miss any of the beautiful information that you would need but the company visuals are worth it I I think so or at least we thought so as we made these things so one of the things about doing the cardboard Harold was trying to celebrate the things that I absolutely love and bring me a ton of joy in my life and one of those things is tabletop gaming and board games and the communities that build around them the imagination that it sparks and being able to have some sort of reverence for that and to participate in the joy and express myself creatively utilizing those games as a platform was a big part of this thoughtful criticism is an

aspect of that getting into video and audio production as an aspect of that and so has been sock puppet making this was so fun and I'm so glad that the sock puppets got a ton of feedback even if they aren't the focal point of the entire view making up what maybe 20 seconds of camera time altogether somewhere around there but that's not the whole thing you're listening to this an audio for Monty cbh reviews you're seeing this as part of the video series that we have going on on our chain in the additional thoughts on review Q&A you want to know what's going on with additional thoughts and review Q&A aspect of spirit island so this game it was not something that I anticipated taking over my gaming habits in the way that it did not to say I haven't played to other games but in 2018 so far I think I played 14 games of spirit island and we are not even halfway through the year for being a big game that is a big deal I think I haven't fallen in love with a game this way since I have mmm I don't know with terraforming Mars probably which is interesting because there's a lot of aspects of the game that even though terraforming Mars is a

competitive game except for the solo mode it has a lot of the same feelings a lot of the same overand vibe that I dig on that Spirit Island actually has the interweaving systems the ways than which you have an arc of empowerment as I mentioned in the review those are all familiar feelings to terraforming Mars when I play Spirit Island and I just can't get enough of it I played it solo several times I've played it with all player accounts several times I loved ratcheting up the difficulty I loved exploring it and in the 14 full games I have played I still haven't even scratched half of the things that I could in the game by way of interacting with different powers and different combinations of spirits in the different enemy nations that you could be facing off against the different scenarios the level of difficulty the blight combination so it's just so much to confront in that game but never to the point where it ever felt overwhelming to me and so my standing thoughts I hear a few months later or at least a month later I think I uploaded that at the beginning of April something like that the pervasive feeling is still

overwhelmingly positive and I am working on a review of the expansion which spoilers I really really like and will have some thoughts and maybe some puppets to introduce with that so let's get to some of these questions one of the questions that I got on social media and it also came up on reddit a little bit was solo is this a game worth getting if you're just going to be able to play it solo either because you don't have a group or your group may not enjoy this type of game or this level of complexity in the game and I'm going to come out and say this is the first game that I have ever recommended even if it's going to entirely be played solo even terraforming Mars a game that I think is fantastic solo I would have a degree of reservation like you're missing out from the full experience by not being able to play with multiple players but here if you want to you could play with dummy players and have you know multiple spirits that you're contending with that's not really my style I still like to solo with just one spirit on their own but the way that it scales to a single player is stupendous and I absolutely would recommend this as a solo game if you're wanting a big B V puzzle that feels like a bold dynamic game like one of my ideal scenarios for

playing spirit island is to have some reruns of the next generation going on while I just sit there and solo my way through with a couple spirits and that is a fantastic evening one that I have done multiple times since having it where I'll just be like how's this spirit do on its own oh I still got another hour left of TNG watching see how this spirit does now the next question that I got a lot was also puppets what convinced me to make puppets well I already kinda tackled that but I will say that in the thought of puppetry and puppet making I've expressed in various sorts of cardboard Harold related stuff before that Alton Brown was a big impact on me is a big impact on me I really enjoy the kind of educational setting and being able to engage people and learn through fun and through silliness I really dig that vibe and some of my favorite teachers in life were able to kind of poke fun at themselves and the formality of learning in order to engage students more and I realized that I'm not always the wittiest guy or the most thoughtful guy but I can make something a little bit silly and I can get people laughing and

if that takes some sock puppets then I'm all about it now the sock puppets themselves they were made by myself my wife and our friend Jennifer so big shout out to both Christina Eddie and Jennifer Kelly for their huge help to make many sock puppets we came up with the designs together and had a killer time making them and then another question that I got a lot when it came to the spirit island review is the the sense of empowerment like does it really balance there even if you are always winning like do you feel empowered and then you just feel like the solo game falls flat and I think that's a misunderstanding of the point that I was trying to make this game you feel very empowered throughout it whether you're winning or not you feel like you have agency like you have choices to make and those choices will lead to you better worse outcomes depending on how skillful you are on that I'm not saying that the game is solely determined based off of what choices you make because there are some random elements you can't always anticipate what's coming up but in the best of ways you have a lot of agents you have a lot of control and the sense of progression the build up a power of

capabilities of skillsets of just the sheer havoc that your spirit can wreak by the end of the game makes you feel very very powerful so even if you lose there's still a sense of accomplishment and that's something that I absolutely dig so that's it thank you for watching I've been jacked for the cardboard Harold

Progress saved