Skip to main content
Loading video...

On The Underground Review - The Broken Meeple

Transcript 21:37

everyone then welcome to the last review that I'll be doing this year yes I've got to take a Christmas break at some point I'm going to be recording this review and the top ten or 2019 today and then that's a wrap you know I need time off okay it's been a long December has been a long November especially with all these essent tiles you know everybody needs a rest so season freeze gonna conclude after yeah basically from Christmas day onwards I don't know what order or at least the videos in but they will that will be the last one for this year maybe well maybe the odd v-log who knows you know depends if I feel like doing anything after Christmas day but for the most part it's gonna be no more reviews and certainly no more tucked ins until we get to January and then season four begin and then obviously we know we're back on track so for now we're talking about on the underground from Ludi creations by Sebastian Bleasdale this is Wow talk about bringing back an Aldi this one came out all the way back in 2006 yeah long time ago for most people that's ancient in terms of board games tend to be honest for the Hobby it kind of is the Hobby exploded after 2012 and suddenly went like insane with the amount of games you got so anything built like 2010 even feels a bit ancient but yeah not exactly cutting the new myself so I do believe that the old games can still be really good question is was this one any good and is it worth free printing so only on the ground involves you as players building up a network of underground tube amps or railway tube networks so the London tube network basically although here you also get burned in so

you get to do the Berlin metro system as well and the idea is that each of you has these like connections that you place on the board in order to just build up your network and you'll have to three or four depending on the player cap but what you're trying to do is build your network in such a way that this one passenger uses your routes as often as possible and don't ask me what his motivation is regardless of what passenger you pick I had a little meatballs I mean you can have my old man you can have man vomiting in a pregnant woman you didn't have disabled person in the wheelchair so I I suppose that's actually got a bit of reason but the rest of hmm but the idea is is that this is the laziest passenger ever so what will happen is the end of every turn the passenger will travel to various spots on the board depending on what cards are out you know location cards and what they will do is they will they will try to take the easiest route possible but the shortest not necessarily the shortest but the easiest so they don't want to walk they don't want to have to get off at a tube station and go how do they all right and get on this station no they want to literally just sit on the train for the entire journey if possible so they don't care how long the route is but they will go from A to B if it means they don't have to walk it could be and get there as long as it's all on a train rather than simply going in you know five seconds across the boundary that that lazy so what how you're building up these networks is designed in such a way that you're trying to build up a system where you think that passenger is gonna

use your networks more often than the opponents you get a point each time so the points are quite tight as they go forward but you can also connect to other spots on the board like the outer the outer areas at the outer connections which get you points as well as these little tokens that allow you to branch off because you have to do a continuous line to begin with but spend these tokens you can branch off and do other things you've only got a finite amount of connections that you can put down and some routes can be longer than others so you're really restricted in terms of how much you can actually put on this board you know with particular connections and there's other ones where you can get some bonus points as well as well as even connect up these little landmark tokens yeah for the London map anyway the Berlin one has a slightly more not complicated but slightly more meaty set collection aspect to it but you know you can get these tokens up you get some spare points as well and the game basically just plays out like that you put down 4 action points worth of stuff be it collecting switch tokens or putting connections down 1 2 3 4 passenger travels one two three four passenger travels one two three four and you just rinse and repeat in that fashion until the death cards runs out at which point check out the number of victory points n have a guess of course so this is obviously a reprint as we say we're talking a 13-year reprint it came out in 2006 I don't know when it went out of print but when it went out print it went out of print just stay out of print you know it never came back and so this is a long time in the making I only heard of this game because of Tom bass already even about it on various top-ten lists like this game sounds interesting I want to try it and then as soon as the

Occulus from Lully creations got in touch with me and said you know we're doing this as a reprint it's like ooh it caught my attention because I've wanted to find out more and certainly when you look at both versions I don't know how the old one plate so I can't talk about rules comparisons or anything like that but I can certainly tell that aspects have been streamlined here but in terms of aesthetics wow they really went to town on this now this is a deluxe version and there are a few cosmetic differences between this and the retail version but not many I mean you get these cool like 3d miniature markers for like Big Ben or some other Tower and Berlin my knowledge of Berlin is not particularly great I haven't visited yet but you know you get these markers to say where the locations are you get that in a deluxe in the normal version I think you just get these like normal markers you know either way it still works here you know I've got a sleeve for the game itself whatever you know it's a nice cover but for the most part because of the retail and the deluxe versions are mechanically the same there's just some odd cosmetic differences but they both look amazing because the board is lovely white and stark it just it's a huge board I think it's bigger than the original board well so you can actually see what's going on on it cuz you know it gets quite busy otherwise and everything is clear the iconography is top-notch there's nothing ambiguous there's nothing like hang on I can't quite see what's there oh why no it's it's as clear as there's this giant blue circle giant green circle oh there's five connections there there's

two there there's one there you know it's so easy to tell what's what and it's even grid referenced to say right okay we're location Carter I need to go to Highbury Queens there or the e

oh there it is so if you're one of these people who in ticket a ride still can't locate places around your own home country then yeah at least the card told you where it was there's pretty much a similar deal to this it's pictured on the card and there's a grid reference what more do you need I mean I don't know that London Metro Tube stations like off the back of my head or anything like that so you know I'll get one that you know says oh I need to go to Sudbury and that is where exactly you know I don't know where they are but the cards are easy enough to follow certainly this game doesn't feel clunky now in terms of the like gameplay itself it's very tactical you can't be a strategist in this game you know you can think oh yeah I'm gonna build a network exactly there and then that's we'll do this no you can't do that and that's one of the things I like this is a reactionary game you have to look at the board state you have to look at where the guy is like the guy or girl is trying to go where is this passenger going next turn yeah do you care about the passenger that's certainly you know can you influence them in any way or are you just gonna say you know what you're not going anywhere near me can't do anything about it but I know what I'm gonna build up my network over here or I'm gonna connect up some of these external points in order to get more points in that way because you can do either raw and they both work as legitimate strategies yeah the scores are usually quite tight by the end I mean there are been tie breakers galore there are people like within a five point spread yeah you may get one maybe two outright losers you know depending how many players you've got but you usually always get at least a couple of people really tug-of-war in

it till the end and that's great because you can it feels like it's anybody's game for a good three quarters of the game you might think well after three quarters I can kind of cool it but even then somebody might surprise you so and brilliant you know I love it when it's like that because you get a lot of Euro games where you know certainly I can go right eyes are my first four turns were bad or well you win you know you could literally cool good game at that point and that's never a good thing so aesthetically fantastic looks the business great reprint love this colorful light cover that's again stark but just I know it there's something about it that just really looks nice this is easily in my opinion I think the most beautiful looking game that Ludi creations has ever put at yeah yeah they're not exactly bad on their aesthetic so you know that's saying something theme wise the theme is a little bit weird I mean the idea that this passenger is super they easier but we've had I've had things from like you know well it's a disabled meeple therefore they want to be taking the train all the time okay that's fine but then you've got one where they use the blow can somebody like refers to him as a drug dealer doing this round you know I've heard all sorts of explanations as to why this meatball is the laziest person in the world but you know you don't really playing this game for a formatic thing it's purely just a it's a mechanical game in its own right but people still banter a lot about this passenger and there's always I you know kind of like slagging off everybody else's Network you know they're the colors they're comparing it to actual London lines you know if you've got net knowledge of the tube net where they go with a red central or the Green Deal are whatever I

can't read what they are but you know they're making those comparisons and even people are just making random comments like you know is that and the passengers gonna use my one and then my one again over to hear it it's like well we never said that we said the passenger was lazy we never said he was intelligent and everyone's just slacking off for their different network connections then granted that's the people rather than the game but the game is just so light and free like light-hearted in such a way that people can just do that and have a laugh this one doesn't feel like you have to play it super serious it's a light Gabe there's not a lot to teach in this you know it is one of the easiest games of this size to teach people you know not quite ticket to right levels okay but why do you go do you've got four actions four actions around and you do one or two things that's it and then the movement and the passenger is the other thing to teach and have the score points that's it that's literally all you got to teach you know how the cards come out at the whole yellow and grey thing again that takes a second to explain you know the really the only rule in this that is even close to being complicated and that's because you do have to cater for a lot of different circumstances is how the passenger moves you know it's like right the passengers going to go take the easiest route possible okay if it's equal either way then how many networks they're using right well he uses free networks to get there to get there so he's going to go there okay no it's entirely equal so active pair chooses okay fine he goes through a yellow one then goes to a grey one unless they're all yellow all grey in which case he

just goes to the closest well you know there's a few of these little ones where you have to go right hang on what is the scenario and follow this little flowchart in such a way that's like right is it has he got this circumstance yes okay right is it closer to you by one network or to get worse no he goes there yeah it's kind of like that you have to just do it step by step and you will get it fine I know people don't get confused by the movement mechanic you know after a good quarter of the game maximum people have kind of got the gist of how this passenger is meant to move even if they're a complete noob to this game it is just a really simplistic teach and that goes a long way gateway level I don't know its gateway level in terms of how complex of rules are but trying to figure out how to do well and move the passenger around it might be a bit much for the brand-new player I don't know this one's a hard one to gauge it could be if someone said this was a gateway game I'd be totally fine with that I'm more thinking it's a next step I think you could play something like Ticket to Ride and various other ones and get simpler experience as a gateway game but it's not far off it's a nice simple like teach but with enough death to make you like really think oh I got this really combo turn this round you know because by putting these networks here suddenly he's gone from there all the way to there he takes this huge Ruby using most of mine and then he comes back and does all this and you feel good when the passenger does what you want in the dope of course doesn't always do what you want them to do but you know

it's it's a lazy passenger you can't predict it entirely you know but it's it's still weird out of this passenger works I want to get their motivation but so although we're looking at a pretty solid here where's the negatives there is really only one negative it's a bit of a biggie but not enough to kill the game the problem that this has is that it goes from two to five players and the game length is meant to be about out to about an hour and it's 75 minutes does it actually say on the front no it doesn't look like it does but yeah you're talking about 60 to 90 minutes is what they're expecting this game to take that's accurate but it goes from two to five players and this is where things get problematic the player scaling the issue with this is that it goes in two to five but it's very much yeah the same situation as you get with a lot of games do not play this with five ever five is right out I'm so glad someone on YouTube actually told me about that me because I can't believe I've never used it in the past but yeah five if right out it really isn't that worth playing this at five because what happens is there's no solo mode unfortunately you have to buy a little mini expansion to play it solo which I have ordered I'm getting it in January so if you're very nice maybe I'll do a solo play for of the solo mode but it's two to five in two players you get four networks each and it's a really cool tug-of-war between you and your opposing player and you've got lots of options because you have four networks so you can do a couple of long couple of short you know do what you like to

player is really good and really fast free player is the ultimate sweet spot the sweet spot I know I sound like a broken record when I say free it's a sweet spot but it just really is here you know you've got enough of an interaction on the board so that it's not completely open-ended you've got free networks each not for so you've got a little a bit less choice but not like so restrictive and it goes on a nice pace even if you do have someone who's a little bit slower and also you can predict a little bit more about what the passengers gonna do into an free player because there's only so many there's only so many ways the boards they can change by the time it gets around to your turn when it gets to four and five there's where things start to get a little bit more problematic because four player is on the bar it's on the cusp of okay this is fine I when I first played it for player I thought I'd really don't like this poor player it's going on too long it's a bit 2k on it but then I played it a bit more a four player and it's like no it is not as bad as I thought and I will play this at four but I'll be a bit more picky about who I play it with because anybody who is a P in this game is going to drag this like crazy because you can't strategize on your turn you might have some idea of where you're gonna build but at the end of the day the passenger could be wanting to go from here all the way to here now so you need to react to that AP players yeah you might have a problem here with four players the board state gets a little bit more chaotic for my liking and it can drag a little bit with time because you've obviously got downtime with three other players taking

their turns but do something do something but you've only got two lines each so there's only so many ways that you can develop your track so you shouldn't have too many options to think about on your turn but because the scores are generally quite tight every point matters it doesn't feel like a point is a wasted point five though there is no point playing with survived because you still have two lines each and you've added another player so all you have done with five players is added more chaos and more time what's the point no way this was the same with the original edition Tom battle always said this was a two and three player game I personally agree with that I will play this at four though I don't think four is bad so I would call this a two to four player game best it free better to decent with four five no way no way that you might as well just cross out the five on this cover and turn it into a two to four play again because I can't imagine any reason why you would do it with five unless it's like what do you want to play this game we have five players ok fine but I will not want to be in that gauge rush me on that so that's a bit of a negatives that the player scaling doesn't quite cover the whole range but it's not the biggest problem in the world because two to four is still not bad okay come on I prefer two to free but I will still play it with four so I've got three out of four possibilities and I'm not passing the solo mode as anything here because that's a separate thing you have to buy so I'm not gonna take that into a cabin I'm reviewing this so overall on the underground is really solid I mean

everybody is coating the new these days and once they buy the new hotness it's like oh here's my tainted ground and here's my barrage and here's my gloom here and there's always new stuff here the old games are still decent winner's circle in code seven seven seven the other week and they're great games they're still my shelf old games were still good then just suddenly become obsolete and old is relative considering how many games come out each year in 2006 is still in the 21st century it's not like we're talking you know taboo in monopoly and yeah all the games from that time period we're talking about you know 13 years ago not that long when you consider in terms of time but just because the board gaming hobbyist had gone lately it's it feels older than it really is but this is a great game I would have happily played this if this was back in 2006 I'm pretty certain it would have been a favor of the year yeah went that many games released in 2006 so I guess it was nice watching in Parratt too but this is a reprint done right you know cuz the old version ascetically wasn't great it was a bit busier and a little bit more complex and places this one has streamlined it it has brought a beautiful aesthetic artwork to it it's made it more accessible to everybody it's on wide distribution this is just a solid reprint of a what must have been a classic game overall I think it just basically ticks a lot of the boxes aside from a bit of the dragging down time in too many players and the fact that because you can't strategize you have to

hope that ap players don't slow the game down for you too much so and like I said you've got two ways to play London or Berlin you know I predominantly play on London but occasionally I flip it over and play the Berlin map there's only a couple of changes how you score points but you've got an entirely new map and being English I have no idea how to pronounce or translate any of the German pins on the map it is quite insane yeah I would love to play this with a German group because I would just be like the complete outsider trying to pronounce all these place names and they just laughing at me it'd be hilarious but they're gonna bring out more map packs so we're gonna have a forget what's coming out next but I mean you could do Tokyo Paris Moscow New York there's all sorts of places around the world you could do this and you just release two maps at a time tweak the scoring perfect you've got nice easy expansion which keeps the game fresh this has got a lot of legs and I think if you have even thought about this game I'm wanting to try it I definitely recommend you do it works brilliantly as a game cafe item you know honestly excellent game yeah not quite the perfect ten out of ten but I would still give this a solid nine outta 10 and call this one of my favorites for the year it is one that you need to check out one that you should definitely get around to video at least having a look at and playing and I would like to think that most of you would be like yeah this is actually really cool and possibly grab it later but of course we all like different games but for me it's just really solid really smooth really like it so that's on the

underground from Looney creations and that's it for me for reviews for the rest of this year have a great Christmas as again I don't know what order I'm going to do these videos so I think I'll just say a Christmas message in every video from this point onwards but you know certainly this is the last review I will do for this year so take care have a great break and I'll see you in 2020 where hopefully we'll get even more great games take care and I'll see you next time

you

Progress saved