On the Underground Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About On the Underground
On the Underground is a route-building train game first released in 2006 and published by Ludi Creations, and the reviewers in this set describe it as a solid, approachable game with a lot of tension packed into a short session. The Broken Meeple reviewed it as a dependable title that still earns its place on the shelf, calling it smooth and easy to like even though not every player will love it. Board Game Coffee said the group that played it with them liked it a lot, and placed it in the same family as Ticket to Ride while noting that it is a bit more complicated.
Player count is where the discussion gets most specific. The Dice Tower hosts who placed On the Underground in their top picks for three-player games argued that three players creates the most interaction, because rival lines compete for the same stations and the passenger route becomes harder to predict. Another Dice Tower host said the game is best at two and three players and that they would not play it with more than three. Across these reviews, the consensus is that two and three players are the sweet spot, with four and five players getting noticeably busier.
Core Mechanics That Define On the Underground
Route Building
Players draw track across a shared map of London or Berlin, connecting stations, landmarks, terminus stations, and national rail stops. Reviewers describe every line as a contested investment: placing track extends your own network, and the same connection can score when it links to landmarks of the same type, completes a loop, or reaches a terminus. The number of lines that can occupy a connection matches the number of lines already linking those two stations, and each station needs one line in and one line out unless a player spends branch tiles to bypass that rule. The result is a map that fills up quickly as players compete for the same routes.
Action Points
Each turn is split into an action phase and a passenger phase. In the action phase a player spends a fixed number of actions, typically four after the first round, and the walkthrough reviewers describe lets players either place track or take a branch tile. Turn in two branch tiles and a line can start from a station other than the ends of your existing line. The opening round gives each seat a different action count, so the first player in a three-player game takes three actions, the second takes four, and the third takes five. That early asymmetry shapes how the first round unfolds, and it is the detail reviewers mention most when explaining the game's rhythm.
The On the Underground Experience
Dramatic Tension Around Shared Lines
Reviewers describe On the Underground as a game where other players are always one tile away from changing your plans. The Dice Tower hosts say the tension of rival lines is what makes the three-player game sing, because you are not just building your network but deciding which rival's track you will cross or leave alone. A line that looked like a sure path can be blocked by someone else's connection on the next turn, and that unpredictability keeps every session feeling competitive without tipping into chaos.
Narrative-Driven Route Puzzles
The passenger token gives each session a small story. Reviewers describe it as a character that always takes the easiest route, which turns the game into a question of anticipating its path. One Dice Tower host describes the goal as setting up a connection that the passenger will choose, and the same host says the finished network looks like a subway map when it is done.
What Makes On the Underground Stand Out
The Passenger Mechanic
The passenger is the feature reviewers most often single out. Each round, the passenger moves toward Express and standard destinations by the least walking, then by the fewest exchanges between lines, and the players who own the lines it uses score points. That rule creates a constant incentive to build connections that the passenger will choose, so one player's route can become a valuable payout for another. Reviewers describe the effect as turning every new track into a small strategic bet on where the passenger will go next.
Multiple Maps and a Recognizable Look
Reviewers note that On the Underground is sold in several versions with different city maps, which lets a group keep playing without repeating the same board. The Dice Tower hosts singled out the cover and the finished look of the map, saying the game's visual identity makes it feel like a subway system coming together. Board Game Coffee pointed out that the Paris and New York releases use the same core mechanics as the London and Berlin originals, with some added rules.
Potential Drawbacks
A Ten-Step Setup
A detailed rules walkthrough shows that setup takes ten steps before the first turn. Players lay out the main board, pick a passenger token, place connection tiles on the green stations, shuffle and place destination cards, and then choose a score tile based on player count. Each player also gathers track tokens in the colors shown on their score tile, and the Berlin version adds stacks of landmark tiles to sort and place. Reviewers who know the game well find this manageable, but newcomers will need patience before play begins.
Crowding at Four and Five Players
One Dice Tower host says that with four and five players the game gets too muddled, which is the main reason that reviewer prefers two or three players. The same host also notes that the game is still playable at two, so the concern is about the crowded table rather than the rules themselves.
If You Enjoy On the Underground
Players who enjoy On the Underground's route building will find a similar satisfaction in Ticket to Ride, which Board Game Coffee cited as the obvious point of comparison even while noting that On the Underground is a bit more complicated and adds the extra wrinkle of a passenger moving across everyone's shared network.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Of course we all like different games, but for me it's just really solid, really smooth, really like it."
— The Broken Meeple
"On the Underground I played this with Brittany and Kayla quite a bit and they both really liked it. I I really like this game."
— Board Game Coffee
"There's more competition. There's also just another set of eyes kind of guiding, being like, “No, no, this is the easiest path.” Something about just having the extra set of eyes that can catch that."
— The Dice Tower