Mansions of Madness 2nd Edition: A Buyer's Guide
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we are bored of it and Welcome to our Mansions of Madness second edition buyer's guide maybe you've heard of mansions of Madness and you're interested in it but you're worried about the extent of the app integration maybe you already own mentions of Madness and you're wondering which of the many many expansions you should get first or maybe you just want an overview of all of the expansions and what they come with well fear not we've got it all covered in our buyer's guide so as you might know if you've seen these before our buyer's guides are generally factual until the end where we give our honest opinion but mostly we're here to tell you what's what so we're going to start by telling you what Manchester Madness is we're going to then tell you how you can play it tell you what content is available what you need to know before buying it and finally what we think and it's important to note that this video was essentially made possible by asthma day nordics as they provided us with all the expansions that you see here but the base game and the extra dice pack we bought ourselves so just know that going before we get deep into the buyer's guide we just want to ask you to please please consider subscribing to our channel the number of subscribers we have means that it's more likely for us to be able to do this kind of content it makes us more attractive to Publishers to work with us and to be able to get this content and to bring you more bias guides more reviews and we really really
appreciate every subscriber that we get we can see in our analytics a lot of our viewers aren't actually subscribed to us so if you're one of those people please just hit subscribe and we can continue bringing you more content thank you thank you Manchester Vans first edition was first released in 2011 published by Fantasy Flight games and designed by Corey caneska in this one player would take on the role of the keeper a kind of pseudo DM who ran the scenarios and would control the forces of evil who played against another one four players who each took on the role of a single investigator who were trying to solve the mystery to feed the forces of evil if you've ever played any of fantasy flights other Arkham Horror games then you're pretty much up to speed because it's the same lovecraftian setting with the same investigators now we're not going to go go too much further into the first edition because it's out of print and we have not played it the reason it's how to print is because in 2016 Fantasy Flight games released a second edition of Manchester Madness this one designed by Nikki Valance based on the design by Corey canaska in this which is for one to five players there is no keeper anymore instead a companion app takes care of everything the keeper took care of meaning that all players will now play as investigators so you're going to pick your investigators form a team then you're
going to pick a scenario the app's going to tell you how to do the basic setup and then throughout the game the app's kind of going to randomize events monsters items what you find what's in a room the map layout things like that to make it a bit more replayable and essentially what you're doing is trying to defeat the forces of evil or maybe solve a mystery before the forces of evil kind of break your body or your mind or maybe both again like the first edition this is a lacrosse team game full of cosmic horror unspeakable evils and loss of 17. although there is an element of humor that kind of runs underneath everything and in fact Manchester Savannah's second edition is a lot like Scooby-Doo the board game just with the horror turned up to 11. the scenarios are really varied and they can kind of run the Gambit from All Out monster brawler to literally logic deduction puzzle with no monsters in sight as you try and solve who don't did a murder now Manchester run the second edition is currently the 53rd best game of all time as rated by Board Game Geek which attest to his popularity especially considering how old this game or Elisa's series of games is
the role-playing and immersion to shine first you're going to pick an investigator to play as which is a character that has a special ability and some different stats for dice checks then you'll pick a scenario to play and complete the setup based on what the app tells you on the table you're going to have the room tiles on which the Miniatures monsters and various tokens will be placed telling you what can be interacted with and where you can go as you explore more more of the map will be uncovered and you'll Place more run tiles as the app directs you the game is played over a series of rounds until time runs out and players fail the scenario all the investigators complete the scenario the first phase will see each investigator taking a turn on which they can take two actions the majority of the time will be spent moving around interacting with things in the room finding new rooms and solving puzzles to interact with something in a room you'll click on that token within the app and then it will direct you what to do or inform you about what happens there are some other actions like attack and evade which come into play when monsters are present as well as a handful of rare actions which are used situationally if at all like setting fire to a room once each investigator has taken a turn the Mythos phase will happen in which bad stuff happens to the investigators as directed by the app you'll also often have a variety of item cards which can help you in some way some negative
conditions which will hinder you in some way as well as mental and physical damage which may or may not lead to ongoing negative conditions much of what you'll be doing requires stat checks where your roll dice equal to the value that you have for that stat so if you have a strength of four and you're trying to break down a door you'll roll four dice and then enter the number of successes that you get on those dice into the app and it will tell you if you succeeded or not now obviously the goal of each scenario will be slightly different but on the whole you're trying to uncover what happened by gathering Clues and evidence to then use it in the Final Act to try and stop whatever heinous ritual is about to occur this might require fighting a boss or deducing which of the many characters that you met along the way is responsible for the situation that you now find yourselves in foreign of course there's the base game Mansions of Madness second edition this comes with all of the content that you need to play such as the room tiles the cards the dice the Miniatures Etc the base game comes with eight investigators and four scenarios and it also comes with a conversion kit so the owners of mansions of Madness first edition can incorporate that content into this game giving more variety for the app to draw on now you do need to have the app in order to play but it is free to download from a variety of sources and you can toggle
off and on what content you have so from Mansion to minus 2 it can be incorporated accordingly there's also a dice pack that can be purchased to expand your pool of dice in case what comes with the base game isn't enough spoiler alert it isn't Then There are a whopping 10 expansions available for Mansions of Madness second edition three of these are Standalone DLC scenarios which can be paid for in the app and any require the base game to play these are titled what lies within altered Fates and dark Reflections these are generally recommended to get because they're seen as most cost effective way to acquire new and official Mansions of Madness content and sometimes they can also be found on sale to be aware though you can't transfer these scenarios from one device to another so if you buy them on your phone and you want to have it on your iPad then you will have to pay for it again then two of the expansions are essentially conversion kits for content for the original Mansions of Madness they're entitled recurring nightmares and suppressed memories and for all intents and purposes are now out of Prem recurring nightmares contains one scenario eight investigators from the original Mansions of Madness as well as many of the rimtiles and miniatures suppressed memories contains very similar content to the original two expansions four mansions of Madness
first edition these are generally not recommended as they're considered kind of worst value for money for all of these expansions the investigators are considered boring not very interesting or overpowered and neither of the scenarios is very highly rated because they're now only available on the second hand Market with no plans for reprint they're only really for the die-hard fans or the completionists okay so there's five expansions left there are two small box expansions and three big books these add some new scenarios investigators spells conditions items monsters tiles and even some new mechanisms beyond the threshold and sanctum of Twilight are the two small box expansions and add to scenarios to investigators and some small amounts of all of the good stuff just listed beyond the threshold has some good scenarios but they're more close in style to the scenarios in the original base game whereas sanctum pushes the boat out a little bit more the scenario is a little bit more different and unique and it comes with some great investigators however whilst one of its scenarios is one of the most beloved and considered one of the most highly rated which is a Twilight of diadem the other one is considered the the hardest and the most unfair out of all of them which is called the high and closed doors and finally we have the three big box expansions streets of Arkham horrific
Journeys and the path of the serpent in these three big boys you'll get three new scenarios four investigators as well as a bunch of new cards monsters puzzles and mechanisms these are some of the best content that Manchester mana's second edition has to offer as they take the scenarios out of the old musty houses and into the wider world the streets of Arkham is set in the town of Arkham and has some great scenarios involving gangs museums and universities horrific Journeys sees you on a train boats and Zeppelins and has some of if not the most imaginative content out of all of mansions of Badness then the path of the serpent we'll see you in some ancient Chambers and the deep dark jungle similar to a very Twisted sort of Indiana Jones Style
what do you need to know well there are a few things actually but please keep in mind before we get into this that we really enjoy playing Manchester on the second edition some of the experiences it gives are really unrivaled in the hobby and we're not trying to be negative we're just trying to tell you things we think you should know so you can make an informed opinion before you buy it so the first thing this is an app-based board game if you're someone who's not sure about apps and board games or if you straight out dislike apps being in board games I don't really know why you're watching this video but it's not going to be for you the app is really integrated and it does a lot of heavy lifting so much so that it is possible to play this with only the app although it will require a lot of effort from your part to put placeholders in but people have done it then the app is a little bit old and clunky and it is prone to glitches so you could have a game ruined which to be fair has only happened to us once out of the many many plays we have had but it's still something to think about and lastly you know the app is functional it sits out to do what it wants to do and it does it without fuss because the app can randomize the layouts the events that happen the monster dot spawn the items you find and even the solutions to Mysteries there is replayability thanks to the app however one thing we would
say is that it's somewhat alluded to that as you buy expansions and content that the app's going to have more of wealth to draw from because how it works is you will take what expansions you have in the app and then you would theorize that that will then content will show up in whatever scenario you play however we would say it's a little bit of a fallacy in that the expansion content is going to show up far less than you expect it would many of the map tiles mechanisms introduced in the expansions are very specific to a single scenario meaning that you're not going to see them in other scenarios and just as an example the kind of thing we're talking about you get Improvement tokens in the streets of Falcon expansion very simple mechanism very easy to include in any scenario essentially if you have one of these tokens that stat that it matches is boosted by one then if you lose it you go down to your normal Style again it could be used anywhere however we've barely seen it used since we've had that expansion we've played a bunch more games and funnily enough most of the times we have seen it even mentioned have been lose an improvement token rather than gain one I think we've only ever gained two maybe three out of all the place since getting that expansion
each scenario has a number of different map layouts but these numbers aren't large and having the all the expansion tiles doesn't really increase that variability ironically the scenario that is most variable once you have all the content is supposedly the intro scenario which is essentially a tutorial so not something that you want to be replaying again and again now this isn't to say that there isn't replayability there definitely is we're just saying that if you buy an expansion and it has some new mechanisms or tiles don't expect things in other scenarios to be really chifferent next time you play also aware of the length many scenarios you're looking at two hours minimum and a lot of them go much longer than that let's not say it's a negative just be aware because you're not going to get this out for a quick session and on the same topic a lot of people might not like the way the scenarios end because what Manchester Madness does is a lot of scenarios have a hidden timer that's counting down and if you don't finish everything time you fail and it can be really obtuse about how long this timer is or how much time you have or one thing that it will do that we find a little bit annoying is rather than just calling into the scenario it will basically try and some other you to death by just pouring out an insane amount of monsters on the board and so you get slowly being to death and then
have the pleasure of managing six monsters at once it's a little bit frustrating it's also worth mentioning that Manchester Madness is unfriendly to lower play accounts if we're going to play solo or with just two of us we're always including extra investigators and you can argue that the app increases the amount of time you have if you say you're playing with less investigators but it just does not balance out at all because think about it if you for investigators standing in a Lobby they can all open one room they're next to and investigate something in that room in one round whereas if you only had two investigators in play it would take at least three rounds to do that same amount of room openings and investigations on top of that the less investigators you have the smaller the pool of skills you have the smaller number of special abilities do you have and probably the small number of different items you have when you start the game let alone pick up along the way so it just puts you at a general disadvantage as well finally in really positive news one thing everyone who has this game or is thinking about buying this game should know is there is a fan made app called Valkyrie which is where people create their own scenarios for matches of Madness and there's a rating system so you can see which ones people like and don't like you can kind of edit for what expansions you have and it's such a great resource that I wish more people knew about because I mean maybe
it's just me but I didn't know about this until after we put out our review of the game last year and somebody commented and I've played a few scenarios in there and they were as good of quality as the base game and it's important because base game is expensive and this makes it almost infinitely replayable with no extra kind of expansion buying needed
functions of Madness from that last section but we do actually think it's a brilliant time we just think it's important to know those things before you get invested and potentially get caught out margins of Badness is relatively easy to play and it's pretty dynamic in terms of what you'll experience it really excels at facilitating role-playing player interaction so you'll quickly be drawn into its world many of the scenarios are excellently designed and to be honest some of the most fun we've had in the hobby has been playing Manchester Madness the laughter we've had role playing our characters and putting our own spin on what's happening in the scenarios doing voices that kind of thing you know the thrill of solving a murder mystery seconds before the Airship were on got sucked into a cosmic void scribbling pages of notes as you try to decipher which artifact in the museum has cursed and something that really elevates all this and facilitates a role-playing is a subtle edge of humor that runs beneath a lot of things in Manchester Madness and I really enjoy that and it brings a lot of fun and you can play around with it and it's just really nice to have something like this that you can basically the extent where you can almost Teach as you play but offers you all these experiences so what do we think well obviously we enjoy the base game although we've already set our reservations as well but we're not going to talk about it too much just because we
actually have a full review of the base game so if you really want to know because obviously I'll support everything go check that out but you should have a pretty good idea from what we've said so far basically yeah exactly for now we're just gonna talk about the kind of other content and what we think so first up we definitely recommend getting the extra dice pack if you think this is a game that you're going to be playing a lot because the base game only comes with five dice yeah right which is just not enough it's pretty painful because everyone's always going to be rolling dice it's pretty much what you're doing every turn yeah so it is pretty painful to have to keep passing them around it's just a nice quality of life Improvement we'd also recommend getting the DLC particularly if it's on sale because we think the scenarios they're pretty fun and then you've pretty much doubled the scenarios that you get in the base game just from getting the DLC yeah they also they're definitely the best value for money that you can get to increase your experience with Manchester Madness because they're only a couple of dollars each even cheaper if they're on sale yeah um and they don't require any any other expansions so you're already good to go with the base game so they're quite nice pretty cool but I agree with the dice as well I it's probably the most annoying thing I had with the base game especially we usually never played with more than three I think people yeah and even passing around because you have to
do these checks in the Mythos phase every turn and to keep passing dice around it's just a bit tedious I can't imagine with five yeah it was pretty nice when we had the last time exactly and it's already a long game yeah in terms of the other expansions then we would oh I recommend them for their content but a little bit of an issue with Mansions of Madness more generally is the price so if you really wanted to collect everything that is going to cost you hundreds and hundreds of dollars the base game is usually what 100 yeah like 100 maybe a little bit more and then each expansion maybe 60 or 70. for the big the big three and then a bit less for the smaller ones so it's going to cost you a lot if you really want everything and maybe that's kind of okay but you really get value for money because the app isn't I mean it's fine but it's not world class The Minis are okay the kind of quality of the components is okay but maybe not for that kind of money right yeah I mean the minis are pretty much universally derided as being a bit crappy because not necessarily the quality of them but the fact that they come in these weird little stands yeah you have to plug them into and they fall off and I think we ended up super gluing all ours actually uh because we knew we were going to play the game a lot especially now we have all this but yeah and I mean going back you only get five dice in a game that all you do is roll
dice right yeah there's not that much in there like I know you get a lot of minis yeah it's not yeah exactly it's not so much substance let's say for for that kind of price yeah so it's definitely the biggest issue with Manchester Madness and I think one of the problem slash good things all in one about the expansions is that none of them really shake up the gameplay they're just more and different scenarios but it's the kind of game that that's where you want you want the new experiences within the same format with literal changes but you just want to experience more stuff so that's great because you can get any one of them that's what you're getting but then it kind of sucks that you have to pay all this money just to kind of be getting more and more yeah and I mean the base game only comes with four scenarios which isn't great when some of these expansions come with three Yeah so basically what we're saying is that is the biggest thing to be aware of before we start talking about these uh expansions particularly because we were gifted them so it's easy for us to recommend them essentially but we can tell them what our favorite one is yeah that's horrific Journeys yeah so horrific Journeys all three uh scenarios uh knock it right out of the park they're the most interesting I think and I think two out of the three are probably our top two favorites that we've played so far yeah or that we've played what I really liked about it is it's tapping more into murder mystery
than the horror theme and yeah maybe maybe other people wouldn't like that so much because you go into Mansions of Madness like wanting the horror theme and I'm not against it but for me personally I just think that's a really nice angle to it yeah um and just a fun Twist on everything I think like the different locations where you are being travel and it's just quite unique I would say yeah 100 I think and the scenarios are really interesting there's one on Zeppelin there's one on train uh that and a cruise and they're all kind of change up your perspective of what you think might happen a little bit then when you move to the other two big box expansions path of The Serpent and the streets of Arkham they're on about a level for us they both have good scenarios uh they are you know they're a bit of a mix I wouldn't say any of them are bad I wouldn't say any of them are as good as horrific Journeys this is obviously personal opinion um but you could do either I think it just depends where you want because Puff The Serpent it takes you out of Arkham into the jungle it becomes more like horror Indiana Jones you're going into tombs you're in the jungle uh it's a bit more different than anything else that's kind of come before except for maybe horrific Journeys whereas streets of Arkham has some great scenarios but it's more rounded it it's good that it takes the system kind of outside of mansions yeah and you do have
some interesting stuff there is one with gangsters yeah that was pretty cool there's the four mentioned one in the museum that I talked about there's also a little bit more of the same that you got in the base game in terms of the structure and what's going on so it just depends really what you're looking for those two but either one good option so then we come down to be on the threshold and sanctum of Twilight these are the smaller ones and we're kind of having these at the back not because there's anything particularly wrong with them but just because they they offer less they're less interesting they're more aligned with the base game uh but there's still good scenarios so I think you might want to weigh it up because the sanction of Twilight it has one scenario that's kind of seen as one of the best and often voted as the best scenario out of all the Manchester commanders second edition of scenarios the other one is known for not being very good or not well liked so you kind of have the balance whereas with beyond the threshold it is more in the middle they're both liked well enough but they're not I think winning any awards so that's some things you want the high and low or do you want the middle and the last thing is the valkyrie app which is I mean definitely recommend even if you have the base game it's going to give you a lot of replayability uh there's a lot of creative things on there and it's really nice that there's this fan Community with Manchester banners that you can use to extend your game
even if you know it kind of makes it maybe worth it a bit more to splurge on the base game even if the price is a bit much for you because then you have this extra content you can just throw in yeah it doesn't cost anything so that's quite cool and do you have any final thoughts on everything Manchester Savanna's yeah I mean it's always just a really good time obviously like you said before maybe part of that is usually when we play the different people we play with we're bringing the role-playing Vibes and you know we're I guess lifting it off the board a little bit more but uh always a good time to be hard what about you yeah I mean it's funny because it's it's probably I mean it's up there as one of our favorite co-op games I guess right yeah yeah um and we're not so Co-op and usually we aren't enamored so much with let's say hard difficulty games where you can just like die if you know what I mean as you can do in here but I think because of the story and the role playing uh you know it's it's much better to not feel like you've failed and rather feel like you've just come to the end of your journey and your characters had a grisly death uh because you've had a lot of fun in the way so it doesn't matter so much it's as cliches is more the experience than having the end because usually the end is like a crappy paragraph that's like and they did some stuff the end right so it definitely is about the
journey here definitely Elder Chara which makes me sad every time see I like El chachorro by playing it solo but this is definitely yeah the fun is in in the journey whereas yeah yeah so that was our buyer's guide for Manchester Madness second edition we really hope it was helpful please uh let us know if it was please like comment and of course if you have any Mansions of Madness questions ask us wherever you see this and please consider subscribing because it would mean a lot to us it really helps describe the channel but don't consider it just do it yeah you're right I'm tired of saying please consider it just just do it now do subscribe because it literally you know it's what people look at when they look at our Channel if they want to work with us and it makes videos like this happen because it'll be very tough for us to do a video this magnitude without help yes so please please subscribe if you haven't already or if you found this helpful but thanks so much for watching and we'll see you next time with more buyers guides and our usual reviews see ya bye