Skip to main content
Loading video...

Buy or Skip The Mix? Best Cocktail Crafting Worker Placement Board Game?

Transcript 15:15

We just wrapped up watching every drop of footage available for The Mix, and I can't believe how much there is to unpack from all those preview demonstrations and campaign details.

The Mix, should you buy it or should you skip? That's what this episode is all about. And don't worry, we're going to have some laughs before we finish.

So, here's what we're working with. The Mix is this cocktail crafting worker placement game where you're a fresh bartender at the Foxtrop Bar aiming to outplay the competition by making the most impressive drinks. We didn't get a review copy, but we watched every available bit of gameplay footage, dug into the campaign page, and dissected everything we could find. That's our whole review angle, just what we observed and analyzed.

Yeah, and the campaign numbers are wild. It's designed by Gilm and published by Ruse Games. funding on Gamefound. It's already hit over 380% of its goal, 77,621 Canadians from 337 backers, which tells you people are definitely interested. We saw the game supports 1 to four players, aiming for a 60-minute session, and it's for ages 14 and up. Though, based on the rules, it's got a fair bit of crunch.

There's a bunch of pledge tiers. base retail edition for $ C90. Premium at $120 with triple layer boards and wooden tokens. Then the big ones, gameplay and master editions go all the way up to $2 and $250 if you want expansions in every add-on. Shipping covers everywhere, US, Canada, Europe, UK, Asia, Australia, and it's available in English, French, and German. plus stretch bowls, linen finish cards, gold foil, a dual layer main board, and a shooters mini expansion. There's still some extra stuff getting unlocked, like the tools mini and a special combo cocktail card if they hit certain milestones, but we both noticed how much of it is still presented as planned rather than locked in, especially with only prototype components shown.

Yeah, it's all previews. The campaign mentions most likely using long pack games for manufacturing. But even in the footage, they're very clear these are not final components, just polished renders. So backers are pledging based on promises instead of finished products. That jumped out to us right away,

which makes sense because as we watch through everything, every rules demo or playthrough is using those prototype boards and placeholder bits. No sign of finished manufacturing samples yet. eight months out from delivery. That's a pretty standard thing for crowdfunding, but it's worth keeping in mind.

Exactly. And we noticed the rule book's not final. There's even a timeline on the campaign. 5 months just to finalize files and rules with a lot of still developing caveats. That has some big implications for gameplay expectations and balance. But more on that when we get into the nitty-gritty.

So, let's set the stage here. worker placement, engine building, offset round structure, lots of component ambition, plus strong market interest, and a very themeheavy approach. That's what got our attention.

Totally. And given all that, let's dig into what makes the mix tick. Starting with how the gameplay actually works.

Now, this is where things get interesting. The mix doesn't play out like most standard worker placement games, at least based on the demonstrations we watched. Instead of everyone taking turns together, each player finishes their entire round of worker placements at their own pace depending on how many workers they've unlocked.

That offset round structure actually feels fresh for the genre. So, you're starting with three workers, and as you gain experience by triggering book symbols on the experience board, eventually you'll unlock a fourth worker about halfway through the game. That gives you more actions per round and ramps up the tempo, which we saw play out nicely in the footage,

right? And the experience system doesn't just unlock extra workers. Every time you hit a new level, you get to snag these experience tiles, which provide ongoing bonuses, like getting a free shaker token when you take a new client card. One strategy we saw was chaining client pickups with tech upgrades to fuel your combo engine.

And speaking of engines, the main action loop revolves around five core moves. selecting clients, gathering ingredients, crafting cocktails, developing techniques, acquiring mixer tokens, and progressing that experience track. Client cards are your scoring core. You choose which mixology challenges to pursue, each with different recipe requirements. You grab ingredients from a communal supply, 180 wooden tokens in the premium edition. Building up your inventory to match with the client's demand is basically a little tactical puzzle each round. Once you've collected what you need, you convert those into finished cocktails to score points and sometimes trigger bonuses.

Techniques are real source of strategic depth. You can only pick up one per turn, and they cost shaker tokens, which are always tight, but each technique card increases your technique die, more scoring at the end, and also gives ongoing abilities. Choosing which techniques to invest in versus chasing client fulfillment is a huge part of your game plan. Don't forget the setup turn. After you've used up all your workers, you trigger a reset. You pull them back and refresh certain action spaces on your boards. There's some cool timing decisions around whether to squeeze out one more action or just reset early and reposition for the next cycle. Endgame triggers vary by player count. In some of the demos, regular games ended after 15 clients were served, but a two-player game ended at 9. The campaign says the actual thresholds depend on number of players, so pacing looks thoughtfully tuned to prevent dragging things out.

Scoring's pretty comprehensive. Points for cash, leftover ingredients, shaker tokens, technique dive values, completed client cards, experience tiles, minus penalties for missed upkeep. There's endgame objectives for sets of clients, techniques, and big combos. and you accuse me of glossing over the engine building part, but you can absolutely lean into different strategies. We saw footage of someone going techniqueheavy and another Russian clients. There's a lot of variability if everyone's choosing different paths.

The tactical and strategic options seem decently broad, so there's potential for replay-ability if you mix up your approach. But let's pivot to what actually wowed us. Okay, let's talk about the best stuff because the mix genuinely has standout elements and I want to give the campaign its due. First, that theme integration, it's not just pasted on in the footage, collecting specific ingredient tokens to make real cocktails, upgrading bartending techniques that actually speed up your workflow. It feels like you're running a bar, not just pushing cubes.

And the component ambition impressed us. The triple layer boards, player, shaker, and bar space, look amazing in renders. If they actually deliver what's promised, it's top tier organization and durability. Wooden ingredient tokens and linen finished cards up the tactile satisfaction, which is massive for a game you want repeated on your table.

Art and iconography are a win, too. The campaign page and what we saw on footage shows vibrant cocktail art, colorful tokens, clear iconography. The client cards depict real recipes. The entire table setup feels lively, not clinical.

There's personality, which is rare in a mediumweight Euro. On the gameplay side, that offset round structure could be a smart fix for usual worker placement downtime. Nobody's locked out waiting for other players. In our viewing, everyone was engaged every round.

Experience-based progression is super satisfying. Unlocking that precious fourth worker right as your operation peaks. It's a cool arc. Moving from constrained early choices to an engine humming along. The engine building lets you chase different bonuses, tech, clients, experience. You can go for quick points, combo strategies, or balance it all. Even funding pace says something. This campaign reached its goal in just over an hour and sits at nearly 400% funded. The market's responding, the theme's appealing, and the publisher seems to understand modern backer expectations. I know you geeked out over those neat recessed areas for tokens and cards on the boards

for sure. That's what keeps the game smooth. No messy table setups.

And we have to acknowledge engine building depth feels present. Multiple viable strategies, technique versus client focus, or mixing approaches to optimize points. Even across limited footage, every preview had players building different combos.

It's worth noting though, everything impressive is based on prototype observations, not final delivered components. No guarantee these production specs will hit the table as shown,

but if the campaign delivers, the premium edition could be a fantastic value. Top tier presentation and true sematic gameplay. All right, before we get too stareyed, let's talk about what honestly didn't land for us.

Yeah, because there's a whole list coming up. Number one, severe limits on what we actually got to watch. All the preview material we saw just rules explanations in peacemeal playthroughs. Not even one full game from start to finish. We couldn't observe long-term balance, interaction, or how play time holds up.

That's especially tough because they promise a 60-minute play time across one to four players, but not one demo confirmed the timing, just theory. We didn't spot any tests of scaling at three or four players. The only clear setup was with two, and it ended after nine clients. What about more? How does downtime and blocking work with a crowd?

And worker placement blocking tension seemed underexplored. We didn't see enough competitive play to judge if strategies become stale or if dominant paths emerge once people grock the system. It's high risk to back at these prices when real world gameplay is untested.

The rule book's a work in progress marked as draft right there. Campaign timelines suggest rules are months away from locked with unknown balance or solo development status. That's a red flag.

And manufacturing uncertainty, most likely longpacked games isn't enough reassurance for a campaign collecting real money now. There's no mention of what happens if plans change, pricing shifts, or manufacturing quality doesn't pan out. Backers have no guarantees.

Even the endgame trigger rule isn't explained clearly. In some previews, it's 15 clients for a base game. In another, it's nine for two players. The campaign itself never puts end conditions in writing. That's a fundamental rule that needs clarity.

Solo mode is completely unressed in every bit of footage or documentation. No mention of AI systems, solo setup, or any actual solo gameplay. For solo gamers, there's nothing to go on except trust in the publisher. That's disappointing for a one to four player title.

The offset round approach fixes some downtime, but might add confusion if people aren't aligned timing wise. Blocking could get muddled and tracking game states might get messy. Analysis paralysis risk rises as people hesitate, unsure when to reset or press for more actions. Even the shooters and tools mini expansions are just titles. No details at all. We couldn't figure out what components or mechanics they bring or how they're balanced. It definitely feels like some stretch goals got added just to drive funding.

Replayability is an open question. Eight mixologist powers, 48 client cards, and 15 experience tiles sound like plenty, but how much variety do you really get after a dozen plays? Are powers unique or just tweaks to numbers? All the component previews we saw, prototype only with big disclaimers that nothing shown is final. Plenty of campaigns promise the world and deliver less. They're asking for faith, not proof.

Bundle pricing is tricky. That big markup for gameplay and master editions C80 to 130 more than premium edition doesn't feel justified by the actual add-ons and stretch goals listed. The math is fuzzy. Overall, backing means gambling on early design development rather than paying for finished polish. Every playthrough we watched left major questions unanswered.

All right, so where do we both land after all that? For me, it's a cautious interest. The theme, the components, the engine building, all the pieces are there, but the absence of tested gameplay, unfinished rules, ambiguous manufacturing, and lack of solo details are substantial risks. My rating is a hesitant 6.5 out of 10. pending major updates.

I'm right there, too. There's genuine potential, and I'd love to see the mix fulfilled and reviewed in full, but there's too much missing for a recommendation. The offset rounds, progression system, and thematic flare earn credit, but without verified gameplay, it's risky. If I had to decide now, I'm in the wait for retail or future reviews camp.

If what we watched actually translates in the final product, sure, I'd grab it at retail, especially the premium edition. But spending C dollar $120 to 250 on a promise, that's not for me. Skip for most backers unless you're obsessed with the cocktail theme or want to support the publisher directly.

It sounds harsh, but it's an honest verdict. There's too much uncertainty, even with a campaign this popular.

Now, let's break down who this game is really meant for based on everything we could dig up.

So, if you love the cocktail theme, really want that mixology experience, it's a standout. The mechanics tie in closely. You'll be matching real ingredient tokens, planning client orders like a bartender, optimizing your operation with technique upgrades.

Experienced Eurogamers should appreciate the multiple engine paths and tactical choices between client pursuits, technique focus, or a mixing approaches to optimize points. There's legitimate depth to how you pursue clients, techniques, and experience combos.

But beginners might land in choppy waters. There's a bit of rules and combo complexity, and with a non-traditional turn structure, learning curve is steeper than the average worker placement. Not the best first euro.

Game groups with three players will probably get the best pacing. Boast on what we saw. Two players looked solid. Offset rounds work well when tracking a single opponent.

If you want solo play, watch out. There's just no info. And if you're shopping for value, premium edition is best. Skip higher bundles unless something specific strongly appeals. cocktail enthusiasts, Eurogamer, tacticians, people after something visually fun. If that's you, consider it. If you want replay-ability over a dozen plays, or clear solo rules, hold off for full reviews.

If you're looking for proven worker placement with engine building, and tight component quality, we both think Vidaulture, Everdell, and Dune Imperium are safer bets. They've got verified retail versions, deep replay-ability, and solid solo modes. Not risk, just reward. Those alternatives sacrifice the unique cocktail twist, but you get certainty. The mix is a gamble, not a sure thing.

So, here's our word to the wise. Buy only if you adore the theme or want the most ambitious presentation. Otherwise, wait and watch. Plenty of great games are already thriving at retail.

Well, that was a wild ride. If you stuck with us through all those ingredients, shakers, and prototype boards, thanks for tuning in.

We might someday mix up cocktails at this table if the game gets finished and delivered. Thanks for joining us on Board Game Critique.

Progress saved