Skip to main content
Loading video...

Herbaceous VS Floriferous: This IS WAR. | Top Board Game Reviews

Transcript 14:01

are you someone who considers themselves as having a little bit of a green thumb or maybe like cutting and collecting flowers and arranging them for that very special someone well if you like either of those things then get ready to get your plant clippers out because we'll be comparing two small box competitive plant themed games herbaceous and floriferous to see which game will outgrow and out compete the other wow nice plants can i pick some whoa hang on a minute one does simply not pick a plant first of all you've got to peruse them and then strategize and then peruse and strategize again look i just couldn't help myself i had to pick them all have you ever wanted to grow your very own herb garden everyone dreams of having the perfect herb garden where they can grow plant and cultivate fresh herbs it's kind of like a chef's dream but that's the thing right we grow these green things we plant them in the soil we care and tend to them every day by watering them but then one day we decide that they're ready to be yanked out of their habitat thrown into a hot frying pan fried to a crisp and digest them sounds pretty voracious i mean herbaceous right in herbaceous each play will be aiming to gain the greatest number of victory points possible by collecting and potting herbs from the community and private gardens like a sunday market each play will have four different types

of containers each with a specific requirement a large pot for gathering the same type of herb a wooden planter for different types of herbs a small pot for pairs of herbs and a glass jar for the special herbs across the game each player will take turns drawing cards off the top of his garden deck and they'll decide whether to place the herb in either the community garden or their own private garden the community garden is a shared pool of cards that any place can access whilst the private garden is for personal use only players then draw a second card and then place the card in the other garden where the first card did not get placed in at the beginning of a turn players can choose to pot herbs into a single container this means that they can gather herbs from both the shared community garden and their own private garden and pot them in their container the catch here is that players will only be allowed to pop each container once throughout an entire game so deciding the best time to take the cards is crucial and that's all there is really plays continue to admire each other's herb gardens they pay each other compliments and then they steal those curves right from under their friends noses to score important victory points have you ever considered that you could be really good at making bouquets arranging flowers or have you ever wanted to dabble in the art of floral growth well in the game of floriferous players will be wandering through the garden clipping flowers and ruining the garden as they go to produce the most blooming great floral arrangements possible a game of floriferous traverses across three days look flowers don't

bloom for very long each play's garden pawn will be allocated a row from the garden and the order in which the players will pick their flowers will go from top to bottom in pawn order the player at the top makes the first decision and chooses any card in the next column to draft whichever card they choose however will be where they must place their pawn and thus that becomes the position that they pick in the next turn so this king domino-like drafting mechanism means that the order that plays will pick flowers will constantly change want to pick a rare flower in the next column then trade it off by picking a card in the top row each flower card has certain characteristics relating to its color insect attractiveness as well as its floral species players on their turn can decide to draft a desire card these desire cards provides players with their own unique end game scoring conditions it might be gathering the same species of flower gathering flowers with a certain bug type or even flowers of different colors additionally within the deck itself there are arrangement cards that have specific combinations of color bug and species arrangements for additional progressive scoring opportunities sculpture cards provide extra points based on how many you gather throughout the game players can also gather stones on their travels these stones help you to step up in your end game points as every two stones are worth one victory point at the end of the game bounty cards are public racing objectives that rewards players the earlier that they complete them it creates a common level of tension as the game progresses overall floriferous is a

game that's budding with opportunity and deep decision making in terms of comparing the thematic immersion of both games herbaceous definitely has you feeling like you're planting sprouts you're watering them you're tendering to them and potting them and waiting for the right moment for them to be cultivated into your collection when you're looking at the theme of the game floriferous despite the fact that the cards are beautifully illustrated and i think they're nothing short of gorgeous the fact that the cards themselves or the flower species themselves don't feel distinct enough from each other or different enough from each other that the art could have easily been replaced with icons or shapes and the theme could have been completely different and the game still would have worked i feel like the flowers themselves are there just to be collected what is thematic however in florifus is the idea of walking through a garden and taking what you want also the arrangement cards that appear in the game where you can collect a particular flower of a particular color you need particular insects or particular species and connecting them together that feels lightly thematic in itself but other than that the game uh theme or floriferous does feel like it's just dressed on top or warted on top so in comparing the two i would say that herbaceous feels more thematic overall does anyone know where this goes this plant's dripping with theme so if we're comparing the car drafting mechanism that elevates and centralizes both games in herbaceous the car drafting is all about being opportunistic trying to wait for the right opportunity to maximize

the cards that you claim that match the pot that you're going to place those curves into and part of it is finding the right timing if you take it too soon you might not be able to get as many points as if you had waited another couple of turns whereas in floriferous a lot of the car drafting is open where you can see all the different icons and different types of flowers out in the field and picking what you want does influence the order that you pick in the next round and that can create a really interesting moral dilemma in itself i mean do you go for a tulip or do you nav up a desire card that will score you lots of different points at the end of the game there's quite a level of complexity that comes to the car drafting process that appears in floriferous which is probably a little bit more planned compared to herbaceous with herbaceous you do need to know the composition of the deck and how many copies of each card there are in order to gauge whether you should take a certain combination of cards from the community and private garden at the same time to pot them so in terms of the car drafting element in both games i feel like floriferous does it better herbaceous and floriferous are both essentially set collecting games and what makes them different from each other or even different from the other games well i think one of the big differences is how you actually collect the sets now i know in herbaceous it's all about having the right pots and putting the right different herbs into them but what changes herbaceous is the fact that there's a private garden and that

you can kind of hoard the herbs that you really don't want other people to get and you can kind of save up the herbs so that you can just really pot them at the right time to get the biggest amount of points possible whereas in floriferous the desire card system is a little bit more robust and gives players a little bit more ownership over how they want to tender and look after their garden i mean players are collecting cards that have bugs in them as well as cards of different colors and different species as well because players get to decide their end game scoring condition they can sometimes veer off the track and not pick a flower card and pick a desire card instead therefore personalizing and tailing their garden to their own needs so in terms of set collecting mechanics fluoriferous has my pick flip reference herbaceous herbaceous in terms of play interaction herbaceous definitely plays best at four plays when a player takes cards and pots them there's that sense of indirect interference that interferes with all players plans that has everybody grumbling around the table also when a player decides to place a card in the community garden it's always interesting to see what sort of thought process that players gone through what are they willing to offer the other players i definitely love playing herbaceous because it has this building or rising tension and that kind of racing element where you want to wait

long enough to get the best cards you don't want to wait too long just in case you miss out blooriferous also plays really well at four plays but there is also a really cool two-player variant which has an extended guard that i definitely recommend this game the interaction all is driven around fulfilling the bounty cards as well as your desire cards and the order in which you pick is probably a little sub element or twist to the game that i have only seen in games like king domino but other than that this idea of racing for common goals and fulfilling objectives is really common in a lot of games of this type of genre it's like buying a gelato and just picking another flavor it's still gelato so we definitely say that herbaceous wins in this category

when you compare the meat and bones of both games or is that leaves and roots well in terms of the strategy in both games they both offer very different experience in herbaceous drawing cards on your turn and the sequence at which the herbs appear and where they go on the play area is going to really influence the flow of the game i mean that first card that you draw i mean you've got to really decide whether you're going to keep that card and hold it for yourself to favor your own strategy or you're going to give it to your opponents and put in the community garden so that they can have it there's a huge binary decision or moral dilemma that kind of occurs when you're deciding where is the most optimal place to place that herb players are often observing the other plays especially towards the end game as some of the containers fill up noticing what containers your opponents haven't filled up is really crucial for also influencing how you're going to decide where the herbs are going to go so if a player is going for pairs of herbs you're really going to try and make sure that there are pairs of herbs in that community garden as well as in their private garden so that level of deciding where things goes becomes more important as the game curves out i like influeriferous the strategy where you can decide which desire cards you want to draft if you've got a lot of yellow cards then drafting that card that triggers uh points for yellow at the end of the game is super crucial maybe going for diversity of bugs or maybe going for all the same flower species whatever you do this game is all about being the early bird catching the worm or being the first person at the

flower market the idea that the turn order changes means that the decisions that you're going to make on the next turn are going to be branching because do you go for one at the top of the column so that you get a first pick at the subsequent column or do you pick something that somebody else needs and that might even be picking a desire card that an opponent needs to deny them the opportunity to score really important points at the end of the game so in terms of the depth of strategy that players can engage with i'll give this win to floriferous in terms of replayability and variability in herbaceous plays are always going to be starting with the same four pots and the way that the pots are filled up is always going to remain the same the only thing that really changes is the sequence and order of herbs that are drawn from the deck and where they're placed so after a few games you do feel like you've seen all that this game has to offer in terms of replayability the bounty cards and the desire cards that appear in each game is going to be different and the combination that they appear out in the garden as well as above the garden is going to be quite varied each time and that means that the challenge and the goals of the game are going to feel different each time you approach a game of floriferous which i actually really like so i think for replayability value my award goes to floriferous in considering my final decision this is a pretty tough one now i really love the high replayability that floriferous has especially with the desire cards and the ways that the different flower cards are

laid out and picked each of turn whereas in herbaceous i just really love the rising tension that the game has to offer and i think it provides for some really cool and memorable tense moments but in terms of which of the two i would recommend as the better game it would have to be floriferous so the plant award goes to floriferous as the game that i would recommend thank you once again for joining me for another board game sanctuary video if you thought this video was super helpful and you would like to see board game sanctuary grow please consider giving me a like a subscribe and also sharing this video with your friends and family if you want to also support board game sanctuary please check out some of my other amazing board game content on this channel don't forget to subscribe for more check out my patreon page if you want all the latest news updates get over to my facebook page this is danny sonia see you next time as we grow more plants and grow more cool board game experiences goodbye

Progress saved