Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dune Imperium has ONE major problem . . . Dune Uprising | Review & Buyers Guide

Transcript 28:48

last night I was up until 2 a.m. finishing a three-hour game of Dune Imperium specifically Dune Imperium Uprising with the brand new Bloodlines expansion included over the course of the last year Dune Imperium has become one of my favorite games of all time arguably in a new top 10 list that will probably be coming out later this year and probably one of my most played games as as well not only for introducing brand new players into the deck building genre which is a genre of gaming that I love but also a game that can satisfy and draw the attention of experienced Gamers last night it was myself my wife and one of the most advanced gamers are in our entire gaming group and all of us were playing strategically carefully and trying to push for victory it was so satisfying and just reminded me of just of of how good and how remarkably intricate and yet accessible Dune Imperium is however there is one major problem and in this video I'm hoping to solve that problem for a few of you where do you start D Imperium is one of those games that like a few other Publishers but not so many have put out an iteration a a standalone not an expansion not a module not another version of the game you know we have

things like wingspan going to worm span going to fish spawn going to I don't know rock collecting sometime in the future that's not what Dune Imperium does instead they put out a game that's about 90 or 80% identical with core strategic changes that vastly impact the experience of the players at the table and the community has been split on it to a large degree depending on if you like introducing you know expansions into your game group if you happen to be a slow plotting careful strategic player or a swingy let's you know Cut the Rope and do battle and win through sheer blood guts and Glory this video has one major statement don't buy both if you're looking to start in Dune Imperium if you're looking to get into this beautiful game which I very much think you should link down below to an Amazon uh page that'll you know give me an affiliate commission cuz I could use it I I still have to buy a copy of Bloodlines for myself this I'm borrow I borrowed this from from a guy in my gaming group either way I think you should buy Dune Imperium but I don't think you should buy both I'm going to break down five core areas that differentiate the two Gam game systems

and talk about what might make one of them right for you and one of them wrong for you and at the very end of this I'll give you my personal opinion as to which one I like the most and in what context I happen to like it the most I think once you own and enjoy and have experienced un Imperium you will end up getting both copies of this game I think that's one of the Strategic and intelligent things that you know direwolf did they put out a game that encourages you to want to own it all but if you're just starting you should buy one core and then start picking up the expansions the

deluxified the tail into the game and steal Victory from other players I want to talk about the Spy mechanic which I won't teach you how to use but I'll give you a threshold for how that impacts the strategy and the depth of the game when tying it to other systems like expansions I want to look at the leaders and again not walk you through each individual one but how good are the leaders and how often are you excited to play with whatever systems or asymmetry they provide we're going to look at the complexity the locations on the board how they adapted those to make them either more complex and worth going to or too complex and hard to integrate and then we're going to talk about the expansion integration there's three core expansions at the moment and where I think those expansions fit best in this core system because once you love Dune Imperium you will naturally be inclined to want to include the expansions in fact when I first played the base game of Dune Imperium it was my least favorite out of this genre the three games lost ruins of arnac endless winter and dune Imperium were all work replacement deck building games and it was the one I liked the least however as I started exploring expansions and adding them to the game mix it has risen to the top of the pile by far measure I still own a copy of endless winter I don't even have a copy of lost ruins of Aro anymore it's good but I felt like I kind of got to the end of the experience whereas Dune Imperium

I'm still constantly and currently excited to get to the table even if it means I'm playing till 2 a.m. and the game's lasting way longer than it reasonably should okay let's break this down let's analyze the properties here and let me know how each one fits for you if it makes it more right for you or or less right for you and where you're going to start again Amazon link I won't mention it after this I probably will but it would it does really it's so much it helps so much and I I want my own I want my own copy of Bloodlines all right combat and swing so the core feature between these two games in my opinion happens to be the degree of Swing or swinging in the victory Dune Imperium Uprising introduces these beautiful little sandworms and the sandworms operate as another unit another uh person that you can add into your battle it takes some strategy to get to a point where you can recruit them but once you do they double your Victory and the combat in this game skews towards endgame combat the last few rounds of combat providing lots and lots of available victory points as long as you meet the required conditions and if you introduce a sand War into that mix and you have the requirements like you know enough Solari or enough uh spice to to add into the equation you could find yourself scoring three or four victory points in one single swoop

that makes June Imperium Uprising both highly combat focused because it drives Victory it drives endgame towards the combat system and way more swingy both with hidden objectives with victory points that are behind closed doors to the public Marketplace of victory points that are here on the table and the amount that you can score at the very end of the game it drives game and I would argue a little bit quicker but when I played Dune base game Dune I almost never saw scores hit above the 11 or 12 Mark a 10 was a solid way to win in 11 you probably had it locked and loaded I never saw all players scale or soar above the 10 which is the threshold for finishing the game and calculating your endgame score looking for any of those hidden victory points that I mentioned well in Dune Imperium Uprising I think almost everyone finishes above that threshold last night I won with 15 points which is more than I think I've ever seen scored in base game Dune I had four hidden victory points at the end of the game the combat that I won gave me an additional two making it a endgame swing of six total points that's significant that's major and that's something to focus on and overcome if you like more careful more

strategic worker placement style games a little bit closer to the euro gaming genre if you want to be able to really count on the victory points that are public knowledge and your strategy being the thing that overcomes and closes that gap for victory then base game Dune Imperium is going to be the game that's right for you however if you like a more swingy more chaotic more climactic finish to the game which I know those are big bold words but it doesn't always make it better Dune Imperium will provide that it's more focused on combat even without the expansions included it's more focused on swing and you can steal Victory from someone who feels very confident closing the game by meeting that 10-point threshold I fall in between on these two categories and I'll tell you when I first moved from Dune to Dune Imperium Uprising I didn't like how swingy it was I didn't know how to balance it and I didn't expect it to happen and so I felt completely taken aback at just how many victory points were available on the table that's changed a little bit as I've played uh you know dozens of games but it still does have that little bit too much let's keep that in mind moving on to the next one let's talk about the Spy which is a new introduction into Dune Imperium Uprising and how the strategy evolves because of them spies

are units that you can place down at different locations on the game this is a worker placement game so you have locations that close themselves off if other people have gone to them well spies allow you to break the rules of the game in two ways in the core system you might have cards that modify this as you continue deck building in the core game uh you don't have spies at all when a location's covered up for the most part that location cannot be returned to however in Uprising if you have a spy you could either recall that spy when you place a worker at that designated location or attached location to get a draw card Effect which can be very powerful and sometimes extremely helpful and impactful or you can use that spy recall that spy in order to place a worker at a location that another player has already gone to making it so it's a little bit multi-use strategically this opens the door to long-term uh you know varying strategies of play it allows locations to not be blocked off by another player happening to go first in turn order or having the resources one cycle before you which can be very rewarding it can be worthwhile to you know sit down and want to go to a place and be able to go to a place CU you've preemptively you know fixed a spy in front of it however this does require a serious amount of boor awareness of long term strategy and if you find yourself blocked off in the Spy

game other players might have a distinct advantage over you because they've purposefully utilized their spies to allow them to go to a location to recruit more troops or gain those resources they need towards the end stage of the game when combat is so essential and you just kind of threw your spies down halfhazard Le and have recalled them for a free card or two here or there spies are Central SP spies open up the strategy spies give you a lot of agency over The Late portion of the game however it doesn't mean they make the game better spies solve some problems while introducing others and and the primary problem they introduce is a need to know where you're headed a need to know where you're playing a need to know how your strategy might progress so Uprising probably fits players who are going to play a little bit more often with a little bit more of a regular gaming group it takes more to learn takes more to think through and the consequence of not having as much experience is felt much more deeply in Dune Uprising uh I would have to say that Imperium takes or or Dune base game Dune Imperium Takes the Cake here if I want to introduce this game to a new gaming group or if I'm buying this as uh you know not a fanatic fan who has a dedicated board gaming group that understands and loves deep strategy but I'm just a hobbyist or a family gamer or someone

getting into this space cuz Dune Imperium is probably closer to an entry-level board game for a lot of people in the community it's like Katan Dune Imperium I think it's probably a better place to start so let me know which one of those two categories sound more like your gaming group the next Point that's worth touching on is something I'll try not to dwell on too much but it's the leaders the a cemetry the strategy for how you're approaching every session of Dune in Dune Imperium you had a fairly reasonable range of low-level to highlevel complexity leaders letting the board balance itself I always let new players get a pick they can read through the cards and decide which leader they want to experience the game with what mechanic system feels interesting and fun to them in Dune Imperium Uprising all of those leaders get simplified to a large degree I would argue and purposefully so I believe dirf D direwolf dorf has even acknowledged that they scaled back the complexity of the leaders to provide space for the board and the game strategy to get a little bit more deep I understand that however the leaders provide a unique way to experience the game every time and if I'm only utilizing a you know signant ring power or a leader specific power once or twice during the course of the game it doesn't shape and direct the experience as much as I would prefer it to I will admit that I think the leaders

that come from some of the other modules and expansions are a bit more compelling with Bloodlines being probably the most compelling set of leaders I have seen to date however between these two core games if you're not going to buy both of them I would encourage you to think through what you and your gaming group value the most do you value asymmetry do you value personal story and strategy the unique way of directing the game in front of you do you want a game system that allows you to balance experienced players with more complex powers and abilities with less experienced players that have simpler rules to follow but can keep in the game a little bit easier because of that Dune Imperium base game will fit that Niche a little bit more accurately Dune Imperium Uprising simplifies the leaders across the board while making the table as a whole more complex meaning the skill level of all players goes up and the interest of the story or the character or the you know strategy you're approaching the game with might actually be reduced to some degree when I played with the leaders from Bloodlines I found my entire strategy to be dictated by the leader that I was playing now it was a level three in complexity specifically the steersman yuranan I didn't say that right you'll correct me down below and I won't be able to hear what you said because you'll spell it out in hieroglyphics a lot of dashes and indications and my dyslexia will prevent me from reading it accurately however I like having a symmetry I like having characters that I

feel like I'm fully embodying that are impacting the game State this game doesn't change this board doesn't change I don't mind if it's more or less complex but the people I have in front of me if they impact the entire course of play that changes from game session to game session and I find that to be very rewarding the next next one let's talk about complexity specifically with locations some of the locations in Dune Imperium Uprising are just better they're more interesting they're more complex they provide you more opportunities to get a wide array of resources and randomize or differentiate the game as you play from Scenario to scenario whereas Dune Imperium base game has a standard set of board actions and some of them actually become a little worthless as the game increases as you get farther along in your session I think Dune Imperium Uprising wins this conversation flat out correct me if I'm wrong argue with me if you'd like but the locations that have changed here from recalling your spy and getting bonuses to making the High Council seat uh which is a location that gives you extra spending resource for buying new cards to add into your deck actually has having a secondary ability after you've utilized it once whereas in base game d d Imperium those two locations are just all right but once you've utilized them once you've gone to them there's not too much reason to continue going back this

provides those new opportunities gives you a reason to utilize those locations and not only that but it also introduces a mini expansion called contracts contracts replace a location in the base game that just gives you two coin here in Dune Imperium Uprising you'll actually be able to get a little tile this tile has an objective a location to go to or a thing to accomplish or an immediate effect and once you do that later on in the game you will unlock whatever that reward or resource is it's usually not too much more powerful than two coins or couple spice or recall or player but it allows you to time when you trigger that and timing can be essential in this game giving you an extra card draw or a resource that you need to take that one additional action before another player is extremely important I think the contracts alone the contract space alone in Dune Imperium Uprising is such an improvement over the variability and the uh differentiation of the game experience that it is extremely compelling and very worthwhile the other areas that they introduced have a few locations that are a little bit more limited based on your reputation or the influence that you have meaning that strategy for Mid and late game requires you to be having a bit more forethought in where your placing your workers and where you're getting that reputation or that influence if you're not up a track there's going to be some locations that are closed off to you and finally the process of summoning a sandworm and breaking down the Dome and being able to

utilize them in battle is intriguing but I don't see it come into play so often in the games that I have experienced I've seen a lot of people on BGG that say that sandworms are end all Beall but I think they probably only come into action about half the time for me we find that players get distracted by other mechanics or other strategies and Sam worms while a fun unique mechanic require a focus dedicated strategy to utilize and they can be gamebreaking they can be your Victory condition but it's kind of nice when they're not so think about that do you want a game that has simpler locations less complexity which has really been the theme of A lot of these categories or do you want what I would argue is the best version of the board to date right with the most available play Space the most available strategy what does that mean in consequence well if you're not adding any expansions to your game you're buying this game and then you're making no more purchases for the next six months and you're going to get these games to the table as many times as you're willing to within that time frame then I think Dune Imperium Uprising has longer legs than Dune Imperium I think base game Dune probably has 10 to 15 plays in it before you start getting a little tired and your strategies start getting a little bit similar whereas Uprising is probably more in the 20 to 30 play range and even once you're there

I think it remains more diverse and more interesting than base game Dune so once we have that established let's go into the final part of this review expansions and how they integrate into the Doom experience I'm not going to talk about the mechanics of them I'm going to have a dedicated review coming out covering all three expansions of this game so hit the Subscribe button down below stay tuned and be ready for that it'll be out within the next week is my intention and I don't know that it matters so much when it comes to a conversation between the two because the answer is very simple the expansions make both games better but the first two expansions that came out uh rise of Xs and blanking on the other one someone leave it down below my active working memory and my uh recall is is not the strongest I find that the first two expansions do match better with base game Doom which makes sense I mean Uprising was created it was probably in mind but created to be a module or a hybrid or an available system post facto like it was it was made after those expansions had already came into existence and those expansions really enhance and really balance out the game with one of them focusing on uh combat and enhancing that experience by allowing you to recruit you know these uh big Destroyer ships or Harvester ships or whatever they're called and you know bising the the the entire desert

and being able to uh conquer regions that give you bonuses when other players Place their workers at them it brings the combat into focus more and I enjoyed that a lot cuz it can be a little underplayed in the original game and then the second expansion allows you to introduce more cards into your game experience it allows you to have these custom cards with this custom resource this gelatinous goo and those cards can be really fun to play with I like anything that enhances the deck building experience and both provide more more opportunities and a growing and deeper experience overall Bloodlines is the hybrid and I'm still not exactly sure how I feel on blood lines it introduces a unique combat mechanic that requires money to hire and uh trigger your effects you know every combat that happens you'll have bonuses that might be included it takes a module which are these Technologies from another one of the expansions the one that's combat focused from the beginning and introduces it in a way that might fit better here with Uprising than it did in the original whereas in the original that sideboard was worthwhile to go to some of the locations here in Uprising just are better you focus on them a little bit more it heightened the experience I mean introducing those big Destroyer ships and sandworms if the conversation is between the two of those the sandworms are just going to win they're just better and then finally it

did introduce some additional cards and some very very satisfying leaders I think Bloodlines matches very well with Dune Imperium Uprising and feels like it was designed with it in mind more it encourages you to go across a wider array of the board gives you more small modules to interact with and provides you with a higher level of complexity when it comes to leaders than you'll find in any of the base game characters or factions so I think if you're going to do what I'm encouraging you to do which is buy one of these two games and then expand it with expansions if you get Uprising then bloodline should be the first expansion you add to your game probably and if you get base game then the two original expansions should be the first expansions you add to your game depending on if you want to focus more on deck building or more on combat all of them are great and you'll likely end up owning them all just slowly you don't need to get it all in one Fell Swoop I also have to know that I don't need the two original expansions to make Uprising playable and sometimes when I do integrate them into the experience of play I find that I end up missing or ignoring one big part of the game the game State just gets a little bit too big and there's too many interesting things to do that could be wonderful for some of you I mean I've played everdale

with every expansion included and had a blast but it also isn't how the publisher intended or encouraged you to experience that game I think the same thing holds true here the expansions aren't meant to be mixed and matched to be added together and create a big cacophony of chaos well you can certainly do that and I think it's fun one expansion at a time or both of The Originals with the base game is probably where I'd tell you to start so if you're looking to expand your game experience then you know I think at the moment base game Dune Imperium would win however I think Uprising probably holds the candle when it comes to uh its ability to last on the table without needing Corrections from extra published content so there you have it there's my breakdown there's there's my analysis of these two games hopefully that helps you determine which one will fit you in your gaming group the best and let me know if you're watching this CU you're just a giant Dune Imperium fan what did I miss what did I get wrong what have I overlooked I'm necky into both of these systems and I like them both a lot if I had to start from zero just get one of these game systems for myself personally I would get Uprising I like a little bit of chaos I like a little bit of swing and I think

it's still very strategic however if I was going to get this and teach it to a new group of Gaming professionals or friends I would probably get base game Dune not because I think it's the best or the strongest out of the two but because I can quickly add expansions to enhance that play after we've all learned how to play it and I think Uprising is just a little bit more of a uh skill needed type of system it's not necessarily a bad thing it's just how I approach games so for me just talking myself personally Uprising winds even though I didn't like it that much the first time I played it because it was way too swingy and I needed a few plays to really get my feet under me however if we're talking about a brand new group base game is going to take it and then expansions are going to come pretty quickly after that thank you for watching thank you for being here hopefully you've enjoyed this little bit of a hybrid right for you wrong for you let me know is this the type of content you're looking for is this review helpful and informative did I talk way too long my throat is telling me that I did whatever the case though whatever you do remember to do the important thing take a deep breath in a deep breath out look around and be both curious and

grateful life is good and I'm so lucky and thankful that I'm I'm here I get to play games with my wife and my friends until 2:00 in the morning and then film a video and talk to thousands of you H about why this is both worthwhile and cool we'll see you next time bye

Progress saved