Crown of Ash Preview: A Game of the Year Contender?
Transcript
this episode of brains on games will preview an upcoming game combining worker placement area control and combat welcome to brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we are going to talk about an upcoming game it's coming to crowdfunding very soon and I will include information about the campaign in the show notes below the video but this is an upcoming game that combines worker placement and and area control making it a super interactive worker placement game it was sent to me very recently by the folks over at card Noir and it's a game called crown of Ash now this is a game for between one and four players there is a solo mode for this game it's four folks age 14 and up so it's more of the teenagers who are going to be able to figure this one out and it's a game that plays in one to two hours let's take a deeper look at crown of Ash crown of Ash is a game that's medium in terms of its complexity there's a reason why it says 14 plus on on the box and it's a game it's played over four rounds uh and a round is finished when each player has placed all of their four workers somewhere on the board and you're trying to earn the most victory points by controlling locations here on the board and by drafting Fighters into your hand players are playing as necromancers who are raising
these Fighters that are going to battle each other in order to win the crown of Ash the game starts in a layout that's something like this I've set it up as a two-player game and in a two-player game you're splitting up for uh starting locations between the two players so they're dealt out at random each player also has a starting hand of three Fighters and they're going to place a fighter on each of their starting locations as well and you also begin with one of these cards call called fate cards this is how you're going to earn victory points at the end of the game by drafting those Fighters because you want to draft Fighters that have a little color at the top I don't know if you'll be able to see this I'll put it under the big camera here that have a color at the top that matches one of the colors on your fake card and if that happens you're going to get a point based on the Roman numeral that's down here at the bottom of these finer cards so you've you're you've got a secret kind of way of earning some victory points at the end of the game it's not really going to be that secret because the other players are going to see which Fighters you're Drafting and they'll probably know pretty quickly what it is that you're looking for the game I mean you can see this is a big board the game is a little bit of a table hog and this is a prototype and the pictures I've seen and I'll put a picture up of the board on the video here but the pictures I've seen show that even the board has been a little bit redesigned I know that resources are being upgraded and the meeples are being there's so many things
that are being planned for this that crowdfunding campaign the game is already pretty amazing and and like I really like the first player counter with the hand that's kind of rising from the grave right because you're all necromancers who are fighting for this crown what you're doing in this game like I said is it's a worker placement game so each player is going to have four of these workers and they're going to place them in these spaces around the board in order to take some action a lot of the time you're going to be gathering resources the resources are what's going to allow you to buy new Fighters so you can see with these two fighter cards one of them is going to require two bone and the other one is going to require four Ash so the I mean the resources are appropriate for a game that's all about necromancy and the fighters are skeletons with arrows in them or ghosts or things like that they're pretty creepy looking cards but I do like the artwork quite a bit once you've resolved the workers action and gathered resources or finished combat we'll talk about combat in a minute or built your structure you can raise one of these Fighters now there are going to be six Fighters that are available for drafting at the top of the board here on this version of the board the pictures I've seen online have spaces kind of in the middle of the board they've rearranged things and so there might be some some cards face up in the middle of the board as well so they do have different levels so there's going to be one level three creature available for you there's going to be a couple of level twos and three level ones and remember you're you're looking at the color at the top probably
to try and earn some extra victory points at the end but you're also looking at these values these numbers at the top are the combat strength of these things and combat is where this game really shines and I think it elevates it above some other worker placement games that are less interactive because you are going to want to steal some locations from the other players and you do that by fighting them for the location so I I mentioned that you're going to start the game with those three Fighters two of them are going to be on the board at your structures you've also got the structures so you're going to have one fighter left in your hand and each action you might be able to get an additional fighter that goes right into your hand not into a discard pile you also each player is going going to have a deck of these combat cards and combat in this game is so clever I think all of the cards are the same and if you look at them and I'll show some some graphics on the video as well if you look at them they have a number on the side that's going to be the combat value that's added to whatever the value is of your soldiers that are in that fight there's there's one that's entirely random you get to roll a die and that's going to determine the strength in in combat so you've got a four and a three you've got a random one that's a die you've got a number one here and you've got a zero and and one of the neat things I think here about combat in this game it's very clever like I said is that both the Victor and the loser are going to get something from combat you might enter combat and lose on purpose in order to
use a card or because you need some sort of resource you can get gold even if you lose you can get if you play this card and you win you're going to get one gold gold is fantastic it'll get you some victory points at the end of the game but it also acts as a wild resource if I lose with this combat card I'm going to get two resources of my choice so there are likely to be benefits for both players in a combat but the thing about this game is that when you enter combat well let me show you what happens you're going to start by of course placing your worker on the combat space at the location that you're hoping to take over now this player has only one card defending if I wanted to change that before combat happened if I happen to put my worker here to gather resources I can take this card out and change the cards that are defending that location so there's multiple reasons why I might want to visit one of my own structures not just to gain the resources but also because maybe I want to change the Defenders maybe I want to put a big one back in my hand and put some smaller defenders in that space or maybe I want to make sure my opponent's not going to be able to get their hands on it but if an opponent does put something here then you're going to enter combat each player is going to play one of these combat cards face down so they get to choose which one they play and the attacker can choose one or two fighters from their hand of course at the start of the game you know on your first turn you'll only
have one of those Fighters but hopefully you've drafted a couple and then you can play one face down so the orange player is going to have one fighter and one combat card the blue player is going to have only the fighters that are here defending that location and their combat card it goes face down everybody reveals all at the same time and then you work out the result if I do win the combat this card is going to go into my opponent's graveyard the cards that I put into the battle are going to go into this space and I'm going to take control by putting one of my control tokens here on that location so now I'm going to earn victory points at the end of their around for controlling that structure I got so many things stacked up on the table I don't have another one of these orange control tokens that I can place there to show that orange has taken it over because the players are playing as necromancers the combat does it's quite unique because I'm if I lose that battle my my Soldier comes off the board but this is a raised fighter he goes into my graveyard but at the end of the round once all of the workers have been placed and you're resetting everything and recalling your workers to your player board the cards in your graveyard also come back into your hand so you don't permanently lose these things the other thing that's unique is that because you've got this limited number of those combat cards those are going face up on your board in front of you but they don't come back unless you place a worker here on this spot to reclaim them
so you can use an action to refresh your comp your hand of combat cards early if you want to but if you've played the last one they all come back into your hand so the combat is made interesting I think by the fact that as players enter battles they're going to be spending these cards if you can keep track of the ones that are in this pile you're not allowed to dig through it you have to work from memory if you can keep track of the ones that are in this pile that have already been played well then you have an idea of what the other player's options are you also might be thinking especially maybe in a two-player game we found ourselves thinking like do I want to enter combat when this guy only has one card left maybe I want him to spend it because if if I fight against him he's going to get to draw all the other cards back and then he'll have lots of options if I try to attack him a second time one of the most important locations in the game is the Citadel and the Citadel is going to start just with the King on here and the King doesn't have any combat cards but you can attack the Citadel so it doesn't have a straw structure on it that's going to give you any resources but it gives you victory points at the end of the round so if I decide to attack it there's one space here where I can attack that's going to give me a bonus of one to my combat total there's another space on this side so another player could attack right after I did so if I win and I've got my fighters on here another player can attack me and take it over before the end of the turn there's a space in the
middle an unlimited number of workers can go on there and can continue to attack so if you're playing a four player game this thing might change hands multiple times so at first you can now this is also a space that can hold three Fighters so you can play three fighters from your hand you add up that total it's got to be greater than five you're going to be playing that combat card as well and then you could take over the Citadel the king just goes off and gets discarded he doesn't come back but then another player is probably going to want to take that from you why is that because each round that you control the Citadel at the end of the round you are going to earn a number of victory points and these are huge we found that this was often a game deciding thing you did not want to leave a player sitting on the Citadel for more than one round because well first of all the number of points you earn escalates at the end of each one at the end of each round so at the end in the last round of the game if you're controlling the Citadel you're going to earn six victory points at the end of your turn so it it's one where it's quite uh it this is the space that everybody is going to be fighting over because it can it can really determine the winner of the game at the end and because there's an unlimited number of attacks that could happen I mean you can see here these other spaces there's only two spots where a worker can go to attack so if you'd manage to defend yourself twice you're good to go but here you're stuck the other thing about The Citadel space is that once you've taken it over and
put your fighters in there you can't change them so it's not like here where I can change the building or add a resource and edit the fighters that are amend they call it in the rule book you can amend the fighters that are here once you've won your battle and you've placed your Fighters here that's where they stay until they get booted out by another player who attacks you so the Citadel is super important and you're really deciding like where do I want what do I want to do here do I want to attack it now do I want to wait to the last turn to make sure that nobody else can take it that's another strategic thing about this game the first round the turn order is determined randomly but in the remaining rounds the the player who's in last place who has the least victory points decides who gets to go first second third and fourth and that's a powerful ability too if you go first you're going to have the advantage of getting the structure that you want or getting the fighter that you want from the top of the board nobody else can get it before you but if you go last you may be the last player to be able to attack so you can see everybody whittling things down at the Citadel and then you can attack and not have to defend that round you'll earn those points at the end if you manage to save enough cards to to attack it and hold on to it hopefully in the next turn as well so there's a lot of of budgeting and planning that you can do and the turn order is an important part of the strategy as well so we're talking about a game that involves a lot of planning
every single time you place one of these workers you need to think about what you're doing so there is a lot of thought and planning involved if you want to get one of those powerful Fighters with the strength of five or six you're going to need to save up a lot of resources and to do that you're going to need to budget your actions and make sure that you control the locations that can give you those resources and you might be thinking well if I use my opponent's location that's going to give him some resources too with the owner's tax so you're thinking about all of that stuff and you're budgeting your combat cards and your budget editing the fighters in your hand and you don't lose those things permanently so and you do get an advantage if you lose so there is a lot of planning and organized approach to turns efficient approach resource management and budgeting this is a game that is heavily involving the executive functioning skills the behaviors and skills that you need to work towards a goal it's a it's a heavier strategy game but it's simple enough to understand uh it's the it's the planning and and how you use those turns that makes it more complicated and strategic it's also a game one of the things I think that I like best about it is the fact that you've got these combat cards and you're trying to remember which one your opponent has left or which two you're which ones is he spent does he have that one with the number four on it in his hand did he keep the one with the dice and then it's going to be a random result uh is is he hanging on to this
one that has a zero on it but the loser of the battle gets to you know gets to to kill one of the owner's Fighters and send that one to the graveyard you know for Mel's heart I stab at the it gives him a strength of zero but if he loses he's killing uh one of the winners Fighters and so remembering what cards have been played is important strategically in this game in addition to budgeting those cards final thoughts about crown of Ash this is a game when you can probably tell from the way I'm describing it we had so much fun playing this game every single decision is interesting and it's giving you something and and you're trying to think about what your opponent is going to do it's so strategic but fairly straightforward in terms of the rules and how to play and it's a really clever combination I think of worker placement and resource Gathering which is typical of most of those worker placement games and then you get the area control role in combat mixed in with that but even if you lose you're still earning something from the combat so you don't feel terrible necessarily about losing and you might lose on purpose in order to to earn the the losers uh reward from completing that battle so it's quite different from you know the other worker placement games I can think of that are on the shelf behind me are everdel and viticulture and I've got Fresco around there somewhere and those are all worker
placement games but everyone's doing their own thing and they're trying to save up resources to buy things or to upgrade things in in their in their Vineyard for example but there's not very much interaction between the players but this one you're constantly thinking not just about blocking players from accessing certain spots you're you're thinking about which location you want to take over and whether you're going to be able to hold on to your own structures in the game so it is um I I found it really a fascinating Converse combination of mechanisms uh that we had so much fun playing the combat is so interesting the need to remember those currents that have been played we really really like that controlling the Citadel is also super important and you're you'll find yourself going back and forth and really spending your whole four workers to try and figure out how to get the fighters in your hand and the combat cards in your hand that will allow you to knock the controlling player out of there so that you can get those victory points uh the art is fantastic on these cards I find it really interesting and every decision that you're making is interesting and you're not losing those Fighters this is a special game I I think it's I mean it's only merch right now as I'm recording this and I feel like this is probably going to be one of my favorite games of the year based on our playthroughs of it it is if if there's a
downside I mean there's not really a downside to Crown of Ash let's be honest it's a bit of a table hog you know you need a big space to play it on all of the cards wouldn't quite fit on like the board just fits on the table the way that I've set it up but I couldn't get all the cards around it the the way that it's supposed to so I need my big board game table for this one uh I think it's a game that we look I've only played it at two and I loved it at two but I think it's a game that with four players the back and forth with the Citadel maybe especially and going back and forth with control of the different structures I think that would be so much fun and that's immediately what I said after I first played it like I really want to play this with four people to see what that would be like and I didn't unfortunately get a chance to do that but I I think with four players it's going to be even that much better this is a gorgeous game it's a clever combination of mechanisms it's so interactive the combat is fun and interesting and I I haven't played a game uh you know other than Scythe that I can think of where you're using those combat cards but the way the combat cards work and come back into your hand is interesting like look we love this game I have to thank I have to thank the folks over at card Noir for sending this game my way this is a real winner I hope it gets funded on Kickstarter because I think I'm gonna back it so that I can have a copy on my shelf too the upgrades
that are planned for the campaign uh were exciting to me when I've sort of got the inside scoop on what's Happening Here so thanks so much to card Noir for sending this and giving me an opportunity to try it out we really love this game information about the kickstarter campaign will be included in the show notes of this video and if you have any comments or questions if you can think of another Super interactive worker placement game that I didn't think of as I'm naming everdel and viticulture uh let me know leave a comment in the comment section below you can of course also email me at Brian at brainsongames.ca brains on games.ca is the website that's where future episodes will go the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time
thank you