Don't overlook it just because it's cute! Bunny Kingdom.
Transcript
as ever we'll be starting with the hook so it's a pick and pass card drafting game where the cards you select dictate grid coordinates you place tokens onto these spaces to claim territory and the player who most effectively dominates the board wins the game now that sounds fascinating i'm not sure i've come across another game featuring a clever hybrid of card drafting and area control like this but how are we going to communicate all of that to players it's a bit of a mouthful but with bunnies bunnies yeah bunnies everywhere like cute little bunnies no warmongering murderous bunnies okay so not like cute little pink fluffy bunnies yeah yeah they're still pink pink fluffy warmongering murderous bunnies that's the hook i'm adam porter and i design games and in this video series i'm looking at board games and reviewing them with a focus on product design i will be discussing gameplay too so you should be able to get an idea of whether the game might work for you in this video i thought it would be interesting to objectively analyze the design of a board game that i love bunny kingdom's in my top five games of all time but just because it works for me doesn't necessarily mean that it's a great product so let's unpick it bunny kingdom is a 2017 collaboration between magic the gathering creator richard garfield and the esteemed french board game publisher yellow it can be played by two to four players or five with the expansion in around an hour
in bunny kingdom each player is trying to establish their own little domains on a large grid board and the aim is to create interconnected areas of bunnies of your own color with plenty of towers and resources so that's carrots wood fish and other materials each player has a hand of cards they select two to play and they pass the rest to the opponent on their left this continues until all the cards have been played and then the round is scored and after four complete rounds the game ends and players add in points from special objectives they've gathered throughout the game the highest scorer wins most of the cards feature a single grid coordinate and when you play the card you place your bunny into that space some of the spaces have cities on them and these are the key to building your empire because the towers in those cities translate into points some of the cards provide you with additional cities which you can place onto any of your occupied territories these might have one two or three towers in them and many of the cards are parchments end game scoring objectives gather lots of fish or spread out to create lots of small domains or place your bunnies on the edge of the board and then there are a host of special cards which allow you to add unique resources to your territories or join up different domains using sky towers or camp out in unoccupied spaces or draw and play additional cards at the end of each round you score points for each domain equal to the number of towers in it multiplied by the number of different resources in it and in the first couple of rounds scoring is generally pretty modest but it ramps up massively in
rounds three and four as you build on the foundations you laid down in those early turns but this in-game scoring only tells part of the story because the big reveal of the secret objectives at game end will ultimately determine the victor now first impressions count for a lot and this is where i think yellow has made a really bold decision on the basis of its cover alone bunny kingdom could be dismissed as a game for young children which it most definitely isn't yellow is gambling on the designer's name word of mouth and their own reputation to ensure that gamers don't walk on by to ensure that they stop they check the back of the box identify the unique gameplay mechanisms recognize the complexity and give it a chance but what's the alternative i mean can we keep on churning out box covers like this time and time again how are we supposed to stand apart well yellow took a punt on cute little woodland critters and it's a trend which continued over subsequent years with complex games like root and everdell using the same formula that said even in comparison to the very cute everdell and root bunny kingdom is sickly sweet i mean the game is awash with pastel colors the bunnies are adorable sat atop their little castles adorned with carrot-shaped steeples the expansion doubles down on that sugar rush aesthetic rainbows beanstalks cities in the clouds yellow is challenging you to bring this out with your gamer mates to expand their horizons stick this on the table between games of
gloomhaven and kingdom death monster i dare you now every game makes promises with its box cover and bunny kingdom is all over the place i'm expecting pastel colours looking at that cover i'm expecting cute artwork and really good table presence and yet delivers on all those things but then i see richard garfield's name now i'm expecting clever gameplay mechanisms a degree of complexity lots of interaction and again it really delivers but what if i don't know who richard garfield is what if i don't bother to fully read the back of the box i can only imagine that this game is sitting at the bottom of some sad child's wardrobe neglected after a baffling first attempt at play in the game an ill-informed christmas gift from a well-meaning grandparent fortunately i don't need to worry about all of that because i bought the game for well me i thought it might appeal to my wife and it did i mean it really really did this was the first modern game that my wife really fell for the first time i really truly managed to convince her that there was a world of games beyond monopoly includo we've played this game an absolute ton after four years it's probably the most played game in my collection and we both still adore it here's my customer journey map when i first heard about the game i thought it sounded fun when i got my hands on it and opened the box i was amazed at what it contained it wasn't the easiest game to learn and setting up was a bit of a pain with all of those pieces but the gameplay was really fascinating there
were so many options on your turn loads of different strategies to explore loads of neat decisions to be made now i have seen players struggle with the game overwhelmed by all the choices available to them you really do need to assess each card in your hand individually check out the grid coordinates consider whether it's worth anything to your opponents and compare the value of your different options it's a lot to take in so the game isn't going to be for everyone the scoring at the end of the game takes a little bit longer than i'd like as players reveal their parchment objectives one by one and count up their bunnies on the board it is exciting waiting to reveal the ultimate victor but it can drag a little so if we chart pain points for bunny kingdom is the fiddly setup the potential for analysis paralysis and extended weights for players to pick the cards they want to play and the long end game scoring but for me the highs far outweigh the lows as always i'm going to use my engagement star and ladder model to analyze the gameplay so these are the five key facets which pull me into a game and i'm going to give each of them a score between 0 and 3. if a game scores more than 10 points that's usually an indication that it's a real winner it reaches the top of my engagement ladder and bunny kingdom succeeds i've given it twos across the board it is really rare to find such a well-rounded game yes the theme makes very little sense but the extensive and beautiful artwork on the cards along with the lovely components
can't help but draw you into this gorgeous little world the interactions are really gripping you have to keep an eye on your opponents and block their opportunities if you want to win there's a high degree of tension challenge and stress in the game waiting for an opportunity to fill that final space to connect up your territories praying to receive that one fish which will complete your objective in the final round of the game the feedback isn't continuous but the scoring occurs at four different points in the game and the pacing feels just about right it's really satisfying to see your score ramp up between rounds so six points in round one fifteen in round two forty in round three eighty in round four there's a real sense of momentum and i've already stressed just how many great choices there are to make in the game i should say that i've primarily played two player though i have plenty of larger games under my belt too my wife and i frequently played this as a head-to-head and it's a very different game of that play account the rules even changed slightly now we each have our own deck of cards and as well as passing cards between us on each turn we draw a card from the deck and discard a card from our hand it's an ingenious system which replicates the experience of pick and pass drafting really well it ramps up the negative interaction in the game the discarded card is always going to be chosen to deprive your opponent so you consistently choose one card to benefit yourself and one card to block the other player this might not be to everyone's tastes and even after years of frequent playing
we still get out of sync with all the passing of cards the drawing of cards playing and discarding as clever as it is it's not a streamlined system now personally i wouldn't change it it works for us as long as we stay focused the game currently has one expansion which didn't take the obvious route of exploring underground realms you know with bunnies being burrowing creatures and all instead we have bunnies in the sky and why not i mean add some clever new strategies opportunities for a fifth player new scoring options and a second board it's a fairly complex addition and i wouldn't recommend it with new players and it's a pain to separate the cards out of the massive deck when you want to return to play in the base game alone so for us it's an occasional diversion we still frequently return to play in the base game on its own leaving the expansion on the shelf but i'm glad that the option exists indeed i really wish yellow would produce a second expansion bunnies underground or bunnies at sea to be honest i just want the experience of opening up the package the excitement of checking out the artwork on all the cards exploring the new rule set all over again even if it rarely gets played a great product grows with its user and whether you're using expansions to add variety or just trying to perfect your skills at the base game there's always a new challenge in every session of bunny kingdom now my wife wins every single time but it's usually close and that little hint of a potential victory one day maybe i might beat her that keeps me coming back
so moving on to my product design checklist number one is the game innovative yeah i mean the combination of grid-based area control and pick and pass card drafting is unusual perhaps even unique both have been used many times independently in other games so seven wonders sushi go tigress and euphrates kingdom builder but the combination here feels fresh and the presentation of the product is certainly a bold move an innovative marketing strategy perhaps so number two does it solve a need well need is a strong word but i do think in 2017 when this was released gamers were looking for a next step from seven wonders and sushi go pick and pass card drafting is such an elegant mechanism it can easily form part of a bigger game and bunny kingdom is just such a product i can't see that many players were crying out for a pastel rabbit strategy game but now i have it i wouldn't want to be without it number three branding well there are opportunities here bunny kingdom is a great title for a game the art style and the world building are immaculate i'm surprised that we haven't seen a bunny kingdom card game more expansions perhaps a standalone sequel a dice game a roll and right it's a distinctive world which could be as iconic for yellow as garfield's other big hit king of tokyo which frequently gets repackaged and reworked into sequels and expansions card drafting area control pink fluffy warmongering bunnies so how strong a hook is that
well to generate commercial success a product needs to have a great core concept and outstanding execution so let's plot bunny kingdom onto my chart i think commercially speaking the idea is good but not exceptional as ingenious as richard garfield's concept is it is a bit of a tricky one to convey to players but it's extremely well executed the presentation is top notch i have very few games this beautiful in my collection the rulebook is accessible and welcoming my only hesitation with the execution is the potential for consumer and retailer confusion so is this a game for kids or is it for gamers and hence the game sits on the border of green and yellow this represents a really successful product but it hasn't quite pushed up into the orange or red section of the grid it's not going to trouble ticket to ride or code names or azul i doubt it has the commercial value of its stablemate king of tokyo nonetheless it is one of my favorite games my wife and i love it and if you're open to a serious strategy game in a silly woodland world then i think you'll love it too if you'd like to see more videos like this please hit like subscribe to the channel and i'll see you next time