Skip to main content
Loading video...

Games of the Month - July '24

Transcript 54:09

welcome to Jong games this is my games of the month Vlog for July of 2024 and in it I'll be talking about the two best gaming experiences that I had over the last month now what you're going to be watching is actually excerpts from the opinions episodes that I sent out exclusively to the patreon supporters of this channel specifically I find those excerpts for the best games that I played and I'm going to be sharing those with you now so what you're going to be watching is the new versions essentially where I talk about uh how the game plays and my initial impressions for these I think I actually played them both a couple of times so I kind of come back and talk about multiple plays I do want to mention if you like what you see here today then you can gain access to the 511 different games that I've covered in those opinions episodes by supporting this channel by going to patreon.com jjong games there are other perks you can get like watching some videos early and advertisement free and getting access to an exclusive podcast feed where you can listen to audio versions of all of my Vlogs including all of those opinions episodes there's 107 of those episodes now now let's talk about these games in particular the first one is Railways of the Lost Atlas I actually just put out a uh non-sponsored play through with friends video where I played a full two-player game of this one it is kind of like an introductory 18xx type of game that has taken uh my world by storm and my friends uh also after that I'll be talking about ano 1800 with the expansion that just released in Germany I imported that over and I played it a couple of times actually what you're going to be listening to is the new version and then I Rec recorded an update later and I

appended that to the end so you'll get to hear all of that this is definitely one of the longer episodes because I have a lot to say about each of these games now the last thing I do want to ask is that if you have thoughts about any of these games while you're watching this maybe you've played them and you disagree with my opinions or you just have questions or whatnot please leave those as comments below this video all right I think it's time to jump into them we'll start with the railways of the Lost Atlas now I backed this on Kickstarter I just got it about a week and a half ago and in that time I've played it twice and one of those I recorded the play with my friend Dave and we put it up as a non-sponsored full playthrough on the main YouTube channel so if you're intrigued by what I'm about to say then you can check that out and watch us play an entire game and I think I love this game again I've only played it twice the first time was two players and the second time was three players and right here at the start it is important that you know that this is an 18xx Style game even though there is no 18 in the title of the name at all now this one is on the shorter side and it is the I think seventh different 18xx game I've played and it is my favorite at this point so uh before you click Skip and go on to the next segment please stick around a little bit because there are some reasons why this one seems special to me a relative 18xx novice now I'm not going to start this off with like a primer on the details of what 18xx is but at a very high level these are train games where players are investors spending their money buying stocks in train companies that are

controlled by the person who owns the most stock in each of those companies you lay track out onto the board and these companies are going to run on those tracks they're going to buy trains to actually make this happen and in general these are not short games I'd say most of them are going to be four hours on the low side five to six hours on the kind of standard length at least for people who are not super veterans every time I mention this kind of thing somebody always comes around and says I can play this game in 90 minutes with my friends and yes if you are an expert you can get these play times down but for most people they are long games if you play a 4-Hour ET XX game generally people will say oh so it wasn't too long to give you some sort of context now again I've played Railways of the Lost Atlas twice the first time we recorded the full playthrough it took us 4 hours to record it but that is not an accurate representation of the amount of time to play because we were recording it and there's various other things that go into it the second time I played was three players and I taught it to my two friends neither of whom had ever played any 18xx games before although they were somewhat familiar with a lot of cube rail style games now it took me 30 minutes to teach the game to my friends and then it took almost exactly 3 hours to play it so it was essentially a three and a half hour experience with the full teach with two people who are very new to this overall style of game and I have to admit that the time just flew by also while part of me was hoping it would be slightly uh shorter than that I'm very heartened by that overall length because again um we aren't all experts at this kind of thing and it still didn't go

that long now it is important for some extra context that in both of these games we played the quote unquote short game the quote unquote long game is essentially the full game and the main difference between these two is the map is smaller in the short game and in the short game you play through four Cycles whereas in the long game you play through six Cycles now this is somewhat different than your average 18xx game usually you play an indeterminate number of cycles and you keep going until the bank runs out of money which is part of the reason why these games can take a long time in order to try and get lost Atlas into a reasonable time frame its standard way to play is four or six cycles and this gives you a very good idea of where you're at in the overall scope of the game as you are playing it now again that short game took us 3 hours to play but I have full confidence that if we sat down to Play It Again the same three people we would get that done in 2 and a half for sure likely even closer to 2 hours because a lot of this is just kind of getting used to the overall systems and how the game flows and it gets a lot snappier as we actually play through it I'm pretty sure uh the first out of those three hours was the first out of four Cycles but it was not a 4-H hour game it just got quicker as we went because we got more familiar with the overall systems now one of the main uh Hallmarks of this game one of the things that really jumps out that separates it from other 18xx style games is that the map is fully modular you actually build the map out of a series of tiles that are three hexagons kind of smashed together and at the start of the game you just Shuffle up all the tiles and then in player

order you draw a tile and place it down next to other tiles with some very rudimentary tile placement rules and you build this map collectively together and I love that now the first time I played this for the video that we filmed we did not build the map we used a introductory map that the rulebook suggested we go with and that was a balanced map and it was an interesting map it was definitely not Bland in any way but after that first play I was like you know I I got to build the map next time I don't even care and so I sat down to teach this to my friends and obviously it's hard to teach a game when the table is blank so I just taught them the rules for laying these tiles out and we built the entire map before they knew anything about how this game actually played and I think that worked really well I mean as tiles came out I pointed some things out like oh you know this is water and you can't build uh into the water so you might want to put it there if you want to to make this better or make this worse but you know the choice is up to you and oh that tile is a starting Hub location for a company um feel free to put it next to other ones or far away from other ones you know go nuts and so if you're looking at the video version of this one you are seeing the end game state after three full hours of this game with a Kookie map that we made with all sorts of little tendril appendages that went out into various areas there was uh two companies that were never started one of them was just off in a corner surrounded by Hills with like nothing going for it and that's just the decision that we made which meant that we actually had a lot less companies in uh circulation essentially in this play when you play

the short game there are eight of these minor companies as they call them and when you play the long game there are uh 12 of them so that's another part of the short game it has less companies to run and then the way things happened for us we only ran six of these companies even as it was and I think that is going to be where a lot of the variability of this game comes into play how you build a map is going to dictate how you actually um get these companies going and if you get all of the compan going now I do want to mention a little bit about some of the rules nothing too crazy specific but the way you get these companies going is through an auction that I really liked generally I'm not crazy about auctions I've learned to accept them as a necessary part of many train games that I love and in this game it has a super standard type of auction where you just say a number it has to be bigger than the previous number if you pass you can't jump back in and then you keep going up until one person is left that's all standard but the part that I like is that you again in a short game have these eight different minor companies and you shuffle them up and then you make two stacks of four companies when you win the auction you can start either of the bottom two companies that are on those Stacks so that means you're not auctioning off the agricultural company for example you're auctioning off agriculture or the express company if those were the two that were down at the bottom and people need to weigh both of those options when they're considering bidding and out bidding also when they consider which one do they they think somebody else might take to then open up another one because as soon as you remove one of these to build it now there is a new

company that is at the bottom and that is just fascinating now again we played the short game and you put two of these Stacks in the short game in the long game you have 12 companies and you have three stacks so when you do this auction you actually are auctioning off one of three different options each time it happens at least until some of these Stacks start to dry up now that right there is quite interesting and also there is no initial auction or setup in this game and many 18xx games have that where you know you set everything up and then you do a starting onetime kind of auction to get some balls rolling in this case you just start the game with a stock round and one thing you can do in the stock round is auction off one of these companies and so you just jump right into the game there's nothing kind of special or anything like that at the beginning and then you start playing the game now again there's a moderate amount going on it took me half an hour to teach this to people who never played uh 18xx before so it's not a crazy teach but it's not super short but there is one more mechanical thing I do want to point out before I talk about the amount of fun I've had with this and that has to do with mergers now I am far from an 18xx expert honestly I feel like I am an 18xx newbie I've only played gosh I think seven different titles at this point and I think nine different sessions total so only uh a couple of duplicates happening there in the middle and as far as I can tell mergers are pretty rare mechanic in Railways of the Lost Atlas the way this works is as I said you start with these minor companies that you are auctioning off and at certain points throughout the game there are merger rounds where you can take two minor companies and fuse

them together into a major company and when you do this you put another card kind of on top of the two minor companies that have been slid together and then you have this big company that has all of the benefits and liabilities and stuff of both of the previous companies if you're looking at the video version the company Express and the company Suburban merged into the express sub Urban Consortium and essentially all of the individual tokens for those companies were swapped out for the centralized tokens of that major company and there's differences with the amount of stocks that can be had and the amount of trains that companies can hold and I'm not trying not to go into all of these overall specifics but this is a really interesting moment in the game because you no longer operate Express by itself and Suburban by itself you now run them both as the Consortium so as you start merging companies the game sort of gets faster because there are less comp compies that actually need to operate because again it's not the players that take turns it's the companies that take turns if I sat down to play a five player short game there's going to be the same number of activations of turns as a two-player short game the only difference is in the two-player short game I'm going to be in the hot seat making decisions a lot more often than if I was in the five-player game for example now at this point I want to start talking about how these plays went and uh in particular how they kind of differed I am going to be spoiling how that playthrough went sorry if if you don't want to be spoiled then maybe skip back and then come back to this but I lost the first game badly and I won the second game by a lot so I'm

kind of slingshotting all over the place and I think there's a lot of reasons for these things but the first thing I want to highlight is the mergers so in the uh first game the two-player game that we filmed I merged my two minor companies into a major company in the very first cycle and there's four Cycles in a short game part of the reason I did this is because I wanted to show merging as soon as possible for a playthrough video but also it was my first time playing the game and I wanted to see what a merger was like and what running a major company would be like and I'm happy I did it I think it showed for some interesting stuff teaching moments and whatnot in the playthrough but after playing this game twice I think there is such a thing as merging too early and I also think there's such a thing is merging too late the reason for that is because in the second game no one merged until the third cycle of the game now this is effectively the last possible second because the fourth cycle of the game does have a merger um round but that happens right before you score and there's no reason to merge then so in a short game there's functionally three Windows to merge in the first time I played I merged in the first window and it felt a bit early and the second time I played everyone including myself merged in the third and final window and that felt late so the next time I play I'm probably going to see about merging right there in the second one and the reason why I think there might be early and late has to do with pulling up your treasury to buy trains so one thing I've been bad at in both of these games even though I lost one and won the other is I have not been very good at getting

enough money into the companies that I run to run multiple trains with that specific company um the train limits uh vary based off of where you are within the game but generally speaking most companies for most of the game can run two separate trains as that one company and you can make a ton of money having a second train and I was very good at just having one train per company so they made decent money overall but oh the money would have been so much more if IID found a way to pay for another train the problem is trains are expensive and they only get more expensive as the game goes on and the big way that you do this is either buying stocks which puts money into these companies um this is an incremental capitalization type game as opposed to a full capitalization type game this is the kind of stuff for like a general essay on 18xx as opposed to what I'm trying to go into here but yeah you can buy stocks to put money into the company so that it can buy trains and you can issue stocks to the bank to get money based off of its stock price and you can withhold your funds that you got for running your trains all into the company instead of paying it out to the shareholders and this is the part that I'm very bad at I never did it in the first game and I lost and in the second game I think I did it once and I won so I'm not here trying to say oh you need to withhold to win win the game but I do think that I was in a really strong position in that second game and I could have won by even more if I had done some withholding now the reason I I don't withhold generally is because I get greedy when I'm playing economic type

games um I am a shareholder in this company and I want to be paid by that company so that I can buy stocks in other companies that just makes sense to me if I withhold the money into that company I as an investor don't get any money but the company gets that money instead that can spend on that precious train to give me even more revenue from running bigger routes later on so essentially I play these games very shortsighted essentially and I I want to learn how to play them more far-sighted now coming back to the mergers um late or early what we realized as we were playing that second game as we were all struggling and my two opponents in particular were struggling to get the money necessary for their mandatory minimum number of trains and we were proceeding to the late game where trains were incredibly expensive we started to realize like it was like impossible to get the am amount of money together to pay for these ludicrously expensive trains based off of the runs that we had even if we withheld multiple times we were going to have to do it too many times to actually even get there and then there was this moment I remember Matt was sitting across the table from me I saw it Dawn on him and it dawned on me at the same moment and we're like mergers if you have two companies that can't get enough money by themselves to buy trains by themselves merge them into one company because you also merger the treasuries of these companies and suddenly instead of having one company with 400 bucks and another one with 400 bucks neither of which able to put the $700 together to buy a train now it's one company with $800 and boom they can buy that train and it was definitely an

interesting moment because when we got to the second merging round and everybody decided not to actually merge none of us were thinking about this and I strongly think pretty much all of us should have merged if we had the opportunity to and most of us did in that second round to consolidate that money that was being made in order to actually get access to those better trains um there's so much more I could say I've already talked about Railways of the Lost Atlas a ton I am super excited by this game I love the map building element um I've seen some friends also post uh images of what their Maps look like I think the fact that you can build your own map and have it be just crazy is just a wonderful element to this game that adds a lot of replayability from one game to the next and I I will admit the number one thing that's kind of sticking out of my brain right now is I'm super curious to try a long game now one of the reasons I bought this game is so that I would have an 18xx game that was short enough that I can actually get it played this is the only 18xx game I buy I've passed on buying lots of them including shikoku 1889 which I played a couple times and Al likee I never actually bought it because in my experience that game for me and my group still took like 5 hours to play which is just a lot longer than I would want to play then this one comes around and I can can teach and play it to complete new people in three and a half hours that's starting to get to a spot where I can actually get this played more but again that was the short game it's my understanding the long game is going to add at least an hour probably an hour and a half to the game but that should go down as you get more experienced now the reason I want to try

the long game is because again there are 12 different companies that you play with instead of eight and it's always the same four that are excluded one of the excluded ones lets you build over water the bridging company that sounds super cool I want to try that another one the spacious company has an increased train limit so we can hold more trains than normal that sounds like it could potentially be incredible like almost feel broken or something like that I want to play with the spacious company and and really lean into figuring out a way to run multiple trains you know be more longterm thinking instead of short-term thinking also the map is just bigger and I just really want to try it I know it's going to be a longer experience and so part of me thinks I'm probably going to have to keep playing the short game to teach this game but if I am in a situation where I play this with people who know it already I'm going to really push to try the long game at least once just to see how that feels and how quote unquote long it actually is as compared to the short game I think it's very likely I will mostly play the short game even though the long game feels like the full experience but maybe time will actually change that for me I I won't know until I actually try I do want to mention at the end of this segment which I really should wrap up even though I feel like I could talk about this game for another hour is micro games um as I said I've played Short games and there are long games but on the other side there are micro games which it's my understanding you can get played in like 90 minutes with people who are still relatively new and if you really know what you're doing with regards to 18xx you could play a micro game in one hour now I've been told that these feel a little bit more

puzzly than like your standard train game kind of experience but I'm curious to see what that's like I think that is probably the best way to introduce somebody to this game and to 18xx games in general if they're really not sold on the idea now again I can't necessarily endorse it because I haven't tried it yet but I've heard good things about it and I am curious to give it a go and I'd like that this game that I own that's in our collection has that option there so maybe someday somebody will be like you know I'm down for 90 minutes just to see if I know hate train games or not I would happily toss this down and actually get the game played there it's a much smaller map there's like four companies I think instead of eight so it's a much more confined overall experience but hopefully that actually works in the ways that everybody else seems to be really enjoying and yeah I am desperately wanting to play this game more honestly I keep going to the board game geek page looking up to see if there are new Forum posts or ratings or something just because I want to experience this game even more and I haven't had a chance to play it again since those two and hopefully I can actually make that happen I clearly have the excitement to and if I have new opinions or if I try new things like micro games or long games don't worry I will definitely record an updated uh segment to let you know how my opinion may or may not have changed all right we now have an update for Railways of the Lost Atlas this is a game I talked a lot about just a couple of episodes ago and I have played this game a couple of times since then and I've seen it played

even more times than that I brought this one to the Portland games Collective convention uh last week and we played two games of this within 24 hours and two of my friends that I played with actually played four games in 24 hours and that's because of micro games and whatnot so let's talk about the long game and micro games because that is the two things that I didn't really discuss in the last segment because I hadn't experienced them well we got to the convention and we sat down to play a four-player long game it was the first time playing for one person and then the rest of us had played before none of us had played the long game before though the long game being a six round game instead of a four round game also a game with all 12 miners instead of just eight so we sat down to play this game we built a uh a world with all the tiles if you're looking at a video version of this you can see uh exactly what that world looked like at the end of the game and we proceeded to play very poorly so this was technically going to be a long game which is a larger map it has all of the miners and you're supposed to go six rounds like I just said we stopped after four rounds we didn't do this because uh we were uh having a bad time or anything like that we did it because of all the asterisks that were piling up uh we had four significant asterisks as we played the game I'm the only player who didn't have one so we kind of joked that I won even though technically after four rounds I came in second place uh one person coming right out of the first stock round was going to be bankrupt

that's because they invested all their money in a company that would have then needed to buy a three train and they didn't have enough money to actually cover it so the as risk was we said they could move their money around a little bit so that okay cool they're not bankrupt we're now continuing to play once we were in the I think second out of the four rounds we ended up playing another player would have gone bankrupt because again they were forced to use their own money to buy trains for a company that needed those trains so we just said okay well here take a free like $60 or whatever it takes for you not to be bankrupt because we want to keep playing so we kept playing um in the third cycle another player a third player this time went bankrupt and we let them take like hundred extra dollars to keep playing and then in the fourth round that player that third player went bankrupt a second time and this is why we decided you know we're just going to call it after this fourth cycle because you know technically you don't have to stop playing when somebody goes bankrupt but at this point everyone but me had gone bankrupt at least once and we figured let's just wrap it up um you know it felt like a decent stopping point for the game already and uh and we had enjoyed it and we kind of wanted to you know move on to something else not because the game is going too long so I want to talk about the long game in its full long Glory but I I am not able to do that because we didn't actually see that we stopped it somewhat early but we still had a blast and it took us like 3ish hours including the map building and all that um and I think that's

pretty great you know that's right around where I was hoping the short game would be or you know get better as time went on and this is sort of the long game even though we only played the short game number of rounds now the reason why this happened is because why all the bankruptcies happened is because we're all new to this game and everybody built two companies uh or started off two miners in the very first stock round I think this also caused the game to be longer because that meant right there in the first two o there were eight different miners that were running and the more miners there are the more time is going to take to get through the operating round but the problem is there aren't enough two trains to facilitate all these so you're going to have people forced into the three train um in that very first o which I've seen in pretty much every game that I've played and we're starting to realize is just a mistake especially considering I didn't see the bankruptcies in the previous games but we did in this long game so maybe it's a long game element or maybe we were just being more Cutthroat but the train rush started so early that we weren't really able to get our own you know economies going and more importantly we weren't able to get cross and investing going we were so focused on desperately funneling all of our cash back into our companies that we have the most stock in to be able to buy trains so that we would survive the train rush but of course as we do this we are causing the train rush to happen and happen it just causes for essentially fail game states with bankruptcies and people getting knocked out what we've

realized moving forward is you know in that first stock round if you're in a position to start like the sixth seventh or eighth of the miners don't certainly the eighth don't do that the seventh probably don't and the sixth maybe there's an argument to be made for it and the reason for this is because unless you have enough money somehow with that second minor that you're getting to win an auction to put that company in the first six operating steps as opposed to being tied for last and going last you're going to be in trouble um and you're going to find yourself overextended and you're going to find yourself being forced to buy into those three trains go you know forced train buys right there in the very first o and it it's fun we had a lot of fun with it but we went away from the game feeling like man I wish we could play this game again like right now but we had like dinner plans that's part of the reason we called it too it was it wasn't going quote unquote too long and I think if we had kept playing it we would have wrapped it up in another hour even though that's two more Cycles just because things were getting Consolidated with merged companies which means less companies are actually running and that kind of thing so anyway we finished this game we went on to uh a game night at another place and we all the four of us found ourselves at the same Airbnb three of us were staying there one person crashed on the couch and it was midnight and that person said hey you guys want to play a micro game see what the micro game is like and we all you know dumbly said yeah so we started an 18xx game at midnight um the same day that we played the long game um with the idea of being

that we're going to play the micro game this time um now the game does not actually technically support a four-player micro game it comes with two and three player micro games but there's a forum post on line where the designer said yeah you could do this that and the other thing to essentially set yourself up for a four-player micro game so we decided to give it a go figuring that you know it was a micro game we'd finish it in like an hour and we'll be done at 1:00 a.m. and it'll be great well what ended up happening is it did take two hours we finished at 2 a.m. and we essentially played a pseudo short game so the micro games take four Cycles just like the short game but they have less other things going on a much smaller app less starting money that kind of thing and so we started that game off I just uh if you're watching the video version of this one I just switched over to the endgame state of the micro game you can see that the map is significantly smaller here um and there are other restrictions there's only one rusting there's only value two three and four trains when four trains are purchased the twos are rusted that means you never actually get into the purples or the gray tiles it's it's a micro game after all it's supposed to be a really quick version of this showing you know a subset of the overall 18xx experience when what ended up happening is it essentially felt like a short game um you know a four-player short game it took us 2 hours and it was wonderful like we all had so much fun with it it was really good I won so that felt good as well um and it was cool to be able to jump into this we were hoping it would be more like 60 to 90 minutes since it was a micro game you know pushing 2 o'clock in the morning was getting really late but it was cool to see how

this all worked and the big takeaway from this beyond the fact that there's only one uh rusting that happens beyond the fact that there's a smaller map the biggest takeaway that I had is in this micro game players don't start with enough money to begin two miners in the first stock round and I think this is part of the reason why you can jump in and is faster because in the first two oos which is you know a quarter of the O in the game operating rounds sorry the quarter of the operating rounds in the game there were only four miners as opposed to Prior in that day with the long game we had stupidly started eight miners so that meant those initial operating rounds took half the amount of time cuz they were half the number of miners that were running and everybody in that first stock round started a minor and then started investing in other companies or their minor again and so we had cross investing going right for the very beginning of the game and I loved that it was so cool to see that happen and it got me really excited about the future for short games because you know if we don't all just start two Miners and are are so poor that we can't cross invest if we actually are a little bit smarter that could be a lot of fun but it also got me thinking I remember the next day day we woke up and we were talking about it I was like I think I'd rather uh instead of playing another four-player micro game which again is not technically supported I'd rather just play a four-player short game where you have a random assortment of eight of those 12 miners so you have some variety there and where maybe you start with a little bit less money as in not $240 which is the minimum that you need to start two miners I actually really liked not being able to start that second

minor which meant mergers were not going to happen in the first round and it just cooled things down what this has me thinking is that is for the future if I teach this game to new people it should absolutely be a short game but I think I might manually tweak the money to make sure that nobody has enough to buy two miners so that nobody falls into that trap and that mistake and they can play the game not being forced into those things and not having a crazy train rush right at the very beginning and then if I'm playing this with you know everybody knows what's going on then we'll play with the rules as written and let people potentially make those mistakes and hypothetically not make those mistakes because we start to have some experience so it was just really fun to explore this twice within 24 hours and then two of the people that were in both of these games the next day played two two-player micro games so I said there were two people who played this four times in 24 hours that's because they played the micro game that comes in the box and they finished each of those micro games in less than an hour including building the map and that is so cool now I wasn't able to actually play these but I talked to them about it and they enjoyed the first one so much that they played it again the micro game again like two hours later and that's just so cool like they were working this in between other games at an open Game Day type thing where it's like oh it's just the two of us let's just play a quick game of 18xx 45 minutes finish up and then move on and it was just so cool there's just a lot of zeal a lot of excitement about this game it was just a lot of fun to play it so much to to see it played so much and I think this one is going to be sticking around for a while and I'm really looking forward to playing it more I

have another game scheduled in just a couple of days and I'm super looking forward to it that might be a five player game and if the five player game feels significantly different I'll definitely do another one of these uh updates for Railways of the Lost Atlas I suspect I might be talking about this one for a decent chunk of time into the near future all right let's move on to the other game of the month I'm talking about today and that is ano 1800 with the expansion now I'm calling this the airships expansion online it's just the expansion although it's actually just in German so it doesn't even say that ano 1800 is a game that came out like three years ago or so and I loved it uh we made a uh playthrough video it's on jits games uh it was talked about on the friendly ties podcast I played it a whole bunch and then like two or so years ago this expansion was announced and I decided I was going to stop playing it because I wanted essentially a little bit of a break I'd been playing it a bunch and I said well I'll wait till the expansion comes out you know I won't play it for a year or so and then I'll try it with the expansion and it'll probably be great well the expansion took a long time to come out it finally just released in German and it will very likely never never get an English uh version and I bought it on amazon.de and got a copy about a week and a half ago so I was able to get this played once it was three players uh with me uh Jessica my wife and then Anastasia also came over to play it and what I'm going to be talking about today is what this game is like with the expansion I'll do a super brief uh explanation of what the base game is like though right here at the start um Down Below in the description I'll put a link to the first time I

talked about what this game was like as well if you want a little bit more context for it now this is a game designed by Martin Wallace and the idea is each player is building up Industries on their own board you're building a tableau in front of you and as you build up Industries and do things you are going to be using your Workforce putting cubes down onto these different spots to make resources to then make industries that can then make you further resources you essentially start off with basic things like planks of wood and pigs and some uh string and you might end the game with like artillery and making uh cars and you know that kind of thing now the key cool part about this game is that you use each other's stuff in positive ways if I want to build something and it requires canned food and you make canned food then I can use your canned food in fact you can't stop me from doing it I'll have to use trade tokens and then you are going to get gold gold is a really nice resource in this game it turns into victory points at a rate of three to one and you can also spend your gold to essentially get more actions out of your cubes before you have to spend a whole turn resetting all of your cubes now the key to this game is cards you start the game with nine cards in your hand and the game ends once any player has played all of their cards that is the only way the game ends and that did not change with the expansion also and when you play these cards they have resource costs on top and again you're going to have to activate Industries on your board and trade with other players to get those specific costs to play the cards these cards will be worth victory points to you and they get you stuff like more

people which might give you more cards or very ious other effects like new trade tokens and gold and things like that now the idea is you want to have the most points when the game is over you get seven bonus points if you're the person to actually trigger the end of the game but that does not necessarily mean you are going to be the person who wins and so the game is all about building up enough industry spending enough turns to get that industry going but then also trading with your opponents as much as you realistically can so that you save yourself whole turns building industries that they've already invested in and you can make use of so that's the general idea of the base game and then what the expansion brings in is a few different elements it's kind of modular overall although not explicitly so so the first significant difference that comes in with the expansion is changes to the base game rule set the first of these has to do with trading in the base game if I was to trade for your uh coats for example that's a really high level thing I am going to spend a bunch of trade tokens and you will get one gold you would also get one gold if I traded for your planks of wood which is a super basic thing the person who gets traded with gets one gold in the expansion that's different now the person you traded with gets gold equal to the number of trade tokens you spend I'm going to have to use two trade tokens in order to make use of your coat so now you're going to get two gold that is a pretty significant difference there's a lot more gold in the system and honestly this is a rule that trip people up a lot with the base game I like that they changed this rule they changed a few other tweaks to the rules I don't want to go into all the specifics but that

trading one is really huge and then the first new mechanic that they brought in is the idea of inventions at the start of the game you're going to shuffle up this invention deck and you'll put eight of them face up onto the table and on your turn you can invent one of these cards now in the base game on your turn all you could do was a single main action and then you could also do a bunch of free actions but with the expansion now you do your one main action and you may create one invention and these inventions generally give you gears which is a new resource in order order to complete an invention you just have to make the associated resource so if that invention requires artillery for example then you have to make artillery somehow and you have to actually make it you cannot trade for that artillery so this essentially gives extra incentive for teching into various things that you might not need based off of the cards that you have in your hand now I mentioned that most of these inventions give you gears well on your turn the third thing that you can do in addition to making an invention and doing a main action is you can do a gear action spending these to do another type of action essentially you could spend one gear to build industry which is one of the main actions so that means you could build industry for your main action then complete an invention getting you gears and then spend a gear to build another industry essentially building two industries in one turn which is something you could never do in the base game so in a lot of ways what these inventions do is they they just add a bunch more incentives for teching up for getting into the higher tier stuff so that you can have more efficient turns

and you can do more things on your turns because at the end of the day this is a race game you get a certain number of turns and you don't know how many that's going to be you keep playing until one person plays all of their cards and if you spend a turn doing effectively nothing then that's really bad and if you are able to utilize these gears to essentially do a double turn then that is effectively good because that lets you just get ahead in this race as you are trying to play all your cards as are probably your opponents now there is more going on in this game in particular the high level ships are gone and they've been replaced with airships which is part of the reason why in my head I consider this the airships expansion these airships are worth more victory points which is nice and they also give even more stuff even though the price is the same and realistically the overall feel that I have for this game is it's kind of like a patch for the original game it tweaks some things around and it adds some new mechanics but the new mechanics that it adds feels like it fixes some of the problems with the original game I loved the original game but I also felt like it was kind of flawed in particular it was a tech kind of game where you start simple and you get really complex by the end of the game and it always felt like the game ended halfway or like two-thirds through that complexity the highest level stuff like the best chips and the best Technologies almost never got made before somebody ended the game and that really bummed me out I wanted to the game to feel like it had the full breadth of the experience that it was showing you with these things on the table like there are technologies that I think I've literally never seen built

over the course of all of the plays of this that I've had and that that bummed me out so here comes the expansion and those inventions are a great way to make this happen because you can do again one main action on your turn you're always going to get to do that but you can also complete an invention that's essentially an extra action because it gives you gears that let you do more actions as well so you're heavily incentivized to go after these inventions and that means there might be an invention for example that you can complete if you have a stopwatch but you have no cards in your hand with stopwatches but that stopwatch is actually really simple for you to get right now you have all the other prerequisites maybe you should spend your turn making that stopwatch so that you then have a stopwatch right now that you can then activate right now to complete that invention to give you gears that you could then spend doing the industry that you actually really wanted what you've done is first of all you've given yourself Points each of those inventions are worth two points to you and you now have stopwatches that you didn't need for anything else but it was pretty easy easy for you to get at and now the fact that you have stopwatches means somebody else across the table who might need a stopwatch is like o and then they trade for you with that for that stopwatch giving you two gold which lets you do something else so you're incentivized to do things to push yourself further into the tech tree earlier which means maybe you're going to be able to get to some of the later game stuff now that's all a little bit hypothetical um we played this game once I've not had a chance to play it again and I really want to play this game again I very much enjoyed it and I very much enjoyed watching Jessica and Anastasia play with the expansion the

reason I say that is because for some reason after all these years of not playing this game waiting for this expansion once the game hit the table I just played the base game essentially effectively like I played with the strategies that I had based off of around the base game not using the expansion and I realized when the dust settled I essentially didn't interact with almost any of the expansion pieces and I lost by a lot it was not even close the person who leaned most into the expansion was Jessica and she won by a decent margin I think she played a decent game overall but also because she leaned into the new stuff that this expansion was bringing in it just let her be a whole lot more effective and about two-thirds the way through the game I realized what was happening and I tried to change things around and lean into some mechanics of the expansion very poorly and I effectively feel like what I'm doing here is reporting what the game looks like when you watch somebody else actually interact with all these things and do all these things now I will admit that Jessica was a little bit frustrated with with her opponents who weren't really interacting with these things to be as efficient to build industry up she felt like she kind of had to do everything herself and that is what happened when the game ended I looked down at my area and I was like how did I do so little I essentially played an incredibly poor play of it honestly if we had not been playing with the expansion I think I still would have lost I don't know where I was in my head that night but I was not playing board games very well at all and so I was I was not really making things that she could use so she felt kind of like she needed to to do everything like I ended

up getting a decent amount of trade uh gold from trades for my mediocre industries that I built but you know like I said I was not able to put the all this stuff together to actually make things happen with these inventions I think I did two inventions by the end of the game and she did like six or eight or seven of them something like that she was able to use her gears to get a hybrid Airship which is like this double wide awesome Airship that's worth points and gives a bunch of uh exploration tokens and a bunch of trade tokens and she just leaned into a whole bunch of these various things uh there are new Mission cards that you have at in the middle of the table in the base game you put five of them out when you're playing with the expansion it advises that you use three base game ones and two expansion ones one of those let her build that hybrid Airship which was cool and she used a whole bunch and was really good for her she actually had way more trade than she could even use um and I think part of that's because I as one of her opponents wasn't really giving her great great options to even use those trade tokens which is definitely a funny part of the overall uh incentives and like the way the economies of each of the opponents works out together like me playing poorly meant that she didn't play as well but she still played better than both of us essentially creaming us once the game was actually over so yeah that's my sort of an initial impression on the game I didn't actually personally play with the expansion stuff all that much but I watched it happen I will say that we didn't see any of the awesome other airships get built we o still didn't see any of the uh final tier workers come out before the game ended that was one

of my complaints about the original game is that the game frequently ended with nobody building the teal workers which meant nobody built teal Technologies Jessica certainly could have but she spent so much of her time building up other things that we weren't like again she kind of had to do everything herself she didn't really have time to go and do the teal stuff so she didn't and that's fine I mean she won the game so obviously she played it better than the rest of us in that way and I'm I guess what I'm saying is that jury is still a little bit out when it comes to the teal worker and playing with it I really want to make that happen and part of the reason I did so poorly if I'm being honest about this play a I think my head was in a weird spot but also b i so badly wanted to play with the end game stuff that I did not play with the early to mid game stuff which gets you to the endgame stuff for example I wasn't building any new ships because I was like no I want airships I want the new stuff I'm just going to hold off and do other things until I can Tech up and then actually build airships well I never built an Airship because because they're really expensive they're hard to get to I needed to build industry in order to get there essentially I was so selfish wanting to interact with expansion stuff I that I put off interacting with most of the stuff so I didn't Tech into anything and I I played a very poor play of it while watching other people play the game well and have a much more interesting time with it well surprise I was able to actually play ano 1800 with the airships expansion again before I put out the opinions episode with the originally a recorded segment so I'm GNA slide this update in right here to talk a little bit more about a specific play I've now

played it twice now in this second play I leaned hard into the expansion because again as I explained at Great length prior to this I kind of didn't do the expansion stuff in my first play and I really liked it it was fun to actually see what happened essentially in this play I looked at my starting hand of cards and five of my cards needed shirts this is one of the kind of standard Tech so on my first turn I built a shirt factory now that ended up being it for me for these basic um Industries until the very end of the game because by the time it came to my second turn I was sitting there thinking use the expansion don't play this like original ano 1800 so instead I built glass now glass is one of the blue industry tiles but it's a tile that's usually built many turns in once the general infrastructure of like canned food and sausages and schops and shirts and all that kind of stuff has been establish establ lished but instead I did it on my second turn and the reason for this is because there was an innovation card for stopwatches and stopwatches require glass and Brass so I just started teching hard at the very beginning of the game to try and lean into that element I figured that if I'm able to get this Innovation like four turns in or so then I could get a couple of gears and then I could use those gears to get schnaps and soap and that kind of stuff with free gear actions instead of spending my full whole turns to do it so then the next turn came around and I built brass and then before the turn after that we had a interesting moment essentially I forgot that patents

existed I I don't remember how much I talked about patents in the last section but I do remember thinking after the first play that patents didn't seem necessary like I remember enjoying the idea of it essentially you put a patent down on top of an industry that you've built and now nobody else can trade for that industry until you use it the first time or until you do a city festival to reset everything we didn't use this at all in our first game and I forgot it was a thing so now here's the second game I have glass I have brass and then Jessica on her turn right before me says okay I'm going to trade for your glass and your brass to build stopwatches and it was like wait a second I spent my entire early game building up towards this and now you're going to trade for these things and then take that Innovation card right before I get it when I spent very obviously spent all this time trying to get there and and clearly I would have patented one one of those Industries if I had remembered it was a thing if if the whole concept of being sto being stolen out from underneath me um was in my head um we ended up actually reconing it she let me patent it and we kind of moved on but that was something I wanted to point out because I now believe that very strongly that patents exist entirely because of the Innovation System because if that didn't exist then it would not be worth your time to Tech up to these things to grab those Innovations because you can't trade for a stopwatch that somebody else has built already for an innovation but you can trade for the materials to build your own stopwatch Factory and of course somebody could do that after I build my own stopwatch Factory but also after

that I've hypothetically taken the Innovation which lowers the impetus for other people to do that so this first little anecdote from the game is just to say that patents are incredibly important when you actually interact with the Innovations and certainly in the early stages of the game now from that point on WE continued to play I got a whole bunch of inovations because I had teched up so hard but also in addition to that since I built brass on my third turn a sewing machine got built very soon after that and then um coats got built relatively soon after that as well and coats are essentially the prerequisite to turn your purples into teals and as I mentioned in the previous News segment nobody built any teals in that first game which was a little bit of a red flag because that was one of my main problems with the original game and I was really hoping the expansion would fix that well in this second play of it it was a four- player game three out of the four players ended up teching up to teal by like the 60% Mark so the ramp was there it did exist it's not a theoretical thing because I pushed so hard to get that Innovation early and other people kind of leap frogged off of that and gave me a bunch of gold to do it um we were able to get to those midate stages of the tech trees much faster than I've seen before and in fact all three of those people who got the teal workers also built an Airship hanger and built those level four airships nobody actually built the explor ship that's worth seven points because nobody got the big guns but somebody did make cannons to make some lower level

Explorer ships but there were several of those trade airships out there which give four trade tokens which is huge now I keep saying three out of the four I was the fourth I was the person who did not get up to teal I contemplated it I didn't actually do it I actually built Windows using my glass to hypothetically upgrade some Reds into purple that I could also go purple to teal but it didn't end up quite working out for me I did not win this game I think I might have come in second or third um I played much more competently in this play but Jessica still won uh by a decent margin I think about 11 points yeah I came in second and she's just very good at this game and it was just cool to see all the stuff actually working it was great to see some basic airships being built it was cool to see people leap frogging off um two steam engines were built built and I don't think I think in the base game I saw a single steam engine get built like in every third game or so which is really rare but you know we had uh competing steam engine technology we had uh cars we had just so much stuff going on um and it was a joy honestly it was really cool to see all this stuff happen now uh the game ended with me I played all of my cards and it took about two hours I will admit that it was starting to feel like okay this game should probably wrap up part of that is because two of the people who were playing had never played ano 1800 at all before so they were completely new to the overall system and then we threw this expansion on top of it but I will say that when the game was over and we

were kind of chatting uh both those people honestly couldn't fathom playing anim 1800 without the expansion the thought of not beginning with a purple had them furing their eyebrows thinking like what how does that even work and wait you have twoo less of those starting ships that seems terrible and wait if there's no innovation then why are you teching and you know I'm just nodding my head the whole time saying yes yes exactly this is why I think they made the expansion and that also leads me to essentially my current position on this game after two plays I think it is kind of a Norwegians expansion you know that referencing uh a froden Norwegians which just patched and fixed and made a feast for Odin from a good game into just a brilliant game I think the airships expansion is starting to feel pretty mandatory to me I cannot imagine playing ano 1800 without it again so so I'm really glad that I have this copy of it it's unfortunate that it's only in German I mean it's mostly language independent but not entirely and um it's going to be a lot harder for you know people in the US to get access to it but if you do uh have an inclination I would say snap it up get it from amazon.de that's where I bought it from it's still there right now this feels like an expansion that might not sell super well and might be really hard to find later on so if you own ano 1800 and you think you might want to try it I'd say give it a go go ahead and grab it because uh you know I can't I can't read the future but I'm going to be very happy that I continue to have this one and I'm looking forward to playing it more it just feels like the better game they made they took a great game and they made it better well

as I mentioned at the beginning I had a lot to say about these games I hope you enjoyed learning about them uh they definitely overshadowed a lot of other games uh I actually played and covered 18 different games in those opinions Vlogs over the last month I went to the Portland games Collective convention and I actually got to play both railways the Lost Atlas and an 1800 with the expansion at that convention which is kind of funny because that's a trick-taking climbing game card game oriented convention and here I am talking about a Martin Wallace Euro and an 18xx game but yeah uh I played a lot of cool games and these were definitely at the top of the pile from this last month and I'm looking forward to see what's going to be at the top of the list for next month as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including these producer level patreon supporters if you too would like to directly support the channel in the creation of future videos just like this one then please go to jungus games.com Support also if you enjoy this video then please click the like button for it down below as well as the Subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved