Inventions: Evolution of Ideas - Review
Transcript
today we're reviewing inventions evolution of ideas from Eagle Griffin games uh Mark Maya and this is boarding coffee thank you oh I love you too thank you thank you before we start you should know that all the components seen in this video are from the Prototype version of the game and do not necessarily represent the final look of the product that said it's still damn pretty now back to our review inventions is the latest game from esteem designer Vita lucerta and illustrated by the ridiculously talented emo tool I mean seriously just look at this artwork oh tools absolutely excellent sense of visual design and attention to detail is the gift that keeps on giving somehow this guy manages to conjure up a unique aesthetic for every project he works on that elevates it from Mere game to full-on experience so you like the art yeah sorry inventions is a one to four player competitive worker placement about the evolution of ideas and the pursuit of knowledge required to make those ideas a reality and it is brilliantly executed but with that said I gotta warn you there is a lot of upfront information to take in when learning this game that might scare a few of you off and the last thing I want to do is scare you off because this game is too good to miss
if if you like heavy Heroes since this game arrived at my door I've taught it to a few people and the common sentiment tends to be I'm not smart enough to play this and I get that I do when inventions was first taught to me I was overwhelmed there was just so much going on so many possible options of things to do and different ways to do them that I felt paralyzed I didn't get it and I was convinced that I would never get it hell if it wasn't for Ryan holding my hand through the entire experience I'm not convinced anything would have been gotten and yes for those of you wondering that is Mr Ryan Shoon from Man vs meeple oh my God I thought that was a picture okay all right my initial struggle with the rules wasn't because I'm an idiot you mean that's not the only reason
it was because I was approaching it all wrong I was trying to commit every possible action to memory when what I needed to do was learn how to read you see like other games in the lasarda O'Toole lineup helpful iconography is strewn all over the board to help guide you through your experience look here every possible action you can take on your turn is made up of multiple steps and each of those steps is Illustrated on the board itself sure at first there will be a lot of what does this mean how does this work where does this go and that's okay because in the beginning it's going to seem impossible but then you're gonna reach that moment where you look down at the board and everything just clicks and when that happens you're gonna feel you can use now I can't speak to the learning aspect of inventions without bringing up the rule book and this one is really good I mean it's not on Mars good but it's very close the one I have here is just a loose page prototype printout yours yours will not be this I really like the layout of the book how each action has its own dedicated page with clearly explained instructions and visual examples and including the icon for each action on the corner of its respective page made it super easy to
find the information that I was looking for now much like on Mars inventions also comes with an easy to follow player Aid which is extremely useful except for one thing while I was still learning the game I would reference this player Aid quite a bit but when it came to looking up these specialist tiles I couldn't find absolutely any information in here at all so I did my best to interpret what I thought the icons meant based on what I knew of the other tiles and pushed forward eventually I did find the information I was looking for you know where I found it at the very back of the rule book now why I never flipped to the back of the rule book I I don't know maybe I stopped reading as soon as I reached the two player instructions because I was never intending to play with less than three or maybe because it came after three text Heavy pages of historical facts used to justify the existence of every card and tile in the game which I'm sure some people will absolutely love but to be honest I am never going to read so yes I am partly to blame for my own frustrations but regardless I cannot fathom why you wouldn't just include the information for those tiles in the player Aid with all the other tiles all right that's that's enough ranting let's take this in another Direction one of the primary aspects that I love about this game is how players can feed off
each other to better their own civilization for example let's say the yellow player had an idea for a lighthouse but they didn't know anything about sailing which meant at this point having a lighthouse was nothing more than a pipe tree but then Along Comes the purple player with all their sailing know-how and makes that idea a reality and what's this it appears the blue player has some ideas of their own to improve on this invention so they too hop on board the collaboration train and now we got three civilizations in one region making strides in evolutionary thinking and invention which is great but the fruits of their labor won't be truly realized until one of them shares this invention with the rest of humanity and I quite enjoy this part we need to share an idea the civilization who presented the idea gets to keep the points listed on the card the inventor of the idea gets to keep the card itself which has some useful benefits which we'll touch on later and the innovator this guy right here gets to increase the size of their civilization in that region by one I assume that's because they were so excited about their breakthrough that they just ran home to celebrate with the misses oh and the person who shared the idea gets to take one of these that's a whole other thing we'll we'll get to that later the loop of presenting an idea inventing that idea and sharing it with the world is what makes up the core of inventions gameplay and the
ability to collaborate with other players whether they like it or not is such a fun little mechanic sometimes I'll just present a bunch of ideas casting them out there like a worm and a hook just waiting for another civilization to take the bait let them invent it and when one of us inevitably shares the idea with the rest of the world who's getting all those points this guy sure you could present the idea invent it and share it all on your own hugging all the points cards and titles for yourself but where's the fun in that actually it is a lot of fun I recommend you should try it it's good it's a good time it's all good it's it's all good I like the concept that anybody can come up with an idea but you need the right knowledge to invent it just makes sense I also like to think of knowledge as a currency that you earn but never lose well almost never but we'll touch on that sore spot in just a bit speaking of knowledge knowledge all the knowledge in the world well at least this cardboard version of it is tracked files are Milestones that represent breakthroughs in human Ingenuity and the knowledge of your people all the tiles in this column represent common knowledge the stuff everyone knows fires tools transportation that sort of thing the column next to it represents knowledge exclusive to your people the yellow civilization for example are experts in Cotton but they know nothing
about sailing that's the Purple People specialty but you do have the option of sending over a diplomat to learn that Knowledge from the purple people which will allow you to invent things like the lighthouse which you couldn't have done before because you didn't have that knowledge but now you do right you you send over Mr yellow here to learn all he could so he could share that knowledge with the rest of your civilization so they could build all this cool stuff with the knowledge that they now know let's stick a pin in that idea for now Shelly inventions does a fabulous job of weaving together theme and mechanics into a beautiful gift basket filled with multiple Avenues to success that flows seamlessly into this big thematic picture laid out before us and nowhere does that shine more than with this Milestone mechanic you see as you progress forward ever trying to improve your Society by reaching one new Milestone after the next you start to impact what becomes known as common knowledge because what is now old news to you starts to permeate throughout the rest of humanity everyone else is learning from your advancements and I just love how all that plays into the context of the game's theme and how well it works as a game mechanic and it doesn't stop there As Time literally Marches On Any Milestones that would be considered
behind the times as indicated on this era track also fall into the parameters of common knowledge not only does this help less developed civilizations catch up it also drives home the idea that you're not the only civilizations on this planet doing stuff because time and stuff will continue to happen with or without you and although there are a lot of abstract bits two inventions I've never felt that it distracted from the overall theme well almost never remember Mr yellow the guy we sent over to learn all about sailing so his people can invent the lighthouse well if you you call him back your civilization loses all that knowledge the whole lot of them just forget it ever happened hey Jimbo ever wonder how we built these big concrete candles uh nope all right then you have yourself a nice day it's like the Men in Black showed up with their little flashy thing and wiped out everyone's memory I mean how does that even make sense how does a whole civilization forget how to do or build a thing that they've been doing for years I'd like to retract my previous statement interaction in the game of invention is
there but it's not all that aggressive or disruptive to other players there are very few things you can do that would classify as screwing over another player but it's not a heads down type of game either you're very aware of what everyone else is doing because it's possible that their actions will impact your next move but rarely have I felt locked out of whatever it is I wanted to do you see unlike a lot of other games that present you with a this is what you got so what are you gonna do with its scenario inventions simply asks the question what do you want to do and it's up to you to find the door that gets you there you see these are your 10 main actions and for the most part everything you'll ever want to do you can find right here and like any other worker placement to take one of those actions you just need to place a worker or a pillar on the action you want to take but here's the catch as long as one of your pillars is on an action you can't take that action nor the action next to it and the more pillars you place the more limited your options become but if you look closely around the board you'll recognize much of the same iconography used to identify a specific action depicted on the tiles cards and even the board itself this brings us back to the question what do you want to do assuming the simple
answer place your pillar on the action you want to take is out of the question you'll start to scan the board looking for a back door that leads you to the action you want to take but sometimes the path to that door isn't always a straight line maybe I take this action here which leads me to this Sage over here who allows me to present an idea that gets me to the invent action which in the end got me to the action I wanted to take in the first place this puzzle of figuring out how to get what I want in this crazy roundabout way of linking one action to another tickles my brain in the best possible way and I just want to tickle it all day it sounds dirty right because there's just me by now you've probably gathered that I'm a fan of inventions but there's one part that I am definitely not a fan of and that's the setup something about it just seems so fiddly and clumsy like I'm tripping over myself to get everyone everything they need and then just when you think it's over you move on to the Stone Age setup round which is basically a watered-down version of a regular round that you play to get you up and running with some minimum board presence and a few additional starting bonuses based on your placement choices now some people may argue that the game starts with the Stone Age setup round but it doesn't feel that way to me to me it feels more like an extension of the overly
cumbersome setup that has me constantly double checking the instructions because I'm sure that I missed something granted when the game starts up you can see why it was all necessary but it doesn't mean I have to like it oh Emma note that I should have probably mentioned when talking about the learning of this game teaching inventions is exhausting you're either teaching everything up front which can get tiresome or you're answering questions all the way through which which is exasperated by my knee to teach people how to read the iconography so they can figure things out on their own teach them into fish and all that if there was ever a need for one of those throwaway it's just a learning game games this is it just take it out for a spin try everything you can forget about winning and just get there and get dirty it's honestly the best way to learn I've said it before and I'll say it again there is a lot to inventions and a lot of it I haven't even covered there's these sages that will impart their wisdom for a cost of a single link influence markers that open up more link options and scoring possibilities and game scoring cards that act as achievements that award you points at the end of the game if you achieve them an influence track that earns you more links and your very own invention Supply that unlocks additional back doors to the actions you want to take and provides discounts for future progress titles which brings us to the society board think of this as a personal
progress board to help Propel your Society forward and earn you some buku points if you play it right the society board takes the game to a whole other level of Min maxing that you'll want to use to get the most out of your civilization as a new player you're probably not going to appreciate all that these progress Styles can do for you and if you're anything like me you'll just ignore it the first time you play and that's okay mind you if anyone else at the table is using the board and you are not you're probably gonna lose okay final thoughts inventions is in no way an entry-level game but you've probably be set together by now although if you're an experienced gamer looking to get into heavier Euros then the step-by-step approach Of Inventions iconography is a great first time experience although you probably won't realize that until you play it a second time the art in the game is great and fits the theme beautifully the teach can be tough but so worth it just hang in there because when you get it you're gonna love it and the thought-provoking gameplay will keep you engaged the whole time and as you get better the experience will too yeah I had a few little finicky complaints but nothing that should sway you from giving this game a try I personally think the game is awesome and after a play or two let's call it two to be safe I'm confident that you'll like it as well and with that I am happy to award inventions the board game coffee seal of approval you've earned it
in this thanks for joining us if you like this video and you want to see more subscribe to our channel it's the best way to keep up to date with everything we do here at board game coffee but if you want to see more right now we got plenty of videos to choose from and if that's not enough follow us on Instagram Facebook and Twitter I'm Mark Maya and this is board game coffee and remember have fun keep gaming be social see you next week