Skip to main content
Loading video...

Polis Review: Boy, Those Ancient Greeks Sure Loved Wheat! - By Board Of It

Transcript 12:43

talia and farrell here from border vic and we're here to help you solve your problem we know you love board games but there just isn't enough about wheat we present you polis the game about creating the biggest baby boom by feeding your citizens ungodly amounts of wheat now i almost didn't want to review this game because i know that at some point i'm going to mess up the distinction between police which is one city and polis which is multiple and it can be really embarrassing for me but we just had so much fun playing this game that we really wanted to talk about it polis seems like it should be peloponnesian war simulator the game but in reality it's actually how much wheat can you get the game if you just looked at the box and read the blurb it would trick you because the reality is is that it's actually a very tight resource management game based around growing your civilization and expanding how many polis are under your control the players will play as either sparta or athens with both aiming to become the most powerful ancient greek civilization hmm what's this hello hate those guys

the board is split into territories with each territory having a variable number of polis you'll start asymmetrically with each civilization controlling three polis each polis is represented by a card and it has population on them with each cube representing a population on your turn you'll do two actions but you can't do the same action twice some of these actions include removing these population cubes from your cards to turn them into units so they can become hoplites galleys or merchants other actions allow you to move these around the board and you could also lay siege to a police and where you attack it and bring it to your league by force or you can be sneaky about it you can send your proximos to apollos and you can bribe the population with silver to instigate civil war and they also come over to your league now importantly when you control a policy you can demand tribute and this will allow you to take a pic of whatever resources they generate and these resources will then allow you to further your expansion now the difficulty lies in that many of these actions require you to spend prestige prestige is your most valuable resource and is also your victory points if you ever end a round without any prestige you automatically lose you don't just get given it either you have to earn it by doing projects which is essentially building temples and wonders you can earn it by absorbing

polis into your league and you can also get it from doing well in battle the game will last for three rounds and each round or error will end when both players have passed now what you want to do is you want to end the game with a lot of police cards with a lot of population cubes on them because you'll get one prestige for each population cube you have at the end of the game you'll also get a prestige for each police that has more population cubes than it began with or more than its base population you'll also get some end game prestige for certain projects and finally any prestige that you had left over will be added to your score however at the end of each round you have to pay as many wheat as you have cubes on these cards and you can only grow your population if you have spare wheat and wheat is very hard to get the first time you play police you're going to find it very tough and very unforgiving the game actually reminds me of most is barrage in feel if not in gameplay there are several traps that if you fall into them you will lose the game and have a bad time of it for example in my first game i turned the only cube that i could use to make a merchant into a soldier instead then because i didn't have the second merchant i could never get enough wheat and then because i didn't have enough wheat i couldn't increase my population to get more cubes which then meant i couldn't ever create a second merchant and you can see how that would have

ended and that was the only game that i've won great game that said what we like is as brutal as it sometimes feels familiarity and learning the nuances really opens up the game you'll be ending the round with more wheat getting more prestige to allow you to do what you want and be ending the game with significantly higher scores than you did on your first game familiarity and learning where the traps are is really going to open police up and it becomes a rewarding experience following on from paulus being tough we'd like to say that the rule book is pretty great and the actions themselves are fairly simple if you're an experienced board gamer you're going to pick this up in no time and it's also surprisingly intuitive which is a comment i had from a friend after teaching it for the first time even better our scores in that game were only two apart despite me having much more experience playing polis and that's always a good sign of intuitive design now for what this is the setup is lightning quick which makes it easier to get to the table and because the actions are simple as we said the turns go by quite quickly even though it's a big chunky thinking game so policy clips along at a really nice pace and it just never overstays its welcome so trading trading is very important in police so luckily it's a cool action to take once you've traded for the allotted value you will roll this dice twice and

move the cube up the track for that good by the lowest amount that you rolled this means that if you can get in there first you can trade for less and you can even prevent your opponent from trading at all because you just priced them out on the other hand you could roll two fours and then you just look at each other in horror trading is also really important for feeding your population so if you want a more interactive game this is going to be where the action is moving your galleys to control a new sea allows you access to their market and taking the trade action that they have been saving up for for ages is absolutely diabolical and could just win you the game less war of the worlds more war of the wheat as you just mentioned war we should speak about the battle system now there's an entire deck of cards and a couple of pages in the rulebook dedicated to this but in all the games we've played we have never once had a combat i find that really strange but it's probably a plus for the game because i think after our third one we were like well we've got to see what it's about so we did a fake battle and it was really tedious and confusing and personally we think that this is down to the design choice of having historically accurate terminology in really small font and also the fact that a lot of the cards have very similar images but the reason it's a problem is because it kind of boils down to a matching game of luck based on what

cards you draw and whether you're the attacker the reason combat doesn't occur is because firstly it's super costly to move your troops around so you're better off moving them and calling for tribute secondly combat occurs when there's eight troops in one region so in the first round that's impossible and in the second round also pretty unlikely so yeah that's the combat don't expect it all this being said paulist is almost certainly a sandbox of a game in that you'll get out of it what you put in we're pretty sure some people will play this and go ah if i move my ships here sparta can't trade excellent and that will start a whole thing whereas others will say i'd rather spend my prestige on calling for tribute and trading with those goods the bottom line is different people will experience different aspects of police based on the type of game that they want to play it's just that we find it strange that after playing so many games that we've never been forced to interact with some of the mechanisms one thing we worry a little about is if police will become stale after a fair few plays particularly with the same person each civilization has very obvious opening moves and in the first era it can really feel like you're just going through the motions at times now there are event cards that are drawn before each error which can shake things up and are supposed to but all too often we've got cards that save no event or just have no meaningful

impact on the board state but in defense of police the variable values of goods for trading at the marketplace and what projects come up when can push players in different directions now while we're certainly not tired of policy yet we do worry that if you play with the same player over and over and particularly if you're playing in a non-confrontational more euro style way that this game allows you'll become locked into the same predictable moves each game but this isn't something you have to worry about if you're going to play with new players most of the time or if you're just a more aggressive player more confrontational more antagonistic with each other then it's probably okay the other thing is whilst it is a really great game and it does feel different to anything else we have in our collection mechanistically nothing is novel here it's certainly not a must-have game nor one that we would avidly recommend over other games and whilst in the next section we'll say hey this is a really great proposition bottom line is not having it won't leave a police sized hole in your collection get it if you have the spare money and it calls to you what first attracted me to this game were the components i was reading a written review on board game quests and i just saw some photos and i went wow this looks incredible and it was an instant buy for me and what we can say is that the components are so high quality you've got the beautiful silk screens on

the merchants and proximos and it just everything looks great also there's a really good storage solution so it packs away really quickly and if you're a regular viewer of the channel you know that we love divots and we think every game that needs it should have divots because it's a massive quality of life improvement and not only do the player boards have divots the main board house divots and we absolutely love it of course but what i find really cool is that this tribute and trading kind of bored it could have been a separate board that just sat on the table somewhere but they've incorporated it as part of the map it folds up and you even have divots for the markets on the map and it just really makes the game pop and just look incredible now i've seen this go for between 40 to 50 pounds and i'd have to say at that price if you're interested in this game it's a good deal just because of the gameplay and the high production value the conclusion is that police is a solid recommendation from us it's not a must-have game but if it interests you it will be a really nice addition to your collection what's really great is that polis allows you to play like a euro game with minimal interaction or more like a war game with more aggression so it will appeal to a wider range of players however be warned pause is a tight tough game where a simple mistake could take you out of it in the first round but police has great table presence

wonderful components interesting gameplay and an engaging theme check it out so thanks again for watching and please check back in next week for further reviews always with doggos and if you enjoyed this please like and subscribe and also just comment if you want to know anything about paulus or tell us about your police experiences bye bye

Progress saved