Skip to main content
Loading video...

Thunderstone Quest Review With Board Game Coffee

Transcript 8:36

today we're reviewing Thunderstone quest by AEG I'm mark Maia welcome to board game coffee Thunderstone quests is a competitive 2 to 4 player deck-building dungeon-crawling adventure sounds awesome right I mean everything about this game sounds like it's right up my alley I love deck building killing monsters and collecting treasure and Thunderstone has all of that with a variety of heroes monsters weapons magic items cetera even talking about it gets me all excited so what is this game frustrate me so much it's not exactly that I'm frustrated it's more like I'm irrationally angry after I read through the rulebook I was left with this feeling of alright that seems pretty straightforward let's do this Thunderstone quest is riddled with things that just baffle me and these aren't complicated matters mind you because it's not the function of the game that's confusing it's the instruction for example but not limited to the rulebook does cover what happens when you take damage you draw those turns but what happens when you take so much damage that your health reaches zero it's a question I had do you die ahead of the game is there a restart situation answer none of the above gotcha and you know and that's fine it's not the mechanic I have the problem with it's the instruction or the lack thereof nowhere in the rulebook does it say what

happens when your health reaches zero other than you draw no cards personally I would interpret my characters health reaching zero meaning that my character is now dead but that's not the case when your health reaches zero you can't draw cards that's it that's what happens you're basically immortal which again is fine I'm not arguing the mechanic I'm arguing the instruction and instruction is important because if you're watching this you're probably considering buying Thunderstone quest and dealing with the instructions is a major part of that experience if you're going to go against normal conventions you need to tell people these things especially new players I shouldn't be looking through your FAQ or scouring the forums of BoardGameGeek looking for such basic information ah yes of course duh Thank You mr.

buttmunch 69 Oh and according to the rule book the treasure chest icon on the bottom left corner of this card denotes that this is a treasure card but the exact same icon on this monster card means that you get a treasure when you kill this monster not that this monster is a treasure so the exact treasure chest icon located in the bottom left corner of those cards means two different things one icon two meanings here's a novel idea don't use the treasure icon on the treasure cards because it's mentioned in the rule book that these gold coins at the bottom of the card also denote that this is a treasure card why do I need two different icons to tell me what I'm looking at now I know no rulebook is perfect I've gone through forums before with questions about other games but never so soon or so frequent for the most basic of information I can go on about the questionable decisions used to convey information in this game but honestly I don't want to waste any more time on this game that I already have okay that was a little hurt Thunderstone quest isn't a waste of time once you decipher the rules it's actually pretty easy to teach to pretty much anyone there's really not much to and that's part of the problem when I saw this quest book for the very first time I was stoked I mean just look at all these quests wouldn't you be excited aren't you a little excited there's a story for each which I like it tells me the exact cards I need for each quest which is awesome and the cards are easy

to find thanks to these beautifully illustrated dividers which I love and this is just some of them there's so many dividers in this game which is really cool if anything else I have to give Thunderstone credit for being the best organized deck builder I have ever had the pleasure of sorting oh and before I forget the art in this game is really nice kudos to the artists I look forward to seeing your art and other games but enough of all that let's get down to the gameplay I do like a lot of the mechanics used in Thunderstone quest although I find the game gets boring pretty fast now to be fair I didn't play through every quest available but I never really had any interesting because no matter what my quest was go there but then find this kill that the game played the same every time kill monsters until you find four keys that's it every time you don't even have to fight the boss that shows up at the end and there's never any threat of the game winning so who cares if there's a boss I can't even die which seems like a missed opportunity to add a little more attention to the game because Thunderstone quest does feel like it's fighting back which is good but it doesn't matter which is bad it all comes down to whoever has the most points at the end you or your opponent basic stuff which is completely acceptable not the problem the problem is I don't ever feel like I'm actually playing against the person sitting across the table from me it's more like we're playing our own solo game I don't ever feel like my actions have any impact on my opponent sure as you play through the game and unwrap new cards you do get some cards that affect your opponent but not in any way that's all that's significant they do their thing I do mine we're not

really playing against each other what we're doing is playing two separate games while sitting at the same table at the end we tally up our points and the player who scored the most in their similar game wins personally I'd rather play Clank now there's a deck building dungeon crawler where my actions actually affect my opponent one Thunderstone quest mechanic that I do like is the option of going to the village versus going to the wilderness it's got a risk reward system that appeals to me go into the wilderness and risk taking damage to get cool treasure or stay in the village rest up and miss out on all the cool loot although you do get to shop and Thunderstone quest does a really good job of conveying the feeling of being in the village versus being in the wilderness when I'm in the village I feel safe but I venture out into the wilderness I get that sense of foreboding danger around every corner based on the game experiences I've had with Thunderstone quest I'd have to say the game's a tad unbalanced I've always had an easier time generating hit points using spells versus swords but maybe that's just because I haven't played every quest that the game has to offer maybe there's a quest out there that favors physical decks versus magic I don't know like I said before I didn't really have any interest in playing more to find out but that aside the most unbalanced thing in my experience has got to be the side quests each player gets dealt random quests and selects one if the player manages to complete the side quests that they selected they get a bonus either during the game as a legendary item or at the end of the game as bonus points the problem is you could be dealt three side quests by each award

you a legendary item which sounds cool and sometimes there but my opponent getting that one legendary item didn't hold a candle to my quest which awarded me with +2 points for every spell I had at the end of the game in my last playthrough that exact quest awarded me with an additional 20 points at the end of the game that's huge I basically shopped my way to victory where my opponent who was never randomly offered this side quest was awarded a whopping 3 XP from their legendary item sure my opponents got a cool legendary item to use throughout the game but the benefits that offered was hardly enough to make up the difference not even close so in short Thunderstone quest is not balanced some matches may be balanced but if only some matches are balanced then the game itself is not and then a competitive multiplayer game balance is crucial if you want to offer a fair experience so final verdict I want it to like Thunderstone I really did there's just better deck builders out there to choose from both competitive and cooperative in the end the game is kind of man you might like Thunderstone quest in the short run but it doesn't have the staying power to bring it back I'm just gonna come out and say it do not buy thunder stone quest you have better options if you liked this video and you'd like to keep up to date on what we're doing here at board game coffee subscribe here but if you'd like to watch some videos right now click here and if you feel a little more adventurous check out our board game coffee Instagram account we updated

daily with cool new pictures and sometimes puppy I'm mark Maia this is board game coffee and remember keep gaming be somewhat Scenic's me

Progress saved