Skip to main content
Loading video...

River of Gold Designer Keith Piggott - TCbH Interviews

Transcript 33:05

hello and welcome back to another episode of the cardboard Herald my chance talk with creative Gamers and game creators and today I'm joined by designer Keith pigot the designer of the just released River of gold welcome to the show man yeah thanks for having me Jack I appreciate it yeah you just had your big debut at Gen Con how was the convention how was debuting a game uh that has such a a buildup to it at Gen Con yeah it was it was a lot of fun a little bit stressful but definitely a lot of fun so now it's kind of you know it's just really neat seeing people excited about the game um getting to play several games with people and just seeing the reaction to it and then you know we had we had three demo tables going pretty much non-stop we had uh four games of ticketed events that were going again pretty much non-stop so it's just really exciting seeing all the reaction to it and definitely a new experience for me it's my first one that's kind of gotten some attention so it's it's been interesting yeah well is the the the audience that uh you were seeing at Gen Con was it made primarily of people who just saw it as Oh what a beautiful looking Euro game or was there a lot of interest from Old School l5r guys like me like what was the reception to uh to just kind of the the presence of the game yeah so I think definitely a little bit of both I think a lot of people it's got a very bright gold board

so so Shin shines in their eyes and you know then they they stop and take a look which is which is really neat but um I definitely I played one game with a lot of old school l5r players who you know have been following the card game since basically its Inception 20 years ago and yeah they they had a really good uh time with the game so it's been it's been nice seeing that um you know that community kind of accepted as well and um you know hopefully it appeals to a bit of both so um definitely drawing a lot of new people I hope to the L5 Community but I also hope you know people like you people who have history with the IP also um are willing to take a look at a Euro game you know sit in their their Universe yeah well no that's exactly what I think is so cool about this is I haven't played a game of l5r in ages but it used to be like my defining game that was my hobby rather than playing box board games and whatnot um and you know I had Clan affiliations I played in uh numerous tournaments uh of varying sizes I I was part of a really tightly knit uh Community up here in Alaska that would regularly send attendees to the World Finals in uh Gen Con or at Asen but I don't know anyone who plays l are anymore you know like I I don't know anyone who's uh really uh heavily into it and so having this uh to present to

people I've shown so many people at public game nights and you know in my own game group River of gold and I've been like dude check out this game this is totally something up your alley however I can give you a little bit of context for the world um which is lovely it's just lovely yeah that's definitely what we're hoping for so I mean I think I think Lords of water deep is a very good comparison right where you don't have to know Dungeons and Dragons but this is a great introduction for somebody use into D and to introduce them to to that world well that's you know definitely what we're hoping with a river of gold um as well that you know it's a way to to sneakily get your friends invested into the l5r world you know there's there's definitely a lot of people at office do and Asma day in general who are very invested in the IP and um you know one of the reason for this game because I know a lot of people are probably wondering again Euro game uh you know kind of light Euro game said in the l5r world it's not the first thought but they want something that reintroduces people to that world because there's definitely you know there's plans for more things coming U there's been a a Miniatures game announced that'll be coming sometime next year there's a video game coming uh so the l5r world and then I know there at least is wishes to go beyond that and you know and do more products in the future rokuan represent well did this start as like a targeted rokan Legend of the Five Rings game or did this start

completely devoid of this give me give me the origins of river of gold so it started quite a bit different yeah so this is a game um I've been working on since I think late 2018 it's when the first idea for it was um and the original theme was Route 66 so instead of going down River you're driving down Route 66 and it's uh you know it's very themed around kind of the the business side um of BR 66 and the growth of it so um you weren't having markets you were going to Farms to get different resources and you know converting delivering those and um visiting service centers and diners and things like that uh so that was the the first iteration of it and the game was actually um so I pitched it at or of 2019 um so sent out some emails to a couple different Publishers one of the first ones to respond was tasty minstral games right right it was a dream I they were one of my favorite Publishers as a old school beige Euro loving uh designer like tast minals is you know an amazing company I've got so many games from them so I was very happy about that um pitched it to them and they they were interested right away so um it's one of these rare cases where first pitch led to a to a signing so the game was with them for a while went through development um and then of course the pandemic happened and ta simrol uh ended

up going out of business during the pandemic so it came back to me and then just uh looking for a new publisher and office dog was one of the ones I saw that had been started as a new imprint under asthma day so I reached out to to them and they kind of let me know right off the bat that um l5r was one of their IPs that they were looking to reinvest in they were looking for games um set in that world so I knew like when I signed with them that it was going to be an l5r game which um Luke petersi with office dog has been invested with l5r since the very beginning he's back from the days of AEG so he has you know a very big love for uh the land of Broan so I was I was all on board with retheming into that a as you did this uh like Evolution from uh Route 66 to uh l5r were there certain things that mechanically had to be adjusted in order to better fit the theme like what are some of the notes that office dog gave you as far as you know taking this iterated product that probably TMG invested a lot of time and developing and getting it polished up what did office dog want to see out of it yeah so we definitely looked for ways that we could integrate the theme more so um you know one of the big things was we expanded out kind of the contract cards which became deliveries to your customers so we wanted that to to not just feel like oh I'm delivering these three things and getting some points um

so now it's you know you're you're delivering to a noble who then upgrades one of your boats and makes it better and gives it these you know special powers because it's a better boat that they've invested in um another one of the big things was we you know we started demoing the game at Gen Con of 2023 and that one of the things we definitely heard was that people wanted to uh feel like they were representing their clan um so they wanted some powers that kind of tied in with their you know with the Scorpion Clan or Crane or um whoever their favorite Clan is which which by the way you're old school L5 player so so which what is your clan well mantis's Clan uh is really what I got into the tournament scene with but uh the the first thing that attracted me was Dragon Clan you know like any any kid who grew up watching kung fu movies uh such as myself is going to see some of those uh Warrior monks and immediately go like I need some Shaolin style Dragon Clan Action I'm glad we could at least get mantis clan in there for you that they fit in the you know the region there but yeah we we um we looked at some you know player powers that kind of represented the clan so we came up with the clan patrons we um it's it's kind of an optional module that's that you can add in if you want to but it doesn't completely change the rules of the game but it gives you kind of a little bit of focus either in sailing if you are the Mantis Clan or if you're the crab Clan you get you know special powers with building or if you're

scorpion then you get to manipulate the influence in regions in fun ways so we hope that's where a bit of the flavor of the you know the l5r universe comes through is office dog brand new as of this uh publication like is uh River of gold their their debut so they had a game called word traveler that came out earlier this year as well that was their first game um and then and then uh River Gold is their second one and should be a new one getting announced here very soon from what I understand very soon well do do you feel like there's some difference or or you know like I guess clear understanding on your part uh of what an imprint under such a big umbrella as Asma day is because you know like I I understand this more in the context of say like record labels you know Trent resner has his you know imprint but it's under a much larger uh record label so you know how much of this is just an asthma day production and what does it mean to be an office dog production yeah so I think office dog is kind of one of the things they definitely looking for is kind of games that fit under IPS that maybe don't fit under the rest of the asade day brand so they're looking at things that maybe don't fit under zman or you know one or plat hat or one of their other Studios

so um I think from you know what we've seen so far of word traveler which is a very different game than River of gold you know it's a um kind of a a light uh word game whereas you're you're trying to direct people across the board going to different places in the city and now River Gold which is kind of a medium light Euro so I think they've got kind of a wide net for the style of games that they can produce um but they're going to have you know a lot more coming in the future which we kind of Define them um as a studio but you know most my interaction was really with the office dog team so started off as a very small team although they've been growing even during the time that I worked with them which has been nice to see uh but yeah definitely good people good people to work with uh during the whole process here well clearly I liked the game based off the review that I put out uh a little bit ago but one of the things that I felt like was such a obvious exclusion from the game was a lack of a solo mode so was that like even a consideration or a discussion because yeah you know Lords of Water Deep doesn't have a solo mode but Lords of Water Deep came out what 12 years ago and especially since the pandemic there is such a big portion of our uh of our hobby that have grown accustomed to and have an expectation that uh most Euro games are going to have some sort of

solo integration yeah so the the funny thing about solo is you know it actually I had a solo mode for a lot of the development of the game actually and just some changes towards the end um would have required some you know some changes and going back to it to get it to fit into to the game as it you know is produced so it was definitely something which we were considering and just one of those things that you know we definitely we don't want to exclude a group of players but you know at the end um we kind of have to decide what's going into the product here by the time that it's it's getting released so it is something we are looking at for the future definitely um if the game is successful then you know we're hoping that uh expansions will be coming in the future and that's one of the things we do want to consider um and then you know I've been very happy to see that there is a fan-made solo mode uh from William Griffin um available on BGG I met him at Gen Con and I think he's the number one player on BGA he completely whooped me when we played at Gen Con uh but his his solo mode is excellent so definitely big thank you to him for uh putting something out there and you know it's definitely somebody who who likes the game game and I was very happy to see uh what he's what he's done there when in doubt you can always count on the community to come up with something right I'm sure there's going to be uh variants for all the different Clans at this point you're going to have tons of variant expansion materials and buildings and and all that you know like

you present a a beautiful vibrant world like this and a great game system and people are just going to want to engage uh creatively with it yeah definitely very happy to see that you know it's not definitely not a well we you know we shch responsibility on the solo mode or anything like that you know it's more just this is it is a you know for a Euro for the style of game that it is it is barely interactive I like to think there's a lot of you know visiting of other players buildings which get some benefits and um lots of things like that so if we do a solo mode I just want to be sure we we get it right and we get that feeling of where you're actually playing against the player making smart moves and would love to see some um you know possibly some scenarios and with some story because again that's another great place where we could have like a little mini campaign even where we integrate more of that uh Rich l5r you know lore and history into it so it's definitely something we're considering and we're looking at but uh we'll see what the what the future holds here did this always exist as this sort of linear worker placement I mean the Route 66 concept uh Works in my mind for that but it's a relatively untapped uh style of worker placement of course there are notable games uh like takido and parks that have done wi or worker placements but the cyclical

nature of this uh it it has a different Rhythm so you know was that there from the get-go were there like key moments during your development that like made everything come together you know talk to me about your your early days with the game yeah so this is one of these rare ones where a lot of it just kind of worked from the start so the the basic idea of the game was definitely taking the Lords of Water Deep um you know build a building somebody uses your building you get a benefit so the idea was all right let's let's run wild with that let's take that let's put it in some sort of movement based system to where you're you know you're not just putting a worker on that building but you're actually moving along a path or a rondale or something to to activate that so that idea kind of came together with the root 66 theme at the very beginning how to activate uh movement how to you know get buildings how to get contracts all of that um changed quite a bit so I tried a lot of things with that I tried uh I tried work replacement straight work rep placement with dice where you had certain spots where if you want to move you go here with the die and that spot is taken and there's only so many move actions that be can can be done like in a round um that felt a little bit limiting so then went with uh tried drafting which uh drafting a whole bunch of dice when you're not quite sure what action you want to take is kind of a

mess so that idea went out the window pretty quick um and then kind of where I ended up for quite a while was um the game had rounds so you had six rounds in the game and you rolled your four dice at the beginning of the rounds and then you used them to take action so it wasn't work rep placement you were taking spots but you could kind of plan out I'm going to use a four to move then I'm going to use this three to build and and so on so that actually worked pretty well um made the game quite a bit heavier than it is now quite a bit more thinky quite a bit more AP prone right right so um you know it wasn't bad thing but definitely you know just was a was a heavier feeling game so during development uh we played around with some different ideas with that because just kind of felt like the idea of moving down the road or the river um and activating those buildings was the heart of the game and we didn't want a lot of things that got in the way of that so we just really felt like the game was leading in a lighter Direction so that's where we eventually we went down to uh roll two two dice at the beginning of your turn pick one and then eventually it got down to to just the single die um and we found that all right if we as long as we give you enough dice mitigation a ways to where you don't feel like you're locked into that value that you roll um that it really felt pretty good um so that really kind of lightened the game made it more accessible to a lot of people it

went from kind of you know a medium even medium heavy feeling type of game to where it's now a very you know welcoming I call it almost Gateway plus Style game with this being asthma day um and I I know it's an office dog but you know like the there's a lot of feeling uh I guess in the The Hobby towards uh the consolidation of so many other smaller Publishers under one big umbrella uh and one of the the fears and speculations has been that if something isn't immediately a massive success that it no longer gets the the support that maybe other Publishers would have continued on for games and you being a relatively uh um new or maybe that that's a poor term here a a designer who is relatively new to publishing um uh with only a couple other games under your belt you know is there any like trepidation or extra pressure that you're feeling like this game either has to be a massive runaway hit otherwise you're never going to get to put out the content that maybe you planned and set aside for possible expansion material well I think I mean I think I don't know if the asthma day really contributes to that or if that would just be a concern really with any um publisher I mean the nice thing with

office dog is yes it's you know you're part of this bigger overall Asma day huge company but um you know I've really been working just with their team so it's felt in many ways like working with a small publisher so it's it's you know been a handful of people who have been very dedicated to the project and have been um you know very helpful along the way so the other the other nice thing with me is this I you know I I do not have any Ambitions of going full-time in game design I am uh I like my My Healthcare I like my yeah I have no plans of fulltime podcasting either yeah I have a good day job you know I'm you know I'm very grateful that there's a lot of opportunities out there now for designers who do want to go that route and we're seeing more and more people go full time and having that opportunity but um I I enjoy keeping this as a hobby thing that I do um you know I I love working on games I love that this is something that I can do in you know in my spare time and ideally if I can get a game or two out there every couple of years that would be amazing but it's a little bit less pressure when I know that uh I have my day job and uh you know what if things don't work out if this is it that's kind of okay um but that being said i' I've got a lot of ideas so you know hopefully some other things do uh do happen in the future

here well you know like we shouldn't diminish what you've put out I mean you have the Great Barrier Reef came out in 2020 you have drawn to Adventure 2021 River of gold you were uh signing with a publisher back in 2019 uh it may just be coming out now but um clearly that's that's a game that's gotten a lot of attention and support what got you into game design in the first place like what made you even think have the audacity to say you know what instead of just playing these things I can make these things yeah I think I I I went in with almost no knowledge which is maybe the way to do it um no I think I honestly I I somehow ran into the gamecrafter website which I don't think I even understood really what it was at the time I just saw oh you can kind of make your own game that sounds kind of fun um so you know I I kind of got back into board gaming I guess about 10 12 years now so you know definitely grew up playing all the big Mass Market games as a kid life and Monopoly and guess who and all those um and played a lot of uh axis and allies with my other big one had a friend who's still very into that still plays it all the time uh but had gotten out for a while and then U my wife and I had heard of a ticket to ride saw it at Barnes & Noble picked it up and then uh down the rabbit hole we go so um you know I think we got back into gaming and then again

ran into the game crafter side and just thought hey this would be a fun little project maybe put together a little card game or something just to see if it's something I can do so the the first game I worked on actually was about putting fish in an aquarium it it ended up becoming the Great Barrier Reef in many many iterations but um you know kind of got a little card game together uh started researching how games are made because you know I I know about video games I know that uh video games are made by mostly by larger Studios with lots and lots of people so that's how board games are made right like tons of people had no idea like oh you can actually make a prototype and you can actually meet with these Publishers who produce these games so uh did a little bit of research at least had enough knowledge to to figure out how to create a Sal sheet and do that um and then ended up going to to Origins I think in I think it's 2018 this the first year um and so I just sent out some emails with my sell sheets attached for two games I created which which ended up being um great be reef and Drawn to Adventure eventually but uh was kind of kind of wild that uh had you know no knowledge sent all this out and was able to get you know three or four pitch meetings with you know companies that people had heard of which is just kind of wild to me right that this industry works by the way but yeah that's kind of how I got into it I um

found the unpub room was at Origins and went and play tested games with a bunch of people uh remember I met uh Chris Chung was like the first person I ran into the designer of lanterns um so so funny story one of my one of my pitches um I I was looking for this publisher was just out in the main play area and kind of the guy waved me over and I when sat down started setting up my game and explaining it to him and realized there's a guy right next to me he's still in the middle of his pitch so I'm interrup that ended up being Chris Chung from uh you know Lantern Fame and all that yeah great great first impression but yeah I mean that first origins was just kind of led me down the rabbit hole and uh you know I've really kind of loved gson ever since I I've talked to a lot of Publishers over the years about uh various things with uh pitches and cell sheets and that kind of stuff but clearly something that you were doing uh was catching attention what in your mind is like something that people who are doing some initial research on how to pitch a game might not know about uh a cell sheet like what do you emphasize or or really want to uh put out there to um distinguish your game or you as a designer or grab some attention yeah it's it's all about the hook and I think one thing you know this this isn't this isn't the sexiest topic here right but I work in software I work in um you know product management and

things so I'm used to kind of developing a product and thinking about how how the whole product comes together how it's marketed all of that um so you know what I think one of the things that helped me is thinking kind of along the lines of well what is the finish product how is what is the selling point of this game why would people actually want to purchase this so if you can do some of the the thinking of front for a publisher where you're not just presenting you know here's this idea here's this but how is it actually going to be presented what is the unique components or the things that could stand out what is the way it could be marketed some of those things can actually help you get a get a leg up um and then you know just I don't I don't know there's any magic to sell sheets it's just look up online you know there's some good examples out there one of the uh first blogs I ran into was uh sen fun Lim and Jay Cormier they have a they had a uh website I'm sure still out there somewhere but they had a lot of steps on how to go through and pict your game to publisher and what to put on a cell sheet and all of that so uh this one of the first things I checked out and just all right check off these boxes here let's make sure I'm doing this so least so taway professional there well when you're not designing you're falling up on uh some of your other Hobbies including reading sci-fi and fantasy books

I'm a big sci-fi fantasy fan myself and now you are no stranger to adapting a design to an existing IP so if you could design a game in any sff Universe whatsoever what would it be wow um so I think my favorite fantasy series of all time is a realm of the elderlings by Robin Hobs I don't know if you're familiar with that shout out to alaskans you know the endlings you know she wrote in Kodiak yep so you know I'm not sure how what even style of game that would translate to but a sad one a miserable one a very tortured one misery every turn Fitz Fitz what are we going to do here so yeah you have no agency in that game at all everything just happen to you just pure misery every turn so yeah but yeah it'd be amazing right like you right yeah I'd love that I'd love that so yeah that would be amazing if we could do something in that um also like I mean Red Rising had the you know the game from Stone Meer but I would love to see a a large scale uh you know space battle style game in that Universe be amazing yeah I I think that even though it was a cool concept and it was you know of course getting the character Focus concept by having all the different uh you know like color banners uh which

is such an emphasis of the story and you know you can do really fun things with like you know this person's red but they're also secretly gold or you know they're gold but secretly red and whatnot which fits in thematically with the story but I kind of wanted a big sci-fi Space Opera you know give me you know some fleets of ships headed by Darrow or something or you know you have to uh do an assault on Luna or you have to you know do some Tower Defense off in the Kyper belt or something you know that would have been cool yeah so what are you're sci-fi fantasy nerd as well right you said so what what's your dream project what are we what are we collaborating on oh I don't know I think uh I I'm a huge James ESS Corey fan so you know the expans was great uh Jeff Angel scen uh expans game was good but uh you know like I think there's more to explore there uh but hey we could just you know contact those authors and be like you got this brand new captives War series let's just you know capitalize on that let's let's do some crazy uh sci-fi space uh multi-dimensional stuff but maybe secretly arcs is already kind of that game so true yeah um uh we we have that but uh yeah no I'm always interested when um these uh really

storied um sci-fi and fantasy settings especially novels get adapted into uh board games um and that's one of the cool old school elements that I find about River of gold um is that it feels that way also because I I've read a lot of l5r books and that kind of stuff but like when Game of Thrones came out the game you know Christian Peterson hadn't watched a show he had read a book he was like how do we capture the the story to Universe uh and uh was able to creatively put a a an imprint and an interpretation uh on that in a way that I don't think you necessarily get to do when you have uh the the investment of you know multi-million doll movie contracts and stuff um sure so I'm always looking for a good uh book to game adaptation mhm well I would be remiss if I wasn't asking you Keith you know after the success of this game you know like what's next on the horizon for you like what what do you got cooking in the fire yeah so don't have anything currently under contract so I'm you know definitely have some ideas that I'm looking to pitch here um possibly even a packs coming up and then you know if again the game seems to be doing pretty well which is which is great so definitely we're starting to

look into some expansion ideas and some I'm here for it I'm here for it so we will see um you know I don't have any irons in the fire yet but hopefully some more things coming well Keith I am really excited to see where this design Journey takes you and I am so happy that you have made certainly the most success ible and probably my favorite separate from the ccg tabletop adaptation of rokugan so thanks for you know making an old nerd uh smile I really appreciate it now I'm glad we could get you back into that world thanks for coming on to the show Keith all right thank you Jack

Progress saved