Skip to main content
Loading video...

Deep Regrets : FIRST IMPRESSIONS!

Transcript 23:51

Yeah. Yeah. Check. All right. Hello everybody. Welcome back to Board Game Buzz today. My name is Carly and I'm Kim and we are back for kind of our part two um regarding Oh, I don't even have the cover. One second. Break for cover. All right. Here's the box lid. We'll put it over here this time though since I have back back over here. Um we are filming this a little bit later in the day than I normally do. So sorry. Hopefully the coloring is okay. I don't know. I'll see what I can do in post. But um um so yeah, we just finished up doing a playthrough of Deep Regret. So if you are interested in that, I will make sure to link to the video in the description below for this video. I definitely made a couple mistakes, but it's okay. I'll try to edit them. Mine were like cost me the game. Oh, I guess that's true.

If I had been able if I had done what I had intended to do one turn earlier, then I You probably would have beat me. You probably Well, actually, no. You definitely would have beat me. It's all good. And Beckham's over here eating dice. Don't eat the dice. Don't eat the dice. So, hopefully if you are interested in this game and kind of were curious about how it played, hopefully that playthrough kind of gives you a general idea of how it operates. But right now, we're just going to kind of jump into our first thoughts regarding this game. Now, I've definitely played it more than you. I think I've played I think this would be like my fifth play. You've played it. This would be your second, right? Your second play um of the game. Literally, you don't eat the dice. Um so, that's how you know it's a good game. So, that's how you know it's a good game.

Yeah. So, let's just go ahead and kind of jump into our first thoughts regarding Deep Regrets. All right. Do you want to start it off? Do you want me to start it off? All right. I have no regrets about playing this game. There you go. No, no regrets about playing the game. Yep. It was not one that I felt like my time was wasted. Um, and I think that like I think this is one that like the more you play it, the more at least like maybe until you get to some point where like you've played it a million times and then you're like, "Okay, now I have a lot of regrets." But, um, uh, so far it the two times I've played it, I'm like, "Oh, now I need to play it again." So, it has like the second time I played it was more slightly more enjoyable than the first time I played it. Honestly, every single time I've played this game, it's gotten more enjoyable. And I think the re I think part of the reason why was I kind of had like an expectation in my head about what the game was. For whatever reason, I really kind of was expecting it to be a very like heavy pusher luck game. And for me personally, the pusher luck element isn't really there. It feels more luck than pusher luck. And I think I actually told you that the very first time that we played.

I was like, this feels just like a very lucky game. And it is inherently very lucky. Um, so if you are not a fan of luck in games, I think inherently maybe do kind of your research before just buying this game because it is very lucky. However, the more you play it, like I said, this is like my fifth time playing it, it really has just grown on me every single play. And maybe that's just me simply adjusting my expectations a little bit. Um, but I really do inherently like a lot about this game. One thing that I really love, um, well, first let's just kind of talk about production and artwork because I 10 out of 10 in regards to artwork from in my opinion. Now, I I know this probably isn't everybody's taste. Oh, yeah. Cuz it is very I think it's going to be it's like a it's going to be divisive a little bit. Yeah. I have a lovehate relationship with it. Oh, see, I thought for sure that you would love it. Oh, I do. But you But you hate it. You hate it too. I like that. Like like the this mermaid the teeth and it's got like three boobs and I mean No, it's got like four. It's got four.

Like I mean but I do love it. I like that it's awful. I love it. Like honestly, everything about the vibe and for whatever I'm surprised how much I love it and enjoy it in this game, but it's so fun. The fishing element is so much fun cuz you don't you don't know what you're going to get, right? You don't know what's out there. Um, another thing that I love that they did with production is the shadows. So, you know the size so you're not completely just blind flipping. You can kind of it it has a level of strategy to it in regards to um deciding where you actually want to fish. So, I thought that was a fantast.

Oh, yeah. Yeah, we can circle back around to that. You'll see like in the playthrough that we did, Carly rolled like a bunch of ones and I rolled like threes. Um, so that definitely has but but then there are cards that allow you to and the dinks that allow you to kind of like mitigate that a little bit. Mhm. Um but in my like the second playthrough of it, I'm like even though my strategy ended up failing me, I think there's actually quite a bit of strategy to the game. Um in terms of or like it more than like what I initially thought, especially in terms of thinking about when to ship or when to go to sea, when to go to port, like on what days do you do that? Is it worth ever using your lifeboat? Like weighing the pros and cons. Um, weighing the uh pros and cons of like going deeper.

Mhm. The madness track, trying to like mitigate that and like where you're at on that um to try to like maximize your points, what you're selling, what you're eating, what you're um nailing up on your trophy board. Mhm. Um, so like to me there's actually a like it's deceiving to me in strategy actually like it there was there's more like and that's why I want to play it again again and and also in terms of like uh like where you're at on the madness tribe because of the dice and um yeah I don't know there's just like there's more to explore more see to to to see and these items I mean the items that get really do help in regards to kind of mitigating that luck factor a little bit. Um, however, I will say that there are inherently rods and reels and some supplies that just are better than others, I think.

Um, and so again, when you do go to these shops, it really is worth it to spend a little bit more. So you you able to actually pick three from the deck and then pick one because if you do just spend a dollar just to randomly pick a card, there is a likelihood that you just get the crappy rail. That really doesn't help you that much in the long run. Um, so I mean I guess I wish that these items were maybe a little bit more balanced because there again you can spend more money to draw more, but there just are inherent rods and reels and some supplies that I just straight up wouldn't want. See, I like disagree with that I guess because I Yeah, it feels on par with the theme of the game. Okay. Um, I mean, maybe not necessarily in terms of like if you're actually going shopping, you're going shopping and you can actually pick what you want. But I guess if you're going to a little like really sketchy place and they're like throwing something at you, you're like, "This is what I want." And then they're like, "Well, show me your moola and I'll show you what I have." And especially in terms of like uh like with the uh like you're go going uh fishing versus like it's that same kind of like you don't necessarily know what you're going to get and there are those cards that allow you to kind of you know like your worms that allow you to like look at it and see if you want sorry oh you're good want it or not. Um, and then also because um, yeah, like I guess like thematically I like that it's not Yeah,

some things are just going to inherently be better than other things. And then it also again adds to that strategy and slightly like push your luck like how much do I want how many how much fish do I want to how many of my fish that I've caught do I want to sell in order to try to have as much cost as I want. um to like to have that extra money to be able to draw more cards so I can possibly get the better item. Yeah. So, it just gives you more to like weigh. I loved the madness track. I thought that was so fun and so clever and how Yeah, you can play. I mean, with our playthrough, we really didn't go that mad, but I've played I've played games of this where we went crazy. Like, we were all the way down at the bottom. We were just trying to get rid of all of our fairish. We wanted those foul fish, right? I was trying. Yeah, I know you were trying.

But I just thought that was so clever and so fun and how it really by advancing or going by either going down or going back up that track, it really does change the value of the fish in your hand. And I like how that contributed to endgame scoring. I like really liked that addition. Again, that was something that like I was weighing against like Yeah. Um cuz I was willing I mean I didn't end up being able to mount any of my fish, but I was willing to try to mount like sacrifice one of them if it meant that I could be mad like I was weighing that that possibility. Yep. The possibility. And then it helped that you only ended up mounting one. But I mean it doesn't matter cuz I didn't know. Yeah. I also just loved the regrets. I just thought it was so something about just getting regrets is so fun. Um I love how uh Moon Rollers kind of has something like this a little bit in regards to those what are they called?

Like the caution token or something that you're slowly getting and everybody reveals at the end of the game and whoever was the greediest or took the most. Yeah, those are definitely more punishing. Um, but it kind of has that similar feel where you're kind of weighing you're trying to figure out around the table like where you're kind of at cuz you definitely don't want to end with the most regrets or you're going to have to lose um some of your inherent points at the end of the game. Um, so I just thought that was a super fun addition and I loved the just the flavor text kind of coming back to production on all of the cards. You really felt like you were telling a story like you really could just straight up tell a story after you play this. And that's actually in the rule books is like one of the things you can do is at the end of the game take all your regrets and go around the table and like make your your tail you tell your tale of woes to the table. I'm thinking of that one that says like you ate human flesh.

I know. It's like it's so fun. It's so thematic. I just was obsessed with the whole vibe um from this. Again, I think you're either going to like it or you don't. But for me, I just I loved it. I absolutely loved the fishing element to it. I thought it was so fun just to flip over those cards and like kind of see what's beneath. And again, once you do get a rod and a reel equipped, you are able to kind of mitigate what you catch. So, I really enjoyed that. I will say, however, and Kim, I think I mentioned this to you when we first played is I wish there was a I wish it felt a little bit more push your luck in regards to the fishing. It does in regards to like deciding what card you want to flip and kind of being strategic about that. that kind of feels a little bit more push your luck. But I wish uh I wish like your the way that you spent resources felt a little bit more push your luck cuz essentially every single time you fish you inevitably have you just you have to give up a dice. You know that's going to happen even if you catch the fish or not. And for whatever reason I almost kind of wish that if you flipped over a card that you couldn't pay for, right? I wish that something inherently bad would have happened like gaining a regret. I wish that because then that would have made it feel almost a little bit a little bit more pusher luck cuz it's like okay am I going to like should I risk it right? Yes, I can kind of I can kind of see the sizes based on um the amounts that I have what I should kind of go for and hope for. But if I don't get it then I know I'm going to

get a regret. Like I just think that I just think that would kind of be a fun element to it almost. Yeah. After our first playthrough, Carly and I were actually like thinking about like home like trying some different variations to make it feel like a little bit more. But I actually after playing and seeing some of the um I guess to me seeing a little bit more depth to it, I'm like no, I think that having to like get rid of a dice that is the most punishing thing. Yeah. I think so. Because the dice is how you catch them and then when you lose that dice, you're like, "Dang it." I guess that's true. Um but um but but I still think that there like to me there's like I some there's some room for like playing around with that idea. my one. Um, besides that, like I it's I I'm still like I still think we should try some of our homebrew ideas to see how it plays out. But my one thing that like I struggled with is that the um it's not obvious enough to me what is um a like I know the outline I guess is the the fowl and I mean it reads fowl and there but like visually I want it to be more like for whatever reason the automatic darkness of Oh, So, so as as

you get deeper, the background of all the cards inher inherently get darker. And so at a glance, you would just kind of assume, oh, black or darker means an evil creature and a light means a light. Yeah. So, if you didn't watch the playthrough, the difference, how you tell the difference between the animals is the fairish are blue and the foul fish are green in regards to the title and then the outline. Um, but I do agree that sometimes because of the back dark, you just kind of assume if you flip over a card that has a dark background, you're like, "Oh, it's going to be it's an evil fish." Um, so yeah, you do that is something you have to be aware of. That never really bothered me too much, but I can definitely see how it can throw people off the different backgrounds of the fish. It made it me have to do a little bit too much brain work and figuring out my score, especially with like paying attention to the negatives and the positives and whatnot. Oh yeah, when like you're adding up. I needed it to be like super obvious what is what and not have to like look for these extra clues to see what it was. Y that was my biggest like I had to I had to like go through it like three different like I should not have to like add up my score like three different times because I realized I messed it up or I added I added a point when I should have subtracted a point.

It was Yeah. See, my my biggest thing was I wish that the action of going to port was more interesting because for whatever reason when you went to port, yes, it's beneficial because you get a rod and a reel, but I feel like I really only need to do that one maybe two times during a game. And when I do go to port, I just wish I was out fishing cuz I see everybody going out and getting their stuff and I'm just here at port getting rod and supplies. Um, so I wish that I don't know how it could have been done differently, but I just wish that that would feel more interesting in the game cuz like inevitably every single time I played this, I realized that I need to go to port. It's kind of like, okay, I guess I'll go to port. I just have like this idea like it was what if like the eating action like what if that was something you had to go and do at port or Yeah, maybe. Like I I I just I wish that it would have just kind of felt more fun. Yes. It's nice because you do get to upgrade, but I never really felt motivated to really go to port. I just I loved the fishing so much. I just wanted to keep fishing like all game. I almost just could do that all game. Just simply fish, you know what I mean? See how many points you get by doing that. I know.

Cuz I just wanted to stay out and just fish. Um, so I wish that something and I have no idea what it would be, but I just wish that that would have I would have felt a more more of a pull to go to port to kind of make it more of an interesting decision at the beginning of of every round cuz I just knew at the beginning of every round I just I wanted to go fishing. That's what I wanted to do at the beginning every round. Yeah. Yeah, it would have almost been nice like if you went to port then you could I know like there's like this max dice thing but I'm like it would be nice if you just automatically got a got a dice to like keep for the rest of the game almost like that would really incentivize you rather than just having to like buy like going when you're like doing the action to get like an extra worker because when you know you're just going to lose the dice like after and that I didn't like that about the dice because it felt like it's a lot of work to get a dice and then you use it once and then it's gone again. I wish that you felt beefier throughout the game. I wish you could beef up cuz you do with your rod and your reel, but you never really feel beefy with your dice. So, I if you could get your dice and actually keep them and retain them throughout the whole game. I think that would be more I would feel more motivated to spend my money on a dice, but right now all I'm going to spend my money on is rods and reels. Really? possibly even like be willing to go more mad because then you get more dice and catch more things and then you can catch more things. Yep. So, I wish Yeah. I I wish that you could

just as you as the game goes on, you get more and more dice and you just can haul in so much more. I really did like how when you passed and every single time something passed over you, you could get a dink or discard regret. So, you didn't feel like you were just sitting around or not doing anything. still kind of getting something throughout the throughout the game. And then also that it was like limited like it wasn't like you'd pass and then another player still had going and going like especially at a two-player game cuz it kind of puts you on the clock at that whoever is still going in. It's like okay I really need to be efficient cuz I only have two more turns and then I have to be out after that. Oh uh I thought the um I liked the element of throwing a lifesaver. I really liked that. It was like a fun little like, haha, you suck and it it really did help. It really I did kind of find myself forgetting about it a couple of times. Something that Jordan mentioned is I mean, don't get me wrong, there are definitely really good fish down at depth three. Um, but it's so hard to get down to depth three that he didn't really feel and I I've never really felt motivated to make it all the way down to depth three. me either cuz it's it's a lot of work. And again, spending those dice, it would help you actually if you did if you did purchase your dice. Sorry. If you did purchase your dice and then you could keep them cuz then by the end of the game, you could actually make it down to depth three. But there also are inevitably some cards at the third depth that are

just as valuable as the ones in depth one. And then you know what would be cool? What? which would make the game feel a little bit more like punishing or push your luck I guess is like with some of the fish if they had more of those like instant reveals. So like if there was one that like ate one of your dice or like something like that or um you know like have some of those more like instant like some fish that are like really going to hurt you. Yeah. Yeah. And that that would be more thematic too. I could get the points that I need and I can get a ton more staying up high. Staying high. rather than having a couple that are point value. It's better to It's like when you go grocery shopping and all the like little things add up. Yep. That's Yeah, that's kind of what it feels like. You might as well just stay high and just use all your dice and go for it. And in my opinion, I do think you would get more by doing that. Mhm. Instead of going down. But again, if if you did if we did have the opportunity to beef up our pool and be rolling a ton of dice, then it would be worth it to go down to the third depth.

Yeah. The last thing that I kind of want to touch on is, and I probably should have mentioned this at the beginning, but I'm just remembering it now that I wanted to touch on this, is there was definitely stuff about the rule book. Oh, yeah. That wasn't super clear. Um, and there's kind of I kind of found myself finding a decent amount of hedge cases in this game. Like, for example, I personally have not found in the rule book. If you know where it is, please let me know. Um, but like there's times where like you would flip over a card, for example, and it would be like you need exactly two dice to fish to like catch this card, right? But what if I have like dinks that can pay for it? Well, like can I use the dinks or do I actually need to spend dice? Like there's lots there's lots but you want but I want it clarified because there's a handful of stuff that as I was playing I would try to find the information and it just wasn't as clear as I would like it to be. Um, I can contest to observing Carly reading the rule book and her having lots of questions about it. I took video. I meant to post it. I think for the most part, like I would probably say it does like an 80% really good job of explaining what you do, but there is probably about 20% of stuff in regards to game play that I I felt was lacking a little bit for me. And I guess I wish it just would have been slightly more clear. Well, that's why we did this play through. So that if you read the rule book and you're like although our our playthrough was a little chaotic, we definitely made mistakes in the playthrough. So kind of rounding out

this first thoughts, do you have anything else that you kind of wanted to touch on before we wrap it up? No. First thoughts. Like I I mean I thought I would like the game, but I like the game. Yeah, I I really despite kind of the handful of stuff that I mentioned, I actually I really like this game. And it's one that the very first time I played, I was kind of like this on, but it's grown every single time I've played. I And I I really do experience I you can see more of the strategy every single time you play. Like you said, there are some stuff that I inherently wish was a little bit more like I wish it was a little bit more pusher lucky. Personally, um I do wish that yeah, some of the stuff was kind of clarified a little bit more in the rule book. I think that could have been um tightened up a little bit better. I do wish you kind of get a little bit more dice throughout the game or go a little bit lower, but I still love the gameplay. I just think it is so much fun flipping over cards, going fishing. Like I just I really really enjoyed this game and I'm really happy that we have it on our shelf cuz I really like it a lot. And this is probably one of Jordan's favorite games now. Oh, really? Yeah. He really loves it. All right, so hopefully you kind of enjoyed us sharing well first doing a playthrough um of this game, but now kind of sharing our very kind of brief thoughts on this game after playing it a handful of times. If you have any deep regrets out there, let us know in the comments. Mhm. This is a safe. We listen and we don't judge.

Listen and don't judge. Thanks so much for watching this playthrough and first thoughts video for you today. If you enjoyed this video and you haven't yet subscribed to the channel, it means so much if you could do that. Really helps kind of support us and everything that we're doing over here. But until next time, I hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you later. That was chaos. You did great. The kids are going crazy.

Progress saved