Descent: Legends of the Dark - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for descent legends of the dark uh now this is actually a pretty interesting discussion one caveat for this is we are only a couple quests in to the the series um so as with most series either we will do depending on how long it takes we might do a discussion in between or we'll most likely do a finale and talk about the whole thing we thought uh but uh with that being said this is actually because you probably wouldn't be aware of it this is actually kind of a remake of a ip that fantasy flight has done really years ago there was a descent first edition in the descent second edition um but with this one it's not even close to the realm of what those other games were okay the original descents were a kind of like a one versus all oh one person played as an overlord and controlled the minions it was scenario-based there was a campaign to them and then the other people played the heroes now descent was actually second edition i haven't played first was the very first game in this kind of in a hobby game that i ever played really talisman was the second one and i'm glad i gave talisman a shot because i hated descent wow yeah it uh it always felt overpowered because the way it would work is like the heroes
would all go and then the the villain would go but i felt or the overlord but i always felt he had way more that he could do that there was no interaction like you couldn't interrupt me you couldn't do any like uh so it's like oh if you didn't complete the objective because each scenario had an objective um then i would just like overload with a bunch of cards and [ __ ] asymmetrical yeah i mean the enemies kind of still did what they it was kind of like i controlled all the enemies and then i had cards that i could play uh so if your heroes would just go down then i could still do more and the overlord had an objective and then the heroes had an objective but each scenario was broken up into two parts okay so there was like the first part and whoever won that one would gain an advantage in the second part and so it kind of felt like the rich got richer where it's like oh okay it just feels bad yeah so if i win as the overlord in the first one then the second part can be really hard for the heroes in the second so i never liked it i i was always an advocate against actual descent but uh so i wasn't even planning on getting this because i was like [ __ ] that there's no way i wouldn't even touch that you're like how could you guys even justify making a third version of this game yeah so uh so i completely stayed away from it and the fact that this has i mean it's a hundred and seventy dollars market price and i'm like yeah be [ __ ] kidding me fantasy flight you make you make three games and then you
you like then you make this one and you're just like oh it's uh nearly 200 but with all that being said i gotta say this game is an absolute blast oh yes this is so fun this is so much fun this is one of the pinnacles of kind of everything that that fantasy flight does really well with dungeon crawls and with with it i mean because they always do a great job with their apps and that's kind of i feel like a big chunk of the price point because this is a the we'll talk about the app in a sec but i'm so glad that they made this and it's not a third edition it's none of that it's hey here's basically rebranding descent and they have a big act one well it's not big but they have an act one so they must have plans for multiple acts in this world with the um you know with this massive map i mean this whole four fourth in i mean we're in the forest but i'm i'm assuming either it's going to be different areas or different whatever they plan on doing um so yeah with two scenarios i thought that each quest was going to be maybe an hour and like but no they are they are sprawling internally like the first one just kept going and i was thinking do we just have to save it and go to town like how do we how do we do this they just take a while yeah and it's so much fun it is it's a blast the
the way that you play it's very familiar to a lot of their other games you know you have your attributes you have i like the unique dice you have some mitigation in terms of what you do with the dice a lot of cool powers like the surge actions that you can just spread around um the fact that the fatigue mechanic is really unique because that lets you kind of truly explore what your characters can do capable of and i would say this game isn't hard but it's not easy either no granted we are playing on standard difficulty we're playing standard we're only playing with two of us yeah so the fact that you can play this game with a varying amount of players on normal and it doesn't feel like busted yeah i was thinking oh we could have more and you were like i don't want to have more things to manage which makes complete sense yeah now that i think about it like getting later on where everybody's got their own massive skill tree right a lot yeah the one of the biggest complaints that people have been hearing about this is that the town phase with with more people becomes cumbersome because it's like you have to you have to spread resources around and things like that and decide who to buy for what uh i can kind of see that slowing the game down but with games like this everyone's like oh play it solo it's the best solo and i'm like i'm sure it is i'm actually i'm
sure it's great with one character well actually i think you always you always control two i believe even in solo but most campaign games like this that are like people say play by yourself i always actually have a lot more fun with at least one other person like gloomhaven it's like in a solo game you control two people okay just play with someone else so you can at least experience the story together and you're not just weirdly sitting in your house just like oh yeah i'm having so much fun yeah and i actually don't mind the town portion like it allows someone to commune with oh hey what should we do how do we want to build what do you want to spend these resources on like the first phase was getting me stuff this next space we got uh if you choose to play galadin again we got arrow types for him so yeah and stuff for for chance and a lot of stuff for to build up all the characters the way that the app will remember um so with that with that being said i think that you you could play this with multiple people and have fun every character like i i don't feel like you go through the motions even though the movement is just kind of movement's kind of arbitrary it's like since you can move diagonal it's like you can almost always get to where you need to um but with this i feel like there was actual some tactical advantage to kind of moving because you knew some of the enemies would they could only move so far so yeah because i was just there it's like oh started backing up and then let them run
to us and it's because you were so far behind that it's like i need to back up so they can run to us so you can get there uh without using multiple actions to close the distance yeah and they included the impeded rule which wasn't in any of their other games uh because i always hated the fact that there's an enemy here you know and you could be here and just go oh okay time to run off it's like how how [ __ ] like you know how are you moving just across like that and they do nothing and in this they actually they don't attack you or anything but they slow your movement yeah they force you to not move yeah you can always move one but it's like oh nope impeded impeded okay well that's your entire turn is is moving so i like that that at least that's something instead of having opportunity attack um josh what do you think of the game uh i think it's really good uh the first quest i didn't do a whole lot and i was like this guy [ __ ] you didn't do you didn't you didn't do nothing well it didn't feel like i was contributing as much as i could have been granted dice or dice yeah uh so there's always that this time around though i felt really useful in certain situations um a chance was also incredibly useful mm-hmm i like the the movement seems a little ridiculous at times but like you're right during combat
it's whatever yeah um i like the skills i like the fact that you get two weapons yeah you get two weapons with different abilities and actually utilizing them yeah you have to flip them uh and actually well just skills and your your character you can distribute your fatigue however you want i like that i like the different amounts of types of things you can do on your turn uh i like the abilities that you can place on enemies and i actually like the abilities they can place on you it seems really useful or uh makes it strategic i guess right i like that there's not instant death yeah and and in the other games like manchester madness or journeys in middle earth there was never instant death you just took like in manchester's madness you take wound to cards and if you ever hit your moon threshold you take a wounded card which like i think slows your overall movement if you take another card then you die and that usually ends the campaign similar here i always like the fact that when you're wounded it's just it's kind of debilitating oh you take a minor than a major and then it's like like the major is hobbled so reduce your speed by one after you shift for the first time each round suffer two wounds or suffer two fatigue yeah i have frustrated after you attack suffer a fatigue and then raging uh after you attack suffer a wound and a fatigue yeah
and and there's not a lot this game is extremely clean like it's very streamlined the uh like all the cards are very concise like with what like the skills the weapons and because what they could have done which i'm glad they didn't is for every shaft every grip every item you get every arrow they could have had a card for so it becomes like you just have a bunch of [ __ ] in front of you and this this [ __ ] manages it all yep the app is just like oh like for like the upgrade we gave you for your half the belt which was which actually funny enough we didn't even really use because it does 20 you have a 20 chance of dealing damage with the bells to other enemies yeah so if you had your bells and you hit with those snipers around 20 percent chance of dealing damage splashing and the app just does all that so you get this game is like 60 board game 40 video game and it's nice yeah but it does most of the work yeah and what's amazing is the app allows you to be like oh like i read the rules once oh wow and i was like okay because it's familiar like it's fantasy flight they don't make a lot of games anymore they used to have their hand on everything now they just do ips they make either marvel champions uh arkham horror the card game but they they did manchester madness i
think they're done but they did this and then journeys of middle earth so all their games are very familiar so they don't do a lot but what they do is very well done what they do is perfect quality over quantity yeah and it shines yeah and so whenever i read the rules i was like okay i understand i'm familiar with it but if you don't you can be like oh oh crap what does what do the spikes do oh you just click on it in the app and it just tells you oh what what does shift mean and then oh glossary shift there it is and even the question we had was does shift ignore terrain and it's like uh no it blatantly tells you so all the stuff that you know the enfeebled the status effects all that stuff you the app tells you yeah and even whenever it comes to line of sight where it's like can i hit that person oh line of sight click where you're at oh yes i can it's it's absolutely amazing it is fantastic it's it's the you know culmination of years of what fantasy flight was doing with their games all poured into you know this i mean i would honestly say get a laptop or a tap like an ipad yeah and run it on that a phone like it works for manchester madness it works for journeys of middle earth but this one is by far the busiest oh yeah app i mean they have animation like that like well not not really like in the battle they have the two people yeah like just kind of like generating
their sprite movements yeah um but it's just they they took all the cool video game stuff where you don't have to have the cards in front of you because what it does is it makes you forget about stuff oh yeah if you had to remember that your grip did splash damage one there'd be no way to do a percentage i mean really except the percentile uh it's just like nope app does that and it doesn't take i don't think it takes away from anything oh no i think it enhances the experience yeah like you're you're kind of involved everyone i mean one person just kind of runs it and they're just like oh okay you want to interact with that read it out loud uh i will say the voice acting for the app is is what you would expect from it's not like topped here it's a nice touch but it was like yeah it wouldn't have hurt if it wasn't there it is quite a bit of reading but i would say after playing like madara for example madara is a narrative game like it's it's [ __ ] i think the app for the entire act one of madara is like 25 hours of narration holy [ __ ] and and but there's an app that i have for it with a professional voice actor doing it here they probably could have put a little more effort if anything higher yeah definitely hire someone every character kind of sounds the same with their
you know whatever they're they're saying it's like you open up a chest it's like looks like i'm the best one for this and it's like then the other one he just does a lower register and he's just like uh i got him or whatever dumb [ __ ] that they say i've given every character a voice but i'm not [ __ ] good at it you're trying that's what matters right i'm just like it's a cat all right i'll do like a seething hiss kind of voice and then yeah uh so let's talk about the 3d aspect of the game i wasn't honestly i wasn't sure how good it would be and uh i actually really enjoy it yeah it's really cool and very few games do it like they most games would just you would just have the tiles and then you would have a stare token and you just have to imagine that it's actually you know a higher level yeah but this game you actually physically get to put it in say we talk about it all the time and joke about getting like dwarven forge stuff for d and d i don't have the money for that yeah this is really cheap and effective use of all the pieces over and over again yeah um because i mean this is the same tiles that we would use in like a cityscape yeah it still feels like oh we're in this dungeon uh this escape room or whatever uh
i think it's utilized pretty well uh i mean there's a select amount of pieces but i mean rinse and repeat it still feels like it's used very well yeah because the 3d aspect of it it's like yeah you are gonna see the same terrain types there's only like four or five there's cobblestone grass wood and dirt but i think what enhances that one they do a pretty cool idea with the uh these terrain pieces so it adds lava and water and things like that that just kind of are underlays which is really cool i haven't seen that before um but what's neat is that what enhances the same terrain type is the atmosphere of the quest yeah like we've seen like this was obviously in a dungeon in a well and the other one was like in a watchtower yeah and it's like just just thematically in my head i'm able to imagine that we're in this scenario and so being like oh cobblestone again you know this is the same thing it doesn't feel that way say we went from a forest by a lake into a town that was had a garrison like a laboratory and then a watchtower and then we jumped out of the watchtower into the forest yeah like it was all executed very very well and then the two that we've done so far they they late they did something unique with the tiles like the one just continued as if you were progressing on and then others was as as if you were
running through the woods trying to figure out where you need to go so none of the tiles inherently connected you had to interact with paths yeah and i'm assuming this is how it's going to continue utilizing yeah the same terrain type or the the tile pieces but utilizing them differently with actual app mechanics yes which is what journeys of middle earth did they had tiles and then you also had well you had battle boards so they they did two different types of like scenarios or situations one for battles one for exploration pretty much is kind of how it was uh it yeah mainly so yeah you have quite a few terrain pieces all of them are interactable not only do you have interacting with the terrain you also have interacting with the these actual pieces and this is manchester madness kind of stuff search tokens that you could click on and be like oh what does this do which is nice there was a game that i played earlier this year where you had to interact with tokens but you couldn't click on it to be reminded what it did so you had to just go there and actually spend time to figure it out and it i always hated that it was like why can't i just it's like because i don't remember three of those things it's like i don't remember what that says so you're able to click on be like oh okay yes i do want to go deal with that um yeah the the 3d aspect is is awesome it really fleshes out the game i think uh i would agree with that
so with that now let's talk about the app a little bit more the app i think i mean essentially you have to have the app it's free so thank god otherwise it'd be i'd be kind of really [ __ ] on if you had to pay for it yeah on top of 170 retail granted you are paying for the app through that price point which we'll actually talk about that as well but what's neat is uh so the app does a couple things it's all your events you have no event cards all the events are going to be things that you can because if you're in town you can actually click on events like events can pop up that you can go deal with oh really uh that might give you side quests i might you know i don't know how much they're gonna do choice based i don't know if if we do one objective if that bars us from doing something else or well i guess we'll figure figure that out but what's really neat is the fact that when you go to the city you are collecting materials like uh like you would in a video game and then spending that on a bunch of recipes that you find out uh what do you think about that uh i like the the uniqueness of gathering materials to craft or buy and then craft stuff mm-hmm really will like make unique scenarios for other characters like we were able to get me
something we didn't get anything well no we did we got one thing for chance we got a thing for galadin uh we got recipes we haven't bought them yet right yeah right correct uh i really dig it yeah i dig the the whole use of the app it like transitions like you're moving from one area to the next you have random encounters that happen um all the like unique things that you would only usually get in a video game or in like d and d yeah you get it in this app yeah and it enhances the experience by leaps and bounds yeah it's not just kind of like kdm for example where it's like oh hunt phase okay you know settlement phase like what's in the book oh it's that again oh right oh what's that oh wow we died you know yeah it's it all flows as if oh hey we just did a quest in d and d now let's go back to town because we have some money and we can buy stuff and ooh what do we want to buy how do we want to level up um it is nice this is this is one of the closest to i wouldn't say to a video game it definitely still feels like a board game oh yeah but it's the closest to d and d like that i think fantasy flight has ever done uh there's def there's other games that i feel are still oh this is pretty much d d but they do a really good job like you mentioned with the encounters and
stuff go into town you know all right either armorer or upgrade your weapons uh or you know buy recipes or get potions or things like that all of that is done and then it's just like oh okay we're done in town let's click on the map and then yo we have some options which one do we want to do what kit like what can we do probably i don't know i don't know how much it sprawls out i don't either we'll figure that out as we continue going i'm curious to see how uh voice you get vocal choices or like choices for the character like you had two dialogue options i wonder how that affects them throughout the game yeah because like i wonder talking about like that yeah like oh hey like i'm i'm because you were like i want to make a settlement for hybrids that's peaceful and yeah away from tyranny uh galladin was real heavy on vengeance and like i wonder what would have happened if he was more towards his new allies like there's the voice option in the cutscene or whatever where it was like we're not friends i wonder if he would say we're friends oh right or something if his dialogue option was changed yeah so i i'm excited to see how the story progresses i'm actually intrigued i've heard that the story was pretty one note i i like it i i think if you're if you have an aversion to this game already you're probably going to nitpick a little bit more by being like oh these characters are all the same i'm i'm i'm
excited to see what the characters can do how their backstories flesh out if we end up caring about them that could just be more of us being way more into role-playing i mean we both you're our dm in the campaign currently uh i have been playing d d for years so we might put a little bit more effort into humanizing our character our characters than someone who just wants to play this so that's very fair and true say critically thinking you would assume well you're assuming the role of a character and you would play it how you would think they would do something yeah but i can see people also just like it's a game i'm gonna play it yeah i just wanna i just wanna i want the i want the game or the app to tell me everything i don't want to input anything which is fine some people are don't want to do that they they want to they don't want to put in the effort but for games like this i definitely like to oh yeah of course uh i was gonna say something but i forgot yeah the the opposite so it's so good the the way that it utilizes like the scenarios and even the 3d terrain isn't that big of a deal like even the levels it's kind of quick playing by yourself it'd be a little bit more annoying i think you'd have to be the one to find all the 3d pieces all the minis and set all that up and then you can go but i feel like it's really quick to just kind of you're the one doing the 3d terrain and i'm setting up and running the app so if you're going to play this game i would imagine play with one other person
uh and then it'll go by smoothly now the ultimate question is of course is this game worth a hundred and seventy dollars or 140 if you are uh if you buy it online really now this is barring the fact that if someone i i don't obviously we don't know anyone's situation on how much exactly a hundred dollars too much a lot of people would say so um so assuming that you have money to burn because if you don't why would you why would you try uh don't go into debt for the game don't go into debt for any [ __ ] game yeah no absolutely not 100 and because that is that is a lot of money that is i mean how much is gloomhaven again hundred it's a hundred bucks does this give you more than gloomhaven has i haven't played gloomhaven so yeah i can't answer that's a good question because gloom haven is kind of the end-all be-all of dungeon crawls hmm there's no app to gloomhaven would i play this over gloomhaven no i would not so that but it does quite a bit that gloomhaven does but in a different way of course yeah
so i would say i'd still probably say no this is not worth the 170. absolutely not unless if you like if you okay if you have a choice of dropping 170 on this or dropping 100 bucks on gloomhaven obviously you're saving 70 bucks use the 70 for something else but i would say you still don't get enough you do get quite a bit of cardboard you get 3d terrain pieces um you don't get that that much minis like the enemies are kind of the same you get a lot of bandits at least in the beginning they're changed in the app though like it's bandit or bandit sniper and that changes how they play so like i said everything is clean everything is you know there was like three decks of stuff this deck right here is skills these are weapons and these are all just for the individual characters and the rest are consumables everything else is in the app so essentially you probably have a hundred bucks worth of stuff on here yeah and if everything in the app was physical like hey okay we have we have a shaft we have a grip we have a pommel we have a like all that then it'd be worth it so you're essentially paying 70 all that stuff is for the app for app convenience that is free one quote but literally you're paying 70 bucks for the app and a hundred dollars for everything
is kind of how i would equate it um because there's no you don't have a scenario book you don't have any of that honestly with i mean but there's a gloomhaven helper app which takes out half of the stuff really like you pretty much have your character all your character stuff and your equipment essentially what we have now and then you have the terrain like we're doing but then the app is kind of like oh it controls all the enemies like you don't have to flip every single enemy card it all does it for you um and is it free yes um so it's not it's not a narrative but there's also the foreteller app which has professional voice acting so actually so there are a bunch of other apps that gloomhaven has but it's still 100 bucks and there's 90 scenarios and 90 plus so actually there's an expansion so i think 100 over 100 and all the apps are they're free yeah so they're free and there's no then in my opinion i haven't played gloomhaven but from all of that there's no reason this should be 170 yeah yeah i mean that's that's absolutely true um if this was i mean if you take if you take each scenario of which as a campaign and you won't play all of them because a lot of them get shut down depending on choices you make if they're about an hour let's say you do half of those that's 40 hours uh 40 plus hours i don't know how long this is so because from the first it was an hour
and 55 minutes and the one we just did was an hour and 15 so we're already in three hours three two scenarios so it depends on how long if this is like a hundred hour campaign which i i can tell you probably won't be um i don't know how many quests it would give us for the first act i don't know how long side quests will be um if this can give me 40 hours uh essentially if it could give me the amount of time i would spend in a video game or an rpg video game i will say this is at least worth 140 i'd say 140 yeah you could get it online uh but what's interesting is i don't know who this is for either because if people are huge fans of the original descents this is this is nothing like it like i know it's been a few years since i've played descent second edition but i know for a fact this is nothing like they've even said it hey this isn't the third edition this is completely different uh so it's like okay new fans of the descent or like me hey i hated the other one maybe i'll try this one because i had to shell out one 140 for it uh i mean it's a judgment call with really anything like if you want an excellent you know i mean it's still unique 3d terrain you know awesome app integration
definitely pick it up but oh yeah if you're kind of on if you're if you're anywhere on the fence like you're waffling i wouldn't drop it i'd say go get gloomhaven but this is also easier to learn than gloomhaven i could i could believe that there's pros and cons uh it's it's a very weird controversial because everyone's pissed about the price point this game already has like a [ __ ] 4 out of 10 on board game geek because everyone was already before the game came out they were like one one because people just suck and man that is i mean i didn't spend any money so i don't i don't yeah i'm gonna say on the price point i will say this actually i do not regret spending the 140. okay so i can go i can go that far is i am very pleasantly surprised that i am having as much fun as i am uh because i was like i'm like i guess we'll see we'll see if this is any good and yeah i'm like oh my god this is so much fun i'm you know the app is really neat let's interact let's let's work together let's be cool uh cool characters you know a tag team so i personally think it was worth the 140. um i i know i would have been fine with 170.
so that's that's definitely one thing and uh for everyone who's [ __ ] on the art i don't i don't see it i think the art is now this is [ __ ] generic the box is kind of i mean they have a pretty cool with the with the um the insert or the way the box yeah the stained glass that whole thing is just for the 3d train which is it is what it is i'm glad they gave you something to store it in but then you have this box which is where everything else goes in the minis with the cool stained glass and then that weird things i wish that though was longer so you didn't have the weird stained glass showing oh yeah and it it's a little odd but probably because you have this box like it would have been hard to get it all out uh i think the artwork's great i i like it i think it's neat the weapons are cool the designs for the characters are a little weird like bryn for example with her oh yeah but it's a little odd and out of all the characters i actually think the elf is the worst looking one he definitely looks it's like it's a weird it's like a harsh gross realism it's like it's like you would see this art on adult swim yeah ugly americans or like those i mean aren't subjective of course but i know a lot of people that's the first thing they say is like oh the art's awful and i'm like it's it's not though it's not bad art's subjective too yeah so as long as they flesh out the characters and you can feel like they
are individual characters and not just you know uh generic stereotypes of each i mean each type of class then i'll take it and depending on how the campaign goes if it's replayable with different decisions and different quests you go on then i think it's i think it's a pretty good success say uh i imagine we'll do another discussion whether it be in the middle or at the end or wherever the campaign stops uh but yeah as of right now i'm really enjoying it yeah i agree all right so on a scale of one to ten what would you what would you give it right now i i'm a little biased because i didn't spend any money on it uh i give it a nine nine yeah that's uh that's really where i'm at because i don't feel like the money was lost yeah like i'm not sitting here like ah this game is good but i did spend quite a bit on it so like i the money is i'm not even really thinking about i knew i had to talk about it but yeah i'm gonna give it a nine as well this is a lot a lot of fun and hopefully in the run-throughs i can actually if the screen sharing it gets if i can figure that out hopefully we can actually show the app but i think it might be visible somewhat from from a distance hopefully but yeah as of right now it's a nine out of ten i'm having a blast all right so that's our thoughts on
descent legends of the dark let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you