Skip to main content
Loading video...

Evacuation Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 1:09:54

hey there welcome to Friendly ties this is a board gaming podcast and today we're talking about fleeing a solar system as a sun explodes this is evacuation so this is one of the hotter games right now this is also like the month of evacuation on John gets games channel right really is yes yeah uh yeah I guess I should get that caveat out of the way right at the beginning I was sponsored to make a video for this game I made a full tutorial video it should be out by the time this episode drops uh I did buy it at Essen that was kind of a convenient thing uh they wanted me to make a video and I was like well don't send it to me I already bought it but um yeah take all my opinions with a grain of salt but I like this game but I also have a lot of things to say about it poor God we we we looped him into we had him to commit to making the podcast before he realized he was going to be like releasing three evacuation videos in a week yeah it's true it's true and the last one was nucleum ah I'm such a shill anyway this is uh the new design from Vladimir Sushi uh came out from delicious games and it is a euro game about fleeing a planet as its solar system as its sun is exploding and you're just trying to evacuate from one from the old planet to a new planet and the game has a big board in the middle of the table with two big beautiful planets on it and you have a four rounds to do it um and then you potentially score this is kind of an odd game in that there's a couple main ways to play

with like a race mode and a points mode we're going to talk about all that stuff yeah I just want to say that my favorite part of the art is actually the curvy crazy line that goes between the two planets rather than the two planets themselves that's the thing that actually really draws my eyes is compelling and I will add is a cool mechanism in the game um that that like travel track that you use between them is um very satisfying I dig this game uh evacuation I'm first of all I'm a Vladimir sui fanboy not every game has landed with me um of his but I generally it's definitely a designer that will pull my eye to the game anytime and I um love this idea of dismantling and then maybe remling I'm sure that's a real word uh ever since we did that episode on Empire's end earlier this year right like you all remember that like I was like I really want to play this game for the theme right like and so that idea of like tearing apart your engines and then in this game also like rebuilding them don't come at me about calling it an engine um is he did it is is definitely something that I think is really neat so I'm I'm drawn in by that idea I really like in a game the challenge of not just necessarily building up but essentially like managing between and I think at its core this game nails that idea if that concept appeals to you um it does make

you balance between the two worlds and the idea that you are tearing this one down in order to make this new one great it nails that theme as far as I'm concerned 100% 100% you know at its core I feel like this game is like really just like super fancified like pick up and deliver like I don't like in in like a way what pick a whole planet pick up a civilization it's a civilization I just like that I thought no I thought you were yeah like I I mean like and it's funny because I'm not a big pickup I I've yet to play a pickup and deliver game that I really like but for some reason I find myself until this one I guess like if if we're going to call it that um because I but I always find myself like really drawn to them because I just find something really satisfying of being like okay like I'm going to take these things I'm going to put them here and I'm going to do this I'm going to put it here and I'm and like I feel like that's kind of what you're doing like you've got two planets and you are literally moving your resources your population your population and your resource production fact the overall infrastructure Yeah Yeah from one to the other and like and then and then and at the same time both of these economies are then producing things and you're continuing you know to kind of try and and move things you know back not back but forth I guess just always forth moving things forth but I yeah I just so so like that idea of like okay cool like

this this planet over here is going to be doing this this planet over here is going to be doing this and then I just got to figure out how I'm going to like pick this stuff up and get it over here before the end of the game and you there's a lot of ways that you can do that but it's also only played over four years which is essentially four rounds so you don't have that many as many opportunities as you would think to be able to move your resources it becomes as incredibly beautiful dance of resource management and production engine manage all these things at once it's really cool this game has a few neat mechanics like I I'm such a a sucker for like a neat mechanic in a euro game and this game's got a few of them but the one that um I think stands at the bottom that doesn't make sense the the the the the foundational one is the fact that you exist on both these planets there are these three resources it's energy food and steel which seems like a low amount it's a Euro game it's a it's a it's a thinky Euro game but there's only three resources but you have to split them apart you have old world steel and New World steel and Old World food and new world food and moving from one to the other is difficult uh it's slow with your ships and you got to get the production going and I I think that's the first thing where like you teach the game you show it to people and like oh that's cool and then like from my experience teaching this a few times 10 minutes in people are just like oh man like you know like thinking about where it isn't where it goes not that it's like an analysis paralysis thing but more of a just like this is funky and

interesting just like managing managing the these two different planets like you really feel like a bureaucrat almost like like managing the evacu I mean the name makes sense it's not like flee the game or or like you know run away or like exploding sun it's like evacuation you are managing this evacuation you have time to like you know we're going to send the the steel factories and the food factories before the energy factories and I don't know I I I think it's really easy to lean into the theme on this one which I don't normally care about but I definitely feel like a space administrator trying to fery the civilization across the Stars yeah yeah I was trying to think about this guys can you think of any other games where you where you have that like you have you know in so many games you collect resources right but like I'm I was trying to think earlier of like other game examples where like you are basically have two completely separate resource generation engines and you and they're separate right like you they don't cross over they don't they don't just go into one big pool the the only thing I could think of which is actually not related at all but it just reminded me of a little bit was actually the um winter and summer actions in viticulture which again has nothing to do that that's not creating two different resource pools but it just reminded me of that like that idea of like these like you play two different sides of the board but even in that game you play one side then you all go play The Other Side that's not how this is you you are kind of actively

working both sides of your you know both planets in every round um and I couldn't come up with another game where I felt like I had two completely separate resource uh engines I can't think of an example of a game that does something like that and I'm really racking my brain I will say that I think that sounds really daunting right if you're listening to this podcast you haven't played this game it's like oh you have to do double the work one thing that I think is a very clean part of this game's design is that most of the numbers in this game are very very simple like you're counting up ones and twos actually you're really just counting up a lot of ones and like they they go up to like seven unless you're Anastasia and you get 15 somehow but um for for the most part like they they count up to seven and yes you have to do it in two places but you also kind of know they're flowing in One Direction and you know when you go to buy things in this game it's like it costs three of this and two of that or two of this and one of that it's a it's a heavy game but the the purchases the numbers that go into it are no more complex than you know a game of spund or something like that yeah yeah one of the like a big endgame purchase you did in the the game we just did it cost you like six things to total you built a stadium and and 222 Yeah 2ed by one so 221 and he did it and it was like whoa that's a huge Stadium he just built so like yeah that that and

that was right at the very end of the game so that makes sense yeah yeah for sure I mean look I'll totally admit that I like Vladimir sui I like underwater cities I loved mesina 1347 from last year which which he co-designed um or or was a part of the design of from last year um so like I so I I knew I was going to play like I I it wasn't it wasn't like a huge leap but hearing those elements I just thought oh my God like you know I there's nothing I hate more than not having what I need when I need it when I want it you guys know it where I need it like oh my God you want to like just let me just like have a meltdown that that is that is me and so so I was really worried about that in this game and and I got to tell you yes yes that is possible and that is there but but Nick is right the math is simple it it does cause a c it does trigger some AP it does trigger a lot of thinking there there are moments where you're like oh no I didn't put this where I needed it or I didn't but the way the system works the way things flow when they flow how they flow there's a lot of opportunities for you to plan kind of know what you need and kind of be ready for what you need to do and kind of adapt in any given moment like I I haven't had as many feel bad moments as I I expected to have with a game that this weight of this complexity with these systems where there is like no resource crossover which is again very thematic as you said John you know a ton of uh frustration with MSA with those

feel bad moments uh and yeah I agree a lot less here I think part of that is because this is a very multiplayer solitire game uh like especially compared to underwater cities and I think this game is going to be very frequently uh compared to underwater cities I've done it and I don't think that's necessarily wrong uh but the core mechanic of underwater cities is worker placement vicious brutal mean I was going to say you going to talk about like mean like feel bad moments I'm like oh boy underwater cities and underwater cities has has neat ways to like try to get around it but at its core worker placement and blocking but in evacuation the way that the core Action System is I'm just doing my thing and you're just doing your thing we have our board in front of us and on your turn you do an action it's going to cost an increasing amount of energy which you spend from your own pool and you choose the actions in front of you you don't even block yourself let alone other people blocking you if you keep hitting the same spot over and over again it starts to cost a little bit more but not even really that much and so I think that is part of it like there are three markets in the middle of the table where you can buy stadiums uh infrastructure cards and spaceships and that is one of the two areas of of interaction really John John says there's no interaction in this game and and he took a thing I needed and I let off a litany a a Litany of bad words profanity at him in the middle of this

game so as much as it is multiplayer solid yeah but at the same time and when you were saying that you're like I can't believe I telegraphed that and I was like you didn't Telegraph that that ship just had the thing like I I have no idea what you want like I'm I'm so focused on my area um that I'm I'm ly surprised at at what can happen from things that are easily countable there's this mechanic about progress that I'm sure we'll talk about but it involves each of us having a progress amount and I remember in the very first round Nick was like okay I have six progress and I do this thing and I was like wait what I have six progress and it's like I could so easily have just glanced at Nick's board and seen that he was GNA do this but it didn't even occur to me I think because I was in that multiplayer solitire mind space and I don't mean that negatively for some people that is a negative I think it's something you should absolutely know going into this game that that it's very heads down you kind of Do Your Own Thing together at the table but I'm curious Nick because uh you have a tendency this is a credit to you uh to be play a little bit smarter a little bit faster than than John and I and and by that I mean that you usually it's like a couple plays before John and I start to get to a point where we're starting to think about what other people are doing you are already seeing it which is why I sort of was like oh I bet Nick saw that I needed that or like whatever and so I'm curious from your perspective if you still think this is like do you really it's just multiplayer like how much were you paying attention to JN and I you know as we were playing

I mean the both of you have played a little bit more than I have so I would say that we're probably on pretty similar levels but I I agree I think it's multiplayer soliter You could argue that like oh like you know with that ship that this person bought like you could have looked over at their board and seen that they're taking great things so they're going to want the gray ship so you really need to rush for that first or ah the really good stadium is out there so you're going to grab that good stadium before anyone else could grab the good Stadium but like th I'll say that those forms of interaction I don't think are terribly interesting and and and the the the puzzle in this game is interesting but the interaction is not and I think that even if you're like very cognizant of what other folks are doing in this game at a certain point like you can only do what you can do like if you look and they're like oh they want to ship over yellow people and I don't care about that you're not going to do anything about it like it's not a game we getting in anyone's way is at at all worth your effort you don't have enough actions in fact I did something in our in the game we just finished that got in John's way and I just like had deep regret because it didn't actually pan out being better for me and you weren't trying to block me either I wasn't but that was but the only value is that somehow was not good for John by because I took something that he needed but you know but I do think that what the interaction in this game for as little as there is what that interaction does do is create a lot of tension or at least in at least for me because you guys know I love to build my sand castles and like not like have them execute there is a I think a fair amount

of tension in terms of am I going to be able to place on the spot that I need to place on or am I going to be able to take the thing that I need to take Nick is right I don't know that that interaction is particularly interesting but it it it does it does add a bit of tension I do think the race to settling is probably is a part of the interaction we haven't mentioned that is probably the most significant part of the interaction but there's already there's just so many like decent places that it's like if you don't get the one perfect placement like it's probably okay certainly there are some circumstances where you really need the particular thing but I don't I don't know yes it can be interactive but like you need to be at a level of this game that I think most people aren't going to get to honestly um unless your group just plays this a ton and again like I think that's totally okay but as as John was saying earlier like you just need to be aware that this is a heads down solit game and it's well worth it if you like those kinds of games yes yeah uh I think Nick just said a very important word in that last bit and that was uh the race to put things down onto the new world uh the new world is a big hex grid there's some restrictions for where you can place and there's definitely reasons why you might want to go in certain spots but I would say you know going to the tension that Anastasia was just mentioning the tension is in how much can I do before these four rounds are up like four rounds does not feel like that much and you are racing yourself and your opponent but it almost feels more like a drag race than uh you know like a Formula 1 on the same track you know

like we're all kind of doing similar things but you know and and who can get there faster and and specifically harping on that word there are two main ways to play this game the first way and the according to the rulebook and the designer primary way to play this game is called race mode the other way is to play points mode and I think we should probably talk about race mode uh now because I think a lot of a lot of stuff orients around that we should talk about both we need to yeah definitely go into this sure rub book recommends that you um that in without anything else pushing you you should the default should be playing race mode and it recommends you play the first game in race mode and I agree that the first time you play this game it really should be the race mode I think for most I think we all agree with that I think do you do you still agree with that Nick no I really hate race mode oh but I think I think you need it I think you need it but so let's talk about a little bit more like so you know what the other part of the design is exactly so race mode is essentially the the strict goal of the game is Just build get your infrastructure going on the new world you're racing to get those three things it's food steel and energy you're racing to get all of your production on the new world to eight or more and you need to construct or have three stadiums on the new world which is kind of a weird mechanic but I guess thematically it's just like the happiness of your people so you want to have productive happy people on the new world and when you

play the race mode the game ends and you need to wait hold on and you need to have evacuated your entire you don't you don't no you don't that's not a requirement for race mode it says you probably should Evacuate the plan fully but you don't have to to in order to trigger the end of the race and wow yeah and when somebody triggers the end of the race the game functionally ends immediately so you don't necessarily play through the four full rounds then you count up some quote unquote points and you mostly take penalties for yeah the stuff that people haven't evacuated yet and and you know various things like that and then one person is going to win and the winning score is going to be something like N9 or 12 or 10 like a really really small number and what honestly feels a bit arbitrary uh the first time we played uh the three of us all together I beat Nick by one happiness on the tiebreaker and so that's kind of what I mean by like winning is is like a case of just a handful of points here or there so it's very kind of one-dimensional in its goal obviously you know but what in the race mode the most jarring part is the fact that it could just end early and in fact every time I've played race mode it has ended early that's it's jarring in a euro game that's like 2 hour long and you have all these plans the the carpet just RI gets ripped out right from underneath you I remember in that first game with you Nick it was also your first play but we started the fourth round and the end of the game was triggered two actions into the fourth round we almost didn't even have a

fourth round and that was pretty unsatisfying yeah I mean I think the thing you know the thing about race mode is like I I see why it exists right and and and to a certain extent there there is a there is there it's simpler we're going to talk about points mode in a minute but it is it is a simpler way to play the game it's it is cleaner to a certain extent you know we talked in the past about ano 1800 and that's a game that sort of similarly has like this arbitrary moment where the game can end and suddenly you're like oh my God like and we played a game once of that where Nick ended it like five turns in or something ridiculous like it we played for like 25 minutes and it was over and we've played games of that that have gone on and on because like nothing ended it right but I think the difference between a game like that and a game like this is that because of the way the rounds work because of the intricacies the efficiencies the mechanisms of like I'm going to move this and I'm going to do this and I'm going to wait I'm going to do that and you're like all the plotting all that multiplayer solitire happening and then for one person in a game that is not otherwise particularly interactive as we said to just be like cool I did it I'm done it's like you're not you're not paying attention enough to those people yeah you're like wait what no I I don't want to be done yeah and kind of like what no Nick said like there's not a lot you can do the actions the ability for you to do things there's only you have lots of options but there's only so much you can do and a

lot of that is because you're doing kind of like one thing after another after another so if you needed four actions to kind of like execute the bulk of your plan like you're screwed you know and and and that that is not a great feeling when you've invested really truly invested in the infrastructure that you're building invested in getting your people off the plan like it is a game that feels very thematic as John said and and you know you've you spent time doing that um so you know I'm glad to have played it I would play it again with a new players because I do think there's a lot going on in this game it's I even saw it on you Nick like you know you you're was the smartest board gamer I know but even in that first play You're like wo there are a lot of things that are like happening here and I do think that if we'd thrown you into points mode and action cards and those things I just you would have gotten it because you're you but like I still think it it I think there's something to be said for I don't I very rarely say this but I think that this is a game where I do think the quote beginner mode or even if sui says this is the mode whatever I think the race mode is I do think it I do think I do think it's worth playing once you know just to get your wet in the game but that that's me yeah I mean I do also want to point out that just because you end the race doesn't mean that you win you know when the first time I taught it to you Anastasia you triggered the end and and I beat you on again the tiebreaker which makes it sound there's a lot of ties when you're playing in the race mode because it's

just like who is eligible to win okay and then check your happiness yeah so Nick you were thinking that maybe you don't think you should start with the race mode I I want to hear Nick thoughts on Race because he hasn't said them yet I I mean I just I I don't care for as you said they so many of them just end in a tiebreaker for a thing the the tiebreaking thing the smiley faces don't feel important enough in the course of the game that they then suddenly become the tiebreaker at the end of the game I find it very dissonant with what I am doing through the course of the game and Frank race mode is not the only thing that's going to come under Fire from me here because we're going to Pivot to talking about points mode here and frankly I don't really love points mode either and you're gonna be really confused listening to this podcast hearing me say that right 15 minutes ago I said I love this game and you should play it and that's true but that's because I really love the playing of this game I really and I I shouldn't assume but I'm going to assume I really feel like the design of this game was so cool it's so satisfying to play you move these pieces between one another and then it was like well okay how do how do I game of how do I make it so that like someone wins this game that you play against other players you know and it it's not super interactive so someone's got to win and so they like landed on you have this

like race thing and then they landed on this like points thing and they're like n let's put them both in and they both are like very mediocre endgame scoring things I find them both to be very dissatisfying for the process that I went through over the of the game and I find that to be very odd for me like I generally the whole thing needs to gel for me to like a game but I've really liked playing this game I really want to keep playing this game because fiddling with it is really fun making the things work is very satisfying but then when we go to count the points at the end I'm like that's what's important like it doesn't feel right somehow um and maybe that's just a reflection of me not appropriately understanding what's important in the game um but I think race mode of two of them particularly pushes you towards hey this is the thing that's most important and to me that feels wrong I love love love that you just said that because you just Capt for me the thing that like I have been grappling with since we finished playing so so before we uh started uh recording this tonight you know we we sat down we played a three-player game we played in point sprad which we will talk about I swear in just a second it was my sixth play of the game I've played it three times two players two times three players one times four players played it all different ways points mode race mode

the only thing I haven't played yet is the the modules there's a couple addal modules um which maybe will help with what I too have been feeling uh which is basically like I'm having like the time of my life playing this game like this this game like I like I'm I'm trying to reduce my collection but I have already pre-ordered this game I didn't know

that I um I fell for nucleum too both of them all right I can you know I got rid of a lot of games I can add two new ones this year all right um enough I I just I just I really enjoy it I want to share it with people um and you know for that I I I yeah so I'm just I'm loving it it's a great game and I and I do want to keep playing it I think that the only my like the only thing that that like honestly it almost like makes me sad because it it is exactly what Nick was kind of hitting on is that uh we go to count up the points and points mode and and I I just like I just feel like I'm bad bad I'm not very good at it and I like hate that I think I'm like playing so well I've done all these things I've I've got all this stuff going on you took like nine actions compared to my five in the last round you had a million energy and like and then the scores were like yeah like it makes me hate Sean who I love dearly because he like I'll be like I did everything so good and then he will be like he'll have his like three you know endgame action cards or whatever like we should talk about how you get points stupid game but but but whatever and he'll just have more of everything right and then like and like he did that twice in a row Nick's done that twice in a row Nick always does that to me but now here John's doing it to me too and I'm like I

can't I just it was not and they're they're like being cute like oh it's close I'm like for you for you too it's close I'm like 25 points behind them this is unimportant but like I don't know why I'm bad at it and and I guess the thing is like it kind of pulls the rug out from under you you're like I'm having fun I'm having fun oh I just I I think I'm killing it and then I'm not and I I think I feel like that part of that's because I need to parse better like what gives me points and how and there are so many things to do about that John please God tell the people how you get points this game so I can keep talking points mode so yeah when you play points mode you first and very importantly you play all of the four rounds you you there's no game ending early so you can plan for all this stuff to happen and then at the start of the game everyone gets uh you do a draft essentially for three endgame goal cards and so you'll have these all game long they're technically hidden but you do a hand draft so you can have a suspicion about what other people are have in front of them and uh for example in the game we just played my three goals uh one of them was have a bunch of spaceships and spaceships are how you actually transport the second one was have a bunch of energy and you literally need energy to power your ships and to take the actions of the game and then my third goal was just try to settle a specific part of the planet and so I was focusing on those things and the last time we played one of my goals was infrastructure cards and so I focused on having lots of infrastructure so it very

much leans into that I don't know very well-trodden field of Euro games of like here's part of the game that you do better or you score better so you know focus on that and I like that it's a hand draft so it's not just like here's some random goals do what you can it's like okay you're drafting you're you're passing around and then you're trying to come up with with kind of a Synergy and then you also score potentially a pile of points for your production you're just trying to have them be equal you you score based off of your lowest production value and then you might suffer penalties if you don't have enough stadiums and if you haven't evacuated enough people off the planet and all those things but the game is is very much about those three goals the play of points mode orbits entirely around those three cards I think yeah yeah for sure and and I think that there are a couple of additional modules that you can add in that add a couple of additional ways to score public goals and like line majority things and we haven't actually tried those yeah no but I will say that I do want to play with them next time because I do think that like what I have felt in the couple of games I guess now four games that I played in points mode was that on honestly for all the things that you're doing in this game the way that you're scoring points for like I feel like I need a just like throwing more darts I need more ways I need more ways to score points because clearly I'm not good at maximizing the Avail points available to me give me a couple more option maybe these points will work for me yeah no I kind of get that I mean the game comes

with like a little score pad and when we were we just played this game the three of us and we were writing down all the scores and and I I definitely had a moment this is my fifth play I like I've played points mode a couple times as well and I had a moment writing them down like oh that's it like it's it's the production it's these three goals and then you you maybe get a few points for happiness and then and that that's really it it's these four things production goal one goal two goal three and I feel like if you're not good like given how we've played like John and Nick with the goal cards they each maximized all three go cards now in most EUR that you play where you have Go Cards like maybe you maximize f one or two yeah one or two or like no no you have to do all of them and you better do them all perfectly right also crushing your production while also crushing your production while also getting all your people off the planet while also having the most happy faces but but then that's it right like and and and don't get me wrong that that's our table that's our group that's our that's this space but I think I do like having Point options right and and then a game like this where like I felt like I well I guess apparently did nothing better than them so I don't know but I felt like like I did I felt it yeah stockpiled energy better than we did thank you that is very true and you had a goal to have energy factories but you had the goal to have energy production and there's no way to get additional goals there's no way to change goals so you you know there is a you know you can kind of maybe know where you are in the game MH before it

ends just based on how well you've accomplished the things are available which you know is fine that that's a that's a game but to next point I don't the points at the end are the my least favorite part of the game yeah playing it is so satisfying but the the you know you draft these things and most of the goals are like do the things that you would be doing already anyway but then like do yours I guess a little bit more because frankly you can't you you can't really ignore you know most of what you're doing in this game this is a this isn't a game where you like learn it and you're like oh I'm going to focus on this one aspect of the game like when you play this game and it's part of the reason why I think we're advocating for playing the the race mode or the beginner mode or whatever you want to call it at the beginning is like well you know frankly you're going to do all the things there's there's no I'm going to pick and choose my little control my little domicile over here or something like that like you you're going to do all of it you have to do all of it and so I think part of the reason that that the points mode like Anastasia um is saying doesn't like resonate with me so much is because I don't know it doesn't feel super special like when we were like scoring up like this last game and like we looked at like that the comparison like between John's and my scores instead of like adding down the column it was easier to just be like all right I'm up two here I'm down one here I'm up three here I'm down five here and like that's just an example to say like how um you know it feels like it's

going to be a point salad counter ball up at the end but at the end of the day it's like it's not and it's honestly just like a modification of the race mode elements it's just the Finish Line has moved to a different play well but at least in points mode you get to play all the way to the end and so if even if you are a player who is losing the game or who is behind Tempo or something like that um you still have the opportunity to complete the evacuation right and like um in the sense that that right one of my one of my working theories about like what are games that people have decided that they really love and in a lot of them it's that people get to build something and in this one you know you're kind of building something which is a new place that you all ran off to and so in race mode having abruptly ended it and not getting to do all the things sucks whereas in points mode even if I don't like the way that the points score at least I've gotten to do all of the things that I've set out to do and I think that this game has a nice Tempo and pacing to it it's does it doesn't to me feel like it overstays its welcome or takes too long you feel like you're under the wire as you kind of get to the end there um and then you know I imagine when you're quite good at it then you're like okay cool now I'm going to do these extra things or build a flourishing Metropolis instead so it's so it's going to be a little bit extra and I think that's cool yeah well and the timing of when you do those things is it Nick's right you have to do everything in this

game but when you do it can change I mean we played with our friend uh Dave and he was like I'm not going to ship any ships until the end which I think he like I'm just going to wait to evacuate until the last possible second which was like insane like I was like what like but it worked for him and the way that he had he didn't win but he came really close yeah exactly you know the way that these things play out so you can kind of change I I'm adding that in because like there's you know that can be like one okay speaking of missina 134 47 we T we when when we all played that game last year we talked about how like there almost was like this track that you felt like you had to kind of follow it's like okay the years go and you have to kind of do these things and kind of Follow The Arc of the story there are all these things you have to do but when and how you do them that's entirely up to you it's like Nick said you are managing this thing and and how you want to do it how you decide to manage your you know evacuation machine here like that's you um but you know you better do it in four years because the sun's going to explode or whatever so I do struggle a little bit separating my my love for the advanced action card module uh from also my enjoyment of the points mode uh we've talked about these two things and we're going to talk about those cards in just a second I want to share just a brief anecdote um I bought this game at Essen uh I got it back and I was really excited to play it um I

played it with uh with a couple couple of friends wasn't any of you though and I taught it I was a rough teach uh just because it was the first time playing and I didn't understand it we played race mode with no extra modules and I remember I got home and I told you all I played it you know we're chatting online and you're like what' you think and I was like I had fun and I remember Nick was like oh no like like you know like like it's not good like you know like reading between the lines John's not excited he thinks it's just kind of whatever and then I played it in the points mode for the first time uh was my third play I think but we also used these Advanced cards and I was just like hopping I was like like hopping up and down I was having so much fun and and so let's talk about these cards because the advanced cards is a module that you can play in either mode we've only played it in points mode so far but but you can do it with either can you really I didn't realize you could use them in race mode oh that's fascinating I mean the advanced action cards are are freaking bomb they're they are the the the the thing that launches this into uh into the uh Stratosphere or whatever for me cuz yeah I have enjoyed my games of this one in race mode without the cards I it was a better playing time than not playing any game at all which is like not a resounding endorsement it is faster six out of 10 or something like that it is it is a faster game in race mode yeah but then we bring these cards in so when you don't play with the cards the way the actions work is you just trigger actions that are static on your board you always have the same set no matter when you're playing this or where you're playing this it's the same ones

same options and you could do a lot of interesting things with those things but when you play with the cards mode you will have a hand of action cards four of them at the start of every turn and you have to play one of these cards and you either put it face down to activate one of the standard actions like you normally have uh or you put it face up and you get to do what the card says and there's like 80 cards or something like that and they're all you know there's a lot that are similar but still they run the gamut of different combinations of actions and discounts and bonuses and extra penalties but gives you extra progress and just like a huge variety of stuff to the point where I I get this like endorphin like you know what's in the box like you know I got draw a new card and maybe it's going to save my butt because I didn't realize that I desperately need one more steel and then you like I draw a card that says build a spaceship and you can convert one resource into another and I'm just like falling out of my chair that's perfect it's not always like that sometimes you have a hand of cards that doesn't work but I love that element and you know coming back to my the start of this kind of new segment here maybe I just love the cards mode and because I played the advanced cards in points mode I'm like therefore I love points mode so it does make me wonder what race mode would be like with the cards the cards are awesome strong agree um I think it's because it makes the decision space of the action you're going to take on your turn surprisingly wide um there's a handful of different kinds of actions you can take throughout the course of the game and

you know you can buy this or that or you know place this or that down um and you know you play the first time you're like okay cool those are all my basic actions and it's kind of interesting because I can decide to essentially you know move more on the progress we haven't really talked about progress but um move more on progress and take X action instead of y action the advanced action cards then essentially say look it's all the same actions but it might have this exception or it might have this bonus or it actually might even let you take two actions but you have really crappy progress at the end of the turn and so do you want to do any of these things uh because if you do they're awesome and they're more efficient than the what I guess I'll refer to as the basic actions the default actions um but hey you know what if you don't want to you can still take the default actions anyway and so you C you can still always execute the plan you want to but if you're able to be responsive to the cards in your hand you get a little you know frosting and that can make a big difference and I think that's part of the very satisfying flow of the game is responding to those cards and feeling that flexibility yeah it's funny that you you used frosting because I was just about to make an analogy to say that um you know Nick is kind of a we haven't really talked about the progress track but but I'm going to just talk about it for a minute here cuz I feel like it is it is

like the the extra drizzle or the extra frosting or the whatever the thing that kind of brings I can't find the right food analogy that like brings the whole game together is it the gluten the gluten I was going to say it was the noodles and the chicken noodle soup but I just wasn't wasn't going already you have a really interesting game between you know these these these two planets and the engines that you're building and the pickup a deliver and all of these things but as Nick is talking about like the act of playing these cards each card gives you a certain amount of of movement that you will move along this track that kind of winds between the two planets if you look at the board and the miname that is figuring out how to play those because the amount of movement that you want and there's again some interaction here because uh how you you know you're not it's not guaranteed depending you know depending on if you're going to get to choose to move first but there are kind of bonuses along that track where you are on that track changes where you can build uh what areas of the new planet you can build on what how many resources you get from the old Planet because you're like basically you're like moving satellites further and further away so you don't have as many resources and you you are playing this miname by playing your cards there are bonuses that you get at the ends another way to play shocking like is is how you whether or not you have to get those bonuses exactly and you know I remember my first play of this I was like obsessed with

playing the right I mean I was spending all this time sitting there like counting like okay this card gave me four movement and then three movement then I like I have you got to hit 11 you got to hit I had to hit it exactly and and and that element is still kind of there and to Nick's point you you can play the main actions you can play the actions in your card you have these choices but there's there's this another layer at play of which how much movement do I want and I think that putting that layer that element that frosting onto the game is just is like the piece that brings everything together for me the progress tracker is is very cool and so far I've mostly played very like low and slow on it because you get rewarded for moving slowly and I I'm not sure if the game does that as kind of a consolation PR or if it does it sort of as like a a limiting factor like right to to essentially say like oh if you're going crazy on movement then it's going to kind of bust the game wide open but um I I'm very curious to see like what it looks like if you just kind of shoot out really quickly and how the game flows and there's there's also something again it's it's it's it's mostly a Euro with numbers but there's something actually like thematically satisfying it's like as your two command nodules are what what are John what are they like officially called you're like AI artificial intelligence like logistic

satellites or something like that yeah yeah so as as and you have two of them and as you move them further like they must be within a certain amount of range of each other so they can communicate to each other and as they move farther away from your starting Planet you lose certain efficiencies and so therefore like fewer like less production on your starting Planet but then it allows you to access you know more difficult to reach region on the new planet and as you get even closer to the new planet then those synergies start transferring over there as your you know little AI nuls like start creating the efficiencies over there and there's something there's something very cool about that um transition and I'm a number of games do this but I'm I'm I'm constantly impressed at how many how much more the decision space is when you are not moving on one track but you're moving two things on one track um because it you're like oh well I could move this one a lot and this one a little or this one what if I move them in tandem with each other and the a point of interaction in this game is if you have fewer happy faces and therefore are going later in the turn then you you know have to you might want to avoid where you're opponents went to because they've already kind of snatched up the the bonus that they get for going there so um that that movement I think is it's just cute and again the decision space is is surprisingly deep for not hard

math right there's not there's nothing challenging about it from like a cerebral taxation perspective but but just from a like what's the right call for me right here um it's it's just satisfying very satisfying yeah I've enjoyed the variety it can also bring uh you know coming coming back a little bit to points mode the first time I played points mode I had a goal that essentially said max out the progress track uh I had that one tonight yeah yeah you did and and because of that I remember when I played that the game was four rounds Long and in that first round I went like 15 or 17 progress nuts I was so jealous like frequently you go like five or seven or eight or maybe 10 but I went like 15 in the first round I went like 19 in the the second round I was just pedal to the metal like crazy strictly because I had this goal that was like max out the progress track and I actually remember the very very first time I played this one we finished the game and none of us got more than like twoth thirds down this track and I remember we all kind of sat there and we're like is it even possible to get to the end of this track because near the end of the track it unlocks an area of the board to build on and we're like how can you ever build in the the ocean area if it's so hard to get your progress token there and then I've played games now where I I've I've easily gotten to that point and I can actually build you know a forest in the second round and then like a c in the third round because

I was so focused on big progress numbers with my actions and that is just one way that you can go but it's not like one is more powerful than the other because and I love this idea I mentioned before that um energy is what you pay to do actions the more actions you do the more energy you spend but you store energy on two planets right the the whole idea of this game is there's stuff in two places and at the beginning of the game you have to spend energy from the old world because the satellites are close to the old world once you move the satellites a certain distance you can start to use energy on the new world and the old world and once you move them even further you can't use energy on the old world at all anymore and remember at the beginning of the game that's where everything is it's all of your infrastructure so I've definitely I think in that game that I played where I just went pedal to the metal I found myself uh going into the I think third round and I wasn't able to use any of the energy that was being made on the home planet anymore for actions you could still use it to power your spaceships and all that kind of stuff but I remembered thinking oh crap like I haven't built enough energy production infrastructure on the new planet to adequately utilize the fact that I now need that for being able to do stuff and that's just there just really there's so many smart aren't things wrapped up into that progress track it really is a neat neat neat element to the game it really is and I think the the last piece of it is actually that you have these goal cards

at the end of every round that reward you as we you know we sort of already mentioned for if you move they basically balance it right so that because like John said you you know if you move really far you unlock more options but then of course you can't move it's a tug of war you can't move too far too fast you need to make sure you you have energy from the right places but then there are some additional incentives so if you move like not that far then you're going to get some additional bonuses and those those bonuses actually seem to be better the less that you they're essentially free actions like like they they're frequently the things that you normally spend a whole action in a pile of energy on yeah exactly so they kind of are also there kind of limiting you kind of slowing you down if you want them but then there are going to be some turns where like wait I don't I'm not going to go for that because I need to just F always kind chic's always thats good there and go to the action cards which are you know as we said that they're fantastic is is is that the really good ones could be zero they're just zero movement you know or one movement and so you you know when we first started playing with them you know I remember like the first like two rounds only only four round game I'm like I have four progress movement because I played you know three Z cards yeah cuz I'm like playing my best card so again the decision space is like well I need to actually play over here I need to take a main board action because it just gives me more movement or I need to do this I need to play this card

which is actually the less efficient action but it gives me so much more movement so so so there there you're it's not I'm not going to call it multi-use cards but it's just like multi- possibility choices they're they're like how you use them and I think I think oh it's just it's it's really cool yeah this is one of the more underwater cities elements to the game I would say as well because you know underwater cities you always play a card with a worker and then you draw a new card at the end of your turn so I definitely felt some similar Vibes there and I really enjoyed that element in underwater cities too like oh what card am I going to draw and what kind of benefit is it going to give me but the big difference between these two games with relation to those cards is that in underwater cities they are like a supplemental type of benefit to the main worker placement action that you're doing whereas in evacuation it's just it's your whole action it's it entirely encompasses the whole thing that you do on that turn and because of that I think they could be just a lot more interesting like the number of times where I draw like the perfect amazing card in evacuation compared to underwater cities I feel like the high is a lot higher like oh my gosh that's amazing versus underwater cities being like oh yeah that card's pretty good I'll play that and get one extra kelp yeah well since we're talking about the progress I think this is a good segue into talking real quick just about the the two-player three player the two-player experience particularly because in the two-player game that's pretty much the only scaling is is this progress track uh there's a couple of lanes uh each lane you know some of the

lanes have like better benefits or otherwise and one of those Lanes goes away so that competition of who has the most happiness and it's going to go first uh is Just a Little Bit Stronger here and then and then the benefits that they're going to get now before we talk about this I will caveat for all of us that we actually played the game uh incorrectly in all of our two-player plays uh the lane that we were blocking at least half of it we had we had blocked the wrong yeah the book was surprisingly vague and we blocked the more punitive Lane which meant we had much meaner two-player games yeah ond and less good feelings I think about how uh how aggressive like yeah exactly how how punishing uh it it was to play by by blocking that but nevertheless it is still much tighter there there is still like a there's it can be a little bit punishing if you are not the leader on that on that track and it can it can be a little bit of a runaway leader on who is the leader on on happy faces and stuff like that so I'm curious to hear your guys' thought on the two-player game I need to play the two-player game more I think that I've got some reservations about the two-player game but I need to play irly to really kind of know know how I feel about but I'm really curious what you guys think sure I mean it's one would assume that this game is best at two players because it is so multiplayer solitire and that generally just like well if you're not really interacting

much then the less people the better because it's going to be a quicker game it's just less people taking turns there is no balancing to take less actions in a four-player game than a two-player game or something like that like a four-player game will generally probably be about twice as long as a two-player game and I am surprised to say that after having played every player count I don't really have much of a preference between them I mean again we did not play two-player correctly but I still really enjoyed that play and I I didn't really notice that we'd played it wrong until the two of you played it incorrectly and you're like wow two player is really harsh and it's like oh well we actually screwed that up uh so I don't know for me I don't have strong feelings I I've liked it at all the counts I mean faster is better our our three-player game tonight took like two and a half hours so like it's not the shortest game in the world I I I agree I'm not so perturbed one way or another I do think that the knocking out the wrong lane in the two-player game is pretty punishing I still think I I still think that there's going to be some some level of of higher tension at like three player is probably the the most open version of this game right because in four players there's just more people and in two-player you knock out one of the two lanes so I've not played it at four player I imagine that that feeling of true I can't go anywhere especially when you're last like is going to be is going to be pretty similar and that's I think that's just the way it is I think that there's still enough space in this game and there's enough heads down this that like yeah you might not get quite

as good thing you don't get this Benny but like it's a probably okay yeah yeah there especially when you're playing in the cards mode because the cards give you ways to get around the things that don't have when when the very first game I played with Anastasia we weren't playing with the cards and I distinctly remember she I think we tied on happy faces but I went before her in this round so it inverted so she went before me and then she went to the progress spot that I needed and then she proceeded to build on a spot that I was desperately trying to build towards and I remember being like oh crap I need to come up with a new game plan because it's impossible for me to build there this round but there's no such thing as the word impossible when you're playing with the cards mod cards yeah yeah I mean the play we just did we were in the third round and I started the round I was like cool I'm the only person who can build in the desert yay me I don't have to worry about it at all and the whole time Anna stage is just in the corner like snickering cuz she has a card that says she can play in the desert and I didn't even realize that she didn't end up block actually cuz Nick kept being like nobody has two sons right and I was like well and he's like well but I'll still have another turn I was like theoretically you like I was I was basically trying not to tell him I had a card that was going to do exactly what he didn't want me to do but like didn't want him to be sad that he was like cuz I hate that feeling where you're like okay no I'm good right and it's like well no you're really not good because you don't know what are in people's hands you just don't you know there's a lot of gamebreaking in that not I don't call it gamebreaking that's too much it's just a lot of possibilities in those cards and so you

know you guys are totally right you know I love it sometimes when we talk on this podcast because I'll come in with a feeling and I'll be like I don't know guys and then we'll talk it through I'm like I take it all back just just just ignore me because it's it's true Nick's right block the wrong lane that is kind of punishing but you know I think what it is is that um happy faces so that I get it I know why happiness exists I know why you're trying to collect these happy faces I know why you're trying to build stadiums but it's just like missina 1347 where you need to like repopulate mesina it's just not the most fun part of the game to me like I just the you build stadiums they don't do anything else right like other than other than needing to have them so I don't get negative points they don't give me points they don't like and I I shouldn't even say that right because yes by having the most you get to go first and that is really powerful in this game but I don't necessarily want to do that once I'm behind I feel behind and I don't want to like spend my whole year like Gathering the resources to just and they and they're expensive too right like you have to spend a bunch of resources to do them we haven't even talked that much about infrastructure it's a whole other thing which is like kind of like basically mapping you know having things in certain places and that increases your production I mean there's there's other elements in this game and things to spend your stuff on and so I do think the stadiums the happy faces are like the one area and this is probably why I suck at this game so don't listen to me talk anymore here but uh it's that's probably something that I need to kind of like step back and be

like hey you you know this is a piece of the game you got to focus on this a little bit more if you want to control this more um but it's not my favorite part and so that's probably why in the two-player game in particular it's it's important because turn order is important it's like any Euro game where you're like I don't want to take the action where I get to be first player well sometimes you need to do it you know yeah I think that I I agree the weakest part of this game is stadiums and happiness as a mechanic uh going back to the race mode right we were talking about it's just kind of weird and and uh that that's fasinating it's also the most important thing like but yeah while you're playing the game the stadiums are just tell it was super important but not they're not something you want to be focusing on it's funny I want to say the stadiums feel like the feed your people mechanism but this game actually has a feed your people mechanism that I don't mind like you have to feed your people food in this game but like the the stadiums are just like like all these shiny things I want to do and then it's like chores it's like and then I guess I got to build a stadium as well I'm goingon to work a stadium into all these super cool fun activities that I want to do gotta make them happy yeah they understand I populated I fed them I'm building infrastructure why do we need to be happy I wonder if the game could have worked with the stadium happiness mechanic completely excised I don't know it does feel tacked on is over an overstatement because it is integrated into a lot of the Technologies which is another thing we haven't talked about

there's a lot going on in this game but I don't know it really does feel like you know it's Pluto orbiting at the very perimeter of the mechanics of this game and not really Central to all these other things that that do kind of work together like without any incentives I would already want to build ships and I'd already want to construct factories and I would already want to uh to do all these things but without a a a big stick or sort of damic or whatever like hovering over your head ready to smack you with penalties for stadiums you would never build them right I I guess yeah turn order but I don't know it just they don't feel they're not fun they're boring I I think it's cuz they yeah because they don't really do anything like the Technologies right so the techs in this game I think actually um are pretty cool you have like a different track I like the way that they randomize the setup for them um they are you know Euro Technologies it's like you do a thing and you get this little you this thing is a little bit cheaper you can cheat at this thing a little bit um and I think they they are Tech trees and I think that is cool like you said and randomized Tech trees yeah yeah I think that and I think they're they're nicely structured and they so far have felt relatively Fair like some feel a little bit better on one board than another but I've not like played through and been like oh my God you're you're playing that set like it they feel all very reasonable but um now it's time for me to bring up my hot take question uh and and it stems from the text is that I

think that the it feels like the rules in this game are not um the tightest the cleanest especially when it comes to the Technologies and like you know the game uses the word gain and take and choose and choose and these things are like not entirely clear to me from like the rule book or even the explanation in the back where it's like hey we'll explain these more complicated Technologies to you I like sometimes we'll read those descriptions and be like I have no further clarification on what it is that I'm trying to find the answer to about this so I feel like multiple times in the couple plays that we've had we've had to just like make a call where we're like well this makes sense but it certainly isn't doesn't feel spelled out in the rules to me right now yeah the lots of lots of gray areas where the Technologies meet bonus actions and and like that I think this is one of those games where it's going to benefit from a little bit of time in the Eos the the ecosphere what word am I looking guys it is late and I don't know what word bere the bhere right and um this is a credit to Vladimir sui he's on BGG constantly commenting um you know kind of clarifying and I think that if that's something that like you know is if if you're listening to this and that's something that's going to really bother you guys really want to get every little rule right you don't like kind of making decisions like that at the table and just kind of like flow in with it you know I think spend a little time on BGG

make sure BGG is kind of like nearby and understand that like in a couple of months I think a lot of that thing is going to be clarified this game still hasn't been released in the US I think you know some of that might even be clarified in the rules i' I saw that happen you know I keep bringing up Ms but like the rules that came out for the English edition tweak things a little bit so I think some of those things are going to kind of iron themselves out but I agree with you that there's you know as we've even touched on this podcast you know there's there's there's so many layers we we we've just we talked about the progress track and we talked about your individual things and the action cards and the tech trees which we barely t touch on and the infrastr like all of these things play together they all change the game and honestly I mean that kind of brings me to like my final like points on this game like sure there are these like little bits here and there that I'm like H I don't know about that or I don't know about that or even just the nature of like the multiple ways to play like I I'm not a big fan I know that this is going to frustrate people who are listening to this and like which way should I play I cannot tell you I am so sorry I hate to break this to you but I don't know and and if I were you and I was listening to this I would i' would be annoyed with me too because that's like that's all I ever want with the game I'm like just tell me what which way to play to start I will say play race mode then at least once then jump into points mode play with the action cards go nuts and I don't know play with the action cards I think that's probably the bigger thing yeah commit to playing it twice and then and then kind of figure it out like we almost played with the extra modules tonight we didn't now

I'm like ready I'm like yeah let's do that and and I'm not I don't really like games that have 14 different ways to play but this this is exactly like nucleum for me this is a game that you just like commit to exploring it explore it this is going to this is going to be an easier it's the same weight I think as nucleum but it will be an easier teach it's it's I've had just as much fun playing this one as I had playing nucleum they are tied for me they were both fantastic I I'm just I'm really loving these games coming out this year I it is it is so much fun I don't know which way is the perfect way to play I don't know if it exists but just play it explore it keep exploring it literally I mean it's it's great it's great it's got some foibles yeah it's great I loved it the number of times uh especially since we started playing with the action cards that I would just I would just sit there we're playing and I'm just like I'm having so much fun right now like like nobody asked me I'm just sitting they like I'm having so much fun I want everybody to know how much fun I'm having I do yeah I mean Nick covered it a long time ago is it's a really it's really fun to do the puzzle it's really fun while you're playing it I think I personally don't mind the point scoring as much as um other of you do because I don't know maybe I've done a pretty good job of focusing on those things I mean I've I've essentially beat on the tiebreaker twice uh so like I think

we're pretty equally um competent when it comes to those kind of things but yeah I I I think I know my preferred way to play in the way that I'd like to play it again always in the future and you know these action cards they have icons they also have text that tells you exactly what it does in English and I think that helps as well uh to the point where I it has me wondering maybe if I teach somebody this game new maybe I should just throw in the action cards and be like let's play you know we could we could play race mode or whatever but just like not even worry about the action cards or maybe some weird hybrid where you play points mode but you don't use the goal cards you just kind of Play points without that but then that's not maybe not enough I don't know I guess I agree with Anastasia too I don't really know what the right way to play it is the best way to play this is is your third play let's put it that way your first couple plays I don't know but the best game it's going to be three plays in commit to three commit don't don't teach this to someone to play once like if you're going to play this like at least two like commited to and even if you guys even if you go in and do Play points mode fine but then just play it again because you you're going to need that first play just to just to figure out the freaking I mean like John said it's a weird game it's weird but it's cool yeah I I just it is just so satisfying to push the pieces around I'm I'm really impressed at how again how simple the math is but how much it makes you have to to think about

and juggle multiple things and that then makes you be like oh but if I do this I want to sequence in this way and I want to count these numbers down um and if you're you know really getting into it you're thinking well but next turn I need to make sure there's this resource over there on the new world that I can use and um you can go pretty deep on it but I I I think that it's you can also just kind of like you can play a little bit more by feel and be successful um it won't necessarily punish you for doing that and yeah it just it it's it's a it's a very good feeling game for Euro players just that the pushing of the pieces this is a game we're just pushing the pieces around is is just it hits it scratches a good itch for me yeah the journey the destination's fine but it's it's all about that Journey the journey yes totally that Journey that joury I know even I I don't hear talk from Nick in the at the end of our game today I heard Nick and the just like like right before we ended or something he was like oh that's so cool and I was like I don't even know what it was but I think something just worked out for you and I was just like and I don't hear you do that that often and I was like oh yeah he's loving it over there yeah yeah yeah even if I even if I don't care for the scoring I just I really like playing the game so much that it's that like it doesn't matter that I have those other opinions you know yeah yeah yeah yeah well I think I think that's it I think we have literally nothing else to say

that's that's a lie I'm sure we could talk about this for another hour but um this has been really fun exploring it I am looking forward to playing it more for sure and uh I do want to say that um anybody listening to this if you have thoughts questions comments if you've played it you want to talk about it please leave a comment on the YouTube version of this episode you can find a link to it in the description of the episode yeah and go watch John's tutorial maybe you won't have to play race mode maybe you won't even need the stumble mode if you go watch him teach you how to play it save you that and then you dive in hey have fun y'all we'll see you soon

Progress saved