Skip to main content
Loading video...

Race For The Galaxy VS Roll For The Galaxy - Board Game Review & Runthrough

Transcript 22:19

ladies and gentlemen welcome to today's Ultimate Showdown a battle between two top contenders in the board gaming World in one corner of the Ring we have multi-award-winning longtime reigning Champion combo card crunching game race for the Galaxy in the other Corner we have it sister game the reimplemented version multicolor dice Chucky engine churning Empire building game roll for the Galaxy the crowd is pumped tonight as you get to decide which of these two games is better mechanically thematically and most of all engagingly fun let the battle begin race for the Galaxy was released in 2007 and rooll for the Galaxy released in 2014 both games are designed by Tom Leman and published by Rio Grande games

with way hang helping to develop role for the Galaxy in both games plays explore the Galaxy settle new worlds develop them trade and produce goods and consume them in order to gain the most victory points to become the most prosperous Empire of the Galaxy in this video we're going to do a side byby side comparison of both games to see which one is better in terms of price race for the Galaxy super cheap for the amount of quality gameplay that you get in one box however roll for the Galaxy slightly on the more expensive side there are more components but you do get your money's worth therefore race for the Galaxy gets our thumbs up in judging the box cover art race for the Galaxy is not too eye-catching but clearly the theme tells us about space with predominantly muted gray colors but the art is quite ambiguous but look blue Thruster beams on the other hand Ro for the Galaxy has a Giant floating futuristic space j with the symbology exploding with light and fire look at the scale of the planet in the distance the role for the Galaxy box cover gets our thumbs up when we do a side by-side comparison of the insert and components from both box when we open the race for the Galaxy box it's a little bit deceptive to the buy cuz as you can see all you really get is a deck of cards and some very uh High quality Victory Point chips but really there's a lot of

unused space the deck of cards themselves however have some really great illustrations the Combos and the symbology is very marked so it's much easier to see as you're playing the game the action cards that are used by the players are clearly colorcoded including all the bonuses that they gain for activating a particular phase are written clearly on the cards themselves despite the deceptive size of the Box the actual cards themselves are really high quality when you open the rle for the Galaxy box it is just brimming with color it's got some really thick tiles which really add to the longevity of the game because you will be playing this uh quite a lot the plethora of dice a gamer's dream hundreds of different color customizable dice I spent literally 5 minutes inspecting the colored dice kind of like the sprinkles that you have on your fairy bread got really thick action selection cards and really thick high quality starting worlds which pay homage to people who have played race for the Galaxy including some of the um original starting worlds in the other game like new Sparta old Earth and you've also got these double faction tiles and when combine together with the uh nine

starting worlds you can get a plethora of different starting combinations that really add to the replayability of the game in fact I think you can get about 81 combinations the tiles themselves in this big giant tile bag the players who have played race for the Galaxy will be very familiar with some of the tiles in this game doublesided really um high quality and when you place them side by side they all connect together I also wanted to show you my side by side comparison of my favorite card from both games the galactic Trend Setters I love how futuristically looking they are and you can see the difference in the size of the images and I like how in the role for the Galaxy they've tried to maintain that lovely theme from the original game but what's with these ridicul ulous looking kid-sized cups but then again I am a big kid in terms of insert and components roll for the Galaxy gets my thumbs up now if you're looking at the player Aid that's used for both games this one's from race for the Galaxy this one's from R for the Galaxy the race for the Galaxy player a upon first inspection looks incredibly confusing there's so many symbols down the bottom with all the different Power icons and explanations uh there's all these labels and a um

text boxes everywhere on the other hand when you look at the role for the Galaxy um player eight it serves as the little uh screen which uh players then allocate their dice behind very clear round summary short sharp straight to the point great use of icons which this game does very well uh extra detail about the phases and also a little bit more information about what you can do in the distribution of the faces on the dice so I think in terms of player Aid this role for the Galaxy one is thumbs up this actual player Aid does become much more useful as you become more familiar with the game it actually is useful for more experienced players just in terms of iconography when you're playing race for the Galaxy for the first time seeing something like this can really make a plays brain Hur so a lot of the time players will have to reference the players uh reference glossery at the back of the rule book which can really slow the game down there are four different main colors in the game green Aqua brown and yellow so the green obviously represents Gene technology novelty Goods mining goods and alien technology and whenever uh these worlds as marked by the circles on them uh when they produce you actually produce a good on them then you've got these worlds with red outline around them they're

also called military worlds and you've got all these other little hexagonal symbols which represent the victory points if you have a gray world it's a world that actually can't produce anything but then you have these Diamond icons which signify developments and then you have wind for worlds which are signified by these Halos the iconography in rooll for the Galaxy is a little bit clearer you don't have to remember what the icons mean they actually have it written down here at the bottom this makes the tiles and icons much easy to understand when teaching new players so this would be a great jumping point for new players heading from rooll to the Galaxy into race for the Galaxy in terms of iconography role for the Galaxy gets our thumbs up there are many similarities and differences in terms of the game play both of them have five main player activated actions in race for the Galaxy you have explore develop settle consume and produce in rooll for the Galaxy you have explore develop settle produce and here is the big difference ship these are the action cards that a player would use in their hand each turn players select one action card to play note that these two cards here have this symbol here and are only included when you're playing with two players each player takes their selected action card and places it face down in the middle of the table once everyone is ready all the action cards are revealed

each of the phases that matches up to an action card on the table is triggered and activated so that means all players will be able to explore all players will be able to settle all players will be able to consume in this particular round however only the player who plays the card actually gets the bonus the red player will get the trade bonus when they consume and only the blue player will get the double victory points in the explore phase all players May draw two cards and keep one however if the player played one of the bonus cards they can draw seven to keep one or Draw three and keep two the player play the action development card they get minus one off the cost in the settlement phase players May place and pay to settle the world as signified by a circle if it is a winfall or Halo World those worlds gain an immediate good represented by a face down Black Card plac based on the actual win for world if the player uh activated the settle phase they get to draw a card after placing a world in the consume phase players may sell colored goods for cards using the base prices outlined on this particular table only the player who played this card can actually use this trade bonus all players in the table need to consume any Goods using their abilities marked out by this number four wherever possible and trade them in for victory points in

the produce phase all players place a good on an empty production world that doesn't have a Halo however the player who activates this phase May place a good hon a win for world when different phases are activated in the game players need to look at the cards in their Tableau to see if the matching phase numbers has any bonus effect Ro for the Galaxy the sequence is a little bit more streamlined players move their little credit marker down to pick two cubes to place into their Cup players then roll their cup behind their screen whatever appears players then use those symbols and match them up to the five different phases outlined on their little player grid this is all done in secrecy the other players are doing this simultaneously players can use a die to then activate one of the five phases as shown in this row so for example this player may choose to activate the explore phase by placing the die and the symbol does not matter when you're choosing the action this person can dictate by reassigning one of the D and sacrificing one to then try and get another phase if possible like the play screens are then revealed and then the activated phases are flipped only the phases uh which have been flipped over are actually activated this turn so for example if these two phases the explore

and the produced phase tiles were flipped over only those two phases would be activated and in this case this person would be able to use these two D to explore but would not be able to use the settle die this game has lots of different colored dice white dice represent the starting dice that plays use when they start the game the red dice are military dice the purple dice are consumption Dice and represent any color so you can see the military dice that are used to heavily develop and settle most of the symbol on the dice match up to the five different phases that we just discussed however if a player ever roles an asterisk it acts as a wild card in the explore phase a player can use an explore die to gain two credits they can use another explore D to draw a tile from the bag or abandon X number of tiles plus one and gain those tiles in order to find a tile that they would like the tiles are double-sided one side has a development and the other side has a world so players can choose which side to use the tiles which are chosen are placed in either development construction area or the world construction area in the development phase players can use their development Dice and place them on a development in their construction zone if players have enough development dice to match the number in the top Corner they can then place this uh card on their Tableau they

then can activate any abilities that this card has in the settlement phase players can use their settlement Dice and place them on the settlement construction planets that are in their construction zone in the production phase players May produce are good using their dice on any non- gray world in the shipping phase players may use a ship to then transport a good off one of their planets to gain victory points or trade it in for extra credits a player can use a blue ship to ship this blue D into their citizenry to gain three victory points because the blue color of the world and the two blue dice equal three points however if a player used a different colored die as a white D there'd only be two matches so this player would only be able to get two victory points if a player uses a purple die this purple D counts as every color and the player would still get three victory points players Place their used worker dice into their citizenry and then use the citizenry marker to purchase new dice that can then go back into their player cups in comparing the game play race for the Galaxy is a little bit more of a gamer's game there's a little bit more Synergy between the Cards and the fun Factor comes from triggering other people's bonuses and triggering your own bonuses and really seeing whether the Tau that you've built has actually really worked

for you and your Empire whether you can outbeat and out compete the opponent players what's also really fun with race the Galaxy is that you can actually Force players to consume and produce especially when they don't want to or especially when you can see they're building up to a mega combo that will allow them to reap Mega victory points and snatching that right from under them is really exciting and quite competitive so a little bit more take that in race for the Galaxy than there is in role for the Galaxy role for the Galaxy in the game play It's All driven by the dice and selecting the right dice at the right time knowing what sort of dice would work better for different types of phases so that when you roll the dice you have a greater chance of rolling what you need so for example the military really good at settling and developing so it kind of works thematically you've got this big army they're invading they're taking over and they're helping you settle either an existing or another new world so this game here is much more streamlined it's easier to teach the game works really really fast and new players are really uh much more likely to pick role for the Galaxy up than they are for race for the Galaxy what I really like from both games is the fun hidden elements I love how you secretly choose your actions and then you put them out and hope that other players choose um a different action so that you can trigger multiple effects from your Tableau but also in race for the Galaxy if you choose a card

that can trigger someone else's bonus consumer effects and they got a lot of them then you're really giving them the advantage so knowing strategically when to use those cards is really important for gaining an advantage with for the Galaxy I love the hidden screen element where you get to manage your dice behind your screen uh the time that you use to play is simultaneous so that you don't have to sit around waiting for plays each turn and then when you reveal you look around and see what other people have done and what phases have been triggered and what's really also good about the worker placement aspect of role for the Galaxy any dice that don't actually get used do get recycled into the cup so there's this really great cyclic nature where nothing is wasted and that's really works thematically for you know space exploration and Empire building so I really love how the designers really worked hard in fine tuning that every dice matters in terms of the engine building I've think that race for the Galaxy works better in terms of the card combos and triggering all the effects whereas Ro for the Galaxy works better in terms of gaining the dice and allocating dice to tiles uh that would allow allow you to gain the most victory points or most credits if that's what your strategy is so in here it's more about picking the right dice the cards themselves don't interact as much as this particular game uh there are some cards that give bonus effects for different uh developments that you

have out abroad on the field but in terms of the engine build I really like race for the Galaxy a little bit better but I love the dice the dice who doesn't like chucking Dice and lots of them this one scales really well from two to five plays whereas race for the Galaxy really works I think best at two plays in terms of comparing the options that players have on a turn I think that race for the Galaxy just out Pips rooll for the Galaxy because all the cards that you need are in your hand there are much easier ways to increase your hand size by using the explore action trading Goods in for um other cards and then because the cards are the currency themselves you can really time the sorts of uh worlds that you want to settle in the developments that you want to invest in and really have a greater plethora of strategy um using the cards and the card hand management system in this game whereas in the role for the Galaxy game you kind of really Limited at times with the credit marker and if you don't invest enough in credits you just don't have a lot to do which does thematically make sense but it does can get a little bit frustrating at at certain times explore phase in the role for the Galaxy does allow players to broaden their options but you do have to invest a lot of your dice and a lot of your time and sacrificing your tiles in order to gain the tiles that you really want and by

doing that you can actually slow your empire development down so I feel like race for the Galaxy streamlines the explore phase and card currency management phase much much smoother than the for the Galaxy race for the Galaxy you can actually start by choosing how you want to begin your actual Empire and Galaxy exploration whereas enroll for the Galaxy it's kind of determined for you and you can't really employ strategy used in the last game until you find out what tiles and starting will you get in the next games and considering the final verdict I really love love love race for the Galaxy it has some really great card Synergy really great player intera action and Tau building and engine building really great fun it does take a lot of time to learn but it's well worth the effort if you are going to put the effort in rooll for the Galaxy it's going to hit the table a lot more often who doesn't like chucking dice it's a lot of fun uh people will get engaged easy to pick up I really would say that Ro for the Galaxy slightly Pips a race for the Galaxy but I really feel that they're actually suited for different types of play race for the Galaxy is more for the gamer Gamers Ro for the Galaxy are for people who get together and just want to play a really fun engine building Tableau building game but in saying that my final word is that if you are interested in race for the Galaxy I would probably get rooll for

the Galaxy first because by playing rooll for the Galaxy you become quickly familiar with a lot of the symbols that come up in race for the Galaxy and so then once you've Master role for the Galaxy stepping into race for the Galaxy is much much easier and you only have about half the number of icons to learn before you uh really get into it this one does take about 3 to four or even five games before you start seeing some clarity within this the card Synergy and the actual gameplay itself but I love both of them I like to give thumbs up for both of them but this one slightly up Pips this one which one did you think was the winner you decide this is Danny signing out see you again for another board game review and board game sanctury bye

Progress saved