Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Lord Of The Rings: Circle of Conflict Review - Don't Go Where I Can't Follow!

Transcript 11:46

Hi everyone. I'm Tally, this is Farrell and we're Board of It and welcome to our review of The Lord of the Rings: Circle of Conflict, a two to four player roll and write that puts you in the shoes of both the Fellowship and the forces of shadow at the same time.

Yes, the gimmick is that the left side of your board will be the Fellowship and you'll be playing against the player to your left's shadow side and the right side of your player board will be your shadow and you'll be playing against the player to your right's Fellowship. Now, this was a review copy provided by the publisher, but let's get into how to play and what we think.

Being a roll and write, each round begins, unsurprisingly, by rolling two dice. Players will then assign the symbols from one dice to one and a half of their board from the second dice onto the other side of their board. Each year, one dice for the Fellowship and one dice for the shadow.

You'll be using these symbols to fill up all kinds of tracks and one of the main ones will be with the different factions. Every faction has its own track and as you fill it up, you'll become friendly with that faction, which will allow you to use their dice every round, giving you more symbols to use. And once you become best friends, as we call it with the faction, you'll get to double whatever symbols are on that dice, giving you even more options every round. Each faction has different types of armies you can recruit from them and these will give you combat strength in battle and the friendlier you are with a faction, the more strength that army will give you compared to if you're not friends with them at all.

Or you can use the symbols to fill up the resolve and hunt tracks. The Fellowship will spend resolve in order to move locations with the goal being to reach Mount Doom. The Shadow will spend hunt in order to hunt the fellowship, guessing their location and corrupting them if you are correct. So, as well as being a roll and write, this is also a hidden movement game. Then, players can spend symbols to recruit many different characters, which can help you in battle, help you move and protect the fellowship, or help you hunt and harm the fellowship.

thing you can use symbols for is to match two or commit to battle. And this can only be done once around per side of your board. Now, you're able to battle with the players to your left and to your right, and you'll match up different factions that are canonically correct, you know, your Mordor will fight their Gondor and so on. So, throughout the game, you're going to be getting strength to that faction, usually through recruiting armies as previously discussed. And then, once three marched to battle boxes are ticked by any combination of you two for kind of that match up, that battle will occur. You'll be able to then add any character powers which are relevant to your strength uh kind of in secret, and then you'll both announce your total strength, and the highest value wins.

At the base as a base, these battles are worth one point each if you win. However, if you tick the commit to battle box, then that lets you increase the points value of that battle, but obviously only before the battle has taken place.

The game will end either when both battles on a single battle board have been resolved, a fellowship reaches Mount Doom, or a fellowship has been fully corrupted. You'll then score for one battles, the size of your strength for each faction, how far your fellowship got, and how much you managed to corrupt your opponent's fellowships. And then, the player with the most points will win.

Like Tend, a game we reviewed a couple of weeks ago, Circle of Conflict is a terrific example of the verb and write genre. And also like Tend, it's much more complex and intricate than usually you find in games of this genre. And what Circle of Conflict does really well is it feels quite big and epic in terms of how the gameplay feels. Uh which is surprising considering all you're doing is taking symbols from dice and putting those into tracks.

The reason it feels epic is because of some clever use of mechanisms. Like installing hidden movement and secret information along with the great arc of the game. Because the longer the game goes on, the more you'll get to do. You'll be rolling more dice. You'll be able to add more strength to your armies. You'll be getting closer to Mount Doom, which in turn increases the tension.

The tension is what makes Circle of Conflict so fun. Because as the fellowship, you're trying to duck and weave across Middle-earth, really worried about being found, trying to be secretive. While as the shadow faction, you're trying to ruthlessly hunt down your friends. And it's quite innovative to play both sides of a hidden movement game you're within the same game for you. And it's a lot of fun. You almost get double the fun you could say by doing both. And I really like this concept. On top of that, the battle system is great because it's like this big game of chicken where you're both heading towards this battle and you both want to win and get the points. But nobody wants to go in unprepared. So you know it's coming. But there are a lot of mechanisms that involve secrecy which make it more interesting, more fun. Such as you can add characters which give you more strength that the player might not know about. You don't necessarily have to announce. You can kind of muster up armies and then suddenly announce three armies coming at once and suddenly you've added 15 points to your strength which they didn't expect. But that does come with the risk that if the game ends and you have an announced that strength you'll lose points at the end of the game for not having contributed that strength because you get points for that. So it's just a lot of great mechanisms that keep the tension between players and keep different kinds of tension because you're doing all of this at once. Something we really enjoyed.

It all comes together really well. It's terrific fun having head-to-head contests with multiple players in different ways and the core mechanisms are really well supported by the characters that you can recruit of which there are many as they all have interesting powers which can be helpful to you or help you mess with your opponents. With all the different areas of the game mixed with the randomness of the dice it means you'll be focusing on different things game to game which gives you some variety and gives the game legs.

We do have a few small issues with the game but these are more generic things that you'll always have with this type of game with this type of mechanisms. So there's obviously a lot of information to give new players which can be a bit overwhelming and then you have to combine that with the fact that it's a hidden movement game and there's hidden information which obviously causes problems because it's very hard for new players to actually ask questions without tanking the game for themselves. Uh and it's also the type of game because of this hidden information that you never know if someone's playing wrong you know kind of behind their board. Then there's also times where even if you know the game you can end up giving people false information accidentally. Particularly in the case of as a fellowship you'll have to provide uh how far away you are by the shortest route from wherever the shadow guesses if they don't guess correctly and because there are so many routes into certain places uh it happened here and there that somebody's just miscounted cuz they've looked at different things and kind of missed one of the routes that's the shortest route. And then this gives false information if the shadow player counts correctly and it can break the game.

So, just those things to be aware of. And then maybe our biggest concern's a bit wrong, but the length of the game can definitely overstay its welcome. And this is very dependent on the luck of the dice. Because you start by only rolling two dice, and these have very variable numbers of symbols. So, you can have rounds where you're only getting one symbol on both the dice, or you could get three symbols on those dice. Uh and that obviously has a big impact on how much you can do in a round, or you know, if you end up needing more rounds to finish the game. And then on top of this, the faction dice often have faces which are blank, which can also slow down the game. So, you kind of sometimes get games that really drag on because you're not getting a lot of symbols to use each round, or you'll have games that will rocket towards the end really quickly because you have symbols galore.

Now, the good thing about that is is or not about that, but about the length of the game is that more players doesn't necessarily mean too much more time because so much of the game is simultaneous. So, you know, going from two to four, it doesn't really add that much. And you can still have quick games if if the dice go your way. The final thing we'd say is is more on the quality. And we've had a little bit of an issue that we've noticed the the kind of either top or bottom of the middle of these boards uh starting to kind of wear and tear and rip. And that was only after three or four games. So, it doesn't really bode well uh in terms of it being a game that you you kind of need this board to stay together to hide your secret information, and it'll be very tough if these end up ripping. So, that's just something to be aware of as well.

Final thoughts? A Circle of Conflict is a game we both really enjoyed. I think although the core of it in terms of I mean, it's a very standard roll and write mechanism of play, the way that it has you kind of be both the hidden movement and the seeker of the hidden movement at the same time is quite novel.

Yeah.

And I think it's something that basically doubles the fun of one of you know, a normal hidden movement game where you're one or the other. And I think it's just something we really enjoyed.

I agree. It is bringing something fresh to the genre because of that mechanism with kind of being playing both sides. Haven't seen anything like that before. I think for me, I just enjoy how it does have that epic feel even though it's a very simple rule set, but what it kind of creates out of that is this kind of big tense battle. I think that's really smart and interesting and yeah, just bringing something new to the genre.

Yeah, I like

Yeah, I like how it has kind of these different areas as well. You know, you've got I guess different mini games really that all feel very distinct. You know, you have the kind of battle system and then you have the the hidden movement system. And on top of that, you have all these characters. You know, each side has 12 characters. Uh they all have different powers and you know, game to game you'll find yourself using different ones in different situations. And I think they're all interesting powers which really kind of elevates the game by having this big range that you can use.

Great.

Yeah.

Yes.

So, yeah. Basically, if it sounds at all interesting to you, if you like Lord of the Rings, if you like roll and writes, really really recommend it. Of course, there are some caveats which we've discussed,

but I really really I or we both really recommend this game. We've really enjoyed it. So, that is our review of Circle of Conflict. Please consider subscribing if you haven't already, and we'll see you next time.

Bye.

Progress saved